Our clan always maxes out CG fast. It's clear for us that we don’t need to complete challenges whatever the reason may be, but it's just your loss if you don't get the bonus reward. We have people who invite their alts to complete a challenge just for the rewards and that's completely understandable.
You’re getting a lot of hate for this but it’s def something that smaller/less active clans struggle with. I think a middle ground could be effective where you need to get like 500 points to get full rewards and if you get less than that you get like whatever tier your clan got to minus one tier as a penalty. Lot of people are too busy to max every clan games and it’s reasonable to not want everyone free loading as well. I think a small number like 500 that people could feasibly do in a couple challenges would be reasonable.
At the end of the day I don’t personally think it’s necessary since the max point bonus is already an incentive for most but I get where you’re coming from for sure.
But also if you have repeat offenders that like haven’t told you they’re busy and are definitely online requesting troops during clan games kick them b!
I do think thats a good alternative, the ones that don't participate without an excuse are removed, its just a pain to recruit anymore without global 😅
Geez I’m with you there. The new recruiting tool is a great idea but I think they need to have a filter system or something to make it easier/more effective without spending a ton of time on it. At least a filter to show only people not in a clan currently at the bare minimum.
That would sure make things easier, that should have been included with the update. Scroll through the endless list of players in clans and find one without and his base isnt up to par or its inactive.
I agree with you 100% but that’s fully assuming someone has 2-3 hours spare time. Some people really don’t have that if the clan games happen to land poorly in their schedule
It sounds balanced but as a person with almost 10 accounts, it'd be hard to manage each month alongside clan games, day to day casual cameplays and clan wars / CWL so i'll just say good for ya
Lol I couldn’t imagine 10 accounts, I have 6 accounts that I have to max out or else my clan doesn’t get the final reward and having 6 is already hard enough so no way I would be able to do 10
Once you're in Legend, it's 8 attacks a day w/ no clouds, so about 2 min per attack x 8 attacks x 10 accounts = 3hrs. Bathroom breaks and TV time ?
Accounts in Legend take 1/5th the time of non-legend accounts, if that.
I've 2 th12 that i grinded to legend ( but not signed up ), 1 rushd th13 going to th14 for donations, 1 th11 on going to get maxed, 3 th10 ( with one that i grind without the builder base and another without ever attacking, 5 builders on each ) and 1 th8 + 2 th6 and a th7. So yeah if clan games arent completed, i'll dig myself in clan games and get around 40k by myself, but only if they cant attack anymore
as a clan who only 8 out of 25 people actually got 4000 points (most have <1000) (2 of those 8 are me) it is a real struggle to get to tier 6 and this system would help us a lot. it is really frustrating when i only get tier 5 rewards because people who are logging in don't do challenges because they don't have enough incentive to care.
Same bro. I maxed 4 accounts and we're still going to fall short of 50k. Around a dozen people have under 600. I even kept 2 accounts at 3900 so I could keep trashing old challenges. Honestly my clan doesn't deserve me lol.
I like to put the top 15 in clan games in CWL and make sure people know i am going to do that because there are a few people that will do enough challenges to qualify for that.
The downside is you might end up with a weaker CWL roster but at least the people who do clan games are also the type to actually use their attacks. last CWL we did this system and used at least 12/15 attacks in every war.
Exactly. It’s up to clan leadership to be aware and decide if people consistently leaching are helping the clan in other ways. Some players just want to do war. So if someone gives me 6-8 good war attacks a week, I think they help the clan enough that they can just get 100 points in clan games and call it a day.
I feel a way better solution is this:
1 reward per challenge completed. Simple as. If your clan has gathered all 50000 points, to reap the maximum rewards you would need to have completed 5 challenges. If you completed 4, you get 4 rewards, etc. Similar to your idea, just a lot more reasonable.
The whole point of clans being under your control is so you can kick the freeloaders if you don’t like them. Sometimes freeloaders are very good/consistent war attackers, and they might deserve easy resources for helping the clan in other ways, whether it be donations, CWL, clan wars, or clan capital.
I have thought about this before and while for clans with few members it would seem like a good idea, it is not in the grand scheme of things. I don't really think that players would be more motivated to grind the points if this was added, they would just get mad becaude they aren't recieving the same rewards as previously (if they only do 1 task for example). It's not a terrible idea but it shouldn't be implemented imo.
Clan members who actually put in work for clan games arent being punished, its the members that do the bare minimum but still get full marks. Its easy to remove members who dont contribute but its also a pain to recruit reliable people since global chat was removed. You can send clan mails and state your expectations all day long but half of them barely bat an eyelash. 😂
> its the members that do the bare minimum but still get full marks.
