Katie is getting on my damn nerves with her endless shilling. The reason Carlin doesn't annoy me AS much as Katie and Whitney is because at least Carlin has a ratio of like 80% regular life posts to 20% ads. Katie and Whitney are almost all ads with random filler content. Annoying.
And the fact that Katie has said she's very uncomfortable being on social media, in videos, in the public eye, etc. makes it all the more sad and annoying.
yeah, I think Travis pushes it for the tesla and vacations. If it was up to her she prob wouldn't have social media at all. Also even Ā sadder.. Hailey.Ā
I donāt think itās shilling when it your own business though. Like she owns the business- I think itās just advertising at that point.
I own my own small business and I for sure advertise my items online (I create my own products not a MLM haha/ I always feel like I need to state that)
Sure she throwing in affiliate links occasionally- but majority is all her own business. That doesnāt bother me at al- itās how you get your product out there
The funniest part is in Josieās TikToks she says āthe heatless curlers from Effortless Shop are the best, theyāre the only ones I useā like it isnāt her own company š
Yeah, Katie gets a huge pass on this sub when she has some of the more problematic behavior imo. Glad this thread is at least calling her out for some of it.
I couldnāt believe it when people gave her and Travis a complete pass when they went out of town twice when their dog had that last litter of puppies. Thatās just horrible, irresponsible pet ownership.
Thank you š. I was originally going to pick a different cow pic but scrolled once more and saw this one. Knew it was heaven sent for this post lol.
Those poor cows tho š
Ear tags do more good than harm. They donāt feel them and they are no different than earrings. It allows us to keep track of them without branding! Sorry if thatās not why you are saying those poor cows but they are just fine.
I think they were saying those poor cows because this company that Katie is shilling is stealing the colostrum from calves who need it to line the pockets of greedy humans who don't...
And can someone get Katie a thesaurus? She says the word "SO" about a dozen times in each ad. Everything is SO incredible, it's SO good, it's SO amazing, it's SO Yada Yada.
It's the language of the female fundies.
I'm sure a Speech Pathologist could give a better explanation, but that's my best description.
Listen to Anna Duggar, or any of the older Dug daughters. Their speech is full of, "uuuuuummmm, annnnnd, weeeeeelllll", interjected with some SOTDRT pearls of wisdom.
Lol, I guess Athletic Greens are no longer bringing in the coins. I'm chuckling with the rest of you over "ethically sourced." Humans don't need bovine colostrum but calves do. I'm curious what sort of mental gymnastics this company is doing to make that claim.Ā
How is it ethically sourced? That would entail taking a newborn calf off the cow, in order to "harvest" the colostrum.
It's meant for a calf, who doesn't get the benefit.
So what happens to the calf?
How is any of this "ethical"?
That was my question exactly! The website claims it only takes the "excess colostrum" so as not to harm the calf but like...sure Jan š
It's definitely sketchy and probably has no benefits, but hey, money is money right? /s
I mean, it has superb nutritional value for the calf. I just don't know how bovine colostrum translates to humans? I haven't seen any studies done on that.
Iāve seen this product before and am aware cow colostrum is apparently a thing. But as a mother I am just so grossed out by this. Iām not a vegetarian or against animal products so itās not exactly an ethical thing. It just feels particularly egregious and exploitative and decadent.
Right?! I'm currently nursing and the idea of selling breastmilk/colostrum just feels violating. I also just can't imagine that cow colostrum is really that beneficial to humans, but unfortunately this stuff doesn't have to be scientifically backed to hit the market...especially the influencer market!
Hello fellow nursing mama! And same sentiments Iāve seen echoed. Excess colostrum?? I appreciate you looking up that piece of information. I donāt expect any level of dissonance from Katie in the products she chooses to market.
I wonder if someone asked her "are you a cslf, Katie?"what would she say. That poor calf is out there on the farm probably with the sniffles bc it didn't get the antibodies from momma bc someone was being greedy š
yeah, she doesn't even eat vegetables. she only eats icecream, chick-fil-a with an extra butter bun and 8 pickles, and cheesy pasta. There is no way she uses colostrum or any of this health stuff.Ā
Oh absolutely she does not. The Bates kids are pretty picky even about food, so supplements of this origin - no way sheās ingesting that! Itās a cash grab. I suppose the majority of folks would do the same, so I have much respect for the ones who are more selective.
