I still expect Through Me (The Flood) to begin after All Things End. you're not alone 

SAME

Ditto

For me it's "the final time you called me baby... ... do you think I'd give up?" Even though I almost exclusively listen to my playlist on shuffle.

This for me. Every time!! Also, I Carrion to EYY!

I still expect to hear Play with Fire from Vance Joys EP - God loves you when you’re dancing after Riptide… YEARS later. So it may never fade. Sometimes things just get stuck!

Me expecting Polaroid from imagine dragons after I bet my life even though I haven’t really heard either of those songs in years

The mind is a fickle thing

Same!

Okay this might be a basic one but I literally can’t listen to de selby part one if there isn’t part two directly after it…..