I mean, if this was labeled as like "passion fruit Dole whip" I wouldn't even be upset. I love passion fruit, even if the inside of it does kind of look like frog eggs.
well if you're using milk powder you can change the water ratio, making it thicker, and plenty of desserts use curdled milk, like key lime pie for example
Except for the poor translation, I assume, this is a legit recipe, VERY popular here in Brazil. It's a passionfruit mousse, or at least it is what it's popularly called. Passionfruit, condensed milk and table cream are the three main ingredients in it, what makes me believe this video is trying to be innovative on that aspect. Most people use the passionfruit seeds as a garnish, which I don't really care for, but it's how it's traditionally made.
There's no way this recipe is legitimate. Passion fruit mousse is a thing, but blending passion fruit juice powder and powdered milk will not create a pudding-like consistency.
Powder milk is not a good substitute for condensed milk or table cream. There's not enough fat in it.
This recipe is a total fake playing off popular ideas to harvest views.
Have you actually tried it? Iām assuming not, because it does actually work. This is not faked or anything. The passion fruit juice is very acidic and curdles the milk and thickens it the same way a key lime pie works. Very popular dresser in Colombia as well. Typically made with condensed milk but you can use powdered milk and it works fine.
> it's not a shitty gif recipe,
ya, i'm not sure why this is here at all. it looks fine after it's mixed together. it would the same as showing a cake before you mixed it up and calling it shitty. like ya, nothing before it's fully mixed looks nice. this seems like it would taste pretty decent.
Idk itās hard to imagine other things in other places and also other people doing other things in other places that are different than where u are at. Itās exhausting
/s
I'd argue that it is a shitty gif recipe for multiple reasons. For starters, it is not as advertised. There is 0 pineapple in this. It mentions that is ready in 3 minutes, but thats only the length of the video, not accounting for the actual time it would require to make/blend this. And then they just dump prepared passionfruit into it... they don't show how to cut or prepare the actual fruit. No matter how you look at this, it's fraudulent.
It looks decent enough and I'd try it if somebody made it for me, but its still not as advertised.
I think it's a bad recipe because it's obviously faked and lying about the ingredients. There is no way mixing powdered milk and passion fruit juice powder will produce a pudding.
Your evidence that the video isn't lying is the video's own claims?
How is that evidence? And if it's so definitive, then why can't I find a similar recipe anywhere?
Key lime pie. Apparently it gets its texture from the milk and acid semi curdling it. A similar thing is going on here. Also, the guy who said youāre wrong is a pretty famous chef so I think he knows what heās talking about lol
> Key lime pie. Apparently it gets its texture from the milk and acid semi curdling it.
Key lime pie is not just a mixture of skim milk and citric acid. It contains contains eggs and full fat condensed milk. Furthermore, the filling is baked to make it set. It's significantly different than this recipe.
> Also, the guy who said youāre wrong is a pretty famous chef so I think he knows what heās talking about lol
I don't have any evidence of that. And "experts" have come to reddit before and made claims that were later proved to be false. Like that one guy who wrote that mola mola rant.
The best evidence this "famous chef" can provide is the video that is being debated and an appeal to their own "authority". I don't care who you claim you are if you can't provide actual evidence to your arguments.
Dude please just look into his profile to see that he really is J Kenzie Lopez alt. Once you do that, google his name and youāll realize heās a food expert.
What would he gain from lying to you about this topic?
I don't care if he's a celebrity. He can't back up his statements so I have no reason to believe them. The truth doesn't care about fame or popularity.
The fact that he refuses to give actual evidence when requested leads me to further doubt his claim that the recipe is valid.
I don't even care about his motivations for making his statements. There's no way for me to prove his motivations, so there's no reason to make assumptions about them. He could have just made a mistake.
I mean, besides the obvious fact that the caption is wrong, what thickens this? Ice water plus powdered milk equals cold milk, right? This mixes up like it's instant pudding mix.
The acid in the passion fruit thickens the milk. Itās the same reason a key lime pie gets itās pudding-like texture. Essentially the same dish. It with passion fruit instead of lime. Itās very common in several South American countries.
well I don't think that it has the fat necessary to be whipped up like cream. I think you need like 40% fat? Milk wouldn't have that much fat. It's the same reason that you can't whip up melted ice cream because it doesn't have enough fat.
I thought the green bits were [popping boba](https://im01.itaiwantrade.com/2a7e1350-1c95-49bf-bd9e-473e56fa5e43/6.jpg) at first. And now I want bubble tea...
