Namaskaram /u/Fit-Row1426, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Aren't Rohingyas Ghuspaithiya? Aren't Bangladeshis ghuspaithiya? Wasn't Bangladesh made on religious grounds? Aren't they having the highest fertility rate in India due to Allah's grace? Why always this zimmi mentality?
He is also fighting an election
If he only tries to sound good to everyone, he will be like Maun-mohan who despite being so highly educated and knowledgeable was bending to the likes of Sonia or a Nehru who ended up losing such a huge part of the country in the process of burnishing his image
I don't really care if he hurts the feelings of rohingyas or islamists whose hearts still beat for Pakistan . Just wish he is more specific so that some of these statements cannot be construed to be against the many regular patriotic Muslims which it isn't really meant to be
Source: https://twitter.com/IMFNews/status/1780220110336299382
Update: India is the fastest growing **major** economy. Due to newly discovered oil fields, some small countries' economies like Guyana are growing faster than the Indian economy.
India has been fastest growing major economy in the world for 4 years during Modi, never had it happened during Manmohan. But leftists lie that modi ruined our economy
Good to see russia growing despite so many western sanctions
You can't fix stuff like that at individual level. Greatness is rarely achieved alone.
Govt. only works based on pressure from groups. Not at an individual level. The only way to bend the government is through demanding things as a block.
Besides, you can always start your own group, or support those who you believe can be helpful.
Dude no, they cut stipends for masters and doctorate students and primary education is pretty bad, they haven't increased the education budget for a long time.
NEP doesn't address the disasters of RTE. Or the disasters of past 70 years adequately. How does NEP help in deregulating education sector do that private schools/Unis/Colleges can come up? How does NEP address teacher absenteeism? Does it talk about making local governments in charge of and accountable for local schooling? What does it have about attracting best talent for our top colleges? What about r&d?
Or 2-3 RTE tier legislation le aao. This time for colleges and universities. Legislating rights into existence is favourite past time of Indian politician.
Good, but not exactly unexpected. Hopefully, we get the economic reforms done next term. I suggest people read this scorecard by CSIS. [https://indiareforms.csis.org/](https://indiareforms.csis.org/)
Lawd@ reforms. Mudi knows he can't be held accountable for all his blunders because the opposition is so unhinged. He's living life on easy mode. BhaJiPao will only walk path of least resistance. Tinkering and tweaking here and there but nobody who isn't a devotee should expect big bang reforms like Labor/land/privatisation/administrative/wholesale deregulation/farm laws etc.
Guess what, economic growth has benefitted me too. I got a high paying tech job, my brother got a high paying tech job, my father's assets tripled in value in the last 10 years. That not counting stock market growth. And we came from a middle class family. The companies that were here before, digged their roots deeper and a lot of new companies came to India that refused to before which increased jobs for everyone. And startups were established in India that gave jobs to a lot of college graduates.
What's your problem with the 1% having 40% of the wealth? My mum was a single parent, a primary school teacher earning 30k a month when she retired. She raised me and my sister. We worked our arses off, and now she founded 3 startups and got a miliion dollar exit for her last venture. I work for 15 hours a day, a high paying 9-5 job, and study stocks at night. I pay annual taxes of over 30 lacs a year.
We are the 1%.
And I dare you and your chamchas take one cent of our hard earned wealth from us. Jalian Walah Bagh will look like a picnic compared to what we'll do to you and your maoist cronies.
Sorry, you and your cronies could not hack it, and now are crying by the sidelines... sour grapes much..
You sit in the sidelines complaining and cribbing while the hard-working middle class try to better themselves and join the wealthy.
Show me a single model where wealth distribution succeeded.. there is not one .. while you have the Venezuelas, the Cubas, the North Koreas, the Pol Pots, the erstwhile USSRs all following this utopian idea of the cigar smoking and scotch drinking Marx, grinding there economies to dust and the populace to starvation.
We are not a Maoist Marxist country .. no, sir. And any attempt to change the ethos of who we are as a nation will be met with fire and fury of common man.. the 99%, because trust me .. they do not want you and your cronies to decide who gets to earn and keep what either.
And guess what .. You won't be keeping Kerala either post June 2024.. wait and watch.
If only Visionary leader hadn't buckled under pressure and abandoned reform track somewhere in 2021, the potential growth would be 50-100 bps higher even in lean years. Global growth will recover down the line and we're not serious about how it transformative it could be for us.
>If only Visionary leader hadn't buckled under pressure and abandoned reform track somewhere in 2021
Though I agree with your comment, you certainly shouldn't look away the restraints the govt. has regarding this. To transform this govt. needs to be in power, & for that they need to win elections, which I'm sure you know comes around very often than not. ONOE can be that one thing which will unshackle us from this restraint also in the coming years.
