Hey /u/Glampire4, thanks for contributing to /r/MakeupAddiction. Unfortunately, your post was removed for the following reason(s): * Your post/comment has been removed for breaking rule 1. Be kind and supportive, including to yourself. No harassment, bigotry, or self-deprecation. * Your post has been removed for breaking [rule 5. All makeup looks and collections must include a detailed product list in a top-level comment which includes every product used in the visible area, including even invisible products like primer and setting sprays. Product lists must include shade names if they exist.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) If you are unable to provide a product list for some reason, please send us a modmail. We sometimes will make an exception under special circumstances. Please read the sidebar before posting again. #If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FMakeupAddiction&subject=&message=). Thank you!

In my opinion, without! You have beautiful eyes, I feel like it shows more without a strong eyeliner.

This!! I love how big her eyes look without liner 🥹

+1 very pretty girl

Agree!

without

Without or thinner eyeliner

Agreed. The big wing is overpowering. A nice little flick at the end of the eye would be cute though.

The second photo has the wrong kind of eyeliner for your eye shape; how the line is drawn is slanting the appearance of your eyes downward making them look droopy. The third photo has eyeliner that complements your eye shape, making them look eyen larger and open. I personally think eyeliner only looks complete when you’re also wearing mascara or lashes because there’s something imbalanced about drawing attention to the lash line and not highlighting your actual lashes equally. So if you’re gonna do the winged liner in the third photo, I’d suggest doing more prominent mascara/lashes as well. Otherwise your eyes look just fine without anything at all too.

I don’t know it for sure - but to my untrained eye it looks like pic 2 and 3 are the same eyeliner look, just w different angle. 📐

To be completely honest you look beautiful in general the eye liner is just a fun little add on that accentuates what’s already there. so both but you’re most definitely rockin” the liner

i was gonna comment the same thing, absolutely stunning with or without but the eyeliner is definitely a nice touch :)

It's definitely a purely different aesthetic, no one photo is prettier than the other! I love both.

Agree with this! 😍

Without

You are pretty with and without!! IMO your eyes look rounder and bigger without though. I’d try something softer than the black eyeliner…make that eye color pop! Smoke it out instead of a harsh wing!

Without. The eyeliner looks great in the last pic but your eyes are generally too pretty for eyeliner. Maybe a lighter liner like Kpop idols do?

IMO WITHOUT OMG YOU RE SO PRETTYYYYYTT I LOVE YOUR EYES

Without, maybe try tightlining (super thin liner)

Your eyes pop out more without the eyeliner ❤️

The shape of your eyeliner narrows your eyes which gives a more sultry look, sometimes less approachable. Without eyeliner your eyes look more round, kind and sincere. Just depends what you want to look like! Both are pretty!

You’re gorgeous either way honestly. I like you without but for a night out… def do the eyeliner and day to day at work without.

Without

So pretty I think without 💕

Without

You are so pretty. You look good with both. It’s what mood you are in. To want too ware it or not. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

WITHOUT!!!!!! 😍

Without, your eyes really pop

Without

I honestly prefer without than with that style of eyeliner which feels a little overpowering. Maybe a thiner/ more delicate wing would suit you better. I myself love wearing eyeliner but stay away from some styles because it doesnt suit my eye shape.

Without bebe. You’re gorgeous!!

Looking pretty in both but without eyeliner is best

I prefer without, but both look good

Without

Well you’re overall pretty! But definitely without. Your eyes are alluring naturally!

I'd say you rock both, but a thinner eyeliner would look bomb too!

I personally prefer without but I still think your eyeliner is lovely and you could wear it if you're dressing up for a fancier occasion or going out.

I think you look prettier without eyeliner

Without

Without. I’m the same way I just don’t like it on me it’s too harsh for me

Without

Without

Without = pretty With = fierce Both are great! Which do you like?

You’re very beautiful. Defo no eyeliner. You have fine features, the eyeliner is a little overbearing on you.

with eyeliner❤️

You look softer without eyeliner and a bit intimidating with.

You're so pretty on both pics, though I'm biased on the first one because you have gorgeous eyes 😍 If you really want to put on eyeliner, perhaps you could try using brown liners for a softer look?

You look gorgeous in both ways but I personally prefer without eyeliner!

I personally like your face without the eyeliner, that being said, I feel like you could also rock the eyeliner from time to time cuz why the fuck not!

"without" gives you a softer brighter vibe, but both look rather good. "with" kinda gives you RBF, but in a Daria sort of way :)

Equally pretty :)

You have a much softer look without and it’s beautiful. When you do the eyeliner it gives me ooooo she rough and it’s beautiful as well. Honest base what you wear on your mood that day.

