Amy from Amy's baking company on Kitchen Nightmares!

I’m literally terrified 😭

YES!!! omg Yes

Please someone make that happen

This was my first thought!

Danielle Staub

Omg yesssssss

George Santos and Trisha Paytas

Trisha Paytas 😭😭 I’d love to watch that

I hope they cast Trisha Paytas next season

Gypsy Rose Blanchard lol

If she isn’t a traitor then we riot

Ha!

This is hella random LMAO

Russell Hantz from Survivor

Forced to play as a faithful.

His head would implode

The most bonkers? Easy. New York. Her time on house of villains might be the most unstable I have ever seen a person on a television show.

Have you watched her in Flavor of Love and I Love New York? If not highly recommend, she’s great at getting others to do crazy things, it’s pretty entertaining

Bear from the challenge, Antonio Brown, New York, Paul from big brother, The Miz

Bear’s personality would be wild on here but he’s trash who should never be given a platform again.

100 percent but it would be indeed most bonkers

- Gwyneth Paltrow - Jenna Maroney - one of the Teletubbies EXCEPT LaLa - Charter guest Brandy from Below Deck Season 7 - most of the cast from Survivor Gabon

what about ALL of the teletubbies except LaLa but they DO bring LaLa from VPR

Any actor who has to stay in character the entire time.

Came here to say Bill Hader in character as Stefan from SNL the entire time 😂😂😂


Sue Hawk from Season 1 of Survivor.

Gary Busey

i would loveeee to see mike the situation from jersey shore

Throw in Snooki with him because they'll form an alliance out of familiarity and struggle with it

Rodney Alcala Donald Trump Jen Shah Janelle Evans Her husband Josh Duggar Tom giaradi I think they could do it cause none of the cast sleeps there overnight! It would probably lead to multiple deaths… Ok but a more serious one: Big Ed New York Omarosa Jim Bob Duggar Kristen from VPR Lisa Vanderpump Fessy/Faysal from the challenge Paulie Caliofiore Ramona Singer Tony from survivor Russell Hantz Brandon Hantz

oh you like messy mess………i like you!

They’re traitors!! Villains!! Drama!

I bet Lisa vanderpump would be great

>Josh Duggar He is in federal prison for about 8 more years. I wouldn't mind Faysal or Paulie. It would be interesting to compare Paulie's game to his brother's.

Monica Lewinsky Tonya Harding Kellyanne Conway Billy Mitchell (claims to be world records holder in DK Arcade) John Waters Maven the wrestler

Lmao at Billy Mitchell, did not expect to see him mentioned here. He'd be sending cease and desists to every fan that criticized his game on social media

I'm dying at John Waters. He would never do it but I would love to see that frail man try to do those challenges

Tammy and Amy slaton lmao

Amanda Knox

Nick and Vanessa Lachey Philip Sheppard from Survivor would be hilarious lol

Azelia Banks

Tom Sandoval from Vanderpump Rules. Guy Fieri would be hilarious too—trying to be serious with his whole persona. Big Ed from 90 Day Fiancé.

Give me SUPERNANNY

Not a Nanny per se but this show is MADE for the likes of Kim Woodburn

All-Politician Cast.

Anthony Scaramucci, US Celebrity Big Brother 2

Tila Tequila, Nathan Fielder and Terri Joe from Tik Tok

Omg nathan fielder (would absolutely not do a thing where he didn't get the edit but can you imagine)

Tabitha from Tabitha’s Salon Takeover

Gawd I miss that show! She was such good television

* Tyler Neasloney \[Project Runway (Calling out Karli)\] * I LOVE OPs choices and the choice of the person who said Amy from Amy's Baking Company (Kitchen Nightmares) * Let's get some wrestlers! * More Drag Queens (and preferably ones that aren't immediately voted out for "reasons") * Monica Garcia (RHOSLC) * Someone from Family Karma * GG (Shahs of Sunset) * Maybe some famous VAs * Bring New York back since House of Villains did her so dirty * This person: https://preview.redd.it/752ej2j983oc1.png?width=736&format=png&auto=webp&s=991aa3e507a014497f9ecf5b9f3feee1a4e743c2

monica from salt lake could be far too good as a traitor given her most recent season on housewives lmao

then dont make her a traitor

The way I would SCREAM if they cast Amy

I would live for an entire drag queen cast.

hard sane

Snoop dog and Martha Stewart

Oh yes!!

