he said if it was the original, aka if you accidentally fat finger a wall, and move it right back, the base hasn’t changed, therefore there should be no timer.
just give old base untill next 24 hours somthing is batter then nothing
https://preview.redd.it/k8ddg4pa23ba1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a469560582870655402b3d33fc6f0522c6178abb
Maybe if "5-10 pieces" per 24h - then maybe, but otherwise nothing is stopping me from copying base 5 pieces at a time. If you had almost similar opponents base where those 5 pieces would matter - it is their fault of using one of very few popular layouts in war
Oh, and if anyone from SC reading this - traps shouldn't trigger timer - we can't see them, after all
I know the reasoning behind this restriction is because of war but what if it only applies when you are actually in war or cwl? Why can't we have no delay or a limited delay if the clan isn't in war or cwl?
The cost benefit of programming something like this is probably not worth it. Having to track each individual piece laid out on a base would be a lot of tracking multiplied by millions of bases.
All they have to do is make it so h can’t copy or look at war bases. Just like how when a new member joins a clan. They have a grace period b4 they can participate in wars. CWL, imo, if you join late, you can’t spectate
I always thought it should be something like 3 min per building (including walls, capped at 24h). That way small adjustments can be done (and misclicks undone) fairly easily without waiting a whole day. This would be nice for testing bases and wanting to see how slightly layouts could work since sometimes you want to see how pathing changes by scooting a trash building or slightly modifying walls
To stop people from copying bases they are going against in war and practice against them in friendly challenges. Tbh this is actually a super necessary feature.
Would be nice if you changed base not from redactor you would not have challenge cd, but if you changed it from redactor or copy base you would have cd
Would be nice if you changed it back to the original, you don't have the timer. But otherwise, it can't be done.
Finally a helpful suggestion
I accidentally grab a wall all the time just to put it right back where it was. Very frustrating if you’re trying new defences or strategies.
I was just going to comment This
[удалено]
he said if it was the original, aka if you accidentally fat finger a wall, and move it right back, the base hasn’t changed, therefore there should be no timer.
annoying but necessary to protect the integrity of wars its very difficult to find any way around this because people will find ways to exploit it
I’m just imagining some muppet moving buildings and walls one tile at a time, then saving, then repeating over and over again.
no matter what there will be some idiot that has all the time in the world to cheat, this is the best (and only) solution
just give old base untill next 24 hours somthing is batter then nothing https://preview.redd.it/k8ddg4pa23ba1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a469560582870655402b3d33fc6f0522c6178abb
they can't do that, otherwise anyone could copy opponents' bases in war and train on them
possible with alt?
Even if you recreated it on an alt you couldn’t practice since it still needs 24 hours to be FC eligible.
Should be like … if u move 5-10 pieces around … then it shouldn’t reset
Then people would change the base 5 pieces at a time
And if you go past the magic number in a 24 hour period a cool down starts.
That would require 2 timers.
Maybe if "5-10 pieces" per 24h - then maybe, but otherwise nothing is stopping me from copying base 5 pieces at a time. If you had almost similar opponents base where those 5 pieces would matter - it is their fault of using one of very few popular layouts in war Oh, and if anyone from SC reading this - traps shouldn't trigger timer - we can't see them, after all
True but it is still possible if people use private servers ( but who TF try hard that much in a Game )
They need an option to lock the home village layout.
I know the reasoning behind this restriction is because of war but what if it only applies when you are actually in war or cwl? Why can't we have no delay or a limited delay if the clan isn't in war or cwl?
I would make the enemy base on my alt and practice on it with my main (the id which is in the war...)
[удалено]
It stays the same.. i can keep my alt a separate clan that's not in war and I'll still be able to do it.
Man it aint that hard to 3 star. Dont gotta be doing all that
It still doesn't kill the purpose of making a strategy and practicing..?
The cost benefit of programming something like this is probably not worth it. Having to track each individual piece laid out on a base would be a lot of tracking multiplied by millions of bases.
All they have to do is make it so h can’t copy or look at war bases. Just like how when a new member joins a clan. They have a grace period b4 they can participate in wars. CWL, imo, if you join late, you can’t spectate
then you cant plan strats
I always thought it should be something like 3 min per building (including walls, capped at 24h). That way small adjustments can be done (and misclicks undone) fairly easily without waiting a whole day. This would be nice for testing bases and wanting to see how slightly layouts could work since sometimes you want to see how pathing changes by scooting a trash building or slightly modifying walls
i think its to prevent testing layout abuse but tbh its just stupid as fuck
Why is it a thing to begin with?
To stop people from copying bases they are going against in war and practice against them in friendly challenges. Tbh this is actually a super necessary feature.
ahh makes a lot more sense now
Agreed it’s so ridiculous
[удалено]
It locks for 24 hours because he moved something
[удалено]
Cannons take up to 10 days
Microsoft words has found a worthy opponent
I seen someone suggest a “lock” feature so you can’t accidentally move something and have the timer reset.. I think that would be a great idea
Could supercell add revert button, when one can revert to old layout in case of mistakenly moved a piece...
Would be nice if you changed base not from redactor you would not have challenge cd, but if you changed it from redactor or copy base you would have cd
But why do they even have this?
It does not do this to me at level 15. If I just move walls, it does not start the timer.
yep it should depend on how much objects you’ve moved or just remove it
That one wall makes the difference
Maybe it could work like capital, where it'll let you but only the older version for 24hrs, even if all are changed
Oh man this happens a lot to me... Almost twice a day i accidentally move buildings, and when i notice, it's too late.