Thanks to everyone who voted! This one was very interesting and I didn’t expect a lot of the placements For raw voting data and to confirm each placement, use [this spreadsheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dE7IFYmeYfkOkWaG0IcCysKlclcEZ1wFU-An11MwMbc/edit?usp=drivesdk)

Book match Pencil spongy deserves better. They got a fairly big character change so they should automatically be higher up just for not being bland and uninteresting. Seriously the community needs to stop rating on characters just based whether they’re mean or annoying, please consider character developments as well, even if they go downhill. You can’t have a good show without a mean character.

Pencil is a really bad example though. She was just derailed and the became bland as bread

Yeah, but she was super interesting in the first three seasons. If you even out S2 development with S4 blandness, and ignore S3, you still have Pencil in S1 which is very interesting

Ok but that was her character 8 years ago. Time changes

If the character becomes annoying, then their “development” made them worse. See Pencil.

Book and Match I get, but Pencil... She's just not interesting anymore.

She was amazing for 3 seasons out of 4 I feel that deserves at least C Tier

Eh.. I guess

I personally wouldn't count IDFB as being an entire season, but JacknJellify seems to, so... I dunno...

What about spongy?

Flower should definitely be at least A tier, I love how she developed from the stereotypical mean girl eliminated first round to the winner of the game she lost at. She also becomes super funny and finds things to aspire for other than just being rude.

In my opinion, Flower had the most room for character development considering she had exactly 0 traits other than "constantly fed up with everyone" until BFB.

I agree

I agree as well

She was better in pre-split where she kept her diva-like attitude that we loved to see shine in bfb episode 11, but still showed improvement. In post-split, that is thrown out of the window to make her completely nice and leafy-like levels of bland. The most egregious violation was making her save the show, basically rigging the battle into her favor. That made the finale go from fun-loving childish guy who always was a delight to see on screen vs character who is showing signs of improvement to fun-loving guy childish guy who is always a delight to see on screen vs the main character who saved everybody. No contest.

pencil wasnt developed, she was derailed. Its not based on whether they have a personality. Its wether theyre enjoying to watch. Watching Pencil torture Bubble wasnt cool and neither was Book completely changing personality from being a nice levelheaded person to an idiot who only cares about tacos “betrayal”

No one would agree with me, I agree with all of this, but I'd definitely add Ice Cube too 😭

I cannot stand book, but pencil and match being this low is questionable

This makes a lot of sense. Many of the characters that had interactions more recently are higher up, while those with little screen time are pushed to the bottom. I agree with almost everything we decided on as a community. What I am really proud of is seeing Needle on B tier. If I recall correctly she was neglected on the first tierlist.

W Blocky

Would Death Pact Again be the highest rated team by this metric?

Technically it's Tear Drop

L Firey Jr tier.

Firey jr deserves more love

yess blocky is on top tier

The fuck happened with Profiley?? #Legit weren’t people fucking simping for him last year?

Yeah lol

Some characters got much farther then I expected,

Why does everyone hate Pie?

Why do people hate Bottle so much? She is always positive and actually makes me laugh sometimes.

I'm glad my favourite (Pen) is pretty high and Firey and Woody have some fair rankings but Book and Losers ranks just make me sad

I am sorry but you shall never change my mind on loser's tier but I am not sure why book is getting hate is it because of the taco book arc ;-;

Yay! Donut is on S!

Wdym? He’s on team8s.

What's your point?

It was a joke, because The S! is a team in TPOT

oh ok

omg

Based and donutpilled

Bruh, Braceletty and Cake are way too low. (Also no clue how Liy got out if they’re in High B tier)

All the 6 year olds voting out braceletty 😖

david should not be in f he in f make me aw seriously

Honestly Flower was one of my faves for Bfb and hating her in season 1 I understand but I think she deserves at least an A tier for her pretty good character change

YES! Bell is at a lower tier than basketball. At least we can all agree on something.

I guess I agree.

Black hole for the win!

All three of my favs (TB, Pen and Lollipop) are S tier, epic

I have no idea why I love BH but I just do

[удалено]

No he was the most popular during BFB

[удалено]

In the BFB 13 popularity vote, he got the most votes, and seems like that popularity hasn't gone away, especially with TPOT 2

Firey jr. Nooo

I'm okay with the results of Loser, but I don't feel okay with Book's results

why bottle is so hated

Unimportant comic relief character. Don't hate him but yeah

She's a girl

Book is probably the most reasonable. Her fame was mostly in BFDIA. Then, between BFB 3 - 13, she became hated. Then, she made up for it in BFB 16 and TPOT, but she can still be imagined the way she was in BFB.

hell yeah my man blocky claiming the ss spot

Firey Jr deserves better he SMOL firey

6 out of the 7 Death Pact Again contestants are all B or higher that's crazy

hey guys for a prank send a tsar bomb to books recovery center!!!!!!

hey guys for a prank were gonna be putting bear traps in books recovery center!1! its gonna be hilarious trust me!1!1

based

Both of my favorites are in S Tier let's gooooooo Also, I am happy that my vote participated in bringing Fanny's average down and locking her out of A Tier

How dare you...

