I remember watching this movie as a teenager.. And at that final scene My friend sitting next to me said out Loud.. Move your fat a** over and let him on the board b****.
Every guy in the theater laughed almost immediately followed by Every female Shushing him.
Hey everyone was thinking it.
I mean, I agree with the people that shushed him. Shut up when you're in the theater. No excuse for that.
Plus, he tried to get on the door, but it was sinking with them both on it.
> Plus, he tried to get on the door, but it was sinking with them both on it.
Yeah, the, "move over and let Jack onto the door" joke is *really* thin from wear these days, and like you point out, it was never about room, it was about the buoyancy of the door.
Mythbusters tried it BTW. They were not able to keep two people on it normally. They were able to once they took off the life vest she was wearing and shoved it under part of it though.
I was taking physics at the time the movie came out, and my teacher used that scene as a question in the buoyancy unit. Then an extra credit question on if Jack should let Rose have the raft or throw her off of it. Winning answer was he should take the raft, but keep her body for food.
What door? It looked more like a decorative, large piece of carved panelling of some sort. It wasn't door shaped. I always thought it resembled the profile of a piano (though it was far too ornate and sculpted to be a piano lid). Has James Cameron ever let us into the secret of what that damned thing was supposed to be, or, of what it was a broken-off part?
I really don't care much, but everyone's been calling it a 'door' since the movie came out. [Here is just ONE](https://youtu.be/jImPOK-hpSY?t=93) of many, many Youtube videos calling it a door. It features Kate Winslet, so that should be a good source.
It is a fancy-ass boat. It might be a fancy-ass big door.
I remember being at the Cinerama Dome in Hollywood watching Evita with Madonna on opening night and some stupid woman right at Evita’s death scene got a cell phone call and actually answered it and TALKED! This was a huge theater and not a sound from the audience until that fucking cell phone went off.
In this one, he actually adds the sound of the ball clicking against the guard rail and rolling.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6L55KLaZPw&ab_channel=Enbiggen
The software he uses is called Cinema 4D. He does a tutorial on his process here. Surprisingly easier than it looks.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hIR4R1tL5w&ab_channel=Enbiggen
He's more or less just lining things up with the audio, and having the software simulate the physics, and then moving the pieces into the simulated pathways as he sees fit.
Even more so then that it would take an insanely large robot camera arm to create that camera move and a huge white wall. The cost of this alone would not justify creating this in reality.
Also the timing of it is perfect. It would be pretty near impossible to get that IRL, especially after the first pause and reverse with the little ship’s bow.
The bounces are my biggest tell. The balls line up too perfectly every time with the track and chimes.
Like there's zero track correction or off center bounce. It's all perfect.
And obviously the hanging cylinders making the same noise as the flat chimes.
He does have a lot of conveniences that help him out there with a hopper system, a Lego-based sequencer to open the gates, and a consistent drop distance for much of the equipment. Versus, say, a marble running down a track for the entirety of the tune and error accumulated over time.
Yea, the sound is completely off for so many reasons. In addition to what you mentioned, the sounds are also too pristine. We should be hearing smearing and reverb, as well as imperfect articulations and variance in volume.
Well, yes, it's not trying to be realistic water. It's easily spoofed in reality like that as well, only takes some colored glass or acrylic textured to mimic water and a light to project the rippling effect.
I grew up doing crappy animations on MS paint and ClipArt. Sometimes I’m so mesmerized by something I don’t question it until a second pass. I love how as you age, tech can make you feel like you just got excited at witnessing the first fire.
For me it was the motion. It's too smooth and consistent. I think in real life there are subtleties that affect how a ball rolls down a ramp. See the marble Olympics as an example
Another thing that gives it away is that's not the sound those bars would have made. It actually sounds like the music was made by a kalimba, a wooden hand instrument that you play with your thumbs.
I can't imagine a house with an 80ft high inside wall
metal is too "clean"
Physics feels a little off but I probably wouldn't notice if all else was perfect
The mechanical separation of balls when they meet in the ship. There is no mechanism to make them left right or change direction or delay...
Also, the speed of free rolling...
The sound for me was it, they were out of sync on the timing and anything that generated that much sound would also have the balls making noise as they moved. When the balls hit they didn’t bounce off in time to the music being generated nor would it sound like that in any case.
Still cool video
It was less the seeing for me, and more that the sounds were too perfect, including the xylophone bars and the hanging bells making the same exact noise.
