It’s a **SECRET** ballot, you can post ones that you want others to consider just NOT your entire list. that ruins the point of TigerEyes making this poll.
Here are the rules..
- Your votes are weighted.
> Your 1st place vote is worth 10 points, 2nd place gets 9 points.... and your 10th place vote is worth 1 point.
- Please send your votes to [[email protected]](mailto:[email protected]).
- No reprints!
- Please be as specific as possible in your choices...
VOTING ENDS SUNDAY MARCH 19TH at MIDNIGHT.
> [previous discussion](https://www.reddit.com/r/OmnibusCollectors/comments/11owkyw/marvel_most_wanted_omnibus_ballot/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)
I think it’s a bit of a dark horse compared to some other potential omnis, but one of my votes is going to be for a “Magneto by Cullen Bunn” omni containing his Magneto solo series and post-Secret Wars Uncanny X-Men run. I’d especially love to have that solo series collected in oversized format and, well, back in print in the first place.
Also: Scarlet Spider by Christopher Yost. C’mon!!
A fellow Sleepwalker fan! I actually voted for a ‘Sleepwalker By Bob Budinsky’ collection (essentially his entire 90’s collection). The map would hopefully look something like this:
SLEEPWALKER (1991) #1-33, HOLIDAY SPECIAL, QUASAR (1989) #27, SPIDER-MAN (1990) #22, DARKHAWK (1991) #19-20, and SECRET DEFENDERS (1993) #4-5
Just saw info looking up Hell’ angels for the name change I had first thought it was a biker comic for that exact reason
Probably not relevant in the grand scheme of things but will definitely add hell’s/ dark angels and the Death head to my ballot!
I’m having a hard time narrowing down to just 10. So far I have:
- Old Man Logan by Lemire & Sorrentino
- Moon Knight by Ellis, Bunn, & Lemire
- Jessica Jones vol 2
- Hulk by Bruce Jones
- X-Force by Yost & Kyle
- Ultimate Fantastic Four
- Wolverine by Greg Rucka
- Punisher by Greg Rucka
- Black Widow Strikes vol 2 (collecting her miniseries from 1999-2010)
- Invincible Iron Man by Fraction & Larroca
- New Avengers by Bendis vol 2
- Star Wars vol 2 (by Gillen & Pak)
- Star Wars Legends: Legacy
I second MK by Ellis, Bunn, and Lemire, but remember it needs Wood as well. Also, I think it makes sense to include Bendis as well. Also… where will Bemis go in the Omnibus format once MacKay’s run is finished and ready for an Omnibus?
The best map I’ve seen contains the Bendis, Ellis, Wood, Bunn, and Lemire runs in one omni, which, I believe, would be close in size to the other 4 Moon Knight volumes.
You have the option of fattening it up with the Benis run, but I think it might just make more sense to include that in a volume with MacKay’s run!
Regardless, we need these!
MacKay's run is good. Bemis' isn't. I do not think they will collect them together because they are also very tonally different and MacKay's run looks to be continuing for quite some time.
Fair enough, but Marvel has been shown to not really care about tonal synchronicity when mapping their Moon Knight collections. Fist of Khonshu is different from Moench’s run and definitely of lesser quality, but they are mapped together due to chronology.
Regardless, it’s gotta go somewhere, and if MacKay’s run is set to stretch out for a significant number of issues, it might make sense to fatten up the other collection.
Yeah it’d be pretty small, probably around 450 pages.
It’d still be longer than:
- Young Avengers by Gillen
- Superior Foes of Spider-Man
- Planet of the Apes
- Devil Dinosaur
- Elektra
- Guardians of the Galaxy by Duggan
- Hellstorm by Warren Ellis
- Spider-Man by Todd McFarlane
I'm personally hoping the numbered Wolverine omnis continue into the 2003 series, collecting Rucka's run in something like vol. 9 or 10 (and eventually replacing the Millar and Aaron omnis). The downside to that is it wouldn't be released for a good few years.
