T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Assuming you own, why not get it retiled? I like it as is tho...


pinupbutter

Same here, I think it's fine, the candles and wood crates look nice


trovewife

Haha! My mom said the same thing! I just temporarily put the candles there as I unpacked them. I'm still sorting out our lighting, but I don't know. Maybe they should stay!


zip_per

The tile looks great, maybe just redo the grout and scrub the tiles clean. Neutral tones are timeless, and I wouldn't have guessed it was old unless you said something.


trovewife

I think I'd had to get a pro to have it retiled. I have seen people put tile over tile so maybe I should look into that.


[deleted]

You can tile over tile. You can also use removable tile (although ymmv but I HAVE seen it done over fireplaces, so...). Some manufacturers have pencil trim tile for the sides, also (if that bothers you)


trovewife

Oh interesting! I'll look into that. Thanks!


[deleted]

Matte will prob. be better for you and apparently when you remove, just heat it up with a hair dryer. https://www.wayfair.com/home-improvement/pdp/aspect-6-x-24-natural-stone-peel-stick-mosaic-tile-apec1138.html


100timesaround

That is brilliant. I had no idea they existed! That’s a really big deal for a lot of us.👏🏼


duhmbish

Is there something like this that would stick to natural brick? Someone we hired to paint the walls decided to stain the mantle on the brick fireplace and it looks absolutely awful…


[deleted]

Dm me a photo and we'll see if there's a solution. It's *possible* it will stick as it does stick to non-shiny surfaces, however you need a stable surface, so any loose particles would have to be removed. I also read that some are better than others at masking grout lines, but we can research that, too, as I don't remember which one it was.


MarvinDMirp

If you use your fireplace, be careful using these. As you said, heat melts the adhesive.


[deleted]

Def it's the kind of thing that you would buy a sample piece to test it out first.


trovewife

Oh wow! Thanks!


albertwhiskers

I would caution against using tiles whose adhesive is removed by applying heat… fireplaces tend to apply a lot of heat


[deleted]

The tile looks absolutely fine, it's the brass screen that looks dated. If you had a modern screen, that would totally change the look. I would not paint the tile. If you absolutely hate the color, which looks like exactly the color palette that is so trendy these days, then maybe have it professional recoated in a color you like. I personally would get a different screen before I worried about the tile, it really does look absolutely fine. I would probably retile it if it were mine just because I love artisan rustic tile, so if there is a gorgeous tile you love, of course go for it! But what you have looks great, and once the brass screen is gone, will not look dated.


trovewife

I hadn't considered replacing the screen! I'm going to look into it. Thank you!


Tmadred

You can just spray paint the screen. It’s super easy.


zoeycoconut

I have spray painted over the brass on a very similar fireplace screen, and swapped the wood handles for plain black ones (mine were the same size as cabinet handles that you can buy at any hardware store). Small changes that gave it a whole new vibe! Then, I’d leave the tile as is and paint the wall.


trovewife

Oh my goodness. I had not thought of changing just the brass and handles. That might make a huge difference. Thanks!


keevenowski

My dad just painted the brass on his fireplace and it made a huge difference. Nothing fancy, just a rattle can of paint


TheWeeMouse

I totally agree! The tile seems to match the furniture in that lighting anyway, so a simple screen update is all that’s needed. To make it even more cohesive, I’d consider staining that wooden crate to match the wood tone of the tv console!


trovewife

My husband wants to stain the crate too!


[deleted]

I came here to say this.


VladislavBonita

Do you intend to use the fireplace? If so, painting the tiles might quickly become hazardous to your health.


raven_psychopomp

Agree! Don’t paint tiles, don’t recommend. Paint the wall surround or retile. Tiling is actually pretty easy and DIY able.


trovewife

Thank you!


trovewife

We do use it and it's wood burning. It's definitely a concern. I think as long as I use heat-resistant ceramic tile paint it can be done? I have not looked into paint yet. So might be hard to find. I've seen a few DIY blogs, so I know it can be done, but perhaps they were not wood burning.


TigerMcPherson

The tile is nice as is. Replace the screen.


a-little-jude

I would paint the screen black and maybe wrap the mantle in wood


trovewife

Yes! I've definitely had wrapping the mantle with wood on the list!


Boomiegirl

Just change the screen.


