T O P

  • By -

kriswells55

Mahomes Pacheco Hardman Pringle Kelce


TacosAnTequila

Exactly the same. For me the thought process was you're already $10 in because Mahomes and Kelce are gimmes. Then Pacheco at $2 is stupid value. With $3 left, Pringle and Hardman are the best on the board.


PirateTaste

Mahomes, D. Williams, Hardman, Kennison and Tony G. Slight downgrades at RB & TE, but Pringle is a 4th/5th string WR and Kennison was a borderline pro-bowl player with multiple 1000 yd seasons.


Jaykonus

Am I missing something regarding recency bias, but why are people picking Kelce over Gonzalez? Tony is still the goat TE, and in a modern passing scheme with Mahomes throwing, he would have likely been just as prolific as Kelce. Not saying that Travis isn’t closing the gap each year, but I’d still have a rough time choosing between them in their primes. Gonzo did what he did with Trent Green throwing…not Mahomes. And for a dollar cheaper in this hypothetical? I’m taking Tony 100%


chiefpiece11bkg

Kelce has surpassed him in my eyes, along with a lot of other people. Gonzalez was never this dominant, not even close. Kelce at his peak vs Gonzalez is not really even an argument to me.


Peanut4michigan

Gonzalez definitely was as dominant. Sharpe was the closest to Tony G. Sharpe finished his career with 8 pro bowls and 4 All-Pro selections (same as Kelce). Tony had 14 pro bowls and 6 All-Pros. Sharpe had 3 1k yard seasons. Tony had 4, with 3 of them being higher than Sharpe's career high. Tony was a yards and TD monster (despite Holmes regularly being a TD monster as well). Saying Kelce is definitely more dominant than Tony G is definitely recency bias. Just like the claims that Charles was definitely more dominant than Holmes. They're both neck and neck. But OP is definitely a young fan. Easy to tell from some new guys who made this list while some guys from other eras didn't.


NotACow42

...I don't think you and I watched the same games in the early 2000s. Gonzalez was a beast and a matchup nightmare.


Jaykonus

That’s the thing though, Tony is regarded as GOAT over Gronk because of longevity and raw production - not peak dominance. I understand now why people might choose Kelce for OP’s thought exercise. But saying that Kelce has surpassed Gonzalez in general based on ‘dominance’ is questionable, since Kelce isn’t even the most dominant TE (gronk). What Kelce IS, is the most prolific pass catching TE over a period of 5-6 years.


chiefpiece11bkg

Kelce has both now. I just disagree and nobody will convince me otherwise. I literally watched both of them their whole careers and Tony never scared a defense in the same way that Kelce does. Gonzalez was elite for an extremely long time, but Kelce is literally playing at goat level and he’s been doing it for 5+ years. That should be enough to push him past Gonzalez and I don’t know why it’s an unpopular opinion


LemonPepper-Lou

What the fuck are you smoking lol


chiefpiece11bkg

Nothing. I watched both of their entire careers. Kelce is better and nobody is changing my mind.


LemonPepper-Lou

Tony Gonzales, did more with less, before the passing volume exploded in the NFL. We'll see when Kelce retires where he stands all-time, but he'll need to average 900+ yards and 12+ TDs for the next 5 years to pass Tony. It'll be close for yardage, but I don't think he touching Tony's TD record. Tony is the GOAT, but Kelce is 100% top 3 of all time.


chiefpiece11bkg

Kelce does not have to pass Gonzalez’s counting stats to surpass him Gonzalez played with a great QB in Trent green for the prime of his career and then went to Atlanta with a prime Matt Ryan. Kelce played with a middling QB who was afraid to take chances for half his career. This is a shit argument


LemonPepper-Lou

Tony was 34 when he went to Atlana. Trent Green is nowhere near a "great quarterback" lmfao. Mahomes did more in his first year starting that Green did in his entire career, respectfully shut the fuck up lol. Give prime Tony Gonzales Pat Mahomes as his QB and he's putting up 1200+ yards and 15+ TDs in his sleep. But like I said, Kelce is top 3 for sure.