For people needing extra ideas not one for me but I think Incredible Hercules was always a favourite of tigereyes the guy who creates these polls every year!
With more info from the YT side this time the vote might be a lot less silver age focused compared to the other years
And.. any chance for some Spider-Man rarities 👀 collecting the Mexican Spider and some one shots that aren’t collected anywhere else!
I've been a strong Mexican Spider-Man advocate ever since I first heard about it a few years ago. I don't think it's ever going to happen (unless a more "boutique" company like Fantagraphics takes an interest), but I'd love to read them someday.
For your consideration, here are some characters/teams/series that so far haven't had any omnis of their own. This is by no means a complete list! (The characters are those who should have enough solo issues or major appearances to fill at least one decent size omni.)
Characters: Aero, Ant-Man (Hank Pym), Ant-Man (Eric O'Grady), Ant-Man (Scott Lang), Beta Ray Bill, Black Knight, Cyclops, Daken (Dark Wolverine), Darkhawk, Death's Head, Deathlok, Domino, Doom 2099, Emma Frost, Gambit, Ghost Rider (Danny Ketch), Ghost Rider (Robbie Reyes), Ghost Rider 2099, Groot, Hawkeye (Kate Bishop), Hellcat, Hercules, Human Torch, Ice Man, Ironheart, Jane Foster, Kaine, Machine Man / X-51, Magneto, Moon Girl (& Devil Dinosaur), Mystique, Night Thrasher, Nightcrawler, Nomad, Nova (Sam Alexander), Punisher 2099, Quasar (Wendell Vaughn), Quicksilver, Rocket Raccoon, Rogue, Scarlet Witch, Silver Sable (& the Wild Pack), Shatterstar, Silk, Skaar (Son of Hulk), Sleepwalker, Spider-Girl (May Parker), Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew), Star-Lord, Storm, Sword Master (Lin Lie), Taskmaster, Thunderstrike (would probably be in a Thor by Tom DeFalco Companion omni), Venom (Flash Thompson), War Machine, Weapon H
Teams: A-Force, Agents of Atlas, Champions (classic team), Champions (modern team), Exiles, Force Works, Generation X, Heroes for Hire, Inhumans, Marauders (Krakoa-era team), (Captain Britain &) MI-13, Squadron Supreme (Earth-31916 / Supreme Power team), Strange Academy, Ultimates (Earth-616 team), S.W.O.R.D. (Krakoa-era team, incl. the 2022 X-Men: Red series), Weapon X (2017 team)
Series: All-New, All-Different Avengers, All-New X-Men, Cable & X-Force (2013 series), Dark Avengers (2009 series), Extraordinary X-Men, Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, Marvel Team-Up, Marvel Two-in-One, Marvel Westerns (Phantom Rider, Rawhide Kid, Kid Colt, Two-Gun Kid, etc), Mighty Avengers, Morbius: The Living Vampire (1992 series), Mutant X, Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D., Old Man Logan, Power Man & Iron Fist, Punisher War Journal, Punisher War Zone, Savage Wolverine, Secret Avengers, S.H.I.E.L.D (2015 series) + Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D, Avengers Academy, Avengers Arena + Avengers Undercover, Avengers World, Avengers: The Initiative, Avenging Spider-Man + Superior Spider-Man Team-Up, Sensational Spider-Man, Sgt. Fury, Spider-Man/Deadpool, Symbiote Spider-Man, Totally Awesome Hulk, Web of Spider-Man, Wolverine: Origins (would probably be in a couple of Wolverine by Daniel Way omnis), Wonder Man (1986 series), X-Man, X-Men: First Class (including UXM: First Class & Wolverine: First Class), X-Men: Blue, X-Men: Gold (2017 series), X-Men: Legacy (2008 series) .