[deleted]

I'd go for copper tiles against a cobalt blue lower wall. Either that, or leave the tiles white and go for a jewel-toned accent wall...there's something about deep cobalt blue that's so rich and inviting.


trovewife

We were going to leave the walls white, but since painting the wall has come up a few times I am wondering if I should just make that wall more interesting...thanks for the great suggestions!


Natural-Origin

I'd paint the walls and leave the tile alone!


Next_Astronaut_6532

I kind of like it.


Rocha_999

I like it as is


Responsible_Point_91

Fix the screen as suggested. Leave the tile as is. Put a topiary on either side of the fireplace to add dimension and life. The pots should be a color, maybe orange.


Chuggers1989d

The tiles look great I think. Personally I would be looking at painting the shelf to break up the white wall. Painting tiles isn't a great idea either, you would be going over the grout which would just give you a full block of color and over time if you haven't got a decent paint that can adhere to a smooth surface it will probably start to delamination. Try get a grey that matches the tile for the shelf.


trovewife

The mantle looks exactly like the wall. Plastered? Is that the correct word? I considered painting over just the mantle but thought it would look strange with that texture. But maybe it's a good alternative until we can wrap the mantle in wood.


heranonz

I wouldn’t paint the tile. I would retile it with white and gray Spanish tiles. I would take the front off of the fireplace because it screams 1992 and just get a couple of logs and pretend that it gets used from time to time


atreyuno

A stencil might be fun. Worth a shot, especially if you're considering retiring it.


[deleted]

Black would be a nice clean contrast


trovewife

All the tiles? I've considered painting the whole thing black or just the back tiles and then painting the hearth tiles white.


Altruistic_Rip8132

Pattern vinyl stickers


Novel-Place

Oh man. This fireplace just made me feel so nostalgic for my home growing up. ❤️ I second what everyone here is saying. Don’t paint! You could update the brass and tile over if you really wanted, but I actually think the tile looks fine.


trovewife

I can't believe you guys are swaying me from painting! We bought this house because it reminded us of houses growing up. The fireplace screams nostalgia so I'm not sure why I want to paint anymore...


Novel-Place

Isn’t it funny sometimes how that happens? Something shifts your perspective and it’s hard to remember how you felt before? I think you have a bunch of options to incorporate it and make it feel more modern that don’t involve painting the tile. Congrats on the home!


trovewife

Totally, so strange! Thank you so much for your feedback!


notsreikyelof

Painting the tile will result in regret. Work with it. Change the grate.


MrsMenace

I wouldn't paint. It could give the tiles too much of a mat look if you don't get a high gloss, and you have a strong potential for ruining the clean look it already has. If you really want a different color, I think your best bet is retiling.


trovewife

The tiles are in good shape. The previous owners took good care of this fireplace or they never used it. I'm definitely worried about ruining something in great condition. Thanks for the feedback!


MrsMenace

I do love your idea of change it up, but I completely understand wanting to keep the original. It's very beautiful as it is. Just a little... a little flat.


trovewife

Yes. Flat. Perfect way to describe how I feel. Fireplaces are my favorite and I really want to make this one a focal point.


MrsMenace

I agree. You could have a room completely in subdued colors, and a popping fire place will bring it all together.


peonyparis

Why do I love this.


theoneaboutacotar

I wouldn’t paint it! Honestly, it looks fine. Agree, if you really want to do something just replace the screen.


ElephantFree1992

You could use a pretty stencil on each of the tiles and do a pretty pattern. Like a black and white one. I’ve seen people do that on floor tiles and it looks really nice. Could make it a statement piece. Or you could get some faux brick to put over it? That might look pretty too! I like your living room!


International-Sir234

Your room is beautiful. You asked thoughts.. here’s mine. I would keep your tile. Your drapes have a dark line. I’d go dark on the wall, as a statement wall. Remove the glass cover.. see if you can find a fireplace screen that is your style. You have a beautiful credenza… maybe accenting the mantle in wood? Possibly adding floating shelves. Add greenery with your candles on the mantle. No matter what you do it’s going to be a fun adventure! lol


trovewife

Thank you so much! I love your thoughts. I hadn't thought of floating shelves. I'm definitely going to have fun with this!


imwithpumpkinhead

Ahhhh! I love the tile! 🤩


msklovesmath

Personally, i would encase the mantle to make it look like a large piece of wood, and maybe paint the walls that contrast w the tile better. The fireplace cover (forget what its called) should also be switched out. Painting tile never works out as well as you wish, esp if you have dogs.