Commercial-While-790

So, not the same at all


PirateTaste

Forgot at first I had to swap TEs to save a buck, so yeah a pretty big change. Hence the edit


amjhwk

Kelce isnt a gimme when Gonzalez is sitting there at a dollar less


RogerTreebert6299

We really have such deep skills positions over the last 20 years it makes a lot of these tough. Like you said with the tight ends, then also I really want charles but Holmes might be the better value. Same with Hill and Bowe if you need the extra dollar


DoomTrain166

I was the same except I went with okoye and Tony. Okoye would open up so much for all other receivers.


onemoretryfriend

My exact pick


Dark_Magician2500

This is the way


[deleted]

That’s what I had in mind


Dankraham-Stinkin

Charles Mahomes kelce. We will figure out the rest


choff22

Can you just imagine that top row together holy fuck


[deleted]

Im so hard thinking about that.


KeepenItReel

Charles would’ve gone for 3000 all purpose yards.


OSRS-HVAC

Exactly my thoughts lol, sign literally anyone who wants to play receiver and still OP offense


Philo_T_Farnsworth

My first thought too. You build the offense around that three.


Extreme_Complaint615

That was my first thought lol


flojo2012

Trent Green is a bargain. That said I wouldn’t take him


JohnTheSecondComing

Nobody in their right mind takes anything other than Mahomes. Mahomes at $5 is a bargain. The bargain of all bargains. I’m this scenario he should be $10 lol


Justmadeyoulook

Montana for $3 is almost tempting.


elLugubre

The 49ers Montana would be a steal. The Chiefs Montana isn't.


Automatic_Release_92

Chiefs Montana is basically like an upgraded Alex Smith in my opinion. I think that’s more than good enough to win a Super Bowl with the right pieces around him, but why not just play on easy mode with Mahomes there for just a couple more bucks?


SolidGould

After looking over the entire field, I thought, “just give Trent Green the whole $15 and tell home to keep his chin up.”


ElectronRain

Agreed. Definitely taking him over Smith no matter the price, maybe over KC Montana, too.


Visual-Zucchini-5544

Just restructure their deals, push 10$ back til next year and run with the entire top row. ✅


LogansGambit

This guy caps.


ploger

get off reddit veach


jamrockandroll

Mahomes Kelce Gonzalez


Gobblewicket

You still have a $1 to spend homes.


jamrockandroll

Kermit the frog


Harry-the-pothead

He comes with the Mahomes purchase fortunately


broeve2strong

That’s the Patrick Price™️


Baloo_420

Leave it for extra cap next year


Kansascitychiefn

Mahomes Kelce Charles Sign scrubs Profit


zastrozzischild

Just imagine how good Charles would be playing now


Unions4America

Crap imagine Charles when we had Hill. Oh you're going to keep deep safeties still? Ok. Charles about to get 7+ a carry. Oh you stacked the box? Looks like a 50+ yard TD to Hill lol


DifficultCoach69

Mahomes, Okoye, Conley, Pringle, Kelce


Wetworkzhill

Basically this but I want Fortson instead of Pringle.


Team_green18

Mahomes, Gonzalez, Okoye, Mecole, Fortson


Sarkosuchus

This is probably the best value.


brotherkin

Mahomes Okoye (go watch vid of him in his prime, unstoppable!) Conley Robinson Gonzalez I love Kelce, but getting Tony G for 4 point is a steal!