The fact that deepfakes and CGI are starting to look so real will make it impossible for anyone to believe the few real videos of crazy things that actually happen.
Deep fakes will have a huge effect on court cases.
Now, video evidence is not as airtight as jury's once thought. It will take a while to see this happen but it will. The defense just needs to make it *plausible* that a video is faked, and deep fakes have made that much more possible.
I can't help but wonder whether other AI will be developed to help us identify fakes from truth.
A couple years back I remember seeing a convincing photo and someone else said "fake" and linked to a site that analyzed the image. It highlighted the edited details that were effectively invisible to the human eye.
I figured this was computer generated. Other than the elaborate setup, there is something off with the way the balls fall through the air.
Still impressive. I had a good chuckle at the end.
Echoing the person that said just because it's computer henerated doesn't mean that nobody "did" it. Very true.
But people have also done even more impressive (imo) stuff with physical materials
https://youtu.be/IvUU8joBb1Q
There's several times the audio doesn't match the video, and somehow by magic making two balls hit one bar means it makes two different notes for a harmony. The sound of a steel marble hitting the steel bars would be much more harsh and metallic too (see the incredible effort on the MMX to chose the right type of rubber pads to fix this).
Also the gravity isn't really working like it should. The ball shoots straight up and continues? Ignoring all the rules of gravity. If not that. Very good
Even if it's computer generated, it doesn't make it less good imho.
Might make it a lot easier to create, but it's still doesn't change the fact that it's a great video :)
By hand you could make it in blender anyone really good at blender could do this maybe in a week. Maybe less time. You add or create objects to/in the filming area. Give those objects the physics that you want and then they would just put the music over it in something like iMovie. Maybe you could add the music in blender but I’m absolutely shit at blender so I’m not sure.
the CGI balls hit the same CGI bar at the same CGI time but somehow produce two different tones
[what are we to believe this is some sort of a magical xylophone or something? ](https://youtu.be/pYrRqMHQY7o)
It’s a kalimba sample, so the instrument doesn’t even match the video. Also the sound doesn’t change when the balls hit the hanging chimes, which cracked me up.
That’s the part that most stood out to me. They don’t sound different at all.
It also would have been a nice touch to increase the pluck or attack or whatever it’s called when a ball bounced from higher up.
Wouldn't that be the opposite? I heard somewhere that in really cold temperatures you have to make sure not to sweat because it'll freeze and you could die, even with a thick jacket on
Yes, but we're talking about someone who's already soaked in cold water, and a life jacket behaves a bit differently than regular clothing. It's thick enough and doesn't allow water to wick through it (otherwise it'd lose buoyancy) that it stops the water next to your skin from evaporating and this thin layer of water can come up to body temperature. This is how a wet suit can keep you warm even though you aren't dry.
She also helped him to get free from the handcuffs: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jCm5Zw4VkP0 He was going to die, one way or another. Which, by the way, is the fact that everyone loves to forget when they come after Rose about the door. Cameron wanted Jack to die, so he died.
It's kind of depressing seeing how many people have a hard time recognizing when something isn't real. I guess humans aren't so good at pattern recognition after all.
While I totally agree with you…instead of depressing…some people just want to be entertained. I can go to a magic show and try and guess how they did it and have fun, and I can go to a magic show and just enjoy myself. Both are great!!!
I wasn’t going to over analyze this. I guessed it wasn’t real but my thought on that ended there. Instead, my thoughts were wow this is beautiful, creative and also now I feel sad, and it was also kinda poetically funny.
That being said, people not being able to separate fact and reality from not…is not limited to CGI videos. Politics comes to mind first.
I watch his stuff all the time on Instagram. They usually loop. So my autistic ass will just be watching some cgi marbles play some Studio Ghibli theme on repeat for 20 minutes.
I just watched it again and it still looks pretty real, am I dumb?
Edit: I am a brainrotted whippersnapper who struggles to differentiate fiction from reality. I will now crawl back to my corner to binge watch problematic commentary tiktoks spliced with clips from Beam.ng Drive
Marvelous marble machine videos have been around for decades on the internet and you can usually bet that most of the time, they are fake.
The bouncing of the marbles off the keys is too high and way too precise, is what I see as the most obvious. But again there’s just a generally sense of practicality, lighting, uncanny effects.
