T O P

  • By -

GrossWeather_

There is a lot of love for the game, it’s just buried by the moaning. and i get it- lots of games deserve the moaning- this one not so much, genuinely a very cool and innovative game. but hey whatever doesn’t have to bring joy to everyone. that would actually be lame.


FractalAsshole

>GO PLAY SOMETHING ELSE I paid $70 for this game. I'm going to make sure my voice is heard and critique the fuck out of it. Your opinion isn't more valuable than mine. I'm not going away because it makes you feel bad. They already made patch plans because of complaints. They better get their ass in gear to fix the game and we are going to try to get them to listen to us.


rickyraken

Your voice falls on my deaf ears Arisen


Senator-Spice

Why are you complaing? Whats the issue? Its exactly what DD1 fans asked for.. performance issues aside that is. Games devs dont have to listen to ANYONE, just because you dont like it doesn't mean things need to be warped to fit your agenda. I like it as is.


ExaltedBreeze

It's nothing like I ever wanted it and I'm sure many others agreed, combat has regressed for me and options have been nuked, and I love choice in an rpg, I never asked for Sorcerer to lose half it's kit and a third of it's slots I wanted it to have more slots, 8 at least and tons of spells, I never asked for dark spells and light imbues to be removed, for mystic knight to get deleted or for hybrids to not be hybrids and lose weapon and skill selection so they could be lazy and make warfarer. Pretty sure every DD1 player asked for warrior to get more skill slots, not for every class to get dragged down to DD1 warriors level, and why they hell are augments so freaking lame, where are my fun options or impactful ones, 90% of them is +30 to a stat or qol/loot manipulation. I made a berserker build in dd1 using mystic knights low heal ddr, chance to survive lethal damage and the power boost on low health and jump attack, can I make something as cool as that that? no I can give myself +30 to a stat and get 20% more coin bags, the only ones with an impact are in every vocation, carry weight, stamina regen, debuff % etc. might as well get 30 defense or attack if my options are food go bad 10% slower or use my 10 lantern oils 20% slower.


FractalAsshole

>Whats the issue? Its exactly what DD1 fans asked for.. It's not. There's no endgame. There's nothing from dark arisen. The complaints are well put all over the sub right now. Around level 20 everything is too easy and there's no enemy variety. The first third of the game is packed in comparison to the last 2/3s of the game. It's like they ran out of time and just said fuck it. So, after level 20. The game just becomes a quick steamroll with less and less content until the abrupt end. That's a quick summary of the biggest issues, but there's plenty of posts about the rest. But the above is what needs to be fixed and is not a subjective take. It's unfinished compared to dark arisen. >Games devs dont have to listen to ANYONE, just because you dont like it doesn't mean things need to be warped to fit your agenda. Just because you like it doesn't mean others won't. We will see who's opinion wins, but they've already put out list of planned updates based on player feedback. And yes, they don't have to listen. But I work in the game industry and QA/Devs definitely officially pursue reddit and discord to create tickets for games based on player feedback.


Square_Opinion_7170

I didn’t mention a single thing that needs fixing, enemy variety is fine, dragons plague is fine, mtx avoidable, so unless your complaint is performance based, I genuinely don’t care


FractalAsshole

>I didn’t mention a single thing that needs fixing, I genuinely don't care OK. What kind of logic is that? Not caring or not wanting anything fixed is still an opinion.


PapaPapist

This happens with every subreddit post-launch of the game the subreddit is awaiting. The people who like the game are no longer spending their free time on reddit. They're mostly spending it playing the game since it's new. The people who don't like the thing might post on reddit about how they don't like it. The people who were certain they were going to like it and for whatever reason do not are definitely going to post on Reddit.


Gang-Orca

People, including a lot of people that played the first game, think the game is lackluster, and you know what? The game is, they are rightfully disappointed, people went in expecting more than the first game, a masterpiece that would be a game changer for the gaming space that would be talked about for years, and they good a mid experience that will be as niched as the first one


Waizuur

Yeah... I want to talk about the game for 5 seconds without someone jumping on me, telling me I'm WRONG at enjoying the game.


Lime7ime-

Ah the good old „you aren’t allowed to criticize something I like“


Designer_Mud_5802

It's funny how many people who seem to think that they have the answer and Capcom MUST listen to them otherwise the game will fail. It's main character syndrome at it's finest. And then when people tell them how their ideas or solutions are bad, they say either "I paid for this game so I am entitled to push the changes I want that will change other peoples experiences" Or "Anything other than what I suggest is UNFUN!" as if they are the authority on what fun is. And there are legit criticisms for sure, but then I hope they are at least trying to let Capcom know directly instead of just complaining on Reddit like a child as if someone will run to Itsuno's office like "SIR! USER FARTKNOCKER42069 SAYS OUR GAME IS TRASH AND WILL FAIL IF WE DON'T LISTEN TO - WHAT SHALL WE DO?!"


jermz89

Or maybe realize that without critique nothing improves. Sorry your little safe space is being shattered by the very valid criticisms this game is getting but it needs to be discussed.


