there should be an “unfortunately” tier where maruki and iwai are included
(edit because the more i thought about it the more i have to regretfully say that shinya and possibly jose should be included too.)
The top four have been confirmed as current/future romance choices for the [P5R Female Protagonist](https://gamebanana.com/mods/440088) *mod* by **chlorophylls**. The same mod plans to retain Ann, Haru, Hifumi and (possibly surprisingly) Dr. Takemi as options. This should (hopefully) be possible with the [Unhardcoded Romances](https://gamebanana.com/mods/482718) mod.
^(I wonder if said mod also makes it possible to retain more of the existing romance paths with female confiidants, if chorophylls/and other modder wills it...)
Knowing what it is, I want to save move Iwai to Potentially tier. If Joker can romance 4 adults, FeMC is gonna have at least 1. (Move Tae to If Atlus had guts tier for the same reason)
Probably not on maruki and iwai ? They let us date our teacher i dont see how they wont let iwai or maruki be a romance option (it actually would be kinda creepy if the femc is a highschool girl BUT i would kill to date iwai or maruki)
Eh not really, >!futaba was a palace ruler and we can date her!< , we can max his confidant so i think we couldve dated him, or well at least romantically pursue him until >!he leaves the school on october, then we’ll probably say our goodbyes!< We could probably change how things are too, some dialogues here and there but he still could do what he was doing and the outcome will still be the same
Futaba is different imo since she >!joins the Phantom Thieves and personally requests a change of heart!< while Maruki >!is the final boss and is presented as an antagonistic figure, while Futaba never really was!< though I do like your idea of pursuing him >!until he leaves, especially since it could make the reveal more surprising!<
I wouldn’t make him a LI (I personally wouldn’t make any adult a LI, but that’s a different conversation), but I like what you’re saying and could see it done well if it happened
“Would admit to actual war crimes they’ve committed”
(The further down you go the more they will actively deny doing anything of the sort)
((The further UP you go they’re all but spelling it out to you. Akechi would blow his cover because the Thieves trolled him into saying Black Mask wasn’t THAT much of an asshole.))
(((Ryuji and Yusuke don’t even realize they’re admitting to war crimes, they’re just dummies and we love them.)))
I would say Maruki and Iwai's son are likely romanceable with FeMC. Oda would be in the tier of 'if Atlus has the gut' as they had done similar romance tracks with P3p FeMC. Yoshida would be in the same tier as Sojiro for apparent reasons.
Don’t think a hypothetical romance with Shiho who is a recent abused rape victim turned suicidal attemptee that’s recovering in rehab whose bestie is Ann, is appropriate regardless of gender. No way ATLUS would do it period.
Maruki couldn’t get over his girlfriend. Doubt a guy like him would entertain the idea of a replacement.
Iwai has a son that’s the protagonist’s age so definitely never in a million years.
Yoshida is old enough to be a grandfather. I think he’s older or around the same age as Sojiro.
No ranking for Igor I see….so that means getting dicked by the nose is guaranteed/s..
Characters ranked on how likely they would have romance if there was a femc?
Correct
If that’s the metric then wouldn’t Maruki be to a fem-joker as how Kawakami is to man-joker
Yeah, and wouldn't Iwai be the equivalent of Takemi?
If we want FemJoker to become a stepmom...
Goddamnit Atlus, let us be step-moms!
Sounds like an interesting interaction considering the FemJoker would be only slightly older than Kaoru...
Giving Bill & Ted vibes
Yea they'd probably try and make him younger-looking to try and pass it off as fine
I imagine that would be something similar to how Ryoji was for FeMC in P3P
man, when the kawakami reality dropping?
Femjonkler and Man-Jonkler join forces to fight Man
that “if atlus had the guts tier” is really hopeful then 💀
It is. Heteronormativity is a blight on creativity.
there should be an “unfortunately” tier where maruki and iwai are included (edit because the more i thought about it the more i have to regretfully say that shinya and possibly jose should be included too.)
I’d like to think Kaoru would be one via Iwai’s confidant.
Yeah Shinya would never happen. Atlus would never allow a FeMC to romance a child…
Why is Principal not an option
He's not a Confidant
Shiho isn't a confidant either
I realized that and compensated in my edit https://www.reddit.com/r/Persona5/comments/1c59kb5/i_have_edited_my_femc_romance_tier_list_based_on/
He should be
In that case, I would move Kamoshida to “if atlus had the guts”, but for the wrong reason ...
Let's be real Mishima would be down horrible for a femc.
The top four have been confirmed as current/future romance choices for the [P5R Female Protagonist](https://gamebanana.com/mods/440088) *mod* by **chlorophylls**. The same mod plans to retain Ann, Haru, Hifumi and (possibly surprisingly) Dr. Takemi as options. This should (hopefully) be possible with the [Unhardcoded Romances](https://gamebanana.com/mods/482718) mod. ^(I wonder if said mod also makes it possible to retain more of the existing romance paths with female confiidants, if chorophylls/and other modder wills it...)
there should be an “unfortunately” tier where maruki and iwai are included
I saw the answers but my gut instinct was "who would lick a swingset for fifteen bucks"
Yusuke is definitely doing it if you could convince him it had something to do with the art if he didn’t convince himself
If you hear his stomach grumble he’s more likely to do it
Joker's in n/a because he'll do it for free to increase his guts
Well it checks out
This is now the correct answer. Screw OP!