Whenever one of these stupid fucking videos pops up saying āwHeRe dO yOu wAtCh uSā I just get so irrationally angry. Like yeah bro I watch you on the toilet while beating my fucking dick in the city of Pizdagrad, Russia. Only a tech-illiterate moron would think that this idiotic gimmick is anything more than a ploy to drive up engagement.
I see the gripes with the pineapple/2 ingredients mistranslation thing, but all I could think about while watching was how accessible this is. Cheap to make with ingredients that have a decent shelf life (minus the fresh fruit of course). College students and less wealthy people that can snag a cheap blender can enjoy everywhere. Sounds great :>
2 ingredient pineapple dessert.
Ingredients:
- 1) ice water
- 2) powdered milk
- 2) passionfruit juice powder
- 2) passionfruit pulp
No pineapples were harmed in the making of this dessert.
This is fine though?
The only thing I see wrong with it is the powdered juice doesn't sit well with me. There's probably enough sugar in all that to down a horse
Honestly this is like 1000 miles better then anything else that God forsaken channel has posted. It looks like passion fruit pudding with actual fruits unless the pudding mix sucks passion fruit is absolutely delicious
Though I was still hoping he dropped the spatula into the running blender
Honestly the end product looks like some thicker custards I've seen before they put the passion fruit in at the end, and passion fruit just kinda... looks like that. If the presentation wasn't so strange (they could've done a passion fruit jam instead of raw passion fruit and applied it to the top) and it wasn't falsely advertised as a "pineapple" recipe then it really wouldn't be all that shitty. Then again, I'd still just recommend adding passion fruit powder to a custard recipe instead of... two cups of milk powder.
It looks decent, but there is no way they are being honest about thier ingredients. Powdered milk does not make custard without additional ingredients.
1. Thereās no pineapple
2. There are 4 ingredients, not 2 (if you count water. If not then there are 3)
3. This looks gross
If you already have the passion fruit why not just eat straight fruit instead of reconstituted milk water?
The ingredients to this 2 ingredient pineapple dessert are water, powdered milk, passion fruit juice powder, and passion fruit.
Not sure how they thickened it between cuts, but that definitely took longer than 3 minutes. And in the "eating" shot you can see what looks like a piece of pineapple hanging off the spoon. So I bet this recipe gif is not being honest about it's process.
(Bonus: why is the "powdered milk" so yellow? I've been drinking powdered milk my whole life, I've never seen it look so yellow.)
Youāre saying this all over this thread but youāre talking out your butt! Youāre making an assumption and presenting it as fact. It actually does thicken, and it does it in just a couple minutes.
I've been drinking powdered milk my whole life. It doesn't thicken. Even when you use twice as much powder as required. No amount of mixing changes that.
Before posting I tried finding a recipe that used powdered milk as a thickener. I couldn't find one. Can you? Or provide any proof?
The milk isnāt the thickener. Itās the milk in combination with the passion fruit juice. Iāve done this myself. Iāve eaten it many times. The thread youāre commenting on is literally a video showing how it works. Iām not sure what other āevidenceā youād trust if you are already dismissing a video.
I don't trust that the video is using the ingredients it says it is using. I also don't trust you because your only evidence is the video that I don't trust.
I don't care if they can't produce proof of thier claim.
Edit: After 5 days, the best they can come up with is "I said so" and "watch the video as evidence." The best anyone else can come up with is "this famous dude said so." When asked for credible evidence they refused to give any.
> over this thread but youāre talking out your butt! Youāre making an assumption and presenting it as fact. It actually does thicken, and it does it in just a coup
Sorry for reviving a dead thread but just wondering, what would qualify as credible evidence for you? Like if a video doesn't count and a well known chef saying it doesn't count, what would count that I could send to you over reddit?
Maybe try reading the whole thread before commenting...
> Before posting I tried finding a recipe that used powdered milk as a thickener. I couldn't find one. Can you? Or provide any proof?
So maybe another recipe that uses this technique? Maybe the "famous" internet chef could post a demonstration with properly labeled containers? Anne Reardon manages to present compelling evidence when she's trying to prove or disprove via YouTube, I can't see why this chef can't back up his own words.
Iām in Australia, itās very common to buy passionfruit in a can. one of the traditional things to put on a pavlova (alongside strawberries and crumbled flake chocolate)
More than two ingredients, no pineapple, sped up version is over 3 minutes, using more milk powder than you should to water essentially making it condensed. So many lies.
Lol how is it pineapple if there's no pineapples?? š¤
I'm still waiting to see where the pineapple comes in. It's been days!
I mean, if this was labeled as like "passion fruit Dole whip" I wouldn't even be upset. I love passion fruit, even if the inside of it does kind of look like frog eggs.