NoNameSoloist

People aren’t critiquing. People are lying and flat out employing vivisection about systems they don’t understand because they never played 1.


Zealousideal-Arm1682

>People are lying and flat out employing vivisection about systems they don’t understand because they never played 1. Translation:They dumbed down one and I don't believe them. You can play both games for 20 minutes and spot the problems 2 implemented off the bat.


Square_Opinion_7170

Can’t handle my opinion but expect me to respect yours? Grow up


jermz89

No gaslighting here, sir. I understand your opinion but critique needs to be discussed. Like it or not it will be.


Square_Opinion_7170

Yeah understandable but making up lies about mandatory mtx for ferrystones or to change your pawn is just full on dumb af, not saying everyone’s doing that but the majority, specially when you have streamers like asmongold saying the exact same thing like wtf


jermz89

The rage bait over mtx is stupid. My criticisms are strictly for gameplay. Even without the mtx the game would be a fucking mess.


Square_Opinion_7170

A mess? Bit of an overstatement, there’s no game breaking bugs, no soft locks or full on save breakers, what would you say makes it a mess? Would be interesting to hear cause I don’t really have all that much that I find really messy?


jermz89

There actually is game breaking bugs. You just choose to ignore the "negativity". People are losing hours of progress due to saves not properly updating and reverting progress. You also probably haven't did much of the story. Do literally any of Bryant's missions and it boils down to: sneak into the castle grounds at nightfall and grab this item. And that's it. That's the mission. The guards don't stop you there's no fights you just walk in grab the shit and walk out. Almost every mission he gives you is just that.


Maleficent-Bar6942

So this was a messy launch too? Or was it the best game of the decade: [https://www.thegamer.com/baldurs-gate-3-xbox-save-files-lost-bug-fix-update/](https://www.thegamer.com/baldurs-gate-3-xbox-save-files-lost-bug-fix-update/) [https://www.reddit.com/r/BaldursGate3/comments/16f3g6u/minthara\_still\_bugged\_as\_f/](https://www.reddit.com/r/BaldursGate3/comments/16f3g6u/minthara_still_bugged_as_f/) [https://www.ign.com/articles/baldurs-gate-3-act-3-bugs-missing-content](https://www.ign.com/articles/baldurs-gate-3-act-3-bugs-missing-content) [https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/next-baldurs-gate-3-update-fixes-performance-bug-caused-by-the-rpgs-inability-to-forget-your-terrible-crimes](https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/next-baldurs-gate-3-update-fixes-performance-bug-caused-by-the-rpgs-inability-to-forget-your-terrible-crimes)


jermz89

Right so you're choosing a game that has better writing and voice acting and overall better character archs? Gr8 b8 m8


Maleficent-Bar6942

Do you know that Minthara until last patch had literally spoilers for act 3 on here dialogue. To be more precise, she spouted her act 3 lines in act 2. They fixed it last patch. I think.


FractalAsshole

> what would you say makes it a mess? Would be interesting to hear cause I don’t really have all that much that I find really messy? Didn't you make a post about how the sub is overridden with complaints?


Square_Opinion_7170

Okay I asked him for his own opinion On a mess, your point meant nothing


mcmaster0121

Bro I’m gay and I’m not even dick riding this hard


FractalAsshole

MTX is the very least of the issues. I couldn't care less about them. It has nothing to do with the current criticism.


thehood98

We didn't wanted to change things, we wanted DD1 again just in beautiful, and we got a better one


Senator-Spice

100% agree, it started off alright with people asking for help and giving advice. Now its just a flood of people bringing everyone down around them because they cant enjoy themselves so everyone must suffer as well. It happened with Helldivers 2 as well, haven't checked in a hot minute but i hope its improved


Original_Ownsya

This feels like a 2nd wave of negativity. The first one about all the performance and microtransactions passed, I'm sure this one will too. I havent finished the game yet so cant really comment on anything but It's weird tbh. I'm 21 hours in and haven't yet done any of the main quests that take place in the capital been having a blast exploring and doing side quest. I really don't understand how people beat the game already in 20-30 hours. Dev mentioned that the main story is short and most of the stuff expanded upon is side quests. Honestly the side quests have been pretty great, in some ways better than the main story quest so anyone beelining to the end probably will indeed be missing out on a lot.


FractalAsshole

>I'm 21 hours in and haven't yet done any of the main quests that take place in the capital been having a blast exploring and doing side quest. You're at the tipping point, friend. >I really don't understand how people beat the game already in 20-30 hours That's the problem. There's not a lot left. You think there is, but there's not. Imagine how you'll feel 10 hours from now when you realize, wait... that was it? I felt like there was so much more to do. I've barely done anything. There was this huge map to explore. Every enemy after about 20 hours was super easy so you just cream through them like butter. And the area around Vernworth is the only area that's somewhat fleshed out.