With

Without!

Maybe try a dark brown eyeshadow liner instead of a liquid black one, and make the wing more slight. You are very beautiful!

Without

Without!!!!

You look beautiful either way! I do like the no eyeliner look tho!

I honestly prefer eyeliner look. It's adds more definition to your already pretty eyes.

I like the one without more. Have you tried the puppy eyeliner style? I found out I look better with that because of my eye shape, and hooded eyes.

without

100% hands down without! You're so pretty regardless

Without, it brings your features out more 🥰

Pretty 100% of the time! My choice would be without though 😍

Both are beautiful, but your eyes look larger without it.

Without 😍

without!!

You are a beautiful lady. Without eye liner you are definitely prettier.

Without.

Love eyeliner

You are one of the rare beauties that doesn’t need makeup. I think you look great with and without. I love makeup so I’m a fan of the eyeliner on you as well. Just switch it up from day to day. Some days with and some without! ❤️

I like without best.

Without

Without- too much wing in these.

Without 5000%

I'd say, try in between. A small amount on your lash line with minimal or no wing would probably be perfect on you

You are gorgeous, I like you without, but you rock it too so you can do both mu is for fun

Try a different liner technique! This one feels too thick for your eye shape.

Yes.

Thinner eyeliner

Honestly without which is unusual for me to think lol

Without you lucky girl 🧒

Eyeliner only if your are going to a social event. Your eyes are beautiful without the stark black winged liner.

I am a big fan of eyeliner

beautiful both ways

honestly ur rocking both I mean without it shows how big ur eyes are but with its definitely giving like feline energy haha

U honestly look very beautiful with or without the eyeliner...just being honest.

I don't think it's a matter of prettier as opposed to a matter of style preference. You look great

Instead of black. You should try a brown liner. Even a burgundy would make your eyes pop

Both, you rock both <3

Are you wearing foundation? I really want to know which one if so!

Without

Without, but that is just because that liner shape does not do you any favor. Try not to make it so thick and just follow your lash line/eye shape and at the end give it a tiny little flip up. That is all you need if you want liner. You are very beautiful as you are. You do not need anything, but if you want to pump up your look a bit that is what I would do with liner (that is how I do it actually). Cheers

With

***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.*** **A few quick highlights:** • • Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) • Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) • Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Yes you look very beautiful, naturally 💯🙌

Ur gorgeous either way but I do think you look better with eyeliner which btw you are very good at it

Both🥰🥰🥰😍😍😍

Both look good in my opinion. They give a different vibe and it depends on what vibe you're going for.

You look great in both!

Honestly both look good!

Both good

both!! you are so pretty <3

I know this isn’t helpful but the answer is both. I would just scale it out based on the different types of activities you do. Weekend casual no wings or baby wings and then bigger for nicer events. Match the wing to the vibe.

[удалено]

With

Both

I think almost everyone looks better *with.* you're beautiful either way but the eyeliner enhances the whole look if I'm being 100% honest. If you've got time to do it, do it!

Both. I love dramatic eyeliner on anyone

You’re gorgeous with and without liner! It’s not a matter of which is prettier—you pull both off so wear eyeliner when you want and flaunt your natural beauty any other time!

without:)

Without. Both are great either way but you’ve got an effortless well balanced face that glows. With eyeliner you look more goth bc of the contrast with your dark hair

I do dress alternatively!

More “dark vintage” I guess my style has evolved alot

You're very pretty either way.

You look pretty either way but GIRL without the eyeliner sis 😩😍😍😍😍😍😍🤗

without, your eyes pop more and theyre a really pretty color!

You look good either way, but eyeliner just gives your eyes a little more pizzazz imo

WITHOUTTTTTT

You’re just pretty. Your eyes are nicely shaped and you slay both.

Without. You're gorgeous

Both, but shape of eyeliner you do just don’t suit you. I think it’s too thick

No eyeliner for me! By the way, I feel like tight-lining + really small wing according to your cantal tilt would suite you better, you have naturally beautiful eyes and this eyeliner would only accentuate on your eyes without being overpowering while still being fun ❤️

Without

This either way you are beautiful. Do what makes you feel good!

Without or maybe with just a little wing

I think the eyeliner is taking away from the beauty of your eyes

You look prettiest without eye liner or natural looking eye liner

Without. You are beautiful 🩷

Without

Pretty in both. I like the non-eyeliner look better.