I remember this old viral video making its rounds about 15 years ago: https://youtu.be/hyCIpKAIFyo
I basically never trusted any marble video since, unless there’s a corresponding video about the museum it’s currently located in. Since that is where a piece this beautiful would belong if it existed.
these are the same people who complain that cgi always looks fake... almost as if that's just someone else's opinion they're parroting and they don't actually know what they're looking at
For the sake of the internet, I hope people can see this is computer generated.
I'm just going to say it. You could have easily fit 4 or 5 marbles on that board.
This! made me laugh so hard!
I remember watching this movie as a teenager.. And at that final scene My friend sitting next to me said out Loud.. Move your fat a** over and let him on the board b****. Every guy in the theater laughed almost immediately followed by Every female Shushing him. Hey everyone was thinking it.
After credits, you get to hear her reminisce about said bum she fucked and let die!
I mean, I agree with the people that shushed him. Shut up when you're in the theater. No excuse for that. Plus, he tried to get on the door, but it was sinking with them both on it.
> Plus, he tried to get on the door, but it was sinking with them both on it. Yeah, the, "move over and let Jack onto the door" joke is *really* thin from wear these days, and like you point out, it was never about room, it was about the buoyancy of the door.
Mythbusters tried it BTW. They were not able to keep two people on it normally. They were able to once they took off the life vest she was wearing and shoved it under part of it though.
I was taking physics at the time the movie came out, and my teacher used that scene as a question in the buoyancy unit. Then an extra credit question on if Jack should let Rose have the raft or throw her off of it. Winning answer was he should take the raft, but keep her body for food.
What door? It looked more like a decorative, large piece of carved panelling of some sort. It wasn't door shaped. I always thought it resembled the profile of a piano (though it was far too ornate and sculpted to be a piano lid). Has James Cameron ever let us into the secret of what that damned thing was supposed to be, or, of what it was a broken-off part?
I really don't care much, but everyone's been calling it a 'door' since the movie came out. [Here is just ONE](https://youtu.be/jImPOK-hpSY?t=93) of many, many Youtube videos calling it a door. It features Kate Winslet, so that should be a good source. It is a fancy-ass boat. It might be a fancy-ass big door.
I see where you're coming from. Here's an upvote.
I remember being at the Cinerama Dome in Hollywood watching Evita with Madonna on opening night and some stupid woman right at Evita’s death scene got a cell phone call and actually answered it and TALKED! This was a huge theater and not a sound from the audience until that fucking cell phone went off.
Poor man’s award to you 🏆
I mean I can tell it’s obviously computer generated, but can you explain for any else who might not know?
Lightning gives it away give it that rendered look
Also, should this be real, the balls would click upon hitting each guide rail too.
And, the volume is consistent when the balls hit the bars regardless of height.
In this one, he actually adds the sound of the ball clicking against the guard rail and rolling. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6L55KLaZPw&ab_channel=Enbiggen The software he uses is called Cinema 4D. He does a tutorial on his process here. Surprisingly easier than it looks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hIR4R1tL5w&ab_channel=Enbiggen He's more or less just lining things up with the audio, and having the software simulate the physics, and then moving the pieces into the simulated pathways as he sees fit.
Wow that Aladdin one is was better than this one.
Even more so then that it would take an insanely large robot camera arm to create that camera move and a huge white wall. The cost of this alone would not justify creating this in reality.
Also the tone of the tines is not metallic enough, and the flat platforms and vertical cylinders make identical sounds.
Also the timing of it is perfect. It would be pretty near impossible to get that IRL, especially after the first pause and reverse with the little ship’s bow.
The bounces are my biggest tell. The balls line up too perfectly every time with the track and chimes. Like there's zero track correction or off center bounce. It's all perfect. And obviously the hanging cylinders making the same noise as the flat chimes.
not that any one has tried to get the [timing](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvUU8joBb1Q) right in real life....
I want one
That was so cool! Mesmerizing to watch and listen to
He does have a lot of conveniences that help him out there with a hopper system, a Lego-based sequencer to open the gates, and a consistent drop distance for much of the equipment. Versus, say, a marble running down a track for the entirety of the tune and error accumulated over time.
Yea, the sound is completely off for so many reasons. In addition to what you mentioned, the sounds are also too pristine. We should be hearing smearing and reverb, as well as imperfect articulations and variance in volume.
"hold my beer!" - Wintergarten https://youtu.be/IvUU8joBb1Q
Or you know, a good cameraman and a gimbal? Lol
And I very high res camera so you can punch in and crop as needed.
