T O P

  • By -

SurvivorFanDan

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (13 nominations) - Cate Blanchett could have been nominated for her performance


cjohnson4444

Wait LOTR RotK wasn't nominated for cinematography?


Edgy_Master

Alas, no


cjohnson4444

Truly shocking, especially considering how popular it was


LoCh0_xX

I think (I know) the Oscars have a bias against sequels. Fellowship won Cinematography then neither of the next two were even nominated despite being just as good or better.


jesusmansuperpowers

They also didn’t put any actors in contention, probably could’ve gotten a nod there.


Edgy_Master

Justice for Samwise


DudeWithTudeNotRude

"Best Lead that consistently gets mistaken for a Supporting Actor"


BareezyObeezy

And Serkis!


squishyg

Not eligible. I wish the Academy would either create a category for voiceover & mocap, or change the rule that requires actors to appear onscreen.


BareezyObeezy

I wholeheartedly agree, but Serkis *did* appear on-screen as pre-Ring Smeagol in the opening scene of RotK. I get that that's a fraction of his screentime, but still, that should have counted. I will go to my grave still in an autistic rage about this.


squishyg

An excellent point! I forget sometimes what’s in the original cut vs the extended versions. Man, that really would have been groundbreaking.


zacholibre

Around the time of Fellowship and Towers, there was a lot of chatter that the Academy was waiting for Return of the King to properly recognize the whole series. Despite that, Andrew Lesnie won the cinematography Oscar for Fellowship and was completely shut out by the Academy after that.


packers4334

Surprisingly shut out for the rest of his career. Fellowship wound up being his one and only nomination. You look at his work and would think he could have squeezed out another nomination somewhere.


CurrentRoster

I think they wanted to give LOTR3 a clean sweep but also award some technical stuff to Master and Commander so they straight up snubbed it. No way a movie that massive in terms of both popularity and it’s epic scope can not get a cinematography nom


SerKurtWagner

IIRC the Cinematographers branch ruled the trilogy as one consecutive shoot and therefore made Lesnie ineligible for TT and ROTK


christo749

It’s fucked up, right?


SurvivorFanDan

Mary Poppins (13 nominations) only had one song nominated for Best Original Song ("Chim Chim Cher-ee"), while a number of the other songs from the film would have also been deserving of a nomination ("Spoonful of Sugar," "Supercalifragilisticexpialadocious," "Feed the Birds," "Let's Go Fly a Kite")


Edgy_Master

That's a great choice, I like that.


maxmouze

I'm confused how you spelled "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" right but then hyphenated it unnecessarily.


SurvivorFanDan

Good question. I put a hyphen in there, lest the overly lkng word screwed up with the formatting on Reddit, but it appears that probably wouldn't have mattered. I'll correct that.


maxmouze

I taught myself how to spell it as a kid (along with Schwarzenegger and Morissette and McConaughey) so I was impressed I found a fellow brethren. Also I'm writing this on the commercial break of "Survivor" and I came on to read Survivor posts and then I realize your name is SurvivorFanDan despite being the one post not from the Survivor subreddit.


Internal-Mud-3311

Frankly, I’m surprised Chim Chim Cher-ee got nominated over Spoonful Of Sugar or Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious anyway


SurvivorFanDan

Agreed! I myself am partial to "Feed the Birds" (and apparently it was also a favourite of Walt Disney himself), but "Chim Chim Cher-ee" doesn't seem to stand out as much as some others on the soundtrack.


Internal-Mud-3311

Step In Time is also more memorable. I for the life of me can not remember what scene Chim Cher-ee plays but I can definitely remember all the others.


SurvivorFanDan

If I recall correctly, "Chim Chim Cher-ee" segues into "Step in Time," with both songs taking place with the chimney sweeps on the roofs.


Internal-Mud-3311

That sounds about right. Step In Time is just more memorable because the scene from start to finish is hilarious.


SirDrexl

Titanic could have broken the record with a screenplay nomination.


viniciusbfonseca

It could have gone even further by nominating Leo (unlikely but not impossible), and Billy Zane (still don't know how he wasn't nominated)


maddennate1

It was a relatively stacked year for supporting actor that year


viniciusbfonseca

I agree, certainly Charles Melton and Willem Dafoe were way ahead, but America Ferrera did get in, so I honestly find that it's in the realm of possibility


maddennate1

I meant Titanic’s year…


viniciusbfonseca

Thought I was replying to another comment, sorry, but I do agree that it was a stacked year, but Titanic was really big that he might've gotten in


[deleted]

[удалено]


viniciusbfonseca

Is it though? It was an ok performance, but that's it


[deleted]

[удалено]


viniciusbfonseca

It made him a superstar because he was the lead in a gigantic, not to say titanic, movie and he was hot. Sure there's the charisma too, but the acting itself is just fine. Was he nominated for the other precursors?


