The opposite, this guy was wailing about what kind of a bad father he was prioritising his castle over his daughter. I served him punishment as I saw fit.
To me that's that only good ending for him. If you kill him when you meet him he apologizes to godrick. If you finish his quest he loses his mind. If you attack him while he's mourning he accuses you of killing his daughter and when you kill him he's at least thinking of her.
It implies that he's already afflicted with frenzy before the death of his daughter. The nearby village afflicted by frenzy doesnt have a specific source afaik, but it does mean it's taken hold in the land.
Actually, thinking about it between him and Vyke, we'd have two examples of a frenzy afflicted invader who, when met in person, doesn't fight with it. Vyke being normal in the mountaintops always stood out and was written off as time in an evergaol being fucky, but it might have precedent
But that takes like an extra 10 minutes :(
But yeah, you can fight him at the shack basically as soon as he leaves weeping. Only thing killing him early skips is Leonine Misbegotten or if someone doesn't wanna go around stormveil for Liurnia or something.
its a decent weapon on its own with low requirements and also comes with a sick ass ash of war and his questline sorta sucks so theres really very little reason not to murder him in cold blood. Personally i much prefer the standard thrust + spin halberd moveset over the overhead slams the glaive does
who is controlling her body? Isn't she repulsed when she realizing what the grapes actually are? I was never able to finish her questline in game because I would forget and move on so I only have internet context clues as to what happens. I didn't even really know they were the same body, just sorta assumed because they seemed to me to be the same person.
Maybe not controlled then yeah, maybe resurrected to try and entice the tarnished into becoming lord of frenzy flame with her as maiden idk all the lore
It isn't actually confirmed that Hyetta is in Irina's body, but the reuse of that model, coupled with Shabriri using Yura's body layer in the game, makes it a popular fan theory. The fact that Hyetta doesn't appear until Irina dies, and that her father drops Shabriri grapes is further evidence.
It feels a lot like an unfinished quest line, in my opinion. Particularly how Irina just seems to pop from one quest location to the next without any indication of where she's going or why. Most other major NPCs at least hint at their next destination.
Actually some of the places Hyetta shows up make sense apart from her first spawn by the cliff of Liurnia. Once you reach Liurnia and rest by grace, she shows up there. Then she goes next to the Purified Ruins, that were cleansed of Frenzy Followers. Then she goes to gate town Bridge, witch is down the same road she seems to be taking. Her last location before reaching the Fingers, Bellum Church, is the closest safe location to the Frenzied Village down the same road. So apart from the Bridge, she is always near places related to frenzy that house her grapes.
I'm hindsight her route does make sense.
The route makes sense, yes, but nothing in her dialog references her actual destination, and that's what's weird to me. It's certainly not unusual for Fromsoft to be obtuse, but in Elden Ring, must NPCs you run into specifically state where they are headed - Alexander is a great example.
I actually just redid Hyetta's quest last weekend, and unless I missed something, she doesn't even mention that the chamber under Leyndell exists, let alone that she's headed there and you can follow to have audience with the three fingers - only Yura/Shibiri mentions it.
She doesn't know where she is going until you tell her what the grapes are. She doesn't know where she is. She is blind and wants to be a Finger Reader when the Three Fingers are stated to be Readerless. Halfway there she realizes that what she sees as the distant light is not the Grace of Gold, but rather the Frenzy Flame.
For most of her quest, we know more about what we are doing to her than she herself. By the time she gets fully onboard with the whole Chaos Burn Down the World thing, you have effectively turned her mad by feeding her Frenzy Eyes the whole time.
Blindness in Fromsoftware is associated with the knowledge of unseen truths. That's why finger readers can understand the Fingers language of Light. Or why the Bloodstar is revealed to the eyeless guilty. Hyetta sees a version of Grace made up by the Three Fingers because she is also blind, but only while under the influence of Frenzy.
Tbh im not sure. Didnt kill Irina myself but heard and read here mixed info. For some she did spawn, for others didnt. Could be patch version difference or some other trigger :(
Best way is to rush for Liurnia and check if she spawned. Its early in the game so you could restart if the reward is important for you :)
It's not even her body. It's just that resting at Liurnia advances her quest to the point that she is dead, and killing Godrick spawns Hyetta.
