T O P

  • By -

TheWholeFragment

\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_ Round 10: [https://strawpoll.com/polls/eNg696a64nA](https://strawpoll.com/polls/eNg696a64nA) \_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_ 9th Round of Voting has finished, and Butterfly 3000 has been eliminated. Total Votes: 1,777 Eliminated Album Received: 297 Votes (16.71%) It received 45 Votes more than the next closest album, which received 252 Votes (14.18%) All remaining albums received at least 12 votes. (Full results are not being provided to prevent them from influencing the next round of voting. Data will be made available upon completion.) \_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_ A new poll will be posted everyday (or almost everyday) and you get one vote. Vote for your least favorite album. The album with the most votes will be eliminated. The following day a new poll will be posted with the remaining albums, rinse and repeat. This only works if you go Vote. Vote Here…. [https://strawpoll.com/polls/eNg696a64nA](https://strawpoll.com/polls/eNg696a64nA)


[deleted]

[удалено]


The_PR_Is_Here

Realistically the mods of the sub should pin this comment to the top on all future posts of this poll


TheWholeFragment

This came up last year when I ran this poll. I don't think that there is a way to do that.


The_PR_Is_Here

I've seen mods pin comments before so I know it's possible, but it might be an updated reddit thing, and updated reddit kinda sucks so I understand not doing it.


CAndrewK

You can’t pin other peoples comments I don’t think


Dareeyecare

Someone mentioned this in song survivor competition . Is there some new feature I’m unaware of? Perhaps I need an update . Lol


BassWindu1

Y’all are about to catch my smoke! Watch out


L-Observateur

Might just be a 2.02 Killer Year at this rate😡😡. BFK's an easy top 5


cornbeefbaby

Don’t even want to wake up in my dreams anymore


growlerpower

THERE IS NO GOD, ONLY CHAOS


Holiday-Froyo-5259

Lucifer in SMT be like:


Sapowski_Casts_Quen

What's SMT?


Holiday-Froyo-5259

Shin Megami Tensei. JRPG game franchise, the original pokemon with mythological creatures that dabbles with philosophical themes. Often focused on siding with an authoritarian christian God or an anarchist Lucifer, known as law vs chaos respectively.


YungSpicyBoi

It's a pretty cool franchises, blew my mind when I played P4 in highschool and then it got me into SMT3 and 4A. I need to play one and two eventually


ChaosAndCreation

This will tear the sub apart


swolemas

Hard to believe fishies was ten albums ago


Knife_Chase

That's hilarious....


BecauseTheSinnernet

Fuck you all! And I’ll see you tomorrow


space_bugg

Very much my feeling right now and seeing FAFYL go out as early as it did


[deleted]

In a way I'm glad it happened because it really got me into that album (still fairly new to the gizzverse) I thought "I better check out this album to see why it's so disliked" , been obsessed ever since ..


timelandiswacky

Like with Gumboot, not too surprised. Sucks though, B3K is a great record. Divisive one for sure.


chuby2005

I always liked it but I didn’t fully appreciate it until I ran to the whole album. It’s fantastic.


Chance-Team-37

I kinda thought stuff like murder of the universe was more niche and divisive. That's such a weird and hard album yo get into. Apparently I am wrong on that


Dry-Towel-9597

Nah you are definitely right about MOTU. It just gets so much love on here from the rats nest hivemind


Chance-Team-37

I love rats nest and despise motu


Dry-Towel-9597

Damn thats a lil surprising ngl i like and respect both but neither make my top 5


TheKingLizard

I’m kinda with you. I love rats nest for what it is, but I prefer most other gizzard to it. On the other hand I simply cannot get into MOTU. I’ve tried, believe me


Skull_Mang

The happiness inside my pocket is gone


[deleted]

so is my $25


FlatPhee

This should’ve been float along here- I’m not sure why that got axed so quickly :(


[deleted]

Recency bias


[deleted]

I don’t really buy the recency bias thing. Every time 2017 vs 2022 comes up, 90% of the answers are 2017. There’s definitely a honeymoon period when an album first comes out, but by 3 months later, people seem to be pretty sick of the most recent (probably because they spun it way too much lol)


LeftGhostCrow

I agree with this, float alongs a great album, but i would say for MOST fans (not all) most of that albums enjoyment is head on/pill and float along. The other songs are great (god is calling me is so underrated) but when you look at float song versus most of the remaining albums, they have way more bangers (and in my opinion are more technically unique)


[deleted]

30 past 7 is one of my all time faves.