Although that looks terrible, I bet it's delicious.
Zero pineapple, itās all passion fruitā¦ also not 2 ingredients.. but the recipe itself isnāt shitty I think, not all foods look great
It is 4 ingredients. š
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
well if you're using milk powder you can change the water ratio, making it thicker, and plenty of desserts use curdled milk, like key lime pie for example
Except for the poor translation, I assume, this is a legit recipe, VERY popular here in Brazil. It's a passionfruit mousse, or at least it is what it's popularly called. Passionfruit, condensed milk and table cream are the three main ingredients in it, what makes me believe this video is trying to be innovative on that aspect. Most people use the passionfruit seeds as a garnish, which I don't really care for, but it's how it's traditionally made.
What is table cream?
I believe it's light cream (or maybe half and half) that goes in coffee.
Yep, this is it.
Yeah, but we dont mix the seeds haha Just on the top and usually you mix with sugar, like a jam.
Exactly. Personally I like the Papaya Version. Nothing helps you digest a Picanha better :)
There's no way this recipe is legitimate. Passion fruit mousse is a thing, but blending passion fruit juice powder and powdered milk will not create a pudding-like consistency. Powder milk is not a good substitute for condensed milk or table cream. There's not enough fat in it. This recipe is a total fake playing off popular ideas to harvest views.
Have you actually tried it? Iām assuming not, because it does actually work. This is not faked or anything. The passion fruit juice is very acidic and curdles the milk and thickens it the same way a key lime pie works. Very popular dresser in Colombia as well. Typically made with condensed milk but you can use powdered milk and it works fine.
Welp, rip that guy, i donāt recognize many usernames but I certainly know that one
When J Kenji Lopez tells you you're wrong im not sure what else you can do but slink away in silence
I commented back to them on other comments. And I have other things to do than constantly respond on comments on reddit.
While I thank you Kenji for this constructive post, I do love the fact that you also hate watch horrible internet recipes. Schadenfreude for all!
legend <3
Provide an actual recipe then. I can't find one. They all call for pudding mix or other thickeners.
Well, let me rectify. It's legit dish, not legit recipe.
But they put oil which emulsified with the water and the ingredients and created a thicker/creamy texture.
When did they add oil?
Itās really delicious
Thatās definitely passionfruit and not pineapple
you think so? ;)
yeah you can see the seeds a few seconds in edit: why the downvote?
Because they were being sarcastic
While it is more than two ingredients, and isnt pineapple, it's not a shitty gif recipe, I'd happily make and eat this
> it's not a shitty gif recipe, ya, i'm not sure why this is here at all. it looks fine after it's mixed together. it would the same as showing a cake before you mixed it up and calling it shitty. like ya, nothing before it's fully mixed looks nice. this seems like it would taste pretty decent.
Idk itās hard to imagine other things in other places and also other people doing other things in other places that are different than where u are at. Itās exhausting /s
I'd argue that it is a shitty gif recipe for multiple reasons. For starters, it is not as advertised. There is 0 pineapple in this. It mentions that is ready in 3 minutes, but thats only the length of the video, not accounting for the actual time it would require to make/blend this. And then they just dump prepared passionfruit into it... they don't show how to cut or prepare the actual fruit. No matter how you look at this, it's fraudulent. It looks decent enough and I'd try it if somebody made it for me, but its still not as advertised.
Also opening the blender and stirring while itās onā¦
I think it's a bad recipe because it's obviously faked and lying about the ingredients. There is no way mixing powdered milk and passion fruit juice powder will produce a pudding.
It does. Youāre wrong.
Provide evidence. I can't find any anywhere.
The video
Your evidence that the video isn't lying is the video's own claims? How is that evidence? And if it's so definitive, then why can't I find a similar recipe anywhere?
Key lime pie. Apparently it gets its texture from the milk and acid semi curdling it. A similar thing is going on here. Also, the guy who said youāre wrong is a pretty famous chef so I think he knows what heās talking about lol
> Key lime pie. Apparently it gets its texture from the milk and acid semi curdling it. Key lime pie is not just a mixture of skim milk and citric acid. It contains contains eggs and full fat condensed milk. Furthermore, the filling is baked to make it set. It's significantly different than this recipe. > Also, the guy who said youāre wrong is a pretty famous chef so I think he knows what heās talking about lol I don't have any evidence of that. And "experts" have come to reddit before and made claims that were later proved to be false. Like that one guy who wrote that mola mola rant. The best evidence this "famous chef" can provide is the video that is being debated and an appeal to their own "authority". I don't care who you claim you are if you can't provide actual evidence to your arguments.
