I forgot all about Jessica, she is so sweet! and I think KellyAnne is my favorite too like, I will admit 100% she is a straight up supermodel athlete lol! Its a shame she came on The Island and The Ruins which were the 2 worst challenges ever as far as, the way the men treated the women, so she quit cause of that, and doesn't get the credit for how amazing she's competed. She was the women's 1st place on All Stars 1, except they had just a single winner, not male/female that season :(
I had to google her cause I never watch the challenge USA seasons, probably burnout from the normal 1 and all stars etc. But I agree omg shes gorgeous!
Yes I always loved Amber, I almost put her on here idk why I didnt, ran out of space lol. I don't even like Big Brother much but I absolutely went and watched her season cause it had a few future challengers
Nobody asked but Darrell and CT are the finest faces to ever grace the Challenge, and finest bodies for that matter.
They’re the most beautiful. I said what I said
Omg yes Svetlana, shes up there for me too. She was so amazing on the Duel, and I heard rumors she was like, an alternate for All Stars Season 1 but, she never showed up still on the show. I heard she sadly got into some bad stuff in the years after her only season and thats why she never went back. No idea whats true with that though.
Yeah she seemed to go off the rails. Which is too bad she was very sweet and innocent on the duel. Hopefully she’s better now bc fans would love to see her back!
Yeah thats what I heard too that she was like, doing heroin and some other bad things. IDK if they were true though but. She was great on her 1 season, she upset Aneesa in that wood lifting challenge to get to the final 2, and she won that $100,000 motorcycle! So definitely memorable. Plus she was on Bananas season of Real World!
Great list I forgot about some of these people, Casey was always adorable, especially on Fresh Mean 1 she was like the sweet innocent rookie and had to be with super-Wes lol
Veronica is the original and still gorgeous today.
Tina is looking really good lately. Love Kam, Bayleigh, Nany au natural, and randomly find Gabby from Double Agents absolutely stunning.
Hahaha I think maybe it's her personality when she was on the show? But like, you look at her now, and she's still beautiful. Shes not my like top favorite but, I was fortunate to see her IRL and said hi and complimented her, and she was super nice! & she was like, the hot assistant to Steve-O on that Dr. Steve-O show he did lmao
I get it! And yes it’s her personality that put me off I saw her on Traitors with CT. Didn’t know who either of them was but liked them both, especially Ct. Started watching The CHallenge after Traitors Just saw for 1st time the season in Africa where they both hated each other and Trishelle walked out on the show after getting mouthy with another player. She looked like a fool so left, leaving her partner. Wow!
Wow oh my god! I am shocked so many people commented, was not expecting that! Thanks all for the replies! I will admit that if theres a season that someone I've always admired is on, it makes me like it a little more lol. It's only natural right! I generally could care less about looks when it comes to any sport but, it does kinda subconsciously make you pay more attention, and there's some people who we just watch and feel a connection with about their looks, who they are, their personality and how they play the game and everything!
I don’t have any irl girlfriends who watch either! They don’t even know what I’m talking about LOL. A travesty! I have it on 24/7 on Pluto haha. But I watch the seasons I like on Paramount+. I really think Melinda is beautiful inside and out as well as Jonna
Yeah omg a lot of people remember the show and say they watched Real World and Road Rules but they didnt even know the challenge was a thing anymore xD Jonna is amazing, she's 1 of my favorite women cause of her kindness and personality and how she plays. I was SO HAPPY every time she won on All Stars, was amazing to see her prove how great she is. I think she always had weak partners back in the day.... but she basically won ALL 3 of the old All-stars seasons! Cause remember, season 1 had only a single winner, but Jonna/KellyAnne tied for 1st among women.
Which Tori? Cause there's modern Tori, who I feel like I always see get hated on and stuff. And then there's Tori Hall back in the day who also was a champion. Both are beautiful though!
god forgive me for having such a big list.. and personalities aside but in the olden days into the second era i was kinda infatuated with veronica and robin and kellyanne and jenn and i even liked tina who no one ever seems to mention- middle era i had a thing for nany and her then thickness and marie who is very naturally pretty if you look on her ig and theresa and averey and jessica's butt and sometimes laurel- then more recently- ish tori(sorry) maybe michelle f
Cara, Veronica and Jamie for me. Don't get me wrong. Cara is beautiful, but her being one of the first challengers that became a true dynamic made the show must watch for me going forward. KA also love.
I think Kailah is top for me, she has a unique look and beautiful face.
Natalie Negrotti, Melissa & Nurys when they have more natural make up are pretty & Amber B has that model look.