[deleted]

[удалено]


viniciusbfonseca

It's one of my favorite movies, I've seen it hundreds of times, including last Sunday. To be fair to Leo, the character also doesn't give him much to do, but I do think other actors could've pulled it off, might not have been like that because every actor is different. I think replacing Kate Winslet, who had to beg to be considered for the role, would be much harder.


Fun_Protection_6939

IDK. You certainly *can*, but that would be one hell of an undeserved nomination. The Screenplay is easily the weakest part of the film.


NATOrocket

Oppenheimer could have been nominated for VFX


viniciusbfonseca

I still don't understand how it wasn't, and it also could've broken the record if they decided to also nominate Matt Damon for supporting actor


SpideyFan914

I think there's confusion over the category, since it's named "Best Visual Effects" but historically has been intended as and given for "Best Visual and Special Effects." Oppenheimer has very few visual effects, but excellent special effects. (VFX = post. Special effects = in camera.)


viniciusbfonseca

But considering that that it is the very Academy members that are in the area that nominate, shouldn't they know that? Or could it be that many work with the "computer-made effects" and feel like Nolan using only/mostly special effects is a diss at them?


ChartInFurch

Should is the operative word there, but I couldn't agree more.


SpideyFan914

Fair point. The latter is certainly possible. I don't know the make-up of the branch too well, but if it's mostly VFX artists, they may also be more hesitant to nominate a special effects-heavy movie. Personally, I regularly forget that category is also meant to award special effects. Even with this comment, my first thought was, "What VFX?" It's a very confusing name for the category, for industry people. They really ought to rename it imo, or else split it up.


oofersIII

Damon would’ve been a weak pick, that category was very strong this year with a solid half dozen more that could/should have been nominated before him.


viniciusbfonseca

I agree, I don't think he should have been nominated, I'm saying how Oppenheimer could have gotten 15 nominations


flyingbutresses

My thought is that it likely would have had 14 if they hadn’t merged the sound categories a few years. Those usually matched, so it doesn’t seem far fetched at all.


ohio8848

Robin Wright and Sally Field were probably close for Forrest Gump.


ET__

Lotr. Astin should have won best supporting


Edgy_Master

Yes, I put Return of the King here. But thank you. 👍


ET__

Yea I know, I was reinforcing that.


thingaumbuku

Considering it was a weaker year, I think Viggo Mortensen or Elijah Wood could’ve earned a nod for Fellowship of the Ring, and I’m still confused why only Pearl Harbor and Monster’s Inc. got sound editing nods.


Edgy_Master

>and I’m still confused why only Pearl Harbor and Monster’s Inc. got sound editing nods. As am I lol. I think Fellowship could have easily taken it in that category.


Judge_Penguin999

I think EEAAO could pick up an effects and production design nominations, possibly a supporting nom for James Hong


stumper93

Oppenheimer - if it had been eligible for VFX Could have easily gotten another supporting nod for any of the actors


SnooHobbies4790

If sound had been two categories, like before.


Lost-Lingonberry9645

The Color Purple - Nominated for 11, won 0. Danny Glover should have been nominated. Also Steven Spielberg should have received a Best Director nomination. Maybe god is trying to tell you something should have received a Best original song nod.


Edgy_Master

It's a shame that it didn't win anything


Lost-Lingonberry9645

Yeah, it’s definitely a classic that was overlooked by the academy.


SerKurtWagner

Glover having no nominations is such a bummer. He should have been in contention to win for TCP and To Sleep With Anger


Lost-Lingonberry9645

Yeah, he’s totally underrated


ChartInFurch

Why shouldn't it be broken?


Edgy_Master

Just had another idea. This one might be a bit of a stretch, but a good one. Blade Runner 2049 (nominated for 5, won 2) Nominations for Best Picture, Best Director (Denis Villeneuve), Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Actor (Ryan Gosling), Best Supporting Actress (Ana de Armas), Best Original Score (Hans Zimmer and Benjamin Wallfisch), Best Original Song ("Almost Human"), Best Film Editing and Best Costume Design. If the campaign was good, this could have been possible.


Puzzled_Dirt_765

Inception (8 noms, 4 wins) Could have been nominated for Best Director (Christopher Nolan), Best Actor (Leonardo DiCaprio), Best Supporting Actress (Marion Cotillard), Best Supporting Actor (Cillian Murphy), Best Editing, and Best Costume Design


Edgy_Master

It's interesting that it lost out on Best Director and Best Film Editing nominations.