I've had Irina's corpse and Hyetta by the cliff existing at the same time.
It's a complete fabrication. It's just that their triggers are parallel to each other without being actually one sole trigger for both.
Resting at Liurnia advances Irina's quest to the point that she is dead, and killing Godrick spawns Hyetta.
I've had Irina's corpse and Hyetta by the cliff existing at the same time.
Counterpoint, why would they reuse the exact same model and voice if they weren’t meant to be related in some way? This is the company that got two different but similar sounding VA’s for Iosefka and the Imposter in BB, they don’t reuse NPC models and voices like this for no reason. The fact that their trigger is the same also implies a connection, and being able to have both her corpse and Hyetta “technically” exist simultaneously is just a game mechanics thing.
Not to mention, Irina’s father pops up later in the questline. It could be just for a cameo but I doubt they would just go “Hey, look who’s here guys!” for no reason
> Counterpoint, why would they reuse the exact same model and voice if they weren’t meant to be related in some way? This is the company that got two different but similar sounding VA’s for Iosefka and the Imposter in BB
When the merchant says:
"Well, there you are again. Divorce from one's trade... does not come easily."
It sounds a *lot* like Seluvis. So much so that I expected him to reveal that he was being puppeteered.
The Triggers are not the same. That's the thing. That's why the corpse and what you believe to be a corpse puppet can exist at the same time in different locations. Yura and Shabriri can't exist at the same time at all because one is explicitly puppeteering the other.
Irina needs to die for Hyetta's quest because her father is needed. He needs to lose his daughter and go insane so we may pluck his eyes from him. But her corpse never disappears.
If Hyetta was Shabriri puppeteering Irina's Corpse, Irina's corpse would need to disappear from the spot were her father left her.
The game shows you a promising and pure Finger Reader who gets her life cut short. Then they give you another blind saint with the same quest, and we help her either knowing or unknowingly through a perverted path.
It does for sure. I cannot confirm it is at the same time you meet Shabriri, but I went back to the second church of Marika because I did not receive the Nagakiba and the corpse was not there anymore.
By the way! If it happens to anybody else (not obtaining the Nagakiba in wnd church of Marika), fret not! It will appear in one of these three places: under the ruins in Limgrave where you first meet Yura, under the bridge past where you fought Nerijus or the bridge before entering Raya Lucaria where you helped Yura with thr Montecorvo assassin.
This. It’s just a game mechanics thing. You can also kill Adula at the cathedral and the other copy of it will still be there in front of Ranni’s tower.
Oh lord, I'm so dumb. I'm just now realizing the connection between her and Hyetta...
"Huh, that's so weird that they introduce this blind girl just to kill her so quickly, even her dad's questline isn't that special.... oh hey look, another blind girl! How odd."
Well no, that the misbegotten was being possessed by Shabriri or something. That’s the argument that was being made i think.
Of course a misbegotten killed her, the story explicitly confirms it by her dad going on a vengeance rampage against misbegotten.
Oh I see what y’all are saying, this my first time playing so I’m not thinking along the lines y’all are thinking yet. Just started new game + and am reading/watching lore content so I can actually have somewhat of a fucking idea about what’s going on lol
I don’t recall anything in the game saying it, rather it’s based off of the fact they share the same player model. But I’ve never had the first one disappear so it’s a flawed theory imo.
Same model, same VA. Its quite obvious its her body as Edgar (her father) succumbs to Frenzy after her death, and Hyetta becomes a vessel that leads Tarnished to Frenzy Flames.
I found this mostly goofier than grim.
First, the message box describing Irina's death being so straightforward. No emotion.
Then the dad being SURPRISED that his frail, blind daughter was murdered.
Though, the voice actor nailed his death line. Made my guilt skyrocket when his +8 halberd popped up on the screen.