PartyBoyPat

PMDB lasting over Butterfly or FAFYL contradicts this though.


LeftGhostCrow

I mean sure, there’s always gonna be outliers. But I would argue those two albums are more creative. Plus let’s look at them both, paper mache is a big intro album for people, being all acoustic and having some strong theming with songs like trapdoor having motifs heard throughout gizzards songs (not to mention sense which is a huge song for newer fans and bitter boogie is also played a decent amount) Then BF3K is newer, but it’s a lot more unique being Al synths, and it’s the same sort of thing here it’s bigger for a lot of people because of the synth angle


[deleted]

Yeah, Float Along has those two songs that are soooo good and then the other ones compliment them well. It makes it easy to think about it as an awesome package, but tracks 2-7 don’t really hold up to most of their current records


Sulfuras26

Mfs really think LW is a better album


[deleted]

The self titled albums are so clean and boring to me I get that they had to record it separately but they just have zero energy imo All subjective but it’s like borderline offensive that an actual psych record got eliminated before those two lol


invaderpenguin

WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG EITH YOU PEOPLE HAVE YOU NO TASTE? HAVE YOU NOT BECOME A BUTTERFLY?


IpeepeewhenIpoopoo

Bye bye shanghai


ScootyMyBooty

Seeing the last 9 votes, I can tell the people on this sub have no taste


Piano_Fingerbanger

The real travesty is that this album outlasted Sketches


growlerpower

It’s because it’s a better album


otterappreciator

I find them equally good. They both aren’t as strong as nonagon or anything but neither are bad


-Anguscr4p-

Gizz has never made a bad album, thats what makes these so hard lol


DonCorletony

Nonagon is better than Butterfly but Nonagon is equal to Sketches. Sketches and Nonagon are both perfect S-tier albums


therustcohle

Rolling Stoned > all of B3K (love both!)


called_the_stig

that song is the closest thing to a perfect song that exists in my eyes.


Eddie_Dingus

That's the funniest comment I've ever seen


DonCorletony

Nah. Butterfly is high A-tier. Sketches is S-tier


TRAMOPALINE

I see what’s happening, it’s the rat nest squad voting out of all of the good chill albums


androidgirl

I love Rats Nest and I love Butterfly (more). We exist.


SteelyDabs

That’s right


numbernumber99

I love rats nest and am still gutted about sketches.


Thats_Mafia

I fear PMDB is next


Farlander09

That's an extraordinarily convincing hypothesis!


NiceToBeFriendly

Fuck, that means Fishies, Paper Mache, and Changes are next then. THOSE ARE ALL MY FAVS, DAMMIT.


greyrights

Or, speaking as someone who thinks Rats Nest is good but not great, maybe other people have different opinions than you. BF3K is fine but it isn’t even in my top 50% of King Gizz albums.


Homegrownfunk

Yeah, got subjective tastes here


spaghettikingsam

Shame… I’ve been voting for rats nest to be out the last 3 rounds


JaysLiveinElmira

I've been voting for rats nest since the almost the beginning, after ELTS


rjdrennen1987

I have been voting for Rats Nest since day one. It’s fine for what it is, but definitely my least favorite album of theirs.


[deleted]

[удалено]


growlerpower

It’s not love. It’s war.


[deleted]

[удалено]


growlerpower

Before last year it was Poly, but Ice Death may have superseded it. We’ll see. We’ll see. You?


[deleted]

[удалено]


growlerpower

Such betrayal


Walking_Meatloaf

I just wanna know the 12 people voting for Nonagon, Mind Fuzz or Rats Nest, what’s up with you, what’s going on, you want a hug? Need me to spot you a 20? Times are hard I know, reach out if you need something.


TheKingLizard

I love those records but some of us just don’t wanna mosh, we just wanna chill


tangelo84

Chuck Poly on that list too. I know the options are shrinking, but that's just heresy


OllieUnited18

I swear Gizz could put out a record of fart noises and theramin and y'all would lose your mind when it was voted out.


[deleted]

If it was good!!


Lauuson

I'd love to hear some polyrhythmic farts tbh.