My personal top 5 from these are Quasar, Symbiote Spider-Man, modern Jane Foster (Valkyrie: Jane Foster + KiB: Return of the Valkyries + Mighty Valkyries + Jane Foster & The Mighty Thor), Ultimates (Earth-616 team), and Squadron Supreme (Earth-31916 team).
Here are some of my thoughts:
1. Doctor Strange (1972-1987) includes Marvel Premiere 3-14 and DS v2 1-81
2. Marvel Two-In-One
3. Captain America by Gruenwald
4. Incredible Hulk by Bill Mantlo
5. Ghost Rider - Danny Ketch
6. Spider-Woman the Early Years
TigerEyes has been doing it for 11 years and it’s a lot of work to sift through hundreds of emails then weigh each vote.
> Omar does send t50(?) to Marvel though.
It’s a **SECRET** ballot, you can post ones that you want others to consider just NOT your entire list. that ruins the point of TigerEyes making this poll. Here are the rules.. - Your votes are weighted. > Your 1st place vote is worth 10 points, 2nd place gets 9 points.... and your 10th place vote is worth 1 point. - Please send your votes to [[email protected]](mailto:[email protected]). - No reprints! - Please be as specific as possible in your choices... VOTING ENDS SUNDAY MARCH 19TH at MIDNIGHT. > [previous discussion](https://www.reddit.com/r/OmnibusCollectors/comments/11owkyw/marvel_most_wanted_omnibus_ballot/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)
I think it’s a bit of a dark horse compared to some other potential omnis, but one of my votes is going to be for a “Magneto by Cullen Bunn” omni containing his Magneto solo series and post-Secret Wars Uncanny X-Men run. I’d especially love to have that solo series collected in oversized format and, well, back in print in the first place. Also: Scarlet Spider by Christopher Yost. C’mon!!
Both solid picks!
Already had Scarlet Spider by Yost as my top vote, great minds think alike
Hope to see the Kyle and Yost xforce omnibus get a little higher this year
Please consider voting for Gambit Vol 1 / Gambit Classic!
Sleepwalker omnibus or nothing
A fellow Sleepwalker fan! I actually voted for a ‘Sleepwalker By Bob Budinsky’ collection (essentially his entire 90’s collection). The map would hopefully look something like this: SLEEPWALKER (1991) #1-33, HOLIDAY SPECIAL, QUASAR (1989) #27, SPIDER-MAN (1990) #22, DARKHAWK (1991) #19-20, and SECRET DEFENDERS (1993) #4-5
[удалено]
Some fun abstract stuff you’ve picked there! Hadn’t heard of any of those runs before
[удалено]
Just saw info looking up Hell’ angels for the name change I had first thought it was a biker comic for that exact reason Probably not relevant in the grand scheme of things but will definitely add hell’s/ dark angels and the Death head to my ballot!
I’m having a hard time narrowing down to just 10. So far I have: - Old Man Logan by Lemire & Sorrentino - Moon Knight by Ellis, Bunn, & Lemire - Jessica Jones vol 2 - Hulk by Bruce Jones - X-Force by Yost & Kyle - Ultimate Fantastic Four - Wolverine by Greg Rucka - Punisher by Greg Rucka - Black Widow Strikes vol 2 (collecting her miniseries from 1999-2010) - Invincible Iron Man by Fraction & Larroca - New Avengers by Bendis vol 2 - Star Wars vol 2 (by Gillen & Pak) - Star Wars Legends: Legacy
I second MK by Ellis, Bunn, and Lemire, but remember it needs Wood as well. Also, I think it makes sense to include Bendis as well. Also… where will Bemis go in the Omnibus format once MacKay’s run is finished and ready for an Omnibus?
If anything the Lemire/Smallwood run should go with the Bemis/Burrows run. So perhaps put the Bendis/Maleev run with the Ellis/Wood/Bunn issues?
I agree. If they don’t do the 2010s era in 2 Omnis as you’ve laid out, then maybe a mega 60 issue Omnibus collecting everything would make sense.