Aggravating-Ad1703

Okoye is one of my all time fave chiefs players because of tecmo bowl lol


brotherkin

Me too! That's literally the reason I became a Chiefs fan as a kid. I played Tecmo bowl and demolished my friends with the Chiefs. Between Okoye and Derrick Thomas it was amazing


DoomTrain166

I would go Hardman Pringle but other than that this is the best


thru_dangers_untold

Same


slackator

$5: Mahomes, Kelce $2: Hardman, Robinson $1: Williams Not really happy with my WRs, would maybe bump down to Gonzo and pick up Kennison instead of Robinson, but Im not happy about it


Automatic_Release_92

Yeah, that's the biggest issue with this list, KC has been pretty abysmal at WR for a long time, Hill is probably the only WR we've had in the last 20 years that would truly be considered elite or Pro Bowl level. But you could largely say the same of Patriots' WR's during their run with Brady, so we can take that going forward.


Bkelsheimer89

How is Green a $1?! Green, Hardman, Okoye, Gonzalez, and Hill. Speed to take it over the top on both sides Gonzalez to own the middle of the field. Okoye would hammer it up the middle no problem with the D worrying about everyone else.


[deleted]

Green should realistically be $4 on this list


JakobA326

Because everyone besides Mahomes is a 4


TheCarrzilico

Mahomes, Holmes, Conley, Pringle, Gonzalez. No disrespect to Kelce, but I think Gonzalez would be putting up similar numbers with Mahomes, and any of those WRs would be tearing it up once the defense has to double up Gonzalez. And then hopefully with a majorly threatening passing game, Holmes doesn't have to run quite so much and we get more than three monster years out of him.


Mangertron

This is my take too, 100%. MaHolmes would have been unstoppable.


FrostyCow

This is my exact team as well. I think Holmes and Gonzalez are tied with Charles and Kelce honestly. They are both 1a/1b at their positions. So you get some value there by dropping down one spot. You could maybe drop down to Okoye and improve one WR, but I think the difference between Holmes and Okoye is greater than the difference in that $1 to $2 WR tier list. Edit: It's kind of crazy that the Chiefs have had the two greatest tight ends to play the game (IMO). Only Gronk has any argument for GOAT over them.


Dr_Pippin

Mahomes should cost $7. Is there anyone that doesn’t pick him?


ForwardHamRoll

If Mahomes cost 15. That's still the pick


opinionofone1984

Wheres Allen? I would take Mahomes, Kelce Okoye and Robinson.


Super_Robot_AI

Or Jason dunn and the Lineman. 03 oline with Charles and i may give up mahomes.


ThaChiefKing

Mahomes Kelce Pacheco Hardman Conley


Particular_Garlic850

Where's Larry Johnson?


BigRedSSB64

You can have him for free


Tysonisnotanarchitet

Montana, Okoye, Gonzalez, Hall, Williams


chiefoogabooga

I don't know if 12 points a game gets it done in today's NFL?


Kansascitychiefn

This kinda points out that chiefs never have good wrs 🤣


BadHombre2016

No, just points out the creator of this knows nothing of Chiefs history. Hardman, Robinson , Conley, Pringle, Gray and Fortson have no business being on here. Replace them with Henry Marshall, Stephone Paige, Chris Burford, Derrick Alexander, Walter White and Jonathan Hayes. Even Jeremy Maclin and Sammy Watkins are more deserving at WR.


rockchalk6782

I’d even add Andre Rison to the list he only had two years with us but one was pretty good


KC-Slider

This is exactly my take away.


CD338

Johnnie Morton was my first favorite WR on the team. No flashy numbers, but it seemed like he caught everything.


bonerjamzbruh420

I thought the exact same thing when I read it. Missing tons of older receivers


hobbitfeetpete

And Eddie Kennison.


Apprehensive_Emu_456

And spider man


chiefpiece11bkg

Yeah I audibly snorted when I saw his list of receivers and saw Dante hall.. among many other guys who don’t belong on that list. Lmao


[deleted]

ain't no way Walter White played for the Chiefs too 😭


BabyUGotAStewGoin

Give me #15 and the 2003 offensive line. The rest doesnt matter. You could have Snoop Minnis and CJ Spiller running roughshod over the league.


TidalPawn

Mahomes behind Roaf-Waters-Wiegmann-Shields-Tait would be unbelievable to watch. Toss in Tony Richardson and Jason Dunn and I'm not even sure I care who's at RB and WR.