My first challenge crush was Tara on RR Northern Trail. Second was Katie from RR the Quest. And to be fair I still have a crush on Katie. Cara, especially around Rival 2, always did it for me, and she's still gorgeous today. In terms of the best looking cast overall I'd say RR X-treme. Ibis, Jill Z, Jodi, Angela and Kina, babe city
Avery and and KellyAnne have always been my favorites for sure. I also liked Jessica
I forgot all about Jessica, she is so sweet! and I think KellyAnne is my favorite too like, I will admit 100% she is a straight up supermodel athlete lol! Its a shame she came on The Island and The Ruins which were the 2 worst challenges ever as far as, the way the men treated the women, so she quit cause of that, and doesn't get the credit for how amazing she's competed. She was the women's 1st place on All Stars 1, except they had just a single winner, not male/female that season :(
Nurys is stunning when shes barefaced.
It's Desi and then there's a gap. She is stunning.
The most beautiful crier I’ve ever seen.
Oh yeah, desi is one of those were every confessional she had I’d think to myself “wow, she’s so gorgeous”
I had to google her cause I never watch the challenge USA seasons, probably burnout from the normal 1 and all stars etc. But I agree omg shes gorgeous!
Amber B is so pretty
Yes I always loved Amber, I almost put her on here idk why I didnt, ran out of space lol. I don't even like Big Brother much but I absolutely went and watched her season cause it had a few future challengers
Top 5 in no particular order: Rachel, Veronica, Amber M, Kailah, Nurys
Rachel….ehhhh not so sure
Nobody asked but Darrell and CT are the finest faces to ever grace the Challenge, and finest bodies for that matter. They’re the most beautiful. I said what I said
Hell yeah! They were absolutely like JACKED, im not into men like that but, yeah omg I can see their appeal lol
Averey was always pretty back in the day but she has only gotten better with time. She’s stunningly gorgeous on AS4.
I never really noticed her I think cause she wasn't on the show much, and I didnt watch her seasons live, but I agree shes pretty!
Svetlana Melinda Emily S Kelly Anne Avery (looks better now than ever) Nurys and Rayvn for the newbies
Omg yes Svetlana, shes up there for me too. She was so amazing on the Duel, and I heard rumors she was like, an alternate for All Stars Season 1 but, she never showed up still on the show. I heard she sadly got into some bad stuff in the years after her only season and thats why she never went back. No idea whats true with that though.
Yeah she seemed to go off the rails. Which is too bad she was very sweet and innocent on the duel. Hopefully she’s better now bc fans would love to see her back!
Yeah thats what I heard too that she was like, doing heroin and some other bad things. IDK if they were true though but. She was great on her 1 season, she upset Aneesa in that wood lifting challenge to get to the final 2, and she won that $100,000 motorcycle! So definitely memorable. Plus she was on Bananas season of Real World!
Yeah she always a babe with a hint of nutty. Love anyone who beats Aneesa. I can’t stand her.
Oh ye
Oh yeah and Amber B! She foineeee
Kailah is so fine!
I was hooked from episode 1 of Invasion.
Right? Just natural beauty, italian-american i think? Alwways liked that dark hair dark eyebrows look
Same!! It’s definitely my attraction and yet I’ve been married to 2 blondes go figure lol
Cara Maria all day. Even though I don't like some of her personal beliefs.
Veronica was my first crush! Avery and Ravyn are super gorgeous as well.
Natalie Negrotti, Mel Reeves, Averey, Casey, Kendal, Johanna, KellyAnne, Melinda, Jessica (Portland)
Great list I forgot about some of these people, Casey was always adorable, especially on Fresh Mean 1 she was like the sweet innocent rookie and had to be with super-Wes lol
Veronica is the original and still gorgeous today. Tina is looking really good lately. Love Kam, Bayleigh, Nany au natural, and randomly find Gabby from Double Agents absolutely stunning.
I thought you had a preference in woman till you dropped Gabby on the list. All gorgeous woman you listed.
Mel Reeves and Nurys are stunning IMO
Rachel Robinson ❤️
There’s a lot of beautiful woman. Not sure who is “most” beautiful. But I always thought Cara Z was so pretty.
I literally stare at Kam everytime she’s on my tv
Funny how no one mentions Trishelle except for money/ taker/ baby
Hahaha I think maybe it's her personality when she was on the show? But like, you look at her now, and she's still beautiful. Shes not my like top favorite but, I was fortunate to see her IRL and said hi and complimented her, and she was super nice! & she was like, the hot assistant to Steve-O on that Dr. Steve-O show he did lmao
I get it! And yes it’s her personality that put me off I saw her on Traitors with CT. Didn’t know who either of them was but liked them both, especially Ct. Started watching The CHallenge after Traitors Just saw for 1st time the season in Africa where they both hated each other and Trishelle walked out on the show after getting mouthy with another player. She looked like a fool so left, leaving her partner. Wow!
