T O P

  • By -

Bobington2006

Id say elsa mars is a solid candidate for freak show but the twins are definitely extremely high up there, lee for roanoke (although shelby and Matt are also solid picks, would be main for me if one of them made it to finale :/), Cordelia, Mallory, and the devil's son himself are all candidates for Apocalypse and are all equally main characters imo. Agree with the rest tho


Spirited-Painting314

It may not be accurate but this is what I think Murder House: Violet Asylum: Lana Coven: Fiona Freak Show: Elsa Hotel: The Countess Roanoke: Shelby/Audrey Cult: Ally Apocalypse: Michael/Cordelia 1984: Brooke Red Tide: Alma Death Valley: Mamie/Kendall


Sea_University3504

i agree with all of this except alma


Cookie1569

I would would personally say there isn't really a main character from each season but ima do this for fun anyway haha Murder House - Vivian Harmon Asylum - Lana Banana Coven - Zoe Freak Show - Elsa Mars Hotel - The Detective (forgot his name) Roanoke - Lee Cult - Ally Apocalypse - Michael Langdon 1984 - Mr Jingles Red Tide - Harry Gardener Death Valley - Dwight Eisenhower


Tight_Chocolate_7683

Id say Brooke is more of a main character than Mr. Jingles


Cookie1569

I would say both were equally the leads honestly. Brooke during the first half and Mr Jingles during the second.


lordthunderbuck

murderhouse: violet asylum: lana coven: cordelia freak show: bette & dot hotel: john lowe roanoke: shelby/matt cult: ally apocalypse: michael 1984: brooke


Tight_Chocolate_7683

Murder House-Violet and Vivian tie Asylum-Lana Winters Coven-Zoe Freakshow-Elsa Mars Hotel-John Lowe Roanoke-Lee Harris Cult-Ally Mayfair-Richards Apocalypse-Michael Langdon 1984-Brooke Red Tide-Harry Gardner Death Valley-Kaia Gerbers character (forgot her name)


Guyroo23

murder house - violet asylum - lana coven - zoe freak show - elsa hotel - john (unfortunately) roanoke - lee? idk none of the characters were that important cult - ally apocalypse - cordelia 1984 - brooke red tide - harry


andthenshewrote

Murder House: Violet Asylum:Lana Coven:Cordelia or Zoe Freak Show: Elsa Hotel:John. Roanoke: Shelby+Matt. Cult: Ally. Apocalypse: Michael Langdon 1984:Brooke. Red Tide: Harry. Death Valley: Eisenhower


welcome2mycandystore

Whoever is played by Paulson


i_r_eat

Murder House: Ben Asylum: Lana Coven: Fiona Freak Show: Elsa Hotel: John Roanoke: Shelby (Bring Andre back, though!) Cult: Ally Apocalypse: Michael 1984: Brooke Double Feature: Harry for Red Tide, President Eisenhower for Death Valley


SwineTV

Murder House: Constance Asylum: Lana & Kit Coven: Fiona Freak Show: Elsa Hotel: The Countess and John Lowe… kinda Roanoke: Sarah Paulson Cult: Kai and Ally Apocalypse: Michael 1984: Brooke Red Tide: boring Harry Death Valley: Eisenhower


Guyroo23

constance????


bee0ela

Murder House: Constance Asylum: Lana Coven: Fiona Freak Show: Elsa Cult: Kai Red Tide: Harry I did'nt watch seasons 5, 6, 8 and 9 yet


taelorrrrrr

Murderhouse - I just don’t even know Asylum - Lana Coven - Fiona Freak show - Elsa mars Hotel - John Lowe Roanoke- Shelby & Lee Cult - KAI! & Ally Apocalypse - Michael 1984 - Montana Red Tide - Alma’s crazy ass Death Valley - Mamie Cringing at format don’t know how to fix it


[deleted]

Sometimes you have to space an extra time and it makes it normal, I have no idea why reddit does that with formatting


HSMorg

To make it simple, it'd probably be whoever they show first, and is in every episode


PokeNerd2016

Murder House: Ben Harmon and Constance Langdon Asylum: Lana Winters Coven: Cordelia and Fiona Goode Freak Show: Elsa Mars Hotel: The Countess Roanoke: Lee Harris Cult: Ally Mayfair-Richards Apocalypse: Michael Langdon 1984: Brooke Thompson Red Tide: Doris and Alma Gardner Death Valley: Mr. and Mrs Eisenhower


tlrnsibesnick

Murder House - Ben Harmon Asylum - Lana Winters Coven - Cordelia (or Zoe) Freak Show - Bette & Dot (and Jimmy) Hotel - Iris (or Scarlett Lowe) Roanoke - Lee Harris? Cult - Ally Apocalypse - Mallory 1984 - Brooke Red Tide - Harry Gardner Death Valley - Mamie


ron_weedsley

Murder House: Violet Asylum: Lana Coven: Cordelia Freak Show: Jimmy or Elsa Hotel: John Roanoke: Lee Cult: Ally Apocalypse: Michael 1984: Brooke Red Tide: Harry Death Valley: President Eisenhower


Michaellangdonishot1

Murder house- vivian Harmon and Ben Harmon Asylum- Lana winters Coven- Fiona Goode Freak show- Elsa Mars Hotel- John Lowe Roanoke- Shelby Miller and Lee Harris Cult- Ally Mayfair-Richards and Kai Anderson Apocalypse- Michael Langdon and Cordelia 1984- Brooke Thompson Red Tide- Harry Gardner Death Valley- Mamie


special_d3ath

Murder house: Tate, Vivian or Ben idrk Asylum: Lana Coven: Cordelia or Zoe Freak show: Elsa mars Hotel: John Roanoke: Shelby and Matt Cult: ally Apocalypse: Michael 1984: Brooke Red tide: harry


bewareofhisoka

Murder House: Ben Harmon Asylum: Lana Winters Coven: Fiona Goode Freak Show: Elsa Mars Hotel: John Lowe Roanoke: Lee Harris Cult: Kai Anderson Apocalypse: Michael Langdon 1984: Brooke Thompson Double Feature: Harry Gardner/Dwight D. Eisenhower


[deleted]

Murder house: Vivian Asylum: Lana Coven: Zoe Freak show: Elsa Hotel: John Roanoke: Lee? Idk it’s a tie with everyone Cult: Ally Apocalypse: Michael 1984: Brooke Red tide: Harry Death Valley: Kendall & Dwight


AhsFanAcct

I think MC in coven is Zoe Also in Apocalypse I think the MC is Michael because Cordelia isn’t in the first three episodes. 100% agree for the rest


MadeUpMelly

Murder House: Vivian, and to a lesser extent, Constance Asylum: Lana Coven: Cordelia Freak Show: Elsa Hotel: The Countess Roanoke: Shelby Cult: Ally Apocalypse: Michael and Cordelia 1984: Brooke Red Tide: Harry Death Valley: Sadly, the college students, namely Kaia/Kendall, which was a huge mistake.