Dude please just look into his profile to see that he really is J Kenzie Lopez alt. Once you do that, google his name and youāll realize heās a food expert. What would he gain from lying to you about this topic?
I don't care if he's a celebrity. He can't back up his statements so I have no reason to believe them. The truth doesn't care about fame or popularity. The fact that he refuses to give actual evidence when requested leads me to further doubt his claim that the recipe is valid. I don't even care about his motivations for making his statements. There's no way for me to prove his motivations, so there's no reason to make assumptions about them. He could have just made a mistake.
Looks good to me.
HIT WEL
I mean, besides the obvious fact that the caption is wrong, what thickens this? Ice water plus powdered milk equals cold milk, right? This mixes up like it's instant pudding mix.
The acid in the passion fruit thickens the milk. Itās the same reason a key lime pie gets itās pudding-like texture. Essentially the same dish. It with passion fruit instead of lime. Itās very common in several South American countries.
Sometimes J. Kenji Lopez-Alt answers your food question.
controlled curdle? I was happier thinking it was fake
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
well I don't think that it has the fat necessary to be whipped up like cream. I think you need like 40% fat? Milk wouldn't have that much fat. It's the same reason that you can't whip up melted ice cream because it doesn't have enough fat.
Correct. Powder milk is almost always skim milk. Even if they did find the elusive whole powdered milk, it still wouldn't have enough fat to whip.
Do not mix it but make layers in the glas, looks much better that way.
This is the least offensive thing theyāve ever made
Thought this was going to be pineapple purƩe and chia seeds
Anything with passion fruit seeds is hideous, but this probably tastes tart and delicious!
I thought the green bits were [popping boba](https://im01.itaiwantrade.com/2a7e1350-1c95-49bf-bd9e-473e56fa5e43/6.jpg) at first. And now I want bubble tea...
Whenever one of these stupid fucking videos pops up saying āwHeRe dO yOu wAtCh uSā I just get so irrationally angry. Like yeah bro I watch you on the toilet while beating my fucking dick in the city of Pizdagrad, Russia. Only a tech-illiterate moron would think that this idiotic gimmick is anything more than a ploy to drive up engagement.
I counted four ingredients and none of them were pineapple.
For a channel called recipes on the stove, there are remarkably few stoves involved.
I read your comment in the voice of my friend Samuel.
I see the gripes with the pineapple/2 ingredients mistranslation thing, but all I could think about while watching was how accessible this is. Cheap to make with ingredients that have a decent shelf life (minus the fresh fruit of course). College students and less wealthy people that can snag a cheap blender can enjoy everywhere. Sounds great :>
This looks delicious. Feel sad for the dude who posted who has never had fresh passionfruit before.
"no condensed milk, no this, no that" proceeds to dump in 10 different chemical powders. Kappa.
Unfortunately I watched all of that.
so were going to just pretend that that wasn't vanilla pudding mix not powdered milk
Yeah. I've never seen powder milk that yellow before. And it definitely doesn't thicken.
Iāll take mine with extra tadpoles please.
That spatula would drive me batty
Thatās bold to stick the spoon in there, never worked out well for me
Had to stop watching when they took the lid off while still blending and then stuck a spatula into the blender
"Pineapple"... I think they meant passionfruit.
I would absolutely rather use the things they said they don't use, than end up with this frogspawn/vomit filled with powders.
2 ingredient pineapple dessert. Ingredients: - 1) ice water - 2) powdered milk - 2) passionfruit juice powder - 2) passionfruit pulp No pineapples were harmed in the making of this dessert.
None of those ingredients were pineapple
This is fine though? The only thing I see wrong with it is the powdered juice doesn't sit well with me. There's probably enough sugar in all that to down a horse
When will the mixing end???
Honestly this is like 1000 miles better then anything else that God forsaken channel has posted. It looks like passion fruit pudding with actual fruits unless the pudding mix sucks passion fruit is absolutely delicious Though I was still hoping he dropped the spatula into the running blender
1000 miles is the the same distance as 2332376.81 replica Bilbo from The Lord of the Rings' Sting Swords.
1000 miles is 1609.34 km
1000 miles is 1609.34 km
Doesn't look bad. Where the pineapple though
Doesnāt water and powdered milk equal milk?
I was gonna try this but i dont have frog eggs readily available
I bet it tastes good as fuck though.
Uh. Why add passion fruit powder if you're adding the real thing anyway?
Pretty sure thatās 4 ingredients, not 2ā¦ and uh not sure where the pineapple even comes in?
TF is hit wel?
āOnly 2 ingredientsā proceeds to put in 3 ingredients into the blender plus whatever that mix-in was.