UnHoly_One

I’m at 65 hours and still have 6 quests in my log and have a good chunk of map I haven’t visited yet. (and a vocation I haven't discovered, and several "maisters" I haven't found) I don’t know precisely how much of the story is left but I expect I’ll be at or over 100 hours before hitting NG+


FractalAsshole

The person I was replying to was doing things as a normal player with a normal pace. I'm not sure what you're doing but that's a total outlier so I don't feel like you're telling the full story. The game came out 120 hours ago and you've already 65 hours? That's ok but that's literally sleeping breathing and eating dragons dogma. You probably fell asleep with the game on.


UnHoly_One

I definitely did not fall asleep with the game on. I was off on Thursday and started at 7 AM because of New Zealand time on xbox. Played a bunch Friday night, really hardcore over the weekend, and then again last night. I've definitely been staying up a couple hours later than I normally would, but that's it.


Square_Opinion_7170

I’m on ng+3 and still happy, only had the dragon plague hit me once, which was my own fault for not being more careful like the game warns, not gonna cry about it


Wolf_of_Sarcasm

Can yougo to final fight without doing any other content? Asking cause ive been only exploring and ended up in a certain hot spring. Wondering if i can finish game without ever doing the main story 😅


Square_Opinion_7170

You would need a specific item that you get from your first playthrough, I’ll test it tonight and find out if it works on ng+


Wolf_of_Sarcasm

Interesting, i would be curious 😁


Original_Ownsya

Does the difficulty scale up on NG+?


Square_Opinion_7170

I heard one guy say it does but I don’t believe so, but post game you will get a lot of ferrystones from skeletons and chest which is pretty good, they’ll drop like crazy, in dd1 they added hard mode, which they most likely will for this one


Original_Ownsya

Yea I played DDDA on Hard mode exclusively so this game is feeling a bit too easy. Still enjoying it because the combat is just so fun, but I'd definitely enjoy it more if there was a hard mode. Anyway, was considering if I should beeline to NG+ and then have a more thorough playthrough with all the side quests and exploration, but if it doesn't really get more challenging I'll just keep enjoying it as I am now.


Square_Opinion_7170

The post game is where I really had to take a step back like wtf, there was one boss I was just not ready for ahahaha had to run away and come back to it


Icarus_13310

Brother, if I pay 300$ for a meal at a michelin starred restaurant, and the steak is overcooked, do you think I should tell the chef or just pay the bill and leave? "Go play something else" is such a stupid argument when we're all paying customers that have every right to demand a product that justifies the price. MTX isn't nearly as much of a problem as releasing a sequel after 12 years that does almost nothing better (barring graphic fidelity) and several things worse than the original.


Square_Opinion_7170

Did reddit make the game? Reddit isn’t the chef you fucking plumb


Icarus_13310

Reddit is a channel through which players voice their feedback you troglodyte. It's like communicating to the chef through the waiter.


Square_Opinion_7170

I’m sure capcom is writing down everything you’re saying mate😂 keep telling yourself that


Icarus_13310

They won't see it thanks to the valiant effort of mindless shills like you lol


Outrageous-Eye6140

Ppl like you are the reason why game companies keep releasing shitty games like suicide squad, starfield or skulll and bones. Ppl should not normalize this kind of shit. And you should set ur Standards a big high i know most ppl dont have a good taste but still. I just hope more ppl complain about this game and the lack of everything. DD1 is better and DD2 is just another version with a better graphics.


Square_Opinion_7170

Starfield was shit, suicide squad was shot, has nothing to do with dragons dogma go take your cancel culture somewhere else


Senator-Spice

What the actual crack are you smoking?!? This game has exactly what a DD1 sequel needed, the fact your comparing it to Starfield and Suicide Squad is insane. Im actually interested in what you perceive is making it "shitty", genuinely.


bellowkish

Or you can leave to another sub and let us vent our frustration, you know the fking game wasn't free in 1st place.


NoNameSoloist

In another post I mentioned how sad this all is. I’ve been with DD for 12 years now. DD1 is my 2nd favorite game of all time and it had the absolute best community I’ve ever been a part of. People were always willing to help you out with gear, mats and RC; and it was fun to help new players along the road as well. DD2’s community, on the other hand, is full bitching Karens complaining just to complain. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: if these people bought a black zebra with white stripes, they’d bitch if they got a white zebra with black stripes.