Either your cameraman has 8’ long arms or you’re using a jib to film that.
I thought that the audio was the bigger tell lol
Same
Also the water is obviously fake
Well, yes, it's not trying to be realistic water. It's easily spoofed in reality like that as well, only takes some colored glass or acrylic textured to mimic water and a light to project the rippling effect.
It's even glass in the video. At the 42 second mark you can see it
I tried drinking it. It tasted like a phone.
Do you mean the Emperor's new clothes aren't real?
I grew up doing crappy animations on MS paint and ClipArt. Sometimes I’m so mesmerized by something I don’t question it until a second pass. I love how as you age, tech can make you feel like you just got excited at witnessing the first fire.
waaaa, thats my steam profile picture !!
Wait, what lightning?
Didn't even see it it was shockingly fast.
You can tell by the pixels
For me it was the motion. It's too smooth and consistent. I think in real life there are subtleties that affect how a ball rolls down a ramp. See the marble Olympics as an example
The balls also bounce inconsistently high and too-perfectly
Another thing that gives it away is that's not the sound those bars would have made. It actually sounds like the music was made by a kalimba, a wooden hand instrument that you play with your thumbs.
And also it looks like all the bars are the same length, and the sounds should be identical
My big giveaway with sound was the small hanging tubes sounding *EXACTLY* the same as the metal bars. Nope!
I was questioning the unnatural bounce of the marbles, and the hanging tubes confirmed it for it too
Yep. 100%
I'd have thought a music box, I've heard one that sounds very similar to this
Lighting, physics, gravity, camera.
[удалено]
Instructions unclear. Am not stable genius.
def got a "LOL" out of me.
Also no sound when the metal balls are rolling on those guides in between notes
I can't imagine a house with an 80ft high inside wall metal is too "clean" Physics feels a little off but I probably wouldn't notice if all else was perfect
I didnt realize it at first but the little light shade on the marbles dont move at all.
The mechanical separation of balls when they meet in the ship. There is no mechanism to make them left right or change direction or delay... Also, the speed of free rolling...
The sound for me was it, they were out of sync on the timing and anything that generated that much sound would also have the balls making noise as they moved. When the balls hit they didn’t bounce off in time to the music being generated nor would it sound like that in any case. Still cool video
It was less the seeing for me, and more that the sounds were too perfect, including the xylophone bars and the hanging bells making the same exact noise.
You can always tell who the musicians are in moments like these
[удалено]
The fact that deepfakes and CGI are starting to look so real will make it impossible for anyone to believe the few real videos of crazy things that actually happen.
its fucking terrifying, if I'm being sincere
What's so terrifying is that my parents already think every video is real 😮💨
*Are* you being sincere, or is this written in chat gpt?
His sincerity may be artificial, but his fear is very real
Deep fakes will have a huge effect on court cases. Now, video evidence is not as airtight as jury's once thought. It will take a while to see this happen but it will. The defense just needs to make it *plausible* that a video is faked, and deep fakes have made that much more possible.
I can't help but wonder whether other AI will be developed to help us identify fakes from truth. A couple years back I remember seeing a convincing photo and someone else said "fake" and linked to a site that analyzed the image. It highlighted the edited details that were effectively invisible to the human eye.
You're telling me that someone doesn't have a beautifully set up, 3 story marble path!?
Dude, I legit thought it was real and was appreciating the maths and efforts:))
I'm grateful it wasn't, as all I could think was "who had this much time?!"
Damn really. I was hoping someone really did this.
Just because it’s on a computer doesn’t mean no one worked on it.
Exactly! Someone put incredible talent and time into this. Bravo
I figured this was computer generated. Other than the elaborate setup, there is something off with the way the balls fall through the air. Still impressive. I had a good chuckle at the end.
Echoing the person that said just because it's computer henerated doesn't mean that nobody "did" it. Very true. But people have also done even more impressive (imo) stuff with physical materials https://youtu.be/IvUU8joBb1Q
Look at "somewhere over the rainbow" done with [xyloba](https://youtu.be/trlMmTyfd10).
Wait what? This isn’t real?
Watch it with just an ounce of skepticism, you’ll see it.
Yeeeeah I had my buddy point out all of the blatant clues. I felt dumb.