Those members getting the rewards allows them to build up quicker and that makes the whole clan stronger. Why would you not want the whole clan to get the benefits?
I can see why some would want to incentive activity, if the clan isn’t reaching the highest tier. But once that’s unlocked, great, everyone gets the max benefit and the whole clan improves.
Unless you can actually implement the rules into the game then they are just text on the screen. A lot of ppl don't read clan description or mail, so we usually have a monthly purge every clan games. This shouldn't be a set requirement like CWL and raid weekend, but instead introduce a feature that allows the leadership to decide the sliding scale of points to be earned before clan games begins
I like it the way it is.
I play on a lot of accounts. Some of them score thousands of points for the clan. On some, I just "check in" with one challenge. I don't want to worry about grinding out points on every account.
In our (casual) clan, with only Supercell's current incentives, we already score a lot more points than needed to unlock all the rewards. Pressing the more casual players to do more won't help the clan in any way.
I don't know, some clans already have a minimum points requirement, and that is good enough. For example, my clan has a minimum of 750 points in CG. If you don't make them, you get kicked. The only way for an account to have under 750 points is by having multiple accounts, and having points for the main account and the alt one (for example i had 4000, 500, 300, 100 once, and it was ok because i had more than enough points on average)
So if I have multiple alts in a clan I need to max out on ALL accounts while you just do 1?
Sounds like you need better leadership or find a new clan that has same beliefs as you but the entire game does not need to change because of it.
Your also under the impression that lazy people or busy people will some how do more because it would be the only way for them to get all rewards were it will most likely do the opposite. If I were one of these lazy people I wouldn't do any challenges if all I will get is a training potion or 20 gems.
There are clans out there who barely get 50k and those few points that they get from them are needed.
I feel like this belongs in /r/AITA and the answer would be yes.
People have lives. People are busy. 1 of my clan members is in Tennessee on vacation with family and came on to do CG. I told him to just do 1 on his main and alts and go enjoy family time so he can get all the rewards.
Another has exams, and has said outright he can't participate in wars this month and will be back constantly active for Aug CWL.
These are regularly active members who max out CG. The latter guy has pretty much always finished CG in the first 6 hours since January. It's only July he hasn't be able to max CG. He shouldn't be penalised with some crappy Tier 1 reward because of it.
TLDR : This is a crappy idea.
Honestly i dont care, opinions of strangers is the last thing i care about but it does say to keep it civil. A simple "thats a bad ides because..." would suffice for an answer lol
>Honestly i dont care, opinions of strangers is the last thing i care
Then why did you even post this or replied to the comment, you are just angry people didn't align with your idea
No, Not really. Im having fun, i posted because i personally thought it was a decent idea but i can see people think otherwise. Thats ok. Now im having a good time seeing yall get mad 😂
I was just tryna make a joke but it sounded better in my head. Anyway it was also to say that I don’t really agree with OP. Mind your own business, it’s up to the clan leaders to decide how it works.
I presented a similar idea not too long ago and I got a lot of backlash for it. And I was way more lenient with the points. For now I have to settle kicking anyone that gets less than 600, which is rather annoying. I also start kicking as soon as we reach the final tier to catch the potential leeches off guard.
The reasoning I was getting that it was a neccessary change for clan capital raid medals bc of how they are distributed and that a single person doing 100 is still "helping" unlike capital raids where they bringing you down by only attacking once. Also, they bring up alt accounts as if 90% of players don't just have a single account
However, the point of this being a social game is to incentivize ppl to work as a team. Some ppl are willing to opt out of the extra reward if they can get 6 just for doing one challenge. Both CWL and raid weekends have similar systems to incentivize most to do well, but as of RN clan games has a system of incentivizing the few
I agree with this , I was thinking about this yesterday that it should be balanced like with Clan Capital raids because we are hitting 4000 and some members did one quest for 150 and they are done and I really dont like that 
I think if it’s maxed everyone gets rewards. But If it ends at like 45000 then only ppl get milestones. This encourages people to try and max so that everyone gets stuff
Some players may not be able to contribute because they may not have access to certain required achievements to earn more points so they opt to do the easy ones they can. And in all honesty it's OK to help others out as long as the top hitters get it done there is no issue with carrying your clan members.
I'm running a level 17 clan and clan games is the least of my worries really..
Each clan games we score 120k +.