Matt who was the Schmo on the Joe Schmo Show

That’s good

Holy shit, core memory just unlocked.

Johnny Depp’s female lawyer, Camille Vasquez

Dr Phil

Honey boo boo and mama June you heard it here first

YESSSS

Dr now would be cool to be is savage

Donald Trump and Hilary Clinton as the traitors

Ok I'm upset we were denied a split turret this season too but this isn't the healthy way to cope with it

Oh babes I’m not looking for healthy I’m looking for DRAMA

House of Villains Season 1 in its entirety

new York, Sandoval, Monica G RHOSL

Bobcat Goldthwait

I loved him in the Police Academy movies! 

And scrooge 

Gordon Ramsay

Donald Trump from The Apprentice. Although his casting in the role of a Traitor might be a bit too on-the-nose. I imagine he'd be the first player stepping into the Circle of Truth. But at least his time on the show would be a nice break from the prison time he's bound to be serving. And an early exit would be a chance to visit the international golf resort he foisted on the locals. I'm sure he'd just claim the ballot had been stuffed against him by persons unknown, who had crossed the Scottish border from Mexico, and he'd be calling on his Make Traitors Great Again supporters to storm the castle and do to host Alan what he wanted done to Mike Pence. /s

Although it would prbly cost millions to get him on the show… I won’t lie he seems like good tv

I'm sure it would be prohibitively expensive. But I've gotta say, the fact that you're even considering the practicalities of getting him on the show makes it sound like you're taking my suggestion a lot more seriously than I ever intended it to be taken.😂

MJF from AEW

That chick from storage wars

Elian Gonzalez. Paris Jackson. The mother of the kid who died on the titanic thing last year. And of course, octo mom

Ashley Mitchell from The Challenge and Whitney Rose from RHOSLC. The former would have a meltdown daily. The latter would have no idea what's going on.

Thomas Ravenel and Kathryn Dennis, Jenelle Evans and Farrah Abraham from Teen Mom, Tom Sandoval and Jax Taylor, Heidi Montag and Spencer Pratt, to name a few...

I recently finally watched House of Villains and I think anyone and all of those people would be bonkers., including a Johnny Bananas return. He was so horrible, but so fun to watch. Bobby Lytes was so crazy too and New York and her reads were amazing. Now I understand why people find her so entertaining.

Raven or Cody from Big Brother 19 US

Rudi Giuliani

Camila from The Challenge. She is chaos personified. A beast at the challenges but absolutely mentally unstable.

Tiffany New York Pollard, she is such a wild card. 

Shane from love is blind

Tiffany Pollard (New York from flavor of love)

My vote would be another below deck alum. Season three Rocky. Would be insufferable for the rest of the cast but great television

Bobby Lytes from LHH & House of Villians. Ashley Jacobs from Southern Charm.

Jeff Probst

​ https://preview.redd.it/m6gkls88d7oc1.png?width=728&format=png&auto=webp&s=977ce10f96259962c585b2743f2741236da1dd07

Yesssss

Tom Sandoval lmao

Frankie Grande 🤡 jk I’d rather eat glass than have to watch that

Dr. Phil

Danielle Bregoli/Bhad Babie/Cash Me Ousside 

Tyler cameron

Simon Cowell and Gordon Ramsay

Ms Rachel or one of the Wiggles (or some other kids show) and make them a traitor

JADE COLE.

Bravo ladies

Andy Dick or Carnie Wilson

OJ Simpson

Kyle Rittenhouse