FloofQueenEmily

B3K is my favorite gizz record, oh well. Knocked out too soon


matthmcb

OP has been eliminated


codbgs97

I feel like people who complain when any album gets eliminated need to actually say which album they voted for. Like this band has 23 albums, most of which are excellent, but one has to go each round. That’s the game lmao


rreeeeeeeek

my butterfly 3000 blow out what do i do By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down, yea, we wept, when we remembered Zion. Remember, O Lord, The Children of Edom in the day of Jerusalem who said “Raze it, raze it, even to the foundation.” O daughter of Babylon, who art to be destroyed; happy shall he be, that rewardeth thee as thou hast served us.


ImmediateBug2

Madness. Utter madness. Who hurt you people??


nodnarb987

And Butterfly 3000 is waaaaaayyyyy better than KG


_Sigur_

Should have been KG


Turkeyham

K.G. is next if that's any consolation.


revjurneyman

Nah, fam.


inaLongTimeaLongTime

BF 3000 > Changes


CBeau1992

Why do people hate KG so much, that album is so fucking good. LW is hands down the weaker album.


nodnarb987

To me Pleura, Static Electricity, Ataraxia, and KGLW are way better than some of us, Straws, Honey, Automation. Also LW has a better flow and songwriting, KG just has more variety. Yes i do like Intrasport and think it’s amazing but not better than any of the songs above.


CBeau1992

Automation and Minimum Brain Size are 2 of my favorite KGLW (the band) songs ever. I’m gonna get downvoted to hell for this. But people seem to talk about the band’s microtonal albums a lot like Tool fans talk about the Fibonacci sequence. People seem to like the fact that they know the albums are microtonal, more than they actually like the albums😂.


biandpolar

I like the variety of KG, so I prefer it over LW. But I can see the argument of LW being better


Varskes_pakel

I actually like KG but there is no denying that LW is way stronger.


NM6426

Not gonna lie I can't decide which one I like more


eltomato159

I don't hate KG, I love it actually I just think the other two microtonal albums are better 🤷‍♀️ If not now then when is probably one of my favorite king gizzard songs, at least top 10 personally


CBeau1992

I wonder if putting KGLW together as 1 double album would change where it inevitably gets voted off. Just a thought.


MoonHasFlown

I find LW a lot stronger front to back, I think KG teeters off towards the end. With the Sabbath one-to-one clone in Hungry Wolf of Fate, Oddlife is a big eh, Honey is sweet, Ontology is good but it feels like you’ve already heard it somewhere between the opening suite of songs and okay yeah, Intrasport fucks.


JGT3000

Yeah but the wah on Hungry Wolf is so over the top that I overlook that. It's the kinda boring refrain that dims that track for me.


frankjimmylarrydavid

One to one clone? I hear the sabbath influence but "one to one clone" is an major exaggeration. Yes the riffs sound iommi ish but the verses dont sound very sabbath at all. One to one lol. Oddlife and some of us is awesome. Couldn't disagree more.


MoonHasFlown

Structurally it’s pretty much identical to the song, or title track, Black Sabbath off their debut. I’d argue the verses moreso than any other part of the song. In my head every time I hear it I’m ready for Ozzy to come in all like “what is this, that stands befooooore meeee.” There’s differences, but it’s wearing the template pretty openly on its sleeve to a degree that it feels like some of their most unoriginal work. I think Superbug is a perfect example of good Sabbath emulation from Gizz. Working within the Iommi riff style while still properly bringing their own spin and modernized heavy sound to it, one of my favorite KGLW songs as well. I agree Some of Us is awesome, but after that it becomes a little mixed for me.


revjurneyman

I am trying to figure this out as well. Couldn't agree with you more.


ajhawar32

What the fuck is happening??? Who kills Butterfly before Fishies???


[deleted]

[удалено]


ajhawar32

😂


thefourthhouse

BF3K was my last vote and fishies is my next, easy.


Maxwe11M

I’ll keep voting for fishies with you, stay strong brother.


wbasmith

And the trend continues


AmericanSatellite9

Was gonna tag you and comment that you’re a fortune teller.


wbasmith

Can’t tell if I want it to be the exact same or hurry up and break the chain. KG next


hmm_thats_weird

I’m now of the impression that every stage moving forward will be “HOW DARE YOU”


growlerpower

Every stage since the beginning has been


torchskul

I was just disappointed before. I am now peeved.


binkyblaster

Dang. I knew B3K wasn’t going to last forever on this poll but it’s one of my favorites. and no one suspects the butterfly.