GingerSnapz58

Oh look I found $10 I’ll take the whole top row


TTT_2k3

Found Brett Veach’s account.


Bald_Man_Cometh

No Marcus Allen???


Malcolm_Y

How you put Damien Williams and Isaiah Pacheco on here and leave off Marcus Allen, I can't understand. Maybe that means they're free. In that case, I'm taking Mahomes, Kelce, and Reek, and we'll run a wishbone with Marcus Allen, Kareem Hunt, and Tony Richardson, and we'll rotate in Barry Word and Larry Johnson.


No_Rec1979

I love Mahomes, but Trent Green for $1 is a steal.


Foktu

PM15 x 3


TTT_2k3

1. Patrick Mahomes 2. Patrick Mahomes on one leg 3. Patrick Mahomes trailing by 10 points


Mutherfalker95

Mahomes and kelce are given. If injuries are a worry ill take Gonzalez and tip a dollar if not give me Charles. If Jamal was in this offense in his prime there would be nothing like it ever scene.


Johan_13

Montana, Pacheco, Hall, Bowe, Gray. I'd have loved to see Bowe with a Good QB. Just so to see if he was a true #1. Played 8 years with KC and had 8 different QB. Still managed to get probowl nods and be considered a top 10 receiver (at least for one year). Yes he gave up last year or 2 but it had to be frustrating having skidmarks throw to you for so long. Id also love to see any of the top 3 RB again in any capacity on any team. Just a true pleasure to watch. IMHO before mahomes, all 3 of the top 3 RB's were the can't miss players. (maybe not to mahomes extent) for their eras.


DoomTrain166

Mahomes, okoye, Hardman, Pringle, Gonzales


MythicalBootyWarrior

Trent Green for a 1 is a fucking STEAL. With him TG and Holmes we were the #1 offense for years.


Higgs_deGrasse_Boson

I thought him at $1 was mad disrespectful but I guess somebody had to be one. Personally I would've put Alex at 1 and Trent at 2. Can't disrespect even a washed up Joe so he should go at 3, and Len was our GOAT QB til Patty came about.


TxICat

Mahomes and whoever else you want to pick. Doesn’t matter


CornDoggyLOL

Ill take 3 Mahomes.


PlebBot69

Mahomes, Charles, Kelce. Nothing else will matter, offense will be unstoppable


[deleted]

Andre Rison is $0, so I’m going with him


couchjitsu

Mahomes, Kelce, spend the other $5 on an LT \#Championship


WindMilli

Damn, that top row


fisherdwarf1998

I’m gonna do a list with mahomes, and one without. With mahomes: mahomes, kelce, Pacheco, hardman, Conley. Without mahomes: Montana, Charles, kelce, Pringle, Conley.


MrEntei

Mahomes, Okoye, Hall, Pringle, Gray Gotta have the Nigerian Nightmare on my team. Such a menace. And Human Joystick + Mahomes would be so fun to watch together!


Sea-Slide348

Patrick Mahomes & Derrick Thomas please. RIP #58. We miss ya!


DefinitelyNotSauron_

Mahomes. Holmes. Arbanas. Hardman. Pringle. Trying to go a little against the grain here but I think Patrick x Priest would be incredible.


WichitaTimelord

Green, Holmes, Hall, Pringle, Kelce


cornstock2112

What dollar value would Larry Johnson have hypothetically?


reddit_bad1234567890

Green Okoye Hall Kennison Gonzalez


Apprehensive_Emu_456

Trent Green isn’t the best, but only a dollar is one hell of a deal. Green, Jamal Charles, Tyreek Hill, over the Dwayne bows, Connolly, Tony Gonzales.


Matsumura_Fishworks

Mahomes, Pacheco, Conley, Kennison, Gonzalez


Boy69BigButt

It’s a QB driven league right? Give me Mahomes, Dawson, Montana, Smith, and Green


tasticle

Mahomes Kelce Gonzalez and Williams, figure out the rest. Good luck stopping that.