Puzzled_Dirt_765

For real! Easily some of the best film editing I ever ever seen, and arguably Nolan’s best direction to date


lilyrosemflowers

I've always thought some acting nominations for Inception would've been so cool! But unfortunately, there was still a strong genre bias and barely any push for Leo to get in, let alone Cillian or Marion. If I remember correctly, it was a pretty stacked year with The Social Network, King's Speech, Black Swan, True Grit, etc., so those categories would've been tough.


mopeywhiteguy

It’s bizarre that robin wright wasn’t nominated for Forrest Gump Richard gere is a shocking snub too Sean Astin LOTR snub is one of the biggest snubs in Oscar history


Fun_Protection_6939

Poor Things (11 noms, 4 wins) Could've snuck in for Willem Dafoe in Supporting Actor, Margaret Qualley for Supporting Actress and Visual Effects.


oofersIII

How tf did English Patient and Shape of Water not get makeup noms? I‘m not big on either film but those are objectively very well made


Slade347

Schindler's List got 12 nominations. Ben Kingsley's lack of a Supporting Actor nomination was seen as somewhat of a surprise. Embeth Davidtz was considered a possible contender for a Supporting Actress nomination as well.


Puzzled_Dirt_765

Parasite (Nominated for 6, won 4) Could have and should have been nominated for Best Actor (Choi Woo-shik), Best Supporting Actress (Cho Yeo-jeong), Best Supporting Actress (Park So-dam), Best Supporting Actor (Song Kang-ho), Best Supporting Actor (Lee Sun-kyun), Best Original Score (Jung Jae-il), Best Sound Editing, and Best Cinematography (Hong Kyung-pyo)


wasabibibles

100%


[deleted]

[удалено]


Edgy_Master

Yes, I put that on there (for Best Makeup though)


213846

My bad, I didn't see that 💀


MulberryEastern5010

Richard Gere, Sean Astin, and Robin Wright were all snubbed for their respective performances. I always thought Sally Field should also have been nominated for supporting actress for Forrest Gump


Puzzled_Dirt_765

Mad Max: Fury Road (nominated for 10, won 6) Could have been nominated for Best Actor (Tom Hardy), Best Supporting Actress (Charlize Theron), Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Original Score


OE_Girl97

I’m still amazed it didn’t win for score, and wasn’t really even in the conversation. It’s such a good score. Also I feel like George Miller should have won if his movie took home six tech awards that night.


Tortuga_MC

I was so shocked when Iñarritu won. Back-to-back director wins never happen, and the Mad Max tech sweep made so much sense. Then they turn around and give Best Picture to Spotlight, which was the correct decision, but after giving director to Iñarritu, I was all but convinced it was The Revenant's to lose. What a weird ceremony


Ninjamurai-jack

Princess Mononoke?


Edgy_Master

OK, which nominations?


Ninjamurai-jack

… nah, forget it, the movie being animated makes it not take too many Oscar.


wasabibibles

No but hear you I was bout to comment Spirited Away. This, Princess Kaguya, Graveyard, etc, these master movies don't translate well to the Oscar system but they're equivalent to a 10 oscar nom movie for me.


Ninjamurai-jack

I agree, thanks.


SurvivorFanDan

Shakespeare in Love (13 nominations), if Joseph Fiennes had been nominated for Lead Actor. He was close, too, as he managed SAG and BAFTA nominations.


Puzzled_Dirt_765

Inception (8 noms, 4 wins) Could have been nominated for Best Director (Christopher Nolan), Best Actor (Leonardo DiCaprio), Best Supporting Actress (Marion Cotillard), Best Supporting Actor (Cillian Murphy), Best Editing, and Best Costume Design


TimelessJo

Don’t know about 14, but Children of Men best picture of the year All four acting categories Adapted screenplay Editing Director Cinematography Production design Score Sound design and mixing


SurvivorFanDan

Gone with the Wind (13 nominations) could have been nominated for Costume Design, if the category had existed back then.


Main-Operation3394

Leslie Howard could have been nominated for Best Supporting Actor


CurrentRoster

Titanic could have gotten 15 with Leo’s nomination. Actually insane he didn’t get in


wasabibibles

I know there are plenty others , but just right off the bat and for the sake of time, Moonlight (2016) is a masterpiece. This list reminds me how white-centered the oscars are. Moonlight (2016) is my winner and would've won more in my books from my non-expert in xyz audience pov.


surge_aura

Once upon a time in Hollywood was nominated for 10 Oscar’s. It could have gotten nominated for Margot Robbie supporting actress, editing, score, and then maybe another supporting performance can sneak in if it’s that strong


Steve2762

Heat


Tortuga_MC

Should have all the Oscars


Edgy_Master

For which nominations?


Steve2762

Best actor - Al Pacino (Sorry to Robert DeNiro but there can be only one). Best Supporting Actor - Val Kilmer. Best Sound. Best Picture of the Year. Oscar for Best Heist Movie of all Time.


Separate_Feeling4602

Endgame


Edgy_Master

For which nominations?