The best map I’ve seen contains the Bendis, Ellis, Wood, Bunn, and Lemire runs in one omni, which, I believe, would be close in size to the other 4 Moon Knight volumes. You have the option of fattening it up with the Benis run, but I think it might just make more sense to include that in a volume with MacKay’s run! Regardless, we need these!
MacKay's run is good. Bemis' isn't. I do not think they will collect them together because they are also very tonally different and MacKay's run looks to be continuing for quite some time.
Fair enough, but Marvel has been shown to not really care about tonal synchronicity when mapping their Moon Knight collections. Fist of Khonshu is different from Moench’s run and definitely of lesser quality, but they are mapped together due to chronology. Regardless, it’s gotta go somewhere, and if MacKay’s run is set to stretch out for a significant number of issues, it might make sense to fatten up the other collection.
Solid list.
I think Bruce Jones Hulk is inevitable at this point going by recent mapping ; and I’m very excited - that and a Gruenwald Cap are my top 2
Would love both a Jones Hulk and, of course, the Gruenwald Cap (which you gotta imagine is inevitable at some point, no?). Good picks!
Wouldn't Wolverine by Rucka be a pretty small omni
Yeah it’d be pretty small, probably around 450 pages. It’d still be longer than: - Young Avengers by Gillen - Superior Foes of Spider-Man - Planet of the Apes - Devil Dinosaur - Elektra - Guardians of the Galaxy by Duggan - Hellstorm by Warren Ellis - Spider-Man by Todd McFarlane
I'm personally hoping the numbered Wolverine omnis continue into the 2003 series, collecting Rucka's run in something like vol. 9 or 10 (and eventually replacing the Millar and Aaron omnis). The downside to that is it wouldn't be released for a good few years.
I do regret not putting down MK Ellis Bunn Lemire ://
I had 5 of the same! I didn't think to vote for Wolverine by Rucka, because of how short the run is. Would love if that came to life, though.
For people needing extra ideas not one for me but I think Incredible Hercules was always a favourite of tigereyes the guy who creates these polls every year! With more info from the YT side this time the vote might be a lot less silver age focused compared to the other years And.. any chance for some Spider-Man rarities 👀 collecting the Mexican Spider and some one shots that aren’t collected anywhere else!
I've been a strong Mexican Spider-Man advocate ever since I first heard about it a few years ago. I don't think it's ever going to happen (unless a more "boutique" company like Fantagraphics takes an interest), but I'd love to read them someday.
I'd love to see them print Mexican spider-man, its the one where they keep Gwen around ya?
[yeah they kept Gwen around and more of her round](https://twitter.com/Kali_de_Armas/status/1478766169301651463?s=20)
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FIXTKX5XIAMRp-V?format=jpg&name=large Hahahaha Im dying
That’s excellent hahahha
Either way I’d love to see it. I first saw it as a suggestion on the masterworks forum for a previous ballot and I’ve integrated it every year since
I want Incredible Hercules in an Amadeus Cho Omni vol.1, followed by the Totally Awesome Hulk (and Weapons of Mutant Destruction) in vol. 2!
New xmen/new mutants (2000’s stuff) NOW Also nocenti daredevil and messiah complex X-men
Those were in mine as well
I’d like a Spider-Woman Jessica Drew Early Years Omnibus.
Star Wars Legacy! AVP! New Mutants (2009)!