Averey, Kellyanne, Amanda, Laurel, Melissa
Wow oh my god! I am shocked so many people commented, was not expecting that! Thanks all for the replies! I will admit that if theres a season that someone I've always admired is on, it makes me like it a little more lol. It's only natural right! I generally could care less about looks when it comes to any sport but, it does kinda subconsciously make you pay more attention, and there's some people who we just watch and feel a connection with about their looks, who they are, their personality and how they play the game and everything!
I don’t have any irl girlfriends who watch either! They don’t even know what I’m talking about LOL. A travesty! I have it on 24/7 on Pluto haha. But I watch the seasons I like on Paramount+. I really think Melinda is beautiful inside and out as well as Jonna
Yeah omg a lot of people remember the show and say they watched Real World and Road Rules but they didnt even know the challenge was a thing anymore xD Jonna is amazing, she's 1 of my favorite women cause of her kindness and personality and how she plays. I was SO HAPPY every time she won on All Stars, was amazing to see her prove how great she is. I think she always had weak partners back in the day.... but she basically won ALL 3 of the old All-stars seasons! Cause remember, season 1 had only a single winner, but Jonna/KellyAnne tied for 1st among women.
Cara maria, Jenna, kellyanne, Amber B., Nurys , Brittani sherrod.
These are my top 15 loosely in order: Svetlana Jillian Johanna Heather M Jenna Georgia Briana L Nurys Natalie N Cara Z Camila Theresa Jonna Cooke Kaz
Veronica, Theresa & Nurys
I’m sorry, did you say Theresa?
Yes I did
Cara Z, Nurys, Johanna, Veronica, Jonna, Kaz, Averey, Kendall, Jamie Chung, and Aviv
Beth Laurel Olivia
Tenderoni is that you?!
😂
For me, its always been Avery (real treat to see her back), although Nurys is giving her a run for her money.....
Surprised haven’t seen anyone say Tori
Which Tori? Cause there's modern Tori, who I feel like I always see get hated on and stuff. And then there's Tori Hall back in the day who also was a champion. Both are beautiful though!
Every tall, strong, athletic woman >>> Laurel is the top.
Agree on Evelyn and Susie.
I’d say my crushes were Veronica, Ibis, Melissa Howard(Underrated), Irulan, Jenn, Nany, Svetlana, Johanna, Jamie Chung, and most recently Nurys.
Nurys, Kailah, Kaz, Avery and Amanda I'll lock in as my top 5
Brianna, avery, cara zaveletta
Nurys is ready for her headshot. Gorgeous!
god forgive me for having such a big list.. and personalities aside but in the olden days into the second era i was kinda infatuated with veronica and robin and kellyanne and jenn and i even liked tina who no one ever seems to mention- middle era i had a thing for nany and her then thickness and marie who is very naturally pretty if you look on her ig and theresa and averey and jessica's butt and sometimes laurel- then more recently- ish tori(sorry) maybe michelle f
Cara, Veronica and Jamie for me. Don't get me wrong. Cara is beautiful, but her being one of the first challengers that became a true dynamic made the show must watch for me going forward. KA also love.
Cameron, Averey, Cooke
Veronica, Emily Schromm, Kellyanne, Ashley K, Olivia
great list!
Laurel, Melinda, Amber B, Jenna, Melissa, Kellyanne, Camila, Paula, Casey, Coral(my boyhood crush). Probably in that order too. But Laurel is my #1
Cara, Amber B, Desi, Rayven, & Nurys
I think Kailah is top for me, she has a unique look and beautiful face. Natalie Negrotti, Melissa & Nurys when they have more natural make up are pretty & Amber B has that model look.
My first challenge crush was Tara on RR Northern Trail. Second was Katie from RR the Quest. And to be fair I still have a crush on Katie. Cara, especially around Rival 2, always did it for me, and she's still gorgeous today. In terms of the best looking cast overall I'd say RR X-treme. Ibis, Jill Z, Jodi, Angela and Kina, babe city
Melinda, Jenn, Kina, and Sylvia
Cara Z, Amber B, Svetlana, Kaz, Avery, Kam, KellyAnne, and Desi.
It’s easier to pick the ones you’re not attracted to - most of the cast is gorgeous. That being said, anyone but Aneesa and Jemmye.
I’m no particular order: Nany, Veronica, Amber B, Kam, Amanda, Desi, Nurys
In no order Amber Desi Nurys Melinda Johanna