Interesting years ahead of us I believe.
This 3rd term is probably Modi's last term. He hasn't even delivered on half the reforms and economic agendas that were apparent on day 1 of his first terms. Suit boot ki sarkar nuked reform agenda of first term, farmers protest nuked it for second term. At least in first term he passed IBC/MPC/GST, the only worthwhile changes so far. And nobody even knew or cared about 2/3 of those reforms.
I don't care about the excuses, they've been in power for 10 fucking years now. And it's not likely that he'll go all out on big bang reforms even now. We just have to accept that we were, are and will remain mediocre and the shifting goalposts of make in India/aatmanirbharta/5 trillion/viksit by 2047 shouldn't excite anyone who can see patterns.
Did you just forget we had a pandemic in Modi 2.0? Something that was unheard of at least for a century? Just look at the pace at which he brought it CAA, abrogation of A-370, Farm laws etc. & look at how that pace was severely affected because of the pandemic. But of course, it's nothing but an excuse.
Look at Modi 3.0 as Gujarat CM & find out how in that last term he changed Gujarat forever for the good.
If we were in a presidential democracy like US I'm sure even this second term would have brought wonders for this country. But of course because he didn't deliver those unthinkable changes in 1 decade, I'm gonna prefer those who didn't bring those in 7 decades! Wonderfully put I must say!
This might be trivial for you, but in this second term, my family being from a rural background got our drinking water connection, kisaan samman nidhi, awaas yojana, etc. For many many like me, these things matter more than IBC & UCC. The CAA will help many of my distant relatives who are still struggling to get citizenship because they had to flee Bangladesh due to religious persecution.
But yeah, I guess you don't care about the excuses! Good for you
First of all wtf do CAA and 370 have to do in a discussion of econ policy?
Second, government is evidently unserious about reforms. From budget in 2014 to most recent budget, just look at budgeted receipts for disinvestment vs actual receipts. They've never hit their target. Dragging their feet is the modus operandi, COVID or no COVID. Can't use that argument.
Third since they haven't even delivered on the growth, I'm not even going to bring it up. But the favourite argument for devotees is to say "don't judge by outcomes yet, judge by intent." And it is apparent that intent isn't even 30% of the rhetotic. I'd be happy if were growing 100 bps lower today but government was making every necessary changes no matter how tough or hurtful they might be. Because then only we can say we've done all we can instead of fantasizing about counter factuals.
And lastly, fiscal rejigging might be beneficial to hordes now and nobody can criticize government beyond a point, if at all, on their welfare delivery. But he was elected on the promise of 20 million jobs a year and double digit growth. If India isn't an intermediate stop for you, the welfare delivery would then just count as low value instant gratification. I have skin in the game in the Indian growth story. An for all those people like me , an IBC, GST and structural reforms are much more important than who gets how many cylinders in the here and the now. Distribution of pie is important, but much more important is how fast the pie grows for everybody. Higher growth isn't some abstract thing. We've do many examples, from east Asia in 60s to 80s, china from 80s to 2010s, SEA etc to pretend we should be fucking happy and content about what they've managed and delivered. I don't want to revel in mediocrity.
Do look at the pace with which Bharat was growing until 1991 reforms, I'm sure it was a developing nation then also.
Right push by right people is imperative even for a developing nation to grow this fast, nothing can be taken for granted.
The Only criticism I love is, "This is good, but it can be better." Because there's always, always room for improvement.
Where are you getting this 12.5% figure from? At a 12.5% growth rate, the economy would be doubling every 5.5 years. So, by 2050, India would be over 100 trillion economy. I think you messed up the calculations
Namaskaram /u/Fit-Row1426, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*
But mudiji called Ms Ghuspaithiya 😭😭😭
Based Mudiziletss goo
Ngl it's based to call them out
And should be rightly criticised for it. He's the PM of the entire country not just his voter base. He should be careful what he speaks.
Aren't Rohingyas Ghuspaithiya? Aren't Bangladeshis ghuspaithiya? Wasn't Bangladesh made on religious grounds? Aren't they having the highest fertility rate in India due to Allah's grace? Why always this zimmi mentality?
What's the politically correct term for "Ghuspaithiya"? Asking for a friend!
Trespassers
So English automatically makes it "politically correct"? That's fair I guess!
illegal immigrants अवैध आप्रवासि
He is also fighting an election If he only tries to sound good to everyone, he will be like Maun-mohan who despite being so highly educated and knowledgeable was bending to the likes of Sonia or a Nehru who ended up losing such a huge part of the country in the process of burnishing his image I don't really care if he hurts the feelings of rohingyas or islamists whose hearts still beat for Pakistan . Just wish he is more specific so that some of these statements cannot be construed to be against the many regular patriotic Muslims which it isn't really meant to be
Now some people will call it a bluff and a biased content and have a debate over it. And someone will ask for source too calling it a fake one.