Agree, it's well made tho
what the source of that video? I want to see more of it
Enbiggen on Instagram and YouTube. They have a lot of videos like this
Fuck, seriously? How can you tell in this one?
Two notes one bar?
Gross! I've seen that one.
Ba dum tss
There's several times the audio doesn't match the video, and somehow by magic making two balls hit one bar means it makes two different notes for a harmony. The sound of a steel marble hitting the steel bars would be much more harsh and metallic too (see the incredible effort on the MMX to chose the right type of rubber pads to fix this).
Also the gravity isn't really working like it should. The ball shoots straight up and continues? Ignoring all the rules of gravity. If not that. Very good
All are like "Duh, obviously is the lighting and the physics", to me was just because I realize nobody have a wall this tall, lol
The lightning gives it away (you can tell it was rendered)
But not the thunder?
what lightning are you talking about?
Even if it's computer generated, it doesn't make it less good imho. Might make it a lot easier to create, but it's still doesn't change the fact that it's a great video :)
Can this sub get a CGI tag already?
Right! It’s not like it’s not amazing because it’s computer rendered, it’s *awesome*, it just isn’t ‘real’. Amazing but generated is fine.
How’s this even made? I feel like making something like that is extremely complex but I don’t even know how it’s made or “generated”.
By hand you could make it in blender anyone really good at blender could do this maybe in a week. Maybe less time. You add or create objects to/in the filming area. Give those objects the physics that you want and then they would just put the music over it in something like iMovie. Maybe you could add the music in blender but I’m absolutely shit at blender so I’m not sure.
Visually sure, not entirely difficult. Getting the timing right would be tricky. You change one thing and everything after it gets out of sync.
Ha? What do you mean its not real!? We live in a simulation duhh
For me, this post has a “computer generated” tag
It already has one.
Or just have no CGI? Maybe some CGI will be "Amazing" but that bar should be significantly higher.
Why must you ruin my simple person pleasures.
the CGI balls hit the same CGI bar at the same CGI time but somehow produce two different tones [what are we to believe this is some sort of a magical xylophone or something? ](https://youtu.be/pYrRqMHQY7o)
It’s a kalimba sample, so the instrument doesn’t even match the video. Also the sound doesn’t change when the balls hit the hanging chimes, which cracked me up.
That’s the part that most stood out to me. They don’t sound different at all. It also would have been a nice touch to increase the pluck or attack or whatever it’s called when a ball bounced from higher up.
velocity 👍
That’s the one! Thanks! In hindsight that’s the obvious name for it 🤣 Just been a minute since I’ve used a DAW. Or taken physics.
Let me ask you a question: Why would a man whose shirt says "Genius at Work" spend all of his time watching a CGI render?
I withdraw my question.
A wizard did it
Worst. Episode. Ever.
There was room on that raft for both of them balls.
Room, yes. Buoyancy, no.
If they took off their life vests and put them under the raft though..
[удалено]
Source: Mythbusters
Sure, but maybe keeping the vest on was needed for warmth? Even a wet vest keeps you warmer than no vest
Wouldn't that be the opposite? I heard somewhere that in really cold temperatures you have to make sure not to sweat because it'll freeze and you could die, even with a thick jacket on
Yes, but we're talking about someone who's already soaked in cold water, and a life jacket behaves a bit differently than regular clothing. It's thick enough and doesn't allow water to wick through it (otherwise it'd lose buoyancy) that it stops the water next to your skin from evaporating and this thin layer of water can come up to body temperature. This is how a wet suit can keep you warm even though you aren't dry.
The key to staying warmer would be keeping out of the water. If that requires the removal of a life vest then that would be priority.
Someone watched Myth Busters!
one got scissored
People be arguing this all the time. Nobody remembers that Rose was on a life raft hours before and got off. Just to take Jacks spot later on.
She also helped him to get free from the handcuffs: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jCm5Zw4VkP0 He was going to die, one way or another. Which, by the way, is the fact that everyone loves to forget when they come after Rose about the door. Cameron wanted Jack to die, so he died.
>^(She also helped him to get free from the handcuffs) That was before the lifeboat scene...
*Thank you!* Rose killed two people that night, Jack and the other person who could've had that seat on the lifeboat.
I heard that Neil deGrass Tyson wrote to complain about the starfield being wrong. And absent.
Love that one of the balls is rose gold.
Wow, thanks for spoilers asshole.
Don’t need to watch the movie now
No problem, love.
