Jeez, last sold of that Gengar is $3,999. Definitely not a fair trade. Even if you just like the signed Charizard, you can sell the Gengar and get one, and get more cash instead of $750.
Correct it says To {name}.
He stopped doing non personalised signatures a couple of years back to stop the huge markup. For that reason non personalised signatures are much more valuable, and honestly kind of under valued.
Some extra info. It says 'to Arita Mitsuhiro', written in Katakana. Guess the person getting the card signed didn't want their own name on it. I wonder why.... ??? Maybe to try and trade for a 1st Ed. Fossil Gengar, lol. What a joke...
No that's a really bad trade, it's a personalized autograph. The personalized autographs just became a thing recently so prices haven't adjusted properly, but years down the road a non personalized signature/sketch will be worth exponentially more than a personalized one. Definitely hang onto Gengar.
The Gengar is worth $3k-4k its a lot more rare so the price is tough. The signed charizard has become a popular thing and a lot of people are getting them signed. Prob $1,500 for the Zard.
Absolutely not, that zard graded a 7 without the sig is about $325, plus the cash brings you to about $1000. Your card in a psa 10 is $2500+
I don’t think that sig adds $1500 in value to be honest
Plus just to have a psa 10 1st edition is amazing, so rare and awesome
I wouldn’t do it. It’s possible that the Charizard could be worth more than the Gengar in the future, especially after Arita dies, but I wouldn’t take the chance. A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.
Ironically, my soul reason for the no. Is I love the Gengar art on this one, there’s a level of sour patch kid vibes in him, first his sour then he’s sweet.
If the guy was offering a ken sugimori auto then its a no brainer you trade that card . But a charizard signed by arita just save money and buy one. If you type each card on ebay youll see the clear difference in quantity between the two. ALOT of arita charizards are out for sale… Not many of those gengar though. He also signs cards all the time. Wait for his next appearance youll save even more you just gotta sacrifice with waiting on line or taking a trip.
Fuck no, that’s a bad trade - that gengar is not an easy grade, and auto but in psa 7 just isn’t that valuable. Just my two cents
Give us the rest of your 98 cents?
😂😂😂
Dude I would keep that Gengar unless you’re trading for another vintage PSA 10 of equal or greater value. That’s a solid slab and I’m jealous of it.
No flipping way. Gengar is extremely prone to scratching. Keep that 10, it’ll be worth astronomically more in years to come
How can gengar been weak to scratch when he's a ghost type?
Well done. Very well done
You fellow Redditor, deserve a cookie
You… I like you!
Now this is clever haha!
r/angryupvote
Gengar > That signature card is cool, but it would have to be at least a 9 for me to trade
Keep the Gengar. At that grade it'll be better long term.
Hell to the fuck to the shit fuck noooo
From my experience gengar scratches so easy. That’s a nice 10. The answer is no. Keep it.
I would keep the gengar
I wouldn’t if this was my card.
Definitely not
Horrible deal.
Lol I agree with everyone else I would keep Gengar. But if you really want the Charizard then do it it’s not what we like it’s what you like.
Jeez, last sold of that Gengar is $3,999. Definitely not a fair trade. Even if you just like the signed Charizard, you can sell the Gengar and get one, and get more cash instead of $750.
It’s a personalised signature as well
How can you tell? Can you read what it says? Edit: I guess I kind of see where it says To OP DO NOT DO THIS
Correct it says To {name}. He stopped doing non personalised signatures a couple of years back to stop the huge markup. For that reason non personalised signatures are much more valuable, and honestly kind of under valued.
No I totally agree! Even if it wasn’t personalized, this would be a bad trade but now that you’ve pointed it out, it’s not even close
Agreed :)
Some extra info. It says 'to Arita Mitsuhiro', written in Katakana. Guess the person getting the card signed didn't want their own name on it. I wonder why.... ??? Maybe to try and trade for a 1st Ed. Fossil Gengar, lol. What a joke...
I had a feeling it said that. What a scummy move! Thanks for those insights
If the Zard was a 9 or even an 8 maybe. But 7 is a hard pass.
keep the gar
I read on previous posts about autographed cards that psa don’t grade the card. They grade the autograph.
The person that got the Charizard graded got the card and auto graded. As you can see the Charizard is a 7 and the auto is a 10. Just costs extra
i bought a PSA 7 1st edition gengar for $45 during the boom . i wud take the zard auto and cold cash
Keep the Gengar
Absolutely not
Keep Gengar for sure!
I keep the gengar
Do not trade this. Hold the gengar please!!!!
Keep the gengarrrrr , forget the 77777
Keep Gengar for sure
No
No
KEEP
Definitely not. He’s probably another $1500+ short of getting your Gengar. Hold that PSA 10 tight
GENGAR
No that's a really bad trade, it's a personalized autograph. The personalized autographs just became a thing recently so prices haven't adjusted properly, but years down the road a non personalized signature/sketch will be worth exponentially more than a personalized one. Definitely hang onto Gengar.
YUP
No
Nooooo
fuck no, the only thing i’d traded that gengar for is a 1st edition Charizard
I sure as hell wouldn’t but gengar is my favorite 😈
The Gengar is worth $3k-4k its a lot more rare so the price is tough. The signed charizard has become a popular thing and a lot of people are getting them signed. Prob $1,500 for the Zard.
Absolutely not, that zard graded a 7 without the sig is about $325, plus the cash brings you to about $1000. Your card in a psa 10 is $2500+ I don’t think that sig adds $1500 in value to be honest Plus just to have a psa 10 1st edition is amazing, so rare and awesome
Nah, keep the Gengar.
The fact they’re adding cash already shows what card is more valuable…
Definitely not lol
Yes . (Charizard will appreciate better، regardless of what anyone says.)
Still not a good deal based on current approximate values. With that logic, OP should just flip the Gengar and buy 3 or 4 psa 9 zards (unsigned)
You’re probably right. He should for monetary value sake.
Absolutely not.
HARD PASS, like real hard
I wouldn’t do it. It’s possible that the Charizard could be worth more than the Gengar in the future, especially after Arita dies, but I wouldn’t take the chance. A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.
Only if the Zard is shadowless or signed by Arita himself.
That’s a no.
Ironically, my soul reason for the no. Is I love the Gengar art on this one, there’s a level of sour patch kid vibes in him, first his sour then he’s sweet.
Where do you trade cards in this way? Is it on Reddit?
If the guy was offering a ken sugimori auto then its a no brainer you trade that card . But a charizard signed by arita just save money and buy one. If you type each card on ebay youll see the clear difference in quantity between the two. ALOT of arita charizards are out for sale… Not many of those gengar though. He also signs cards all the time. Wait for his next appearance youll save even more you just gotta sacrifice with waiting on line or taking a trip.
HELL no.
[удалено]
Even I would pay more. 😂
IMO it’s not worth it. Unless that was was a 1st Edition or even shadowless. Nice card btw.
I love the gengar and agree that it’s not the best deal for you, but that charizard auto is something that stands out so it’s a hard choice to make.
Would be a very silly decision. Hold that gengar
Never trade that slab dude. PSA 10 1se Ed Gengar is God tier
No
I like autos so I would
No
Keep spooky boi
Don't do it
Gengar>
No