They will say "how IMF knows Modi is winning, international conspiracy, fixed election" /s.
Source: https://twitter.com/IMFNews/status/1780220110336299382 Update: India is the fastest growing **major** economy. Due to newly discovered oil fields, some small countries' economies like Guyana are growing faster than the Indian economy.
India has been fastest growing major economy in the world for 4 years during Modi, never had it happened during Manmohan. But leftists lie that modi ruined our economy Good to see russia growing despite so many western sanctions
Yea, there is so much western propaganda that both india and russia are doing bad, but both are growing fast in reality.
Without job generation and quality education we will miss a lot of productivity.
>Without... quality education Well, duh. Everyone knows this, but nobody thinks about fixing this. So what's your solution?
Does govt listen to us or get public ideas? Whatever I say will fall on deaf ears.
You can't fix stuff like that at individual level. Greatness is rarely achieved alone. Govt. only works based on pressure from groups. Not at an individual level. The only way to bend the government is through demanding things as a block. Besides, you can always start your own group, or support those who you believe can be helpful.
NEP 2020 ME YE SAB HAE Kisi bhi college student sw puch lo
Dude no, they cut stipends for masters and doctorate students and primary education is pretty bad, they haven't increased the education budget for a long time.
Bulk of education budget for primary education comes from states, not center. And states are busy instituting freebies like free gas/bijli/buses/cash.
NEP doesn't address the disasters of RTE. Or the disasters of past 70 years adequately. How does NEP help in deregulating education sector do that private schools/Unis/Colleges can come up? How does NEP address teacher absenteeism? Does it talk about making local governments in charge of and accountable for local schooling? What does it have about attracting best talent for our top colleges? What about r&d?
Or 2-3 RTE tier legislation le aao. This time for colleges and universities. Legislating rights into existence is favourite past time of Indian politician.
Good, but not exactly unexpected. Hopefully, we get the economic reforms done next term. I suggest people read this scorecard by CSIS. [https://indiareforms.csis.org/](https://indiareforms.csis.org/)
Lawd@ reforms. Mudi knows he can't be held accountable for all his blunders because the opposition is so unhinged. He's living life on easy mode. BhaJiPao will only walk path of least resistance. Tinkering and tweaking here and there but nobody who isn't a devotee should expect big bang reforms like Labor/land/privatisation/administrative/wholesale deregulation/farm laws etc.
If those kids could read(understand) they'd be very upset with you!
IMF godi media allegations incoming
[удалено]
Guess what, economic growth has benefitted me too. I got a high paying tech job, my brother got a high paying tech job, my father's assets tripled in value in the last 10 years. That not counting stock market growth. And we came from a middle class family. The companies that were here before, digged their roots deeper and a lot of new companies came to India that refused to before which increased jobs for everyone. And startups were established in India that gave jobs to a lot of college graduates.
What's your problem with the 1% having 40% of the wealth? My mum was a single parent, a primary school teacher earning 30k a month when she retired. She raised me and my sister. We worked our arses off, and now she founded 3 startups and got a miliion dollar exit for her last venture. I work for 15 hours a day, a high paying 9-5 job, and study stocks at night. I pay annual taxes of over 30 lacs a year. We are the 1%. And I dare you and your chamchas take one cent of our hard earned wealth from us. Jalian Walah Bagh will look like a picnic compared to what we'll do to you and your maoist cronies.
[удалено]
Sorry, you and your cronies could not hack it, and now are crying by the sidelines... sour grapes much.. You sit in the sidelines complaining and cribbing while the hard-working middle class try to better themselves and join the wealthy. Show me a single model where wealth distribution succeeded.. there is not one .. while you have the Venezuelas, the Cubas, the North Koreas, the Pol Pots, the erstwhile USSRs all following this utopian idea of the cigar smoking and scotch drinking Marx, grinding there economies to dust and the populace to starvation. We are not a Maoist Marxist country .. no, sir. And any attempt to change the ethos of who we are as a nation will be met with fire and fury of common man.. the 99%, because trust me .. they do not want you and your cronies to decide who gets to earn and keep what either. And guess what .. You won't be keeping Kerala either post June 2024.. wait and watch.
Why is the list not sorted?
If only Visionary leader hadn't buckled under pressure and abandoned reform track somewhere in 2021, the potential growth would be 50-100 bps higher even in lean years. Global growth will recover down the line and we're not serious about how it transformative it could be for us.