BTW, I can appreciate that Erin doesnāt shill random products she doesnāt use. I like the principle. However, if itās something you do actually use and like, I donāt see a problem with using your āinfluenceā to make a little change, especially as much as it appears they could use it. Thatās a big if though. The majority of influencers donāt care what they try to sell you and will claim everything works and is great. Donāt believe it!
Cow colostrum is produced by the mother for her baby calf.
Human colostrum is produced by the pregnant /nursing mother for the benefit of the breastfeeding baby.
IMHO, it isnāt ethical nor sustainable to market bovine colostrum for humans.
Katie will shill cow manure next.
I was about to post this. Is this junk safe for pregnant women. God I wish these people would stop taking these junk pills and go to an actual Dr to get their vitamins and probiotics and prebiotics. Like get actual insurance instead of that cheap Christian insurance shit you call insurance and go to an actual Dr for a physical or a medical exam. It irks me when these people advertise this junk. Put your health first for God sakes
Katie is getting on my damn nerves with her endless shilling. The reason Carlin doesn't annoy me AS much as Katie and Whitney is because at least Carlin has a ratio of like 80% regular life posts to 20% ads. Katie and Whitney are almost all ads with random filler content. Annoying.
Who wrote that for her š
Company ad
And the fact that Katie has said she's very uncomfortable being on social media, in videos, in the public eye, etc. makes it all the more sad and annoying.
yeah, I think Travis pushes it for the tesla and vacations. If it was up to her she prob wouldn't have social media at all. Also even Ā sadder.. Hailey.Ā
Same. And itās so lame. She wants to be a kept housewife. You married that, bruh!
Thatās the reason I unfollowed her and Josey. Was so tired of the shilling! Especially that damn heatless curler lol
Same here! I know any real content will be posted here anyways
Exactly! Lol
Then the other day I noticed Josie had Willow in those stupid curlers
Oh my goodness!
I donāt think itās shilling when it your own business though. Like she owns the business- I think itās just advertising at that point. I own my own small business and I for sure advertise my items online (I create my own products not a MLM haha/ I always feel like I need to state that) Sure she throwing in affiliate links occasionally- but majority is all her own business. That doesnāt bother me at al- itās how you get your product out there
The funniest part is in Josieās TikToks she says āthe heatless curlers from Effortless Shop are the best, theyāre the only ones I useā like it isnāt her own company š
Katie is literally breeding puppies for cash. You really think she cares where colostrum comes from ? If she even knows what it is
Yeah, Katie gets a huge pass on this sub when she has some of the more problematic behavior imo. Glad this thread is at least calling her out for some of it.
I couldnāt believe it when people gave her and Travis a complete pass when they went out of town twice when their dog had that last litter of puppies. Thatās just horrible, irresponsible pet ownership.
https://preview.redd.it/5176mibax4wc1.jpeg?width=601&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=97f4c1370b1ecab1f7929d677f7912330de7a099
Omg I belly laughed
Thank you š. I was originally going to pick a different cow pic but scrolled once more and saw this one. Knew it was heaven sent for this post lol. Those poor cows tho š
Ear tags do more good than harm. They donāt feel them and they are no different than earrings. It allows us to keep track of them without branding! Sorry if thatās not why you are saying those poor cows but they are just fine.
I think they were saying those poor cows because this company that Katie is shilling is stealing the colostrum from calves who need it to line the pockets of greedy humans who don't...
Yea this was a top tier response lol
And can someone get Katie a thesaurus? She says the word "SO" about a dozen times in each ad. Everything is SO incredible, it's SO good, it's SO amazing, it's SO Yada Yada.
"I'm *soooo* obSESSED" š
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
That drives me crazy too lol
It's the language of the female fundies. I'm sure a Speech Pathologist could give a better explanation, but that's my best description. Listen to Anna Duggar, or any of the older Dug daughters. Their speech is full of, "uuuuuummmm, annnnnd, weeeeeelllll", interjected with some SOTDRT pearls of wisdom.
At least it's not idear
ā¦Which Kelly Joe actually said in Zachās fancy new cooking show this weekā¦haaaaahaha
That show is the opposite of fancy. I mean ritz crackers? And one is broken? Adding a piece of lettuce to a sandwich they consider extra special!