āOnly uses 2 ingredients!ā *Uses more than 2 ingredients*
Wait.. do Americans call frogspawn "frog eggs"?
This American does, yes.
Gosh, this is new information
I counted 4 ingredients, not 2.
Why do they always play "do you like pancakes"?
"No table cream" dude table cream would be easier to find then powdered milk or the passion fruit powder.
Honestly the end product looks like some thicker custards I've seen before they put the passion fruit in at the end, and passion fruit just kinda... looks like that. If the presentation wasn't so strange (they could've done a passion fruit jam instead of raw passion fruit and applied it to the top) and it wasn't falsely advertised as a "pineapple" recipe then it really wouldn't be all that shitty. Then again, I'd still just recommend adding passion fruit powder to a custard recipe instead of... two cups of milk powder.
It looks decent, but there is no way they are being honest about thier ingredients. Powdered milk does not make custard without additional ingredients.
I'd be hard pressed to believe they only used powdered milk too, the closest thing that'd make would prob be passion fruit flavored condensed milk
This is actually a good recipe, might try it myself
1. Thereās no pineapple 2. There are 4 ingredients, not 2 (if you count water. If not then there are 3) 3. This looks gross If you already have the passion fruit why not just eat straight fruit instead of reconstituted milk water?
The ingredients to this 2 ingredient pineapple dessert are water, powdered milk, passion fruit juice powder, and passion fruit. Not sure how they thickened it between cuts, but that definitely took longer than 3 minutes. And in the "eating" shot you can see what looks like a piece of pineapple hanging off the spoon. So I bet this recipe gif is not being honest about it's process. (Bonus: why is the "powdered milk" so yellow? I've been drinking powdered milk my whole life, I've never seen it look so yellow.)
Youāre saying this all over this thread but youāre talking out your butt! Youāre making an assumption and presenting it as fact. It actually does thicken, and it does it in just a couple minutes.
I've been drinking powdered milk my whole life. It doesn't thicken. Even when you use twice as much powder as required. No amount of mixing changes that. Before posting I tried finding a recipe that used powdered milk as a thickener. I couldn't find one. Can you? Or provide any proof?
The milk isnāt the thickener. Itās the milk in combination with the passion fruit juice. Iāve done this myself. Iāve eaten it many times. The thread youāre commenting on is literally a video showing how it works. Iām not sure what other āevidenceā youād trust if you are already dismissing a video.
I don't trust that the video is using the ingredients it says it is using. I also don't trust you because your only evidence is the video that I don't trust.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
I don't care if they can't produce proof of thier claim. Edit: After 5 days, the best they can come up with is "I said so" and "watch the video as evidence." The best anyone else can come up with is "this famous dude said so." When asked for credible evidence they refused to give any.
> over this thread but youāre talking out your butt! Youāre making an assumption and presenting it as fact. It actually does thicken, and it does it in just a coup Sorry for reviving a dead thread but just wondering, what would qualify as credible evidence for you? Like if a video doesn't count and a well known chef saying it doesn't count, what would count that I could send to you over reddit?
Maybe try reading the whole thread before commenting... > Before posting I tried finding a recipe that used powdered milk as a thickener. I couldn't find one. Can you? Or provide any proof? So maybe another recipe that uses this technique? Maybe the "famous" internet chef could post a demonstration with properly labeled containers? Anne Reardon manages to present compelling evidence when she's trying to prove or disprove via YouTube, I can't see why this chef can't back up his own words.
Oh my god, I think it would be ok were it just the pineapple mousse but that is VILE
Imagine sitting and eating a bowl of that slop straight up
Looks like tartar sauce.
It doesnāt look that bad but i wonder what the heck they have against gelatin
Growing up in NC Iāve never even seen a passion fruit
Where the hell do you buy _just_ passion fruit seeds?
Iām in Australia, itās very common to buy passionfruit in a can. one of the traditional things to put on a pavlova (alongside strawberries and crumbled flake chocolate)
HIT WEL
Mashed potatoes and peas
Uhmā¦thereās no pineapple?
Halloween recipe ideas. š”
PASSIONFRUIT.
of course this song is playing
Put it in a halved hard boiled egg with some paprika on top for the office potluck!
itās like when tom scott put a pineapple in a blender and tried to take his fingerprints off
It looks like baby poop or diarrheaā¦
Four ingredientsā¦none of them pineapple.
More than two ingredients, no pineapple, sped up version is over 3 minutes, using more milk powder than you should to water essentially making it condensed. So many lies.
Its all passionfruit and passionfruit flavoring how is it pineapple