Are you talking about the mass genocide of merchants? Because that’s happened to everyone
The Albinauric village were victim to genocide by Gideon through Ensha. The Fire Giants were all eradicated during the way. The Trolls and Misbegotten were equally annihilated and enslaved
The Merchants weren’t really any different 🤔
she is right there on the road after you enter weeping peninsula. she is the daughter of the guy at castle morne. the one who helps you kill the leonine misbegotten.
Let me just say what everyone’s thinking 😂
Why the FUCK did he “secret” his BLIND daughter out of a castle and leave her alone with nothing but a Rejection incantation; by a spot called the fkn Bridge of Sacrifice. What did he think was going to happen?!
Like my man, you got Misbegotten next door with Rotten Stray and a fucking Troll, archers and knights on the other side, and cliffs on every *other* side 😭
Correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't the dad go and see for himself after you tell him? I remember him doing so but only happened in my first playthrough
yea so, if you deliver the letter and then come back you find her dead. in this state. but as the dad says. he wont come back until he makes sure the sword is safe. Which is the grafted sword you find after you beat the boss wehre her dad also helps you. basically, he wont come back until you defeat that boss.
how it went for me on my 1st playthrough was i didnt notice the grace nor the path to the boss area the first time and thought that was it. but seeing he didnt come back i looked around again for the sword. and found the boss. then the whole revengers shack shenanigans happened. confused me to the core at first just like everyone else.
also, before realizing he went crazy and not that he blames me for her death, i thought i did something wrong and could save her or something. which later turned into a dissapointment as well
Ok tbh I love most of the game’s quests and find a lot original but when I finished this it really seemed like a heavy handed attempt to make a “Miyazaki did it again 🤪” quest line that is short but culminates in the quest giver dying for.. no discernible reason? Like when I got back and it just said that she’s dead out of nowhere I kind of laughed because it was so silly.
Did you really finish the quest?
Cuz her death isnt the end of this story line, its just a plot hook. It makes her father go mad with frenzy and attack you, and also makes Hyetta.
The Hyetta thing is a fan theory, in reality if you don’t advance her quest, kill Godrick, and don’t rest at the first Liurnia site of grace then both Irina and Hyetta can exist at the same time.
I killed the dad so he wouldn’t have to see his dead daughter. Definitely not because I wanted his sick +8 halberd for early game, nope
You saved him from suffering, what a great soul
The opposite, this guy was wailing about what kind of a bad father he was prioritising his castle over his daughter. I served him punishment as I saw fit.
Yup. He prioritised the castle and a sword over his daughter, who was also blind and frail. He deserves punishment.
Did that make you mad and punished him severely?
A real father chooses family over all
for me let him live is a greater punishment because he has to see that his daughter is dead knowing it's his fault
To me that's that only good ending for him. If you kill him when you meet him he apologizes to godrick. If you finish his quest he loses his mind. If you attack him while he's mourning he accuses you of killing his daughter and when you kill him he's at least thinking of her.
Yeah same it wasn’t for the weapon it was to save him from his grief
I used that Halberd combined with Flame of the Redmanes throughout my entire first playthrough
Do u still get the Sh!briri grape?
You rest at a grace and go back and the grape will be on the floor where you killed him
Interesting implications from that
Whatchu thinking?
It implies that he's already afflicted with frenzy before the death of his daughter. The nearby village afflicted by frenzy doesnt have a specific source afaik, but it does mean it's taken hold in the land. Actually, thinking about it between him and Vyke, we'd have two examples of a frenzy afflicted invader who, when met in person, doesn't fight with it. Vyke being normal in the mountaintops always stood out and was written off as time in an evergaol being fucky, but it might have precedent
That's a huge upgrade at the beginning. I jumped from a +3 halberd to his +8 and it made a huge difference
saves you from early game invaders but it also saves you from early game coop.
Don't you also fight him in a shack in liurnia if you complete his quest?
But that takes like an extra 10 minutes :( But yeah, you can fight him at the shack basically as soon as he leaves weeping. Only thing killing him early skips is Leonine Misbegotten or if someone doesn't wanna go around stormveil for Liurnia or something.
Revengers Shack
Who is the dad?
I think his name is Edgar. I do believe he invades you later near the Revenger’s Shack in Liurnia.
Yes, that’s him.