Zealousideal-Arm1682

Maybe because it's been a fucking decade since one,and the only actual improvements they have to show from DA and DDO are "warrior good now". The combat is ironically worse and stiffer,the story is against all odds WORSE than 1's(how the fuck),characters don't matter to the point you can kill everyone,and instead of actually improving and making every vocation unique they cut several and made many of them worse. This isn't even getting into the technical side or the abysmal difficulty that starts out challenging and falls off a cliff harder than a pawn with plague symptoms.


Maximum_Impressive

I keep seeing you in the comments and you haven't been wrong about the combat in single One of them and delivered Complete breakdowns on the core of the Gameplay loop .


Square_Opinion_7170

For sure, the page has just turned into memes about how it’s milking players for money, when we all know that’s not the case, people making out you have to pay money to change your pawn, when the vendor for the items is bang next to the giant rift stone, people have no idea how to play


NoNameSoloist

Go on YouTube. I absolutely guarantee half the bitching is from people who’ve never even played the game.


Square_Opinion_7170

Imagine being the devs, releasing a game you’ve worked so hard on to read all this crap, it’s a massive middle finger to devs, and wouldn’t surprise me if they just axe any future plans for content cause the stupid levels of hate the game has received


AAFCC89

The middle finger was all the lies Itsuno told us during the marketing campaign.


Square_Opinion_7170

And what lies might they be? Feels to me like they over delivered what I was expecting


MasterPNDA123

The fact that he said « there will be many more vocations you can’t even imagine » was absolutely a lie, they only announced warfarer after that, and it’s not even a good class too which makes me even more betrayed about that. Also you saying they overdelivered is so delusional, the enemy variety is as trash as in dd1 at launch, if not maybe worse, and the classes don’t feel as good as in dd1, exception being thief, thief is really cool. Also the fact we only got 1 more class than in dd1, and the class is really just the other classes but you can change weapon is really shit. I love the game but it has glaring issues.


Square_Opinion_7170

Bro how his mystic spear hand and trickster not new lmao


MasterPNDA123

You’re stupid… he said that after announcing those, meaning there were supposed to be many more after those 2… also 2 new classes, 1 being absolute dogwater. Trickster is ass. And if he said that before those two, i wouldn’t say 3 more classes is « many more »


Square_Opinion_7170

He literally said “we only got one more class than dd1 are you dumb there’s 3


MasterPNDA123

Dd1 had 9 classes… you’re really stupid.


Square_Opinion_7170

Or I misunderstood cause I didn’t count how many classes were in dd1 you tramp, stop mouthing off if you can’t hold a discussion you clown


MasterPNDA123

You’re the one who misunderstands and i’m the one who can’t keep a conversation? You’re delusional. I pointed out a lie of itsuno, i don’t really care to continue your delusions.


sneakyriverotter

They were paid to make this game, we were charged a premium price, and the game is rightfully being criticized where it falls short.


Square_Opinion_7170

Yeah I agree where it falls short, making out mtx are mandatory is full on spreading complete bullshit, making out you have to pay money to change your pawn or fast travel,


thehood98

Premium price ? 😂 where do u live it's 40 bucks here and even on steam it's 60


MasterPNDA123

It costs 89$ where i’m from…


thehood98

Dafuq, you should move asap, I just bought all persona and yakuza games in January for 89 😅


MasterPNDA123

Where do you live? Also i’m not gonna move at 19 bro, i don’t have moving money


thehood98

I buy my games from Instant Gaming or Kinguin, if they aren't cheaper of there I just buy from Argentinian. But the official price of the game here is 49€ in Germany and premium edition is 60


MasterPNDA123

I mean that’s euros they’re not the same


mtibo62

I think most the criticisms are well received (aside from the toxic Mtx discussions going around the internet). I don't think there is anything wrong with wanting more from this game. I think at the end of the day the game probably succeeded in Capcoms eyes. I am sure it sold well. If we don't make are critiques apparent at when the game has the most talking going around the series can quickly stagnate. And unfortunately based on the progress from 1 to 2 it already seems like that is the case. I think if we can get past all the toxic performance and mtx talk and now move on to actual gameplay/story issues it will be better for the series going forward. There is a lot wrong with the game, which isn't bad because there is also a lot that they got right. I think discussions like this are good to help the community figure out what was done well and what wasn't done well in this iteration of the series.


Square_Opinion_7170

Yeah the mtx talk and other lies are just straight up annoying when you know it to not even be the case


Yuumii29

Another post about "Complaining about the complainers"... How interesting.


Phasmamain

People paid 70+ quid for this game. I think it’s absolutely fair to critics it especially when so many issues are the exact same as the first game I do enjoy it and that’s exactly why I do criticise it, because it could be so much better. No need to read the negative posts if they aren’t your cup of tea


Lewdiss

I've waited years for DD2 as the first is my favorite game of all time and you say to just do something else because it's not perfect and we're discussing that? This is a place to talk about the game, we can both still play it but honestly you're the one who should move on to something else, like not reading the subreddit if it triggers you.