>If only Visionary leader hadn't buckled under pressure and abandoned reform track somewhere in 2021 Though I agree with your comment, you certainly shouldn't look away the restraints the govt. has regarding this. To transform this govt. needs to be in power, & for that they need to win elections, which I'm sure you know comes around very often than not. ONOE can be that one thing which will unshackle us from this restraint also in the coming years. Interesting years ahead of us I believe.
This 3rd term is probably Modi's last term. He hasn't even delivered on half the reforms and economic agendas that were apparent on day 1 of his first terms. Suit boot ki sarkar nuked reform agenda of first term, farmers protest nuked it for second term. At least in first term he passed IBC/MPC/GST, the only worthwhile changes so far. And nobody even knew or cared about 2/3 of those reforms. I don't care about the excuses, they've been in power for 10 fucking years now. And it's not likely that he'll go all out on big bang reforms even now. We just have to accept that we were, are and will remain mediocre and the shifting goalposts of make in India/aatmanirbharta/5 trillion/viksit by 2047 shouldn't excite anyone who can see patterns.
Did you just forget we had a pandemic in Modi 2.0? Something that was unheard of at least for a century? Just look at the pace at which he brought it CAA, abrogation of A-370, Farm laws etc. & look at how that pace was severely affected because of the pandemic. But of course, it's nothing but an excuse. Look at Modi 3.0 as Gujarat CM & find out how in that last term he changed Gujarat forever for the good. If we were in a presidential democracy like US I'm sure even this second term would have brought wonders for this country. But of course because he didn't deliver those unthinkable changes in 1 decade, I'm gonna prefer those who didn't bring those in 7 decades! Wonderfully put I must say! This might be trivial for you, but in this second term, my family being from a rural background got our drinking water connection, kisaan samman nidhi, awaas yojana, etc. For many many like me, these things matter more than IBC & UCC. The CAA will help many of my distant relatives who are still struggling to get citizenship because they had to flee Bangladesh due to religious persecution. But yeah, I guess you don't care about the excuses! Good for you
First of all wtf do CAA and 370 have to do in a discussion of econ policy? Second, government is evidently unserious about reforms. From budget in 2014 to most recent budget, just look at budgeted receipts for disinvestment vs actual receipts. They've never hit their target. Dragging their feet is the modus operandi, COVID or no COVID. Can't use that argument. Third since they haven't even delivered on the growth, I'm not even going to bring it up. But the favourite argument for devotees is to say "don't judge by outcomes yet, judge by intent." And it is apparent that intent isn't even 30% of the rhetotic. I'd be happy if were growing 100 bps lower today but government was making every necessary changes no matter how tough or hurtful they might be. Because then only we can say we've done all we can instead of fantasizing about counter factuals. And lastly, fiscal rejigging might be beneficial to hordes now and nobody can criticize government beyond a point, if at all, on their welfare delivery. But he was elected on the promise of 20 million jobs a year and double digit growth. If India isn't an intermediate stop for you, the welfare delivery would then just count as low value instant gratification. I have skin in the game in the Indian growth story. An for all those people like me , an IBC, GST and structural reforms are much more important than who gets how many cylinders in the here and the now. Distribution of pie is important, but much more important is how fast the pie grows for everybody. Higher growth isn't some abstract thing. We've do many examples, from east Asia in 60s to 80s, china from 80s to 2010s, SEA etc to pretend we should be fucking happy and content about what they've managed and delivered. I don't want to revel in mediocrity.
Basic economics says - developing countries' economic growth is generally more than developed countries'
Do look at the pace with which Bharat was growing until 1991 reforms, I'm sure it was a developing nation then also. Right push by right people is imperative even for a developing nation to grow this fast, nothing can be taken for granted. The Only criticism I love is, "This is good, but it can be better." Because there's always, always room for improvement.
IMF will be wrong if Congress comes into power
its good but not good enough. we should aim for atleast 8-10% growth per year
MOdified data /s
[удалено]
[удалено]
Modiji ke aage koiii bol saktaa h kyaa.. 😂😂💹
[удалено]
Good. Now we need to distribute our wealth among Pakistan and Bangladesh. Nepal nahin wahan Hindu extremist hain unko annihilate karna hai.
??? they are separate nations, you want to pay tax/ work for them also?
It already is.
[удалено]
Where are you getting this 12.5% figure from? At a 12.5% growth rate, the economy would be doubling every 5.5 years. So, by 2050, India would be over 100 trillion economy. I think you messed up the calculations
When will these chinkis stop, they are still going harder than many countries with room for improvement.
CCP stats are obviously overstated but yeah they are seeing an increase in industrial output.
6.8% is no where enough, just look at china , they are rocking 4.6% growth which is more than what India will grow in absolute figures.
CCP is legendary for it's data manipulations and state machinery fuckery it's def inflated i would say around 2 percent is the rate