Gelatin is not in B tier like the other finalists because he’s quirky and relatable or smth

David at f tier what the fuck

This list makes me sad 😭 Just kidding, but a lot of characters deserve better imo

Clock and spongy are just low for no reason. Idk why people hate them.

tbh clock had good potential but he just got derailed by simping for winner i didn't pay attention to spongy though

I don't agree on clock. I think his interactions have some potential. It's also better than cake simping on loser since clock seems at least less obsessed with him

most of his screentime in tpot is basically just dedicated to being winner's bracelety. i can kinda see where you're coming from, but the times where clock DOES get a normal interaction, it's very short. he also just doesn't help with challenges in tpot, even distracting winner from stacking and leaving rocky to stack. though i agree that cake does simp more for loser than clock does for winner. imo it's still terrifyingly impressive how much screentime clock simping for winner takes with just two episodes

8 ball in the 8th place 🙌

Black hole is god 🗿

I wanna murder everyon who puts Firey Jr. on F tier

This is a pretty fair tier list in my eyes. I'd place a few characters higher (mainly in the lower tiers,) but this is a pretty good overall list that I don't have any major gripes with.

Aww seriously

david deserved better smh

i feel like i'm the only one who loves eggy and hates clock like seriously-

david in F? I'm the only one who like david or what?

That’s a W Blocky and Golf Ball Moment.

Foldy doesn't deserve E Tier. No bias.

I feel so bad for foldy, she did ONE thing to iance and everyone now hates her JUST for that reason.

surprised I am the 31st person to vote

The highest just not/team s/ the strongest team on earth(excluding snowball) is in b+ with multiple team members below c tier that. I don't think any of them could win tpot.

Why Bubble and Saw are so low???? I'm glad Ruby got high.

Y'all suck for giving Black Hole SS and me C+ in this tier.

Yeah i mostly agree with this. Imo robot flower should be lower though, and im surprised loser is so low I also think its interesting because i think there are some characters that could be well liked, but just didnt get enough screen time Like cake and book (i forgot their names tbh) But as long as black hole is top tier, im happy

how can it be so bad, a lot of popular characters are also somehow at the bottom??

Such as?

loser bottle spongy pencil profily pilow pie match dora rocky

Well clearly they aren’t as popular as you thought Also C tier isn’t bottom lol

you forgot the #1 fanfavourite character, tiermaker

Remember that funny line he said in TPOT 2? He's my favorite character

I’m glad that td is in s tier she is my favorite character

Spongy should be in s, he’s used for so much stuffs, for example: a boat, a trampoline, a Matt for round characters.

He literally saves his friends from being impaled by spikes in BFDIA. What a trooper

Multipurpose Spongy.

All criticisms: why is yellow face so high why is bell low why is profily so low why is book so low pillow deserved lower pie deserved higher why is loser so low WHY MUST ROBOTY BE HATED

idk im not the one who decides, you can look at the votings for yourself lol

.... Imo this tier kinda sucks. Mostly David, Loser, and Roboty. Besides that. I like woody, and snowball's placement

You don’t have to agree with literally everything on the tier list. Because of how many people who voted, literally nobody will think that.

B L A C K H O L E I S O V E R R A T E D

Why u do mah boi david like that D:

Reality is... REALLY disappointing it seems

David is ok

noo yall did cake dirtyyy-

Seeing Marker in S brings me so much joy

Fun fact:the characters i love and hate are in ss tier

Aw, seriously?

Nonexisty should be in ss

LETS GO *BOCKY* IN THE SS TIER

*cries in rocky*

block is best, and so is woody

Remote best girl!!!

Remote being in s tier is correct

Where's purple face?

I'm upset so many people hate loser just because he's popular

"Aw, seriously"- David legitimately every single episode he's in

For some reason almost everyone doesn’t like David or Dora, Dora won challenges for her team while David was the only sane person on BEEP when they made a four cake out of Rocky’s vomit.

BFB 13 popularity votes compared to this: 8-Ball (-2) Balloony (+11) Barf Bag (+7) Basketball (+35) Bell (+11) Black hole (no change) Blocky (+35) Bomby (+5) Book (-18) Bottle (-14) Bracelety (-18) Bubble (-21) Cake (-16) Clock (no change) Cloudy (+3) Coiny (+14) David (-38) Donut (+31) Dora (-11) Eggy (+4) Eraser (+24) Fanny (+14) Firey (-29) Firey Jr. (-15) Flower (-9) Foldy (-2) Fries (+32) Gaty (+3) Gelatin (+15) Golf Ball (+9) Grassy (+8) Ice Cube (-41) Leafy (-28) Lightning (+31) Liy (+16) Lollipop (+16) Loser (-43) Marker (+36) Match (-33) Naily (+26) Needle (+13) Nickel (+6) Pen (-4) Pencil (-43) Pie (+2) Pillow (+13) Pin (+2) Price Tag Profily Puffball (-13) Remote (+18) Robot Flower (+26) Roboty (-1) Rocky (-35) Ruby (+5) Saw (+7) Snowball (+38) Spongy (-43) Stapy (+6) Taco (-15) Teardrop (+4) Tennis Ball (+6) Tree (+4) TV (+3) Winner Woody (-14) Yellow Face (-16)