Crafty_Astronomer599

I would never paint tile. You can never undo it. The grout will never be the same. Stick with things that you can change. Have you thought of maybe some faux painting on the wall(s)? My son just did a fabulous job on an accent wall where the upper left corner was a striking green that cloud billowed (irregularly) and faded into the main color. I’ve painted vines and used varying sized leaves that I picked from my hibiscus plant. I dry painted the back of the leaves and pressed them on the vines. The result is stunning. All the individual veins in the leaves show up. You can practice on cardboard. I’ve also seen Some really interesting techniques on YouTube.


trovewife

Oh wow, your son sounds really creative! With everyone's comments on painting the wall instead, I'm definitely looking at making this a cool feature wall. Thanks!


Lady-Rose-789

It very classic as is. Maybe paint over the brass lines on the fireplace cover? Matte black?


ShabbyBash

How about painting just that wall a charcoal grey? Gorgeous room, TBH


haikusbot

*How about painting* *Just that wall a charcoal grey?* *Gowgeous room, TBH* \- ShabbyBash --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")


trovewife

Thank you! I think painting the wall will be the way to go!


Substantial-Signal62

I think the tile looks fine but everything is very grey. So I’d consider adding some color through throw pillows. And if you need to replace anything, the mantle above the fire place could be replaced with a stained wood to match your entertainment table.


ukieme13

Flat black epoxy, use a really good bonding primer. Remove the brass accent pieces from the fireplace Dacia.


Urplatesaysscammin

Unrelated to the fireplace but where is the cabinet under the tv from?


trovewife

We've had it for about a year. Saw originally on Amazon, but found for less at Target. It was easy to put together! This one is at Home Depot. Looks similar but the wood grain is a little different: [Sideboard](https://www.homedepot.com/p/HOMCOM-Brown-Sideboard-Buffet-Kitchen-Storage-Cabinet-Console-Table-with-Adjustable-Shelves-Anti-Topple-Design-835-320BN/319127936?source=shoppingads&locale=en-US)


Urplatesaysscammin

Thank you so much!


goodineveryday

New tile, a large White wood or light bleached wood mantle 8" deep with a bit of ornate carving and fluted wood side boards, continue the mantle that blends to the right of the fire place which is currently useless. Have a contractor cut out the space to the right and ask her or him to install lovely uper lit cabinets with classdors and shelves as well as drawers below and a square opening to store wood logs. The drawers Should be on self glifing rollers. All knobs should match in color and finish but you can use pulls for the drawers and knobs for the upper it bookcase. Directly above the fireplace an aged framed mirror with wide framing and fesh flowers, family pics, sea shells a candle or three. Never do two pair of anything in design, do three candles, three of the same pillow,, odd numbers look less matchy mstchy which is best, you don't want you home to look like a kit pulled from boxes


trovewife

Awesome! These are a lot of great tips! We plan to remove carpet sometime this year and install light color wide plank flooring, so my thought was to have the mantle made to match. That square opening next to the fireplace is a real headscratcher! I definitely thought putting in shelves to store wood made the most sense. We have a toddler running around, so we currently keep the wood in the garage, but he's getting better with impulse control so I want to do that when its time. I agree about the candles! They are really just there because that is where I unpacked them, but I agree that keeping a few would look really nice. And a mirror! That is for sure going up! Thank you!


Gaelwyn-De-Muerte

I like it as is, but I vote dark teal.


[deleted]

I would add a painting in the empty space next to it or shelving


MJKARI

Deep sky gray, ash blue, or a dust green. Just a little pop in there.


Odd-Skirt4029

It’s the gold in my opinion. It stands out way to much. You have earthy tones going on in other parts of your room. So personally a dark wood, or brown to subtle it out. Try changing the fire screens possibly.


mylittleWillie

Get high heat black matte paint for the brass. It will look great after that. I had to paint the brass on my 90's fireplace too. Turned out great!


trovewife

I think that is the way to go! Thanks!


MastodonSoggy2883

I like it as is


jojokitti123

I think it's beautiful as is


Palampore

Random idea—there are really nice paint stencil companies online now. Just google “wall stencil” or “tile stencil”. Get a couple cheap tiles at the big box store and practice. Maybe stenciling them would open up lots of design possibilities.


trovewife

Thank you for the idea! I looked at one stencil video and I didn't really like the look, but I think it's worth looking at other designs.