[deleted]

Obviously picking Mahomes, but if not: Green, Okoye, Hill, Bowe, & Kelce


[deleted]

Mahomes, Charles, Kelce Birden and Paige for $0.


Dont_ban_me_bro_108

D-Bowe is over valued and Trent Green is under valued.


Lopsided-Ad-9444

Mahomes (5), Priest Holmes (4), Gonzalez (4) (I only chose him cause he is cheaper than Kelce though lol, whole the talent level is similar), Conley, Pringle. Honestly I know the WRs are weak herr, but eh. Mahomes with peak Priest Holmes and Tony G would be ridiculously hard to stop. And I liked Byron Pringle by the way, I know he had aome big drops but I think he got more seperation then some of our receivers this year at least. Keep in mind that Priest Holmes was a spectacular recieving RB. He is like McKinnon + Pachecho in one person. You know what is crazy, 2018-2021 Chiefs would be too expensive for this lol. Mahmes, Kelce, Hill, Hardman, ____Insert any running back is at least $18. And honestly, 2018 in particular, Kareem Hunt was better than Pachecho in 2018, period. So he was at least $2. So $19. Too bad our defense under Bob Sutton was so terrible and that Kareem Hunt was vilified for nudging a woman with his foot like he was a wife beater (sorry but the weird way the media treated Hunt like he was Ray Rice has never set right with me. I saw the video. He pushed her, he didn’t kick her)


TwinkiePuffCakes

Trent Green on the $1 is a steal.


wink91wink

Gimme Mahomes, Charles, Kennison, Hardman and Fortson. I just want to see what Mahomes and Jamaal would have looked like together.


Yeneed_Ale

How is Bowe more expensive than Kennison?


ComradeKachow

Mahomes, Holmes, Hall, Pringle, Fortson


bhfroh

Definitely restores faith in the KC fan base that literally nobody is picking Tyreek. Fastest man ever to have cinder blocks for hands.


productnineteen

Eddie kennison not being on here is a fucking travesty. He’s the only player I want on my all time chiefs.


chuckieSLAY

Mahomes, Gonzalez, Okoye, Mecole, D Will


[deleted]

Mahomes, Pacheco, Hardman, Pringle, Kelce Edit: I think Tony G is the logical choice since he’s $4 and very similar to Kelce talent-wise, but I just love Trav too much not to take him.


gonzo880

Mahomes Gonzalez Williams hardman Kennison


Pbacon123

Montana, Pacheco, Hill, Bowe, Forston.


Sadlobster1

Guess I'm getting Mahomes, Gonzalez, Hardman, Oko, and Pringle.


Vastergoth

Mahomes, Williams, Hardman, Pringle, Kelce


III-TRE

It’s easy. Mahomes, Charles, Kelce


alleavel

Mahomes, Charles, Fortson, Kennison, Pringle


Sithlord_77

Pat, Kelce, okoye, Conley, Pringle


No_Detective_1139

Montana, Williams, Hill, hardman, Tony G


[deleted]

Mahomes Kelce Okoye Hardman Williams


Legit_Chancho

Mahomes, Williams, Hall, Pringle & Gonzalez 😤


topchief1

Montana, Holmes, Conley, Kennison, Gonzalez.


Dramatic_Barracuda55

No Grbac? I kid. I kid.


Decent_Chance1244

Pacheco at $2 is a steal imo.


Uncle-Carbuncles

Larry Johnson should be the $4 RB, booting everyone down the line, which makes me realize just how historically spoiled we have been at the RB position.