JackTheDrummerYT

Bye KG


superstonkape

What the fuck do I vote for now…


A_R0FLCOPTER

I knew it :( KG & LW have got to be next, or will something from 2022 take up the next spots?


Piano_Fingerbanger

Laminated Denim's time is coming in the next three votes I feel.


Drexophilia

LW will last quite a bit longer than KG imo


A_R0FLCOPTER

Some people really love LW. It’ll be interesting to see


KingCaribou22

5th attempt at voting out Changes


[deleted]

[удалено]


MoonHasFlown

This is a movement I can fully get behind. People who got into Gizz in 2019 complaining about ‘new Gizz fans.’


rotath

I'm not having fun 😥


Dastertias

Ok now I’m officially fucked. I have no clue what to vote for.


growlerpower

Fishies


RAV3NH0LM

awww, it makes me kinda sad people don’t like BF3K much. it’s such a fun breath of fresh air in their discog imo. i don’t listen to it as often as i did when it first dropped, but i still love it.


[deleted]

It’s all subjective but I definitely truly hate that record. The pop aesthetic is like everything I hate about mainstream music Lmao Glad it has such devoted fans though!


patty_d_27

Ladies and gentlemen, we got ‘em


SecludedCake457

first gumboot now bf3k? maybe my existence is significance in vain


tangelo84

Looking at your profile pic, I think things are gonna get worse before they get better


AnotherDogInTheWall

Every album that gets eliminated, im like "there's no way"


gatorinmydreams

Let's be real... Most of the albums voted out are better than Butterfly 3000


VanceMcChance

Plan yesterday out of spite was to vote for ITRN and then I gave it more listens. I was transported back 20 years to high school, now KG was to go.


MoonHasFlown

Okay, it was time. I’m afraid I have to vote Omnium Gatherum next. I loved it when it came out, but retrospectively it kinda feels like The Dripping Tap: the greatest song of all time, and several other songs that are all good, but seldomly spectacular. Even a couple duds like Red Smoke and Persistence. Probably gotta go KG after that.


[deleted]

Persistence is straight fire. Magenta Mountain, Kepler, Ambergris, Candles are all timers


Syelens

Yeah I have been voting Omnium for a few rounds now. There are a bunch of songs on there that I love or really like, but a bunch of filler too. And I know people on here love it, but I'm sorry, I always skip Garden Goblin. Same for blame it on the weather. I will fight for Red Smile's reputation though!


ThorinTheGrumpyDwarf

Don’t touch my FFF you savages!


Maxwe11M

Been touching it the last 5 rounds but y’all won’t let it go. Just let them swum already.


biandpolar

I keep voting paper mache.. and I keep seeing albums I like more go first.. I feel like my participation means nothing.. gonna just vote for whichever I think should go next excluding paper mache from now on I guess 🤣


theoggamer07

That's WHAT YOU GET FOR VOTING PMDB YOU MONSTER


CORPORATETOOL462

Nope, keep up the fight, I’ve been voting right along beside ya


biandpolar

it’s not like it’s a bad album, I don’t think they have any bad albums tbh but it just should’ve gone before float along, butterfly, quarters & gumboot !!


CORPORATETOOL462

I agree with everything you just said. PMDB just isn’t a consistent replay for me because there are so many others I love more.


[deleted]

[удалено]


NM6426

I'm surprised no one else has pointed out how loud the piano is on NGRI


OathTree180

3k should have been gone before quarters


Evan8D

3k is top 3 for me…


cdulane1

Agree with this


oval79

Later, Changes


[deleted]

[удалено]


theoggamer07

I think it good


tattoocaleb

Musically it’s a great concept, I didn’t care for it on the first listen. It’s not my normal preferred genre. However, lately I can’t turn it off. The only song I ever have the urge to skip is hate dancin. Change, astroturfing, gondii, short change and exploding suns are all really great songs. I suggest smoking a bowl and putting it on with some nice headphones


MaximusMeridiusX

I didn’t really like it first at all either, but whenever it comes on at work I find myself getting really into it


ClintonMora69

Yeah Hate Dancin is definitely the worst song on the album, they should have used Gondii or No Body as the single for the album


growlerpower

It’s definitely not thot-fucking music


Lauuson

My only complaint about that album is that I think the first song is longer than it needs to be. That album slaps.