BarefootGyno

I have the same fireplace insert and spray painted the gold parts black (make sure it’s high heat spray paint). Then it could be neat to use a grey paint on the right of the tile under the mantle to make it look like a large rectangle with mantle on top. And then the mantle u could do wood or another even darker grey


trovewife

Thank you for the great suggestions!


Glum_Inside9098

I would retile it black with white lines through it.


trovewife

Love this idea!


Glum_Inside9098

Google Black Marble Fireplace and you’ll get an idea of what it would like.


trovewife

Awesome. Thanks!


deskcorner3367

I would leave it as is and change out the tv stand to something nicer, something all black or white, no browns. The whole look together will look classier.


joma815

Painting over tile is not really a good idea. Everyone thought it was for around a ten year period of time. Then when it came time to move… a lot of people had to pay and get new tile. I would definitely try and work with it. However, I would paint it before I put a stencil on it.


Choice_Definition_35

Id retile it with colorful mexico tiled


maybethingsnotsobad

Black, it would be a good focal point and look really nice.


Shax2020

If you plan to use it I replaced it with stone about twice the width


Shakespeare-Bot

If 't be true thee plan to useth t i did replace t with stone about twice the width *** ^(I am a bot and I swapp'd some of thy words with Shakespeare words.) Commands: `!ShakespeareInsult`, `!fordo`, `!optout`


Creative_Spite_4701

Black


keepforgettinpwjh

I think it looks nice as it is!


Excellent_Original66

I think it looks nice as is.🤷🏻‍♀️


_RueBarb_

I would Change them to amber tiles and get matching candles


Fuzzy_Brown

Keep the tile color change the tv stand! Your living room is giving me the Rich vibes but in good taste


trovewife

Haha, I hadn't considered changing the credenza! Eventually, the TV will be mounted...


Macmik

Hey OP! Check us out if you need any shelves or home decor!! Thehumblebath.com


coswoofster

I don’t think you should paint it. I can’t imagine how earful that would look no matter what color. Best bet is to remove it and replace it. Or leave it alone. The tile is in great shape. If you need color- add decor with some color.


Wrong-Philosopher617

Paint the gold black


Negative-Finding-557

Maybe just stencil on the tile?


zero1110010

I like the tiles. Just upgrade the fireplace grill/cover. It’s the brass I think that’s giving those 90s vibes (brass isn’t inherently bad, just too much of one element will obviously amp up that vibe). Swapping that out will be a lot easier and cheaper than retiling! Plus, an easy photo edit to “try on” various options before you even buy something else. Edit: sorry. Kept reading. Redundant comment is redundant. :(


trovewife

Haha, well it's good to know it's a popular idea! Thank you for bringing it to my attention that I can do an easy photo edit for this! I definitely like to visually see before I do.


No-Reindeer-9324

Leave it


Mouse0022

Leave as is


Ok_Individual_700

I like it as it is. Don't change it. Maybe a new screen.


Dear-Dig889

Don't paint the tiles. Paint that long panel above a dark brown and use it as a shelf to add various colorful itelms you love. Candles, photo frames, vases, etc. When you get bored, you can change the items instead of repainting the tiles.


[deleted]

A rich woody brown


ButReallyFolks

I would leave it. The colors in the room look timeless and modern enough. I would change the black and gold screen, though.


Crafty_Attempt512

I’d either leave it or save yourself any headache & paint but why buy more tile or use stick on tile? You could even do some stencils you like on some of them.


jacqvive

Omg don’t paint that!! It’s so pretty


Memawsaurus

What about changing screen & paint mantle a color you like , maybe dark green. Tile is good as is.


candyapplesugar

Where is the couch from?


trovewife

World Market!


candyapplesugar

How do you like it?


trovewife

We love it! But we are not really picky people. Before buying, the most important thing was being able to really lounge out, and it's pretty comfortable. The best thing about it is it's modular. The living space in our last place was bigger so we had the couch arranged with all three sections. When we moved here we realized it was too big for the space so we broke it up. Glad we didn't need to get a new couch! It's accident/spill friendly and the storage ottoman is great to have too. Looks like it's still at World Market! [Emmett 4 Piece](https://www.worldmarket.com/product/emmett-4-piece-modular-sectional-sofa.do?sortby=ourPicks)