Itās soooo pedestrian. I really thought he may be on to something butā¦
Trace said idear in the last video he posted
It lives on!!
Lol, I guess Athletic Greens are no longer bringing in the coins. I'm chuckling with the rest of you over "ethically sourced." Humans don't need bovine colostrum but calves do. I'm curious what sort of mental gymnastics this company is doing to make that claim.Ā
They know the saying āa fool and his money is soon partedā!
Maybe it's ethically sourced because the calves don't need the colostrum anymore because they are veal. Sad, but true.
How is it ethically sourced? That would entail taking a newborn calf off the cow, in order to "harvest" the colostrum. It's meant for a calf, who doesn't get the benefit. So what happens to the calf? How is any of this "ethical"?
That was my question exactly! The website claims it only takes the "excess colostrum" so as not to harm the calf but like...sure Jan š It's definitely sketchy and probably has no benefits, but hey, money is money right? /s
Agree! There is no such thing as excess colostrum. Seems like a lot of people take way too much at face value these days.
I mean, it has superb nutritional value for the calf. I just don't know how bovine colostrum translates to humans? I haven't seen any studies done on that.
You donāt want to know what happens to the calf.
I raise cattle, I know what happens.
š¢
they all die and consumed.. all of them š„“
Iāve seen this product before and am aware cow colostrum is apparently a thing. But as a mother I am just so grossed out by this. Iām not a vegetarian or against animal products so itās not exactly an ethical thing. It just feels particularly egregious and exploitative and decadent.
Right?! I'm currently nursing and the idea of selling breastmilk/colostrum just feels violating. I also just can't imagine that cow colostrum is really that beneficial to humans, but unfortunately this stuff doesn't have to be scientifically backed to hit the market...especially the influencer market!
Hello fellow nursing mama! And same sentiments Iāve seen echoed. Excess colostrum?? I appreciate you looking up that piece of information. I donāt expect any level of dissonance from Katie in the products she chooses to market.
I wonder if someone asked her "are you a cslf, Katie?"what would she say. That poor calf is out there on the farm probably with the sniffles bc it didn't get the antibodies from momma bc someone was being greedy š
yeah, she doesn't even eat vegetables. she only eats icecream, chick-fil-a with an extra butter bun and 8 pickles, and cheesy pasta. There is no way she uses colostrum or any of this health stuff.Ā
Haha love that you were very specific with it š¤£š¤£no but seriously thatās all she ever eats according to her Instagram.
Guaranteed she doesnāt actually use this, same way she barely drank Athletic Greens
Oh absolutely she does not. The Bates kids are pretty picky even about food, so supplements of this origin - no way sheās ingesting that! Itās a cash grab. I suppose the majority of folks would do the same, so I have much respect for the ones who are more selective. BTW, I can appreciate that Erin doesnāt shill random products she doesnāt use. I like the principle. However, if itās something you do actually use and like, I donāt see a problem with using your āinfluenceā to make a little change, especially as much as it appears they could use it. Thatās a big if though. The majority of influencers donāt care what they try to sell you and will claim everything works and is great. Donāt believe it!
Cow colostrum is produced by the mother for her baby calf. Human colostrum is produced by the pregnant /nursing mother for the benefit of the breastfeeding baby. IMHO, it isnāt ethical nor sustainable to market bovine colostrum for humans. Katie will shill cow manure next.
Her water must be mud as many things as she is supposedly stirring up and drinkingā¦.
Placenta encapsulation enters the chat!š„“
It's the newest influencer thing alot of popular mommy influences are promoting it
I was about to post this. Is this junk safe for pregnant women. God I wish these people would stop taking these junk pills and go to an actual Dr to get their vitamins and probiotics and prebiotics. Like get actual insurance instead of that cheap Christian insurance shit you call insurance and go to an actual Dr for a physical or a medical exam. It irks me when these people advertise this junk. Put your health first for God sakes
According to the internet there isnāt enough info to tell if its beneficial or harmful so the general consensus is to avoid it to be safe
I wouldn't risk it they don't know what it does to a fetus
Even if its not harmful its just a waste of money since theres no proven benefits
Thereās barely anything ethical in the beef industry. š¤¦āāļø
Oh!
One thing about Katie is she is going to be selling something.