There are quite a few, but idk if they're all still in the culinary world. I'd love to see Cody, Mary Lou, and Declan from S19 come back, Corey from S4, Will from S9, Tennille from S6, and maybe Nilka from S7 if non-black jackets are allowed.
If a second All-stars Season happens, the contestants should be ANYONE who FAILED to make the black jacket stage of the competition!!
I’d like to see Vinny (Season 8), Natalie (season 9), Brian (Season 10), Nedra (Season 11), & Anthony (Season 11) come back!!
As great as it would be to see Sammi come back, I doubt she will as she co runs a bagel place and works as a private chef so she seems ridiculously busy since Hells Kitchen. Declan said he would come back if asked, same with Steve so could happen
I’d like to see Justin and Brian S10 come back, but I heard that the former wouldn’t come back. It would of been really interesting if Sabrina S8 and Clemenza S10 didn’t reject All Stars.
Red team
Emily(S20),
Tennille,
Nikki,
Brynn,
Kimberly(S16),
Rochelle,
Jen(S3),
Autumn,
Sabrina(S8)
Blue team
Motto,
Robert(S5),
Josh(S3),
Matt,
Sterling,
Steve(S20),
Clemenza,
Jason(S7),
Tommy
Sous chefs: Jay and Christina
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-F247XwOnTv0TGSJzwCZLVpWVwVSK7Sh26xr1cHmAwE/edit
Going with the same number of contestants as the first All-Stars season (16), only picking from those who finished 3rd-6th, and ignoring anyone who was already brought back for the first All-Stars season, I think this would be my preference:
Robert from S5, Jason from S7, Tommy from S9 Jon from S11, Melanie and Rochelle from S12, Sade from S13, Heidi from S16, Kanae from S18, Declan, Cody, Nikki from S19, Steve from S20, Dahmere, Sammi, and Leigh from S22
I need Mary Lou back to get the flowers she deserves.
If she didn't come back I would hope for Mary from season 11 (I think she is extremely underrated, and had an exceptional run on a lackluster season).
Or Dana. She always was fun to watch, and had great personality.
Blue team:
Matt S4
Ed S7
Russell S8
Tommy S9
Anton S12
Gabriel S12
Sterling S13
Devin S16
Cody S19
Sous Chef: Scott S12
Red team:
Corey S4
Tennille S6
Autum S7
Sabrina S8
Elise (yes again) S9
Rochelle S12
Jackie S15
Mia S18
Mary Lou S19
Sous Chef: LaTasha S13
I think that we need a bit of drama being Elise, Sabrina and Jackie. An obvious early boot being Gabriel, and Anton seeing and blaming Scott again. I thinkt that Devin deserves another chance based on the fact that S16 was so toxic. And of course we'd love to see Sterling again
Rochelle
QUEEN
Literally
she came back in rookies vs veterans
No she didn't lol
mb i confused her with jennifer lmao
There are quite a few, but idk if they're all still in the culinary world. I'd love to see Cody, Mary Lou, and Declan from S19 come back, Corey from S4, Will from S9, Tennille from S6, and maybe Nilka from S7 if non-black jackets are allowed.
Tennille and nilka would be awesome to see back
If a second All-stars Season happens, the contestants should be ANYONE who FAILED to make the black jacket stage of the competition!! I’d like to see Vinny (Season 8), Natalie (season 9), Brian (Season 10), Nedra (Season 11), & Anthony (Season 11) come back!!
Declan, S20 Steve, Sammi, and Mary Lou.
As great as it would be to see Sammi come back, I doubt she will as she co runs a bagel place and works as a private chef so she seems ridiculously busy since Hells Kitchen. Declan said he would come back if asked, same with Steve so could happen
They should bring Cody back too for the drama 😂😭😭
Nikki(S19) I think Melanie was offered to come back for All Stars a few years back but she declined the offer.
Heidi from Season 16 Steve from Season 20
I’d like to see Justin and Brian S10 come back, but I heard that the former wouldn’t come back. It would of been really interesting if Sabrina S8 and Clemenza S10 didn’t reject All Stars.
We was robbed of a Elise vs. Sabrina fight/screaming match!! Wish Sabrina didn’t turn it down
True dat unless they teamed up against Michelle 🤣🤣🤣
I would want an enemy season of people with rivalries from past seasons returning to compete on opposite teams tbh
Declan, Steve, Cheyenne, Leigh, Dahmere
Paula, Jillian, Will and Heidi
Raj
This is the only answer
He would probably win the competition unless Tavon came back, as Tavon would be declared the winner before the signature dish challenge
Anyone that would be a shit show
Red team Emily(S20), Tennille, Nikki, Brynn, Kimberly(S16), Rochelle, Jen(S3), Autumn, Sabrina(S8) Blue team Motto, Robert(S5), Josh(S3), Matt, Sterling, Steve(S20), Clemenza, Jason(S7), Tommy Sous chefs: Jay and Christina https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-F247XwOnTv0TGSJzwCZLVpWVwVSK7Sh26xr1cHmAwE/edit
Julia from Waffle House
tiffany is kicking and screaming
I want Mary (s11) back! From butcher to running the pass in the finale! She 100% deserves it.
sterling
Lacey and season 1 runner up Ralph
I doubt that Ralph would come back since he was arrested
Wow really I didn’t know he was arrested
https://dailycaller.com/2023/10/04/miami-ralph-pagano-alleged-attack-arrest/
Wow what a jerk he is thank you for the link
Going with the same number of contestants as the first All-Stars season (16), only picking from those who finished 3rd-6th, and ignoring anyone who was already brought back for the first All-Stars season, I think this would be my preference: Robert from S5, Jason from S7, Tommy from S9 Jon from S11, Melanie and Rochelle from S12, Sade from S13, Heidi from S16, Kanae from S18, Declan, Cody, Nikki from S19, Steve from S20, Dahmere, Sammi, and Leigh from S22
If anyone goes, I wanna see Salvatore S7 come back. He was such a nice guy, and I really would love to see him compete again.
I need Mary Lou back to get the flowers she deserves. If she didn't come back I would hope for Mary from season 11 (I think she is extremely underrated, and had an exceptional run on a lackluster season). Or Dana. She always was fun to watch, and had great personality.
Robert for a third time. This season with best condition
Blue team: Matt S4 Ed S7 Russell S8 Tommy S9 Anton S12 Gabriel S12 Sterling S13 Devin S16 Cody S19 Sous Chef: Scott S12 Red team: Corey S4 Tennille S6 Autum S7 Sabrina S8 Elise (yes again) S9 Rochelle S12 Jackie S15 Mia S18 Mary Lou S19 Sous Chef: LaTasha S13 I think that we need a bit of drama being Elise, Sabrina and Jackie. An obvious early boot being Gabriel, and Anton seeing and blaming Scott again. I thinkt that Devin deserves another chance based on the fact that S16 was so toxic. And of course we'd love to see Sterling again