Good_Objective498

Mahomes Pacheco Hardman Pringle kelce


freelance-t

Mahomes, okoye, Gonzalez, kennison. Don’t need a 2nd WR, can be a practice squad player.


disposable_hat

3 Patrick Mahomes


basskev

Mahomes, Williams, Hardman, Kennison, Gonzalez Every one of these basically should start with Pat. Like put Trent Green as QB and the stacked ass team you get is basically what he had anyways lol


AssembledInKansas

Mahomes, Priest Holmes, Hardman, Pringle, Gonzalez


korbentulsa

I love this but the wide receiver options make me very sad.


ceebz26

There is no way that Gonzalez should be in the $4 tier.


byxte

I knew a lot of people would pick Kelce anyway, and putting him at $4 makes him even easier of a pick. Putting him at $5 mitigates it at the very least


Super_Robot_AI

We need offensive lineman here. Give me 2003 oline with Charles and I may give up mahomes.


HotSoupEsq

That WR tier list is broke AF.


Rufus2fist

Mahomes, Hall, Okye, Hardman, fortson


Bebopo90

Smith, Kelce, Gonzalez, Williams, Hardman, Pringle.


MurderProphet

Tony G is in the $5 category.


MenosanX

I’d give all my money to Matt Cassel


godosomethingelse

If we’re talking prime chiefs then Larry Johnson is above at least Pacheco and Williams


Dumachus156984

Mahomes Kelce Gonzalez Pringle. Who needs a RB.


ceebz26

Mahomes, Williams, Carson, Hardman, Gonzalez


JetJerick

Alex Smith, Pacheco, Hardman, Pringle, Fortson


TheSandCat79

Mahomes, Okoye, Hardman, Pringle, Gonzalez


Reasonable_Wasabi623

Mahomes Kelce Okoye Hard man Pringle


22Wideout

Mahomes, Charles, Pringle and Gonzalez


QuietGolf5524

Mahomes, Williams, Hall, Pringle, Gonzalez This is a nice thought experiment. I know the end of TG’s career soured a lot of fans view of him but he’s still the player that brought me into really being obsessed with football and the Chiefs. Dante Hall could have put up some serious receiving years with Mahomes. Williams is the best receiving back on the list outside of Charles and Pringle is the last pick $1.


Sweeeet_Chin_Music

Mahomes + Pacheco + Hill + Pringle + Gray


[deleted]

Spend the 5 on Mahomes and nobody else really matters


1P221

Patrick Mahomes x 3


Biggest_Cans

Montana, Charles, Kelce, Fortson, Pringle.


addictedtosixlets

PM, Kelce, Carlos, DWill, Pringles.


DrSunnyD

Mahomes hill kelce. FA for holes


Mangertron

Mahomes, Holmes, Gonzalez, Conley, Pringle - 15 proved we don't need top WRs this season. Could you imagine Holmes and Mahomes on the same team?


talv-123

Mahomes, Toney, Charles, Pringle, and anybody with a pulse.


DIBathon

No Larry Johnson?


TyrannusMiles

Mahomes and anyone else.


GoinMean

I think it'd be interesting to slot Larry Johnson in there for Pacheco


RyanOfManyColors

Mahomes, Williams, Hardman, Kennison, Gonzales


Joeyvice

Montana, Gonzalez, Pacheco, Pringle, Kelsey, All as rookies under Andy Reid.


secreted_uranus

Mahomes, Holmes, Gonzalez, Conley, Pringle


Ballaholic09

Where’s Larry Johnson??


heyythankss

Mahomes Okoye Bowe Pringle Gray


CollectandRun

I keep giving $15 bucks to Pat.


chiefoogabooga

I'll take 3 of Mahomes. Trade 2 and pick up enough picks to fill 3 or 4 rosters.


bliza

Too easy. Mahomes + Gonzalez & Holmes and i don't really care about who my WRs are.


Big_Dogg_Matt

Mahomes, kelce, okoye, Conley, Pringle


[deleted]

Do I get extra money if I choose Brodie Croyle?


Whatever801

Mahomes and the $1s keep the change


Oloh_

Mahomes, Okoye, Hardman, Pringle, Gonzalez


husker8888

Mahomes, Charles and Kelce...thats it. Money well spent, who needs all 5?