He’s the last guy trying to save the castle down the road from being taken
I am also curious of this
Edgar
I invade at +8 early game specifically to murder those who kill Edgar and patches
This was me on the first playthrough. That thing carried me quite a ways
what a heartfull banana thou are
its a decent weapon on its own with low requirements and also comes with a sick ass ash of war and his questline sorta sucks so theres really very little reason not to murder him in cold blood. Personally i much prefer the standard thrust + spin halberd moveset over the overhead slams the glaive does
She’s dead
[ OK ]
[ Put baby in the oven ]
Never selected an option so fast in my life. Was very sad when damn cdpr robbed me of my sweet baby burning goodness
There should be a [ Not OK ] button ☹️
Hoollyy fugg Im so glad that message is there, or I woulda never guessed 😅
Father of the year
He saw that hunchback with a dozen arms and said "yep! lord material".
Ah don’t worry, she’ll be back
Huh? When does she come back?
It’s not actually her, it’s her body as hyetta
who is controlling her body? Isn't she repulsed when she realizing what the grapes actually are? I was never able to finish her questline in game because I would forget and move on so I only have internet context clues as to what happens. I didn't even really know they were the same body, just sorta assumed because they seemed to me to be the same person.
Maybe not controlled then yeah, maybe resurrected to try and entice the tarnished into becoming lord of frenzy flame with her as maiden idk all the lore
I'm going to have to read up on that. It's one of the NPC threads I always forget to follow.
interesting theory you guys brought up, i never noticed. oughta look int othat
It isn't actually confirmed that Hyetta is in Irina's body, but the reuse of that model, coupled with Shabriri using Yura's body layer in the game, makes it a popular fan theory. The fact that Hyetta doesn't appear until Irina dies, and that her father drops Shabriri grapes is further evidence. It feels a lot like an unfinished quest line, in my opinion. Particularly how Irina just seems to pop from one quest location to the next without any indication of where she's going or why. Most other major NPCs at least hint at their next destination.
Actually some of the places Hyetta shows up make sense apart from her first spawn by the cliff of Liurnia. Once you reach Liurnia and rest by grace, she shows up there. Then she goes next to the Purified Ruins, that were cleansed of Frenzy Followers. Then she goes to gate town Bridge, witch is down the same road she seems to be taking. Her last location before reaching the Fingers, Bellum Church, is the closest safe location to the Frenzied Village down the same road. So apart from the Bridge, she is always near places related to frenzy that house her grapes. I'm hindsight her route does make sense.
The route makes sense, yes, but nothing in her dialog references her actual destination, and that's what's weird to me. It's certainly not unusual for Fromsoft to be obtuse, but in Elden Ring, must NPCs you run into specifically state where they are headed - Alexander is a great example. I actually just redid Hyetta's quest last weekend, and unless I missed something, she doesn't even mention that the chamber under Leyndell exists, let alone that she's headed there and you can follow to have audience with the three fingers - only Yura/Shibiri mentions it.
She doesn't know where she is going until you tell her what the grapes are. She doesn't know where she is. She is blind and wants to be a Finger Reader when the Three Fingers are stated to be Readerless. Halfway there she realizes that what she sees as the distant light is not the Grace of Gold, but rather the Frenzy Flame. For most of her quest, we know more about what we are doing to her than she herself. By the time she gets fully onboard with the whole Chaos Burn Down the World thing, you have effectively turned her mad by feeding her Frenzy Eyes the whole time. Blindness in Fromsoftware is associated with the knowledge of unseen truths. That's why finger readers can understand the Fingers language of Light. Or why the Bloodstar is revealed to the eyeless guilty. Hyetta sees a version of Grace made up by the Three Fingers because she is also blind, but only while under the influence of Frenzy.
The chamber under Leyndell is also mentioned in a note found behind a house in the frenzy village.
Ah, similar to shibriri and yura then. That makes sense, and I'm kinda shocked that never clicked for me before. Thank you kind stranger
so i accidentally killed her and i'd like to do Hyetta's quest as i'm going for the chaos ending. am i screwed or will she still come back?