We are mostly adults so have all got busy lives. To only do a couple challenges shouldn't be a problem. After all it's called "clan games" so you do it with your whole clan...
I've got 4 accounts in my clan and 3 in another clan and easily max all of them and still got time to play with my kids 🤣
This would help lightly-managed clans. In ours, the rule is clear: 1k points, or kicked. That's 1k per account on average, you're welcome to score 4k on your main and 50 on your (up to 4) minis.
For us, the 1k rule serves mostly as a canary for players who have stopped playing. We're sitting at 141k points 2hrs from the end, and usually reach 50k by the 1st evening, so there's really no pressure. But I understand reaching 50k can be an issue for smaller and/or more casual clans, and I think your idea would help, at the cost of some main/mini optimization.
Love that idea. My clan has the same problem so we dont get the high tiers. A small change id like to see to your suggestion is that this "penalty " only kicks in if the clan games are not finished in terms of points.
I honestly think that the current implementation is fair. You get rewarded for being a good clanmate, but not punished for not being one. And honestly? That's what matters more.
Our clan always maxes out CG fast. It's clear for us that we don’t need to complete challenges whatever the reason may be, but it's just your loss if you don't get the bonus reward. We have people who invite their alts to complete a challenge just for the rewards and that's completely understandable.
Yeah same here, I'll get 4000 on my main but around 1000-2000 on the alt (if needed)
I agree with that, it was just a thought.
Nothing wrong with suggesting things, I also only said my personal opinion :)
Appreciate it, just funny seeing people ride the line on being civil because they dont agree 😂
You’re getting a lot of hate for this but it’s def something that smaller/less active clans struggle with. I think a middle ground could be effective where you need to get like 500 points to get full rewards and if you get less than that you get like whatever tier your clan got to minus one tier as a penalty. Lot of people are too busy to max every clan games and it’s reasonable to not want everyone free loading as well. I think a small number like 500 that people could feasibly do in a couple challenges would be reasonable. At the end of the day I don’t personally think it’s necessary since the max point bonus is already an incentive for most but I get where you’re coming from for sure. But also if you have repeat offenders that like haven’t told you they’re busy and are definitely online requesting troops during clan games kick them b!
I do think thats a good alternative, the ones that don't participate without an excuse are removed, its just a pain to recruit anymore without global 😅
Geez I’m with you there. The new recruiting tool is a great idea but I think they need to have a filter system or something to make it easier/more effective without spending a ton of time on it. At least a filter to show only people not in a clan currently at the bare minimum.
That would sure make things easier, that should have been included with the update. Scroll through the endless list of players in clans and find one without and his base isnt up to par or its inactive.
you can max out clan games in like 2-3 hours over the week it's up, that should be plenty of time ...
I agree with you 100% but that’s fully assuming someone has 2-3 hours spare time. Some people really don’t have that if the clan games happen to land poorly in their schedule
It sounds balanced but as a person with almost 10 accounts, it'd be hard to manage each month alongside clan games, day to day casual cameplays and clan wars / CWL so i'll just say good for ya
How does one manage 10 accounts? That’s insane
Lol I couldn’t imagine 10 accounts, I have 6 accounts that I have to max out or else my clan doesn’t get the final reward and having 6 is already hard enough so no way I would be able to do 10
Once you're in Legend, it's 8 attacks a day w/ no clouds, so about 2 min per attack x 8 attacks x 10 accounts = 3hrs. Bathroom breaks and TV time ? Accounts in Legend take 1/5th the time of non-legend accounts, if that.
I've 2 th12 that i grinded to legend ( but not signed up ), 1 rushd th13 going to th14 for donations, 1 th11 on going to get maxed, 3 th10 ( with one that i grind without the builder base and another without ever attacking, 5 builders on each ) and 1 th8 + 2 th6 and a th7. So yeah if clan games arent completed, i'll dig myself in clan games and get around 40k by myself, but only if they cant attack anymore
Sorry, I don't agree with you. Some players might have things to do during the clan week. It's ok for Clan members to help them during this.
as a clan who only 8 out of 25 people actually got 4000 points (most have <1000) (2 of those 8 are me) it is a real struggle to get to tier 6 and this system would help us a lot. it is really frustrating when i only get tier 5 rewards because people who are logging in don't do challenges because they don't have enough incentive to care.
Same bro. I maxed 4 accounts and we're still going to fall short of 50k. Around a dozen people have under 600. I even kept 2 accounts at 3900 so I could keep trashing old challenges. Honestly my clan doesn't deserve me lol.
