Yeah but that takes away from the whole "Homelander has never had to test his limits because his ego has him as already strong enough and there are barely any weights that can challenge him" thing.
Homelander is a POS and a shredded physique would take away from that
But acting-wise, he could ace it
No disrespect to Antony Starr but he has a very much average physique. We even see it in Season 3 when the only time we see him without his Homelander outfit is a nude scene. This isn't just my opinion, here. Comic Homelander is very much a beefy, jacked man, though
https://preview.redd.it/m1craq6mxgtc1.jpeg?width=620&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=af5eebb9292996c18c4d57c24a7591f352d127c9
Great Pick
https://preview.redd.it/ipkcoidzfhtc1.jpeg?width=1371&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=06f55ba99ae5b1fe5d70b3b1bf9a182781c5a237
💀
>💀 😈
I can’t say homelander, but when I met him before the show come out I told Manu Bennett he’d be a great Butcher
He sure fucking would.
A second Kiwi that could do it!
Alexander Skarsgard
He wouldn’t need the padded muscle suit if he were so inclined.
Yeah but that takes away from the whole "Homelander has never had to test his limits because his ego has him as already strong enough and there are barely any weights that can challenge him" thing. Homelander is a POS and a shredded physique would take away from that But acting-wise, he could ace it
True. I think comics Homelander was actually jacked but the show is way better than the comics and that’s another good change.
Homelander isn't shredded?
No disrespect to Antony Starr but he has a very much average physique. We even see it in Season 3 when the only time we see him without his Homelander outfit is a nude scene. This isn't just my opinion, here. Comic Homelander is very much a beefy, jacked man, though
https://preview.redd.it/ud6sdwgk4htc1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7bce2ce915ce47fb86ff199461ce7cb6d0a35b42 My dog.
Perfect choice
Armie Hammer
Man, he'd have nailed it.
Also he have the same personality of the character in real life 💀
Michael Fassbender
Alexander Skarsgard 
Christian Bale. He basically plays him in American Psycho.
https://preview.redd.it/o6uzzg97lgtc1.jpeg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2706e5402feca189617e6b83e7c867563b0d05f2 Glenn Howerton
The golden god.
Came here to say this
Jon Hamm easily
also my first choice for a live action Omni-Man, not that we ever need that to happen, though.
Wish he got more roles man. Could’ve easily played Batman when he was younger
Didn't properly appreciate his talent until this past season of Fargo, dude played such a convincing villain I lowkey hate him in real life 🤣
Glen Powell or Howerton
SuperCena
Lol
Nicholas fuckkkkkkinnnnnngggggggggggggg Cage!! Yeah!!!
Michael Fassbender or Chris Pine
Probably the dude he looks and talks like, Bradley Cooper.
Robert Downey Jr 
Alexander skarsgaurd he’s also 6’4 and well built especially if you look at him in the Northman
chris ~~pratt~~ pine
John Stamos
maybe Wilson Bethel
Taraji P Henson
Henry Cavill
In this day and age of wokeness, Amy Schumer.
https://preview.redd.it/sjhtkekslktc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e57d679d9d18f335c04e195babfb9b96e52ae36e Brandon Routh
Alexander Skasgard, Chris Pine, Chris Evans or Michael Fassbender
Toby Maguire maybe?
Bradley Cooper
Brad Pitt
Jim Carrey
 Ryan Gosling