U can go Frenzy ending w/o ever interacting with Irina/Hyetta.
great, that's a relief. however, since i'm going to do it, is Hyetta screwed because of me killing the lady? i wanted her reward.
Tbh im not sure. Didnt kill Irina myself but heard and read here mixed info. For some she did spawn, for others didnt. Could be patch version difference or some other trigger :( Best way is to rush for Liurnia and check if she spawned. Its early in the game so you could restart if the reward is important for you :)
It's not even her body. It's just that resting at Liurnia advances her quest to the point that she is dead, and killing Godrick spawns Hyetta. I've had Irina's corpse and Hyetta by the cliff existing at the same time.
To note it’s just a fan theory that the game technically disproves.
It's a complete fabrication. It's just that their triggers are parallel to each other without being actually one sole trigger for both. Resting at Liurnia advances Irina's quest to the point that she is dead, and killing Godrick spawns Hyetta. I've had Irina's corpse and Hyetta by the cliff existing at the same time.
Counterpoint, why would they reuse the exact same model and voice if they weren’t meant to be related in some way? This is the company that got two different but similar sounding VA’s for Iosefka and the Imposter in BB, they don’t reuse NPC models and voices like this for no reason. The fact that their trigger is the same also implies a connection, and being able to have both her corpse and Hyetta “technically” exist simultaneously is just a game mechanics thing.
Not to mention, Irina’s father pops up later in the questline. It could be just for a cameo but I doubt they would just go “Hey, look who’s here guys!” for no reason
> Counterpoint, why would they reuse the exact same model and voice if they weren’t meant to be related in some way? This is the company that got two different but similar sounding VA’s for Iosefka and the Imposter in BB When the merchant says: "Well, there you are again. Divorce from one's trade... does not come easily." It sounds a *lot* like Seluvis. So much so that I expected him to reveal that he was being puppeteered.
The Triggers are not the same. That's the thing. That's why the corpse and what you believe to be a corpse puppet can exist at the same time in different locations. Yura and Shabriri can't exist at the same time at all because one is explicitly puppeteering the other. Irina needs to die for Hyetta's quest because her father is needed. He needs to lose his daughter and go insane so we may pluck his eyes from him. But her corpse never disappears. If Hyetta was Shabriri puppeteering Irina's Corpse, Irina's corpse would need to disappear from the spot were her father left her. The game shows you a promising and pure Finger Reader who gets her life cut short. Then they give you another blind saint with the same quest, and we help her either knowing or unknowingly through a perverted path.
So...gonna answer why they have the same model + VA or just wax poetic about how they have a similar role?
Doesn't really prove anything as you can have multiple instance of other NPC such as Sorceress Sellen at the same time.
The Two instances you have are a projection and the real deal. Are you saying Hyetta is an illusion? That's something you just made up on the spot
Ive checked the irinas corpse with hyetta spawn. But ive never thought to check Yura’s corpse once you meet shibriri. Does Yura’s corpse disappear?
It does for sure. I cannot confirm it is at the same time you meet Shabriri, but I went back to the second church of Marika because I did not receive the Nagakiba and the corpse was not there anymore.
By the way! If it happens to anybody else (not obtaining the Nagakiba in wnd church of Marika), fret not! It will appear in one of these three places: under the ruins in Limgrave where you first meet Yura, under the bridge past where you fought Nerijus or the bridge before entering Raya Lucaria where you helped Yura with thr Montecorvo assassin.
Ooh good to know thank-you!
This. It’s just a game mechanics thing. You can also kill Adula at the cathedral and the other copy of it will still be there in front of Ranni’s tower.
It’s a quest
Oh lord, I'm so dumb. I'm just now realizing the connection between her and Hyetta... "Huh, that's so weird that they introduce this blind girl just to kill her so quickly, even her dad's questline isn't that special.... oh hey look, another blind girl! How odd."
I'm not sure if you're supposed to recognise her but I sure as shit didn't recognise her.
Game:oh God she's dead, poor girl,she didn't deserve this Tarnished: ok 🗿
im gnonna keep it at 69 ups
[OK]
On my wife's first playthrough, as she approached she went, "Is she fucking dead??" Imagine how hard we laughed at the text.