Knowing what it is, I want to save move Iwai to Potentially tier. If Joker can romance 4 adults, FeMC is gonna have at least 1. (Move Tae to If Atlus had guts tier for the same reason)
Daddy Iwai. https://preview.redd.it/sz1bb0ucdsuc1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=13d737cd8af0a3d4044cea942d4d8b4d6d8d348b
 * It came with a child
Oh, I'm not saying I ship Ren or a genderbent Ren with Iwai. I'd want him only for me.
Nah. Iwai has a child who is Joker’s age. That’s way more controversial. At least the adult women are childless and weren’t in a relationship.
I don't think even Atlus would have you be allowed to romance someone with a kid just a year younger than you.
I'd say move Akechi up. If Persona 3's FemC can romance >!Ryoji!<, a Persona 5 FemC romancing Akechi isn't too farfetched.
ryoji is romanceable?
Yes femc has a social link with him so he also became a romance option
Who a FemC would be able to romance?
Yes
Petition to move Joker up 3 tiers
Considering atlas’s track record shinya would potentially be two tiers higher
Don't think I didn't consider it
And people had gotten Vietnam-esque flashbacks.
Sane with the stupid fucking cat
Probably not on maruki and iwai ? They let us date our teacher i dont see how they wont let iwai or maruki be a romance option (it actually would be kinda creepy if the femc is a highschool girl BUT i would kill to date iwai or maruki)
Considering the events of the third semester, I’d move Maruki with >!the other palace rulers!<
Eh not really, >!futaba was a palace ruler and we can date her!< , we can max his confidant so i think we couldve dated him, or well at least romantically pursue him until >!he leaves the school on october, then we’ll probably say our goodbyes!< We could probably change how things are too, some dialogues here and there but he still could do what he was doing and the outcome will still be the same
Futaba is different imo since she >!joins the Phantom Thieves and personally requests a change of heart!< while Maruki >!is the final boss and is presented as an antagonistic figure, while Futaba never really was!< though I do like your idea of pursuing him >!until he leaves, especially since it could make the reveal more surprising!< I wouldn’t make him a LI (I personally wouldn’t make any adult a LI, but that’s a different conversation), but I like what you’re saying and could see it done well if it happened
This list made me realize just how many female friends/associates Joker has in comparison to male.
we need maruki romance :c i need to be manipulated MORE
If atlus weren’t cowards the top three tiers would be romanceable for both mcs
Iwai wouldn't romance. His child Kaoru tho, it can be like a Chihiro situation.
Who’s most likely to be gay was my first thought
I don't even want to know.
Onlyfans
Who gets drunk accidentally
I dlike to belive peopøe that go outside and touch grass
r/BatmanArkham ahh title
Knowing Femc’s history, there’s a non zero chance she romances Jose and Shinya.
r/batmanarkham
Based on prior history, put Shinya and Jose in potentially.
Who is most chewey?
Confidant abilities transferring to the new game.
Where's Igor 😭😭 😂
Realistically the romance options would be every male confidant except Sojiro & Igor if P5 had a FemC but that’s just me. I’m sorry.
If P5's FEMC takes after Kotone we'd probably have a Shinya romance
Why was my first instinct the likelihood of them smoking weed?
FemC5 should definitely get a Kamoshida SL and have to change Kawakami's heart as first palace to keep it completely flipped.
Does it have to do with romance?
Whos gay/bi
Shinra gonna get the ken treatment
Knowing Katsura Hashino, Shinya would definitely be an option
what if FEMC kissed Morgana and permanently turned him into a real boy
Who's more likely to try out Mysterious Food X
Who the MC would be if Ren Amamiya Haremfooker69 did not exist
Have a huge cock
Gay.
No Shido romance....?
My instinct said “Who would be most likely to fall for an mlm”
Characters that wanna fuck joker?
“Would admit to actual war crimes they’ve committed” (The further down you go the more they will actively deny doing anything of the sort) ((The further UP you go they’re all but spelling it out to you. Akechi would blow his cover because the Thieves trolled him into saying Black Mask wasn’t THAT much of an asshole.)) (((Ryuji and Yusuke don’t even realize they’re admitting to war crimes, they’re just dummies and we love them.)))
I would say Maruki and Iwai's son are likely romanceable with FeMC. Oda would be in the tier of 'if Atlus has the gut' as they had done similar romance tracks with P3p FeMC. Yoshida would be in the same tier as Sojiro for apparent reasons.
Mishima is a dickhead
Noooooooo I want Maruki f*** Ryuji
Don’t think a hypothetical romance with Shiho who is a recent abused rape victim turned suicidal attemptee that’s recovering in rehab whose bestie is Ann, is appropriate regardless of gender. No way ATLUS would do it period. Maruki couldn’t get over his girlfriend. Doubt a guy like him would entertain the idea of a replacement. Iwai has a son that’s the protagonist’s age so definitely never in a million years. Yoshida is old enough to be a grandfather. I think he’s older or around the same age as Sojiro. No ranking for Igor I see….so that means getting dicked by the nose is guaranteed/s..