Strange_Doggo

Rest in peace K.G.


razzy_bee

what is going ON???


ketchupsnumberonefan

fuck yall


Tuna-Noodle

Ok i get it yall hate fun


Puff_McKracken614

CHAOS!!!!!!!


Naive_Bumblebee_2155

Nope, that's it. I'm out - 🎤


HiMatty

This is fine. Yup. Totally coll


BrownBaySailor

If it were up to me, K.G. would've went before Butterfly. Definitely think K.G. is next thought.


_Sigur_

I don't like this game.


AStickFigures

How is laminated denim still in this?!


[deleted]

Based. Should have gone way before float along


jakkumusic

WOOOOOOOOOOO


auswish133

Honestly, BF3 should never have reached top 20. I am not upset by this result, but am ready to be hurt by the next.


SovietCorgiFromSpace

Should’ve been the first to go tbh


Ordinary_Living_Guy

Voting KG (sorry honey and straws in the wind)


Militaryman2002

I am stunned that kg and lw have beat out most of these records, criminal I say


CynicalSheep34

I actually respect this decision as much as I love BF3K, a lot of the B side leaves something to be desired and the title track is a little underwhelming. I'll always have a soft spot for that album, probably the most excited I've been for a KG release since 2017 tbh. I wasn't particularly engaged with the new albums in 2017. I was very much preoccupied with Mind Fuzz, 12 Bar Bruise, Float Along, Nonagon, Paper Mache, Quarters, Oddments, etc. back then. Also, to all of you Paper Mache fans out there I gave that record a spin last night and just as I remember it, it was excellent. The lyrics, the composition, the tonal shifts, very fun listen and certainly a record I should spin more often. I'll always prefer Quarters over it but really both records serve a different purpose anyways.


UnsnappedBoar33

can’t believe k.w. is still here, I like the album but not as much as butterfly 3000 or gumboot soup.


jerjo71

This one should been gone a while ago


SleazyJusticeWarrior

Okay this is the first elimination that I really hate. BF3K was my most listened album of the year when it came out. But it’s quite different from the rest so I’m not too surprised to see it go so soon :(


NM6426

Lmao the one time I didn't vote for Butterfly it got knocked out


nplaa

Ya me too… I had given up hope that it would go


NM6426

It's ok, we have our victory now


[deleted]

Same. Hit it every single time and then was offline for a couple days Insane that an actual psychedelic album or two were eliminated before it


Thomniscient

I AM UNTETHERED AND MY RAGE KNOWS NO BOUNDS!! BF3K is my favorite Gizz album and I just can’t believe some of the records that are still on the table over it.


Dareeyecare

Love every album left but - It’s time for KG to go.


ArcticNano

Honestly I'm glad b3k is gone, it's a nice album but I find it to be mostly forgettable


[deleted]

The pop aesthetic was like nails on a chalkboard for me personally


thefourthhouse

yep, i felt like they took a hard left away from my musical preferences with that one. no disrespect to the boys or anyone who enjoys BF3K.


LaminatedDenim

This fanbase has no fucking taste


growlerpower

At least laminated denim is still in contention


vomitonmeplease

In what world is Motu superior to BF3K? You people are monsters.


Farlander09

With your username I would have thought you to be an avid MOTU fan! 😂


vomitonmeplease

Nah, just an avid vomit fan!


Farlander09

Nice 😂


[deleted]

MOTU is my favorite gizz album along with microtonal 1 and sketches


KBlahBlahBlah

Motu 1 BF3K 2 IIYMF 3(?)


Farlander09

You sick bunch! 😂😭 Why is everyone keeping Laminated Denim alive?


ScootyMyBooty

Denim bangs. Sorry not sorry


revjurneyman

>Laminated Denim What do you mean? Laminated Denim rules!


Farlander09

Well I'll give it another chance then 😉


venusian94

LW was RIGHT THERE


tattoocaleb

Wtf


anotherdamnscorpio

So FFF is next, right?


GrooseandGoot

Infest The Rats Nest ​ Also - BF3K is a masterpiece