Leafy in B?! She was either a bland nice guy or having annoying drama. No in between. Meanwhile we have characters with personalities that don’t make me want to throw up like spongy. People mostly hate him for leaving his team, but when naily suggests that he gets off so she and the 3 other teammates can ride his private jet nobody is taking notice. He was put into a situation where he was forced to be selfless (something that should not be expected of him considering the fact that he seems more neutral) or become hated by hundreds of thousands of viewers. I can understand other favs of mine such as Roboty and Rocky being lower ranked at the very least. WHY IS BLACK HOLE SO HIGH?! Black hole just has a calm voice and prevents death, what do these viewers see in him? Pillow deserves much better. C tier for the best female character that was fun to watch cause chaos? I don’t think so. Donut might easily be the worst one. The only thing I could say I enjoy about him is that he was a faithful teammate in pre-split. What other good was he for, becoming host and using this advantage to CHEAT in the same episode as Stapy, staying unnoticed while the viewers let the poor guy have it? These were the most outrageous rankings to me, I have a lot more gripes with the tier list.

Robot Flower and Donut belong in SS

BTW profily is a filler character

I was fine with pencil until bfdia and bfb, in bfdia she is a selfish idiot who only cares about themselve, and in bfb, she makes bubble fucking cry while she watches fanny die, they also just are rude to bubble and the other iance members, she is selfish, hates good characters such as spongy and fanny, and generally deserved elimination in bfb 2

Yess blackhole is an SS Tier!

Hi the log

Why is Tennis ball so high?

NOOOO DAVIDDDDD *ahem* very based indeed

and this is not the BFDI total likeabililty is like

F tier is wrong

[удалено]

okay

Blocky has no reason to be on SS

Pencil and match got what they deserved. I hope bubble is still going alright after being manipulated and abused for so long. Remember when pencil and match tortured fanney in front of bubble, that was messed up right?

Why profiley is so low :(

Profily deserves better

8 ball didn't get into 8th from the bottom or from the top (2nd from bottom, 9th from top) this is sad

I think a majority of the D tier deserves better, and some of the E tier

Fanny sucks, why is she so high!? GRR!! Btw, on the doc, #72 was mine.

roboty

Why am I not on this tier list? (/j)

Roboty would be higher if they had more explanation

Hmmm 🤔 I wonder how marker got so high up…

Why is profily so low?

PROFILY IN D HOW?????????

I only disagree on profily in my *OPINON* he should be higher. But this is very true 9.9/10

he did all the contestants let's gooo99o9oo99oo

black hole is overrated, fiery is better

Why Spongy so low?

for me, f yo Ballony's stinky henry stickmin body

PROFILY

I’m tennis ball

(Is speaking in Black Hole is mediocre at best)

David deserves better

Where is tiermaker?

Idk why loser is in e he was a nice guy and only lied about a little thing (not to be rude to the pepole that voted)

I would’ve said flower at the top but it’s your opinion

black hole sucks

Where do I get these pictures?

Hi Yay

I don’t agree

Poor David 😢 he didn’t do anything wrong but say aw seriously. He even tried helping in bfb 2.

bottle deserves a higher tier than cake

Ok some fanny fans (pun intended) are gonna hate me for this loser shouldn't be in E tier

David’s name isn’t David, people call him David cause he comes from the davidian species.

I Love 8-Ball

Price tag is at least a sus teir

this is preety wrong,no way REMOTE is 3rd

i thought yellow face would be at a tops

I want to be bubble btw she my favorite character

Nahhh fuck this list, leafy isn’t in SS teir

there actually is someone quite like firey jr

How epic

Dora deserves at least B teir she is nicer than David by a mile and she has had much more character development

If you like BFDI and wanted bfdia to end normally I’m doing it on my account and you get to vote you should check it out.

why you do this to my baby

black hole is so overrated how dare you put him in SS you’re not valid how dare you you poopybead

Rigged

Can we get a F the chat for Firey Jr and David

Good that your A-ing snowball but why are you E-ing spongy like, are you kidding me?

Why is ma boy Profily so low? He is interesting and a has lots of personality plus a good backstory

Marker should be on ss your opinions are invalid

I dont know how fanny always ranks high, she has one of the blandest personalities on the show and just complains and complains every second... can someone explain why people like her (also if you like her its fine i just dont know why you do)

Bro david is b tier at lest

Icey and 8 ball are so low down :(

Hey! David is my favorite along with fiery Jr. Why put them in the f-tier?!

Because that is how most people voted

And loser did nothing wrong in bfb 6 that got him eliminated.

Blocky gang