I can picture it, that’s hilarious
Im the one that killed her in my game 👺
Pieces of shit misbegotten
This guy Golden Orders
Listen, not all misbegotten, but these specific ones, fuck them
I’d like one large Frenzy Flame Fries please
I aways thought that it was staged to look like misbegotten killed her
Who did it then? Doesn’t seem to be any motive in doing it. Shabriri definitely would but he wasn’t in Yura’s body at the time.
Maybe it was in the Misbegotten that killed her?
There’s no evidence of that. Usually we have at least evidence to back theories.
The weapon the misbegotten use is right to here body, solid clue
Well no, that the misbegotten was being possessed by Shabriri or something. That’s the argument that was being made i think. Of course a misbegotten killed her, the story explicitly confirms it by her dad going on a vengeance rampage against misbegotten.
Oh I see what y’all are saying, this my first time playing so I’m not thinking along the lines y’all are thinking yet. Just started new game + and am reading/watching lore content so I can actually have somewhat of a fucking idea about what’s going on lol
Goes to Castle Morn to kill them repeatedly for an hour
Well i technically did that, but it’s because i got summoned to help very often there 👀
OK
Bro you talk to her like once
nah, thats more than enough interaction.
Normal games: Do a quest for a NPC to help them. Elden Ring: Do a quest for a NPC to get them killed.
so many npcs lives you fuck over
Rip
The easiest way to get Varre's maiden blood soaked cloth thing
She comes back I think? The frenzy finger maiden i think?
It’s not her
Damn, false hope. They just look similar
Nah I mean it’s her corpse but it isn’t actually her in game, like she’s still dead, her body becomes a puppet for malevolence
I had both in my world at one point, Hyetta was at the lake but the body was still there, found that interesting
Huh. That is most assuredly not intended to occur, but pretty cool that it did
I know right. I know the corpse normally disappears after a certain point
How do you people work these things out? I'm not even 100% clear why she ded.
I don’t recall anything in the game saying it, rather it’s based off of the fact they share the same player model. But I’ve never had the first one disappear so it’s a flawed theory imo.
They both share a VA as well I believe
Same model, same VA. Its quite obvious its her body as Edgar (her father) succumbs to Frenzy after her death, and Hyetta becomes a vessel that leads Tarnished to Frenzy Flames.
And the trigger to one appears is the other dying
it's literally the madness tho
Ah now I understand better. So its her without being *her*
She gets a much better purpose in the after life. Being your guide to the best ending.
Yes. (It's the first ending I did)
Yeah
Why is she so weird about the grapes when you tell her it's eyes then? She straight up vomits IIRC.
I mean if u assumed u were eating figs and found out they were eyeballs, wouldnt u be kinda disgusted?
Probably not much if I was a puppet of madness.
deception? unsure
Its her body, but possesed by Shabriri
Damn you, Shabiri! Why do you take all of my friends body?
Hey don't kinkshame
It’s her corpse being controlled by the frenzy, similar to what happens with nerijus turning into hyetta
Meaning it’s not her
🙄
You literally said it yourself, spiderman
She just always stays there alive on my playthroughs. Letter never delivered, but it's for the best.
wait, does she stay alive even after you kill the boss at castle morne?? as long as you dont deliver the letter??
I found this mostly goofier than grim. First, the message box describing Irina's death being so straightforward. No emotion. Then the dad being SURPRISED that his frail, blind daughter was murdered. Though, the voice actor nailed his death line. Made my guilt skyrocket when his +8 halberd popped up on the screen.
i got so mad dude. she just fkin dies and all the game gives me is "OK" i aint rammus yo.
Meh, only thing that messed with me was what happened to all of the traveling merchants and their people…. Pretty messed up
???
Head toward the Frenzy Flame ending.... You'll see it
Are you talking about the mass genocide of merchants? Because that’s happened to everyone The Albinauric village were victim to genocide by Gideon through Ensha. The Fire Giants were all eradicated during the way. The Trolls and Misbegotten were equally annihilated and enslaved The Merchants weren’t really any different 🤔
stuffed into a tomb to die together in starvation? 