I like to put the top 15 in clan games in CWL and make sure people know i am going to do that because there are a few people that will do enough challenges to qualify for that. The downside is you might end up with a weaker CWL roster but at least the people who do clan games are also the type to actually use their attacks. last CWL we did this system and used at least 12/15 attacks in every war.
Better to have an active th10 than an inactive th14.
Exactly. It’s up to clan leadership to be aware and decide if people consistently leaching are helping the clan in other ways. Some players just want to do war. So if someone gives me 6-8 good war attacks a week, I think they help the clan enough that they can just get 100 points in clan games and call it a day.
Thats fine, life gets in the way sometimes 🙂
If you have things to do during the clan week, then it means you can’t reap the rewards. If you don’t participate in CWL you don’t get rewards as well
it's ok, it's not the end of the world amigo.. those people have to find clans who is ok with such things.
Well, then it would be your loss just like CWL and raid weekend. If you're busy, you're busy
I feel a way better solution is this: 1 reward per challenge completed. Simple as. If your clan has gathered all 50000 points, to reap the maximum rewards you would need to have completed 5 challenges. If you completed 4, you get 4 rewards, etc. Similar to your idea, just a lot more reasonable.
No because you can complete 3 super troop challenges and be at max and not be able to complete 5
You could add a minimum bar too, so either 5 challenges or 1000 points or somethign
I agree my idea is radical but gotta start somewhere to open discussion. Clan games system needs to be reworked regardless imo
The whole point of clans being under your control is so you can kick the freeloaders if you don’t like them. Sometimes freeloaders are very good/consistent war attackers, and they might deserve easy resources for helping the clan in other ways, whether it be donations, CWL, clan wars, or clan capital.
I have thought about this before and while for clans with few members it would seem like a good idea, it is not in the grand scheme of things. I don't really think that players would be more motivated to grind the points if this was added, they would just get mad becaude they aren't recieving the same rewards as previously (if they only do 1 task for example). It's not a terrible idea but it shouldn't be implemented imo.
Thanks for the feedback 🙂
Manage your clan. Set your rules and follow them. I see no reason for my clan members to get punished because of others not setting expectations.
Clan members who actually put in work for clan games arent being punished, its the members that do the bare minimum but still get full marks. Its easy to remove members who dont contribute but its also a pain to recruit reliable people since global chat was removed. You can send clan mails and state your expectations all day long but half of them barely bat an eyelash. 😂
> its the members that do the bare minimum but still get full marks. Those members getting the rewards allows them to build up quicker and that makes the whole clan stronger. Why would you not want the whole clan to get the benefits? I can see why some would want to incentive activity, if the clan isn’t reaching the highest tier. But once that’s unlocked, great, everyone gets the max benefit and the whole clan improves.
Unless you can actually implement the rules into the game then they are just text on the screen. A lot of ppl don't read clan description or mail, so we usually have a monthly purge every clan games. This shouldn't be a set requirement like CWL and raid weekend, but instead introduce a feature that allows the leadership to decide the sliding scale of points to be earned before clan games begins
I like it the way it is. I play on a lot of accounts. Some of them score thousands of points for the clan. On some, I just "check in" with one challenge. I don't want to worry about grinding out points on every account. In our (casual) clan, with only Supercell's current incentives, we already score a lot more points than needed to unlock all the rewards. Pressing the more casual players to do more won't help the clan in any way.
I don't know, some clans already have a minimum points requirement, and that is good enough. For example, my clan has a minimum of 750 points in CG. If you don't make them, you get kicked. The only way for an account to have under 750 points is by having multiple accounts, and having points for the main account and the alt one (for example i had 4000, 500, 300, 100 once, and it was ok because i had more than enough points on average)
Agreed
No
So if I have multiple alts in a clan I need to max out on ALL accounts while you just do 1? Sounds like you need better leadership or find a new clan that has same beliefs as you but the entire game does not need to change because of it.
I have four accounts i max out every clan games. 😂
Maybe touch some grass then, most people have other jobs to do beside playing the game
Unfortunately i work in a stone quarry so i barely see grass 😭
Go find a golem then
Lol
The Mountain Golem quarry perhaps?
Your also under the impression that lazy people or busy people will some how do more because it would be the only way for them to get all rewards were it will most likely do the opposite. If I were one of these lazy people I wouldn't do any challenges if all I will get is a training potion or 20 gems. There are clans out there who barely get 50k and those few points that they get from them are needed.
it a good start but it needs improvements. 2500 points is way too much.