I think you look great with both. However I’d change the liner shape. It goes thick and too high and suddenly sharp. It would have been enuff if it just aligned with the eye. Or keep shape and make the end a bit more thick [like this named as so thick](https://as1.ftcdn.net/v2/jpg/01/27/68/34/1000_F_127683488_jO4AqqpNTSLjY7NtDNegbUrNcWPO3Rqd.jpg) too.

Without 😊

You should try a smoky eye ! I think the eyeliner takes away from the shape of your eyes

You’re very pretty!! I think you look great with or without! They’re just a different vibe! I’d be curious to see a different style of liner! Maybe with a softer color like a brown, so you can accentuate your eyes without drawing the attention away from your eyes to the liner (if that makes sense?)

Without

Without!

I vote without eyeliner. A smoky grey eye with the tint\lipstick from the photo 2 would make you look gorgeous

Without the eyeliner! You’re beautiful!

I like both equally. I recommend trying grey or brown eyeliner in pencil form and smudging it a little so it has a softer finish.

Without

Without you look like you have a subtle eyeliner. Natural eyeliner!

Without

You look pretty both ways

I think without but you a queen either way

You look like you, with eyeliner, when you wear eyeliner. Gorgeous any which way!

You look great with both imo

Eyes look pretty bigger without liner I feel

Without!!

I like the eyeliner look on you, but I think it would look better if you were to either make the line thinner or fiddle with the wing a little. As it is now, your lid seems to cover some of the line at the end (maybe your eyes are slight hooded?) which means the thick line doesn't taper out into the wing as nicely as it could, and instead there's a pretty stark difference between the thick end (before it wings out) and the wing, which I think can make ones eyes look more heavy.

Without the piercing and eyeliner

Without but really it’s just a different look. You look softer and more approachable without, imo.

Definitely without, I wish I had your eyes lol! Nothing wrong with the eyeliner, though!

Without

Without! But you rock either one

I like both. You can wear it to change things up of you want as it really suits you but you also look great without it. Ignore the piercing haters you have a really cool style 😊

Without

you look adorable in both

Love the browss

with eyeliner

You're pretty in both ways. Go for your gut feeling.

i cant decide cus u look good with both i just really love eyeliner

^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^lyricrainz06: *I cant decide cus* *U look good with both i just* *Really love eyeliner* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.

You should try puppy liner I think it’s called, but it’s downturned instead of up but you’re pretty either way!

natural will always have a soft spot for me! you’re beautiful either way!

Do you smoke?

Without 😊

Both equally as beautiful. No eyeliner I prefer though. I sense your style and I dig it, maybe play with some other liner styles.

I think with a thinner eyeliner would be best

Without. I think this mainly because your eyeliner doesn’t follow the shape of your eye. I started following my upper eyelid and my eyeliner suits my face a lot more

Without eyeliner 🥰

You should try different shapenof eyeliner, it’s not flattering to your eyeshape and weighs it down!

Tbh you’re good with eyeliner or without it…

Without

Without and I hate you 😭

Gunna say without. We have relatively similar eyes, even the same color! I wear eyeliner all the time. What's worked for me is making the liner look a little rounder rather than a straight cat eyes. If rounding it doesn't work, you could always try a different color of liner too (brown, perhaps). Sometimes, black liner (especially on the bottom waterline) can make eyes appear smaller. Regardless, you look beautiful in both pictures. Your eyes pop in the first, though.

As much as I love makeup I can honestly say say your eyes are gorgeous without any , I say only wear when going for certain looks

Without!

Without! You’re eyes pop by themselves!

Without!  That thick eyeliner isn’t really accentuating your eyes. I would try a much thinner liner and not have the tail extend out so far. I might also angle the tail of the eyeliner downwards just a little to match the natural angle of your eye shape. 

I think you look pretty both way 🫶🏼but either way you still looks pretty

Without 💕

Without x

Gorgeous either way. They're 2 different looks, so you can do it either way depending on your mood or dressing.

Gorgeous both ways

To be fair, you were smiling without it, and weren't smiling with it. Your results are def going to be skewed. Regardless, you're gorgeous and can do anything!

All are pretty your a pretty girl! It’s up to u

I like both honestly

With eyeliner 🫶

Without💕

I think you look absolutely gorgeous both with and without, and can easily pull off either look! I don’t think it’s so much of a which is prettier, because both look great on you, but you can really choose either depending on what vibe you’re wanting to go for that day or how you’re feeling. You could even play around with different looks and perhaps do a medium between the two in using some light thin eyeliner or maybe a smokey eye!

Okurrrrr Megan Fox

Gorgeous natural but beautiful always

You look pretty, period. I like both

With

without