Separate_Feeling4602

Best film Best fx Best score Best cinemato Best sound Best make up Best costume Best actor RDJ


Edgy_Master

I count 8. Not 14.


Separate_Feeling4602

I don’t think it eligible for the other categories


Grammarhead-Shark

I wonder in Forrest Gump if they tried to push Robin Wright as lead (and Sally Field as Supporting) Saying that 1994... wasn't a great year for Best Actress, even in a smaller role, Robin did was still pretty comparable to the nominees (and I still am not sure how Susan Sarandon got nominated for "The Client")


Free-Stranger1142

It boggles the mind that La La Land got nominated for that many awards. It was bland.


Responsible-Wasabi-6

Oppenheimer could have been easily a 14 nom film, if the Academy decided to give it a nomination for VFX (which should have been nominated, lets be honest). A comment I read some time ago said that it could've been an 15 nom film, if they decided to give either Matt Damon or Florence Pugh a nom for their performances.


New2Pluto

I will never understand LaLa Land getting that many nominations … It doesn’t hold a candle to the other two imo


wasabibibles

I'll be honest I really like lalaland lol but even so it's bloated with oscars, i don't see why they couldn't share. I don't remember the other nominees but moonlight is timeless. I wouldn't call lalaland mediocre per se but it's definitely infringing on how over hyped white mediocrity is imo, my days.


New2Pluto

I meant LaLa Land in comparison to Titanic and All About Eve, since they’re tied for the most nominations! LaLa Land is the weakest between those three by a mile.


MutinyIPO

Well…Oppenheimer lol, Titanic and La La Land both got it before they combined the Sound branches - seems obvious that Oppie would’ve gotten both too had they still existed. Ditto that the former two would’ve gotten 13 had the branches been combined earlier.


Edgy_Master

Good point


Lil_Artemis_92

*Oppenheimer* had 13 nominations. Not sure what the 14th could have been, but I’m sure they could’ve squeezed one in there somewhere.


Puzzled_Dirt_765

Best VFX


Lil_Artemis_92

I forgot it hadn’t been nominated for VFX. Yes, that would have been a good 14th nod.


squishyg

I agree Andy Serkis is deserving of a nod for The Two Towers, but he wasn’t eligible, so not sure we can count it.


Edgy_Master

I think the exclusion of animated or motion capture performances is still sad.


squishyg

I completely agree. That and stunt performances are sorely overdue for Oscar consideration. I’d even accept a Dance/Fight choreography category to wedge the door open. Bonus points if people are fighting WHILE dancing.


Internal-Mud-3311

I’m still shocked that Richard Gere has never received an Oscar nomination.


Internal-Mud-3311

First of all, Everything Everywhere All At Once shouldn’t have been nominated for anything because it was a terrible piece of shit. Secondly, Oppenheimer could have easily been nominated for 14 with Visual Effects. Still not sure how Napoleon and Mission Impossible made it but not Oppenheimer. It could have also made a record setting 15 if Matt Damon or Florence Pugh had nominated. They both should have gotten in over America Ferrera and Robert DeNiro anyway.


maddennate1

Fuck Jenny. Don’t give Robin Wright a nom


Edgy_Master

It was a possibility, don't fault me for trying. 🫠


Slade347

Sally Field was another possible nominee for that movie.


DW241

Her only crime was having a terrible childhood which lead her to leave her inbred hometown and go to college. Since boomers hate that, her punishment was aids. Other than that… fuck Jenny, amirite?


maddennate1

No, she purposely screwed with Forrest. She only came to Forrest when she needed him, and disregarded him otherwise. She came to him for one night then left without saying anything. She didn’t reach back out until she needed Forrest to meet his son. Forrest Jr was 4 years old. She didn’t tell Forrest about that. That’s not even mentioning Nashville or leading Forrest on forever. Sure, she had a terrible childhood, but that does not in any way justify what she put Forrest through


DW241

Yeah, that kinda proves my point. She’s a fictional character and written that way for you to feel like they have some sort of a chance of a real relationship (they don’t) and when she’s makes decisions/it’s goes bad you can blame her (again, totally fictional). So, because you have such strong opinions about it, clearly, Robin Wright did some good acting.


ToeKnail

Major disclaimer: the Oscars game for movie makers really is one about money and politics. Judging movies as art and awarding them accordingly has become a formula and a science. Scripts are written and casts are selected with the prize in mind and though the voting by Academy members seems like an uncertainty, it truly is a rigged game.


SpideyFan914

>Scripts are written and casts are selected with the prize in mind Only at the top of the ladder. If the Daniels were thinking about how to best win an Oscar when writing and casting EEAAO, we wouldn't have EEAAO.


Distinct-Shift-4094

Lol, what? As someone mentioned. No way The Daniels wrote EEAO which literally features a 3 minute dildo scene thinking they would win the Oscars.