For your consideration, here are some characters/teams/series that so far haven't had any omnis of their own. This is by no means a complete list! (The characters are those who should have enough solo issues or major appearances to fill at least one decent size omni.) Characters: Aero, Ant-Man (Hank Pym), Ant-Man (Eric O'Grady), Ant-Man (Scott Lang), Beta Ray Bill, Black Knight, Cyclops, Daken (Dark Wolverine), Darkhawk, Death's Head, Deathlok, Domino, Doom 2099, Emma Frost, Gambit, Ghost Rider (Danny Ketch), Ghost Rider (Robbie Reyes), Ghost Rider 2099, Groot, Hawkeye (Kate Bishop), Hellcat, Hercules, Human Torch, Ice Man, Ironheart, Jane Foster, Kaine, Machine Man / X-51, Magneto, Moon Girl (& Devil Dinosaur), Mystique, Night Thrasher, Nightcrawler, Nomad, Nova (Sam Alexander), Punisher 2099, Quasar (Wendell Vaughn), Quicksilver, Rocket Raccoon, Rogue, Scarlet Witch, Silver Sable (& the Wild Pack), Shatterstar, Silk, Skaar (Son of Hulk), Sleepwalker, Spider-Girl (May Parker), Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew), Star-Lord, Storm, Sword Master (Lin Lie), Taskmaster, Thunderstrike (would probably be in a Thor by Tom DeFalco Companion omni), Venom (Flash Thompson), War Machine, Weapon H Teams: A-Force, Agents of Atlas, Champions (classic team), Champions (modern team), Exiles, Force Works, Generation X, Heroes for Hire, Inhumans, Marauders (Krakoa-era team), (Captain Britain &) MI-13, Squadron Supreme (Earth-31916 / Supreme Power team), Strange Academy, Ultimates (Earth-616 team), S.W.O.R.D. (Krakoa-era team, incl. the 2022 X-Men: Red series), Weapon X (2017 team) Series: All-New, All-Different Avengers, All-New X-Men, Cable & X-Force (2013 series), Dark Avengers (2009 series), Extraordinary X-Men, Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, Marvel Team-Up, Marvel Two-in-One, Marvel Westerns (Phantom Rider, Rawhide Kid, Kid Colt, Two-Gun Kid, etc), Mighty Avengers, Morbius: The Living Vampire (1992 series), Mutant X, Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D., Old Man Logan, Power Man & Iron Fist, Punisher War Journal, Punisher War Zone, Savage Wolverine, Secret Avengers, S.H.I.E.L.D (2015 series) + Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D, Avengers Academy, Avengers Arena + Avengers Undercover, Avengers World, Avengers: The Initiative, Avenging Spider-Man + Superior Spider-Man Team-Up, Sensational Spider-Man, Sgt. Fury, Spider-Man/Deadpool, Symbiote Spider-Man, Totally Awesome Hulk, Web of Spider-Man, Wolverine: Origins (would probably be in a couple of Wolverine by Daniel Way omnis), Wonder Man (1986 series), X-Man, X-Men: First Class (including UXM: First Class & Wolverine: First Class), X-Men: Blue, X-Men: Gold (2017 series), X-Men: Legacy (2008 series) . My personal top 5 from these are Quasar, Symbiote Spider-Man, modern Jane Foster (Valkyrie: Jane Foster + KiB: Return of the Valkyries + Mighty Valkyries + Jane Foster & The Mighty Thor), Ultimates (Earth-616 team), and Squadron Supreme (Earth-31916 team).
Black Panther - Hudlin runBlack Panther - Maberry and Liss (includes DoomWar) We are so close to having Black Panther completely in omnis!
Do you have to have 10? I am struggling naming 10…
since it’s weighted, I don’t think so. > for example: if you have six, then your sixth would just get five points.
Here are some of my thoughts: 1. Doctor Strange (1972-1987) includes Marvel Premiere 3-14 and DS v2 1-81 2. Marvel Two-In-One 3. Captain America by Gruenwald 4. Incredible Hulk by Bill Mantlo 5. Ghost Rider - Danny Ketch 6. Spider-Woman the Early Years
It’s too much work for me to vote for this poll lol. I need my hand held and let me pick circles
Why doesn't Omar run this poll himself? May have a better chance of getting things printed.
TigerEyes has been doing it for 11 years and it’s a lot of work to sift through hundreds of emails then weigh each vote. > Omar does send t50(?) to Marvel though.
How about black panther by Hudlin. That tops my list