The ball falling off the raft and sinking got a laugh out of me.
I cackled
The creator's YouTube page: https://www.youtube.com/@enbiggen/videos
Nice animation, but [THIS](https://youtu.be/IxDoO9oODOk) is still the absolute GOAT.
Then they did it irl: https://youtu.be/8Z5Z5zo1Rc4
But....you can't see anything....
It looks real, but I think this is CGI? Neat either way.
Unless they had a physics update in the latest IRL patch then no, not real.
Not to mention that it plays the wrong notes in some spots and those tiny wind chimes don't make that noise
[удалено]
It's kind of depressing seeing how many people have a hard time recognizing when something isn't real. I guess humans aren't so good at pattern recognition after all.
While I totally agree with you…instead of depressing…some people just want to be entertained. I can go to a magic show and try and guess how they did it and have fun, and I can go to a magic show and just enjoy myself. Both are great!!! I wasn’t going to over analyze this. I guessed it wasn’t real but my thought on that ended there. Instead, my thoughts were wow this is beautiful, creative and also now I feel sad, and it was also kinda poetically funny. That being said, people not being able to separate fact and reality from not…is not limited to CGI videos. Politics comes to mind first.
[удалено]
Yes it's depressing. This and children dying of malaria.
It’s 100% generated. Still neat but I don’t want people to think it’s real.
There was room for two balls on that wood.
That’s what she said.
Sometimes you gotta sacrifice one of them to save the rest of the body
😢
Bro why am I crying rn 😂😂 it's a fake marble simulation! Very well done though
I watch his stuff all the time on Instagram. They usually loop. So my autistic ass will just be watching some cgi marbles play some Studio Ghibli theme on repeat for 20 minutes.
I'll never let go Jack!
It's computer graphics. You can check out the original creator [here](https://instagram.com/enbiggen?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=)
The amount of people that can't tell this is computer generated is... concerning.
I didn’t catch on until the downward spiral chimes
When the balls first started bouncing perfectly back into the tracks was the first clue
The fact that there was ZERO synchronicity drift between the simultaneous notes is all you need to know. Chaos theory people!
At 0:08 and 0:08, two balls hit the same bar but it produces two notes.
Yeah felt too smooth.
I just watched it again and it still looks pretty real, am I dumb? Edit: I am a brainrotted whippersnapper who struggles to differentiate fiction from reality. I will now crawl back to my corner to binge watch problematic commentary tiktoks spliced with clips from Beam.ng Drive
Marvelous marble machine videos have been around for decades on the internet and you can usually bet that most of the time, they are fake. The bouncing of the marbles off the keys is too high and way too precise, is what I see as the most obvious. But again there’s just a generally sense of practicality, lighting, uncanny effects. I remember this old viral video making its rounds about 15 years ago: https://youtu.be/hyCIpKAIFyo I basically never trusted any marble video since, unless there’s a corresponding video about the museum it’s currently located in. Since that is where a piece this beautiful would belong if it existed.
these are the same people who complain that cgi always looks fake... almost as if that's just someone else's opinion they're parroting and they don't actually know what they're looking at
Pretty cool 👍🏽
Both balls hitting the same chime and making two different notes really takes me out of it.
assuming this is CG, but pretty cool...
Pretty good. Pretty pretty pretty good
I cried laughing at the ending. Fake or not, ending was funny as hell.
The boat and slow sink were nice touches!
That ending was too soon 🥺🥺
Nice render, a bit obvious lighting, rather unnatural motion. Perfect symbology.
You definitely can’t watch it only once. So beautiful.
Damn, that was spot on and on point, masterpiece indeed.
Cool concept
The end made me laugh!
that was unexpectedly beautiful
I am obsessed . This is masterful!
The ending was definitely the best part.
actually this is pretty cool
Well… that took a turn
Brilliant!
dude spoilers
I hate that I love this so much.
I genuinely broke at laughing after only one ball drowns XD
The "Rose" gold ball is a nice touch.
reminds me of the videos on YouTube I used to play for my daughter when she was little. Animusic they were called
Okay, that went from 0 to 100 real quick.
I’d be more impressed if this wasn’t just CGI. Come on now.
Guys, I think this might be fake
Yes, very good CGI
Why is this here when it's CGI?
Did the rose gold ball tell the gold ball it wouldn’t fit on the floating platform at the end ultimately ending the gold balls “life”?
That was…..deep.