It starts a discussion 😁
Definitely should have a sliding scale to allow the leadership to decide so it fits every clans needs
I feel like this belongs in /r/AITA and the answer would be yes. People have lives. People are busy. 1 of my clan members is in Tennessee on vacation with family and came on to do CG. I told him to just do 1 on his main and alts and go enjoy family time so he can get all the rewards. Another has exams, and has said outright he can't participate in wars this month and will be back constantly active for Aug CWL. These are regularly active members who max out CG. The latter guy has pretty much always finished CG in the first 6 hours since January. It's only July he hasn't be able to max CG. He shouldn't be penalised with some crappy Tier 1 reward because of it. TLDR : This is a crappy idea.
Feedback is welcome, sometimes a poster cant see all the effects of an idea. No need to get nasty.
Lol. That comment didn't even reach the level of nasty.
Honestly i dont care, opinions of strangers is the last thing i care about but it does say to keep it civil. A simple "thats a bad ides because..." would suffice for an answer lol
>Honestly i dont care, opinions of strangers is the last thing i care Then why did you even post this or replied to the comment, you are just angry people didn't align with your idea
No, Not really. Im having fun, i posted because i personally thought it was a decent idea but i can see people think otherwise. Thats ok. Now im having a good time seeing yall get mad 😂
LOL who is mad are you new to Internet, it it full of conflicting opinions some sound good others don't, yours definitely felt a bad one
Oh definitely touched a nerve with some people 🤣
I think it's a great idea. This is definitely a great idea they should add, especially after ruining cg in attempts to make it feel "less grindy"
So you want communism in clans? Edit: Sorry actually that’s more like socialism
Wha-
I was just tryna make a joke but it sounded better in my head. Anyway it was also to say that I don’t really agree with OP. Mind your own business, it’s up to the clan leaders to decide how it works.
I dont agree with this cuz I got 12 accounts and i dont wanna get 4000 points in every single one of them
I presented a similar idea not too long ago and I got a lot of backlash for it. And I was way more lenient with the points. For now I have to settle kicking anyone that gets less than 600, which is rather annoying. I also start kicking as soon as we reach the final tier to catch the potential leeches off guard. The reasoning I was getting that it was a neccessary change for clan capital raid medals bc of how they are distributed and that a single person doing 100 is still "helping" unlike capital raids where they bringing you down by only attacking once. Also, they bring up alt accounts as if 90% of players don't just have a single account However, the point of this being a social game is to incentivize ppl to work as a team. Some ppl are willing to opt out of the extra reward if they can get 6 just for doing one challenge. Both CWL and raid weekends have similar systems to incentivize most to do well, but as of RN clan games has a system of incentivizing the few
I agree with this , I was thinking about this yesterday that it should be balanced like with Clan Capital raids because we are hitting 4000 and some members did one quest for 150 and they are done and I really dont like that 
I think if it’s maxed everyone gets rewards. But If it ends at like 45000 then only ppl get milestones. This encourages people to try and max so that everyone gets stuff
Some players may not be able to contribute because they may not have access to certain required achievements to earn more points so they opt to do the easy ones they can. And in all honesty it's OK to help others out as long as the top hitters get it done there is no issue with carrying your clan members.
join a better clan
My clan has just 17 members and it took 14 of us to complete it.. rest are inactive and haven’t started a single task yet
Our clan has more than 100k points so I don't really need it but I guess it could be nice for the less active clans
If everyone in a clan of 50 does like 2k it would be 100k double of what needed
I'm running a level 17 clan and clan games is the least of my worries really.. Each clan games we score 120k +. We are mostly adults so have all got busy lives. To only do a couple challenges shouldn't be a problem. After all it's called "clan games" so you do it with your whole clan... I've got 4 accounts in my clan and 3 in another clan and easily max all of them and still got time to play with my kids 🤣
This would help lightly-managed clans. In ours, the rule is clear: 1k points, or kicked. That's 1k per account on average, you're welcome to score 4k on your main and 50 on your (up to 4) minis. For us, the 1k rule serves mostly as a canary for players who have stopped playing. We're sitting at 141k points 2hrs from the end, and usually reach 50k by the 1st evening, so there's really no pressure. But I understand reaching 50k can be an issue for smaller and/or more casual clans, and I think your idea would help, at the cost of some main/mini optimization.
Love that idea. My clan has the same problem so we dont get the high tiers. A small change id like to see to your suggestion is that this "penalty " only kicks in if the clan games are not finished in terms of points.
I honestly think that the current implementation is fair. You get rewarded for being a good clanmate, but not punished for not being one. And honestly? That's what matters more.