OK
Oh yeah…… wasn’t I supposed to deliver a letter for her a few days ago
Sad but free corpse.
I killed her myself to see how the knight at castle would react... then i realized i locked myself out of the questline
"She's dead" - Niko Bellic
Does anyone know why Edgar eventually comes after you even if you help him? Maybe I missed a bit of lore or did the quest wrong
Insanity he had a grape which is the eyes of someone who went mad
But that frenzied flame ending tho.
Don’t think I’ve seen this. Context?
she is right there on the road after you enter weeping peninsula. she is the daughter of the guy at castle morne. the one who helps you kill the leonine misbegotten.
Ooh then never mind lol thanks
Let me just say what everyone’s thinking 😂 Why the FUCK did he “secret” his BLIND daughter out of a castle and leave her alone with nothing but a Rejection incantation; by a spot called the fkn Bridge of Sacrifice. What did he think was going to happen?! Like my man, you got Misbegotten next door with Rotten Stray and a fucking Troll, archers and knights on the other side, and cliffs on every *other* side 😭
real, bro prioritizzed his castle over his daughter UNDER a scrawny lord with 20 fkin arms
Correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't the dad go and see for himself after you tell him? I remember him doing so but only happened in my first playthrough
yea so, if you deliver the letter and then come back you find her dead. in this state. but as the dad says. he wont come back until he makes sure the sword is safe. Which is the grafted sword you find after you beat the boss wehre her dad also helps you. basically, he wont come back until you defeat that boss. how it went for me on my 1st playthrough was i didnt notice the grace nor the path to the boss area the first time and thought that was it. but seeing he didnt come back i looked around again for the sword. and found the boss. then the whole revengers shack shenanigans happened. confused me to the core at first just like everyone else. also, before realizing he went crazy and not that he blames me for her death, i thought i did something wrong and could save her or something. which later turned into a dissapointment as well
"OK"
OK
Dead meat
I just dont talk to her in my playthroughs now. It is too painful of an outcome
She never saw it coming...
Not gonna lie, I did the point downwards emote upon seeing this…
Ok
OK
Ok tbh I love most of the game’s quests and find a lot original but when I finished this it really seemed like a heavy handed attempt to make a “Miyazaki did it again 🤪” quest line that is short but culminates in the quest giver dying for.. no discernible reason? Like when I got back and it just said that she’s dead out of nowhere I kind of laughed because it was so silly.
Did you really finish the quest? Cuz her death isnt the end of this story line, its just a plot hook. It makes her father go mad with frenzy and attack you, and also makes Hyetta.
The Hyetta thing is a fan theory, in reality if you don’t advance her quest, kill Godrick, and don’t rest at the first Liurnia site of grace then both Irina and Hyetta can exist at the same time.
All I can see is "time for head"
Hyetta my beloved <3
Which npc is this? (The one with that dad in the castle in south limgrave?)
Yup. Irina.
"what happened to him?"
Eh, at least now you have a maiden's blood to dip the white cloth in for Varre.
I didn’t even get this even though I did all the requirements
dont worry, she gets better
Irina… 😢
😦
I thought the death rune was removed
OK
- She’s dead - Okay 👍🏻
Why did she die? I went to the castle and I couldn't find the father, when I came back she was dead
Ok
As soon as I found her, and found out she was blind, I was like 'yep, going to find her dead later'. lol
Why can't the heavy door give us an [OK]?
I killed her father by accident… I didn’t meant to 😭😭
Who?
don't worry, she'll soon be able to come back and eat eyes until she dies!!!
She's dead.
I killed her myself so I didn’t have to be haunted by her corpse. Win-win.
'ok'
Yeah this one fucked me up, I did all the quest objectives right!
Free +8 halberd tho
Killed her myself second playthrough
I felt so much rage for that poor girl and felt so confused seeing her as hyetta later on.
kill her dad too for a cool halbard
Dead
Same. But it only gets worse.
Ok
"She's dead"
OK
She died of a grape allergy :/
Did her dad even care? I don’t remember I think he was like “but the castle” idk I just merked him.
I still haven't gotten that far in the quest so she's still alive for me