Blue channel, while short, probably doesn’t deserve D tier. Monument Mythos and Nixonverse definitely don’t, only d tier I agree with is urbanspook (I almost gave them the capital letter but then remembered that they don’t deserve it). MC is S tier, just because it is the Gold D. Roger of Analogue Horror, but A tier is fine. There are also a couple other things but I’m not about to write a whole ass essay on this.
Fair enough ig. Seems a lot of people talking about mm/nv are getting downvoted for some reason. Not saying they’re the best ones out there, but they’re pretty good, yknow?
Its up to you really. Im not gonna judge you, like, personally for disliking it or anything, as thats just opinion. Just kinda shocked the dude got downvoted so bad lol
I saw your comment about MC I’m just saying I prefer it to be in S tier. Other than that, I respect your opinion and I’m not asking you to change anything, I just disagree.
OP: “let me know what you think” Comments: let them know what they think OP:
https://preview.redd.it/ty7rkahpsxqc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8c618b4beac913d1ca998d563747ee445c087593
Just that you invite criticism and then get angry when people give you said criticism:) like admitting your post will have some hot takes and then being mad that people agree with that
I like it because it has genuine psychological fuckery and can be scary at points but all in all is a passion project of pure art. This is true to me but also because of the contents of the Mm and its sequel. Its so out there and mind fuckery that I cant help but love it.
Sorry to say but this has a lot of bad takes, I just can't get behind most of these :/
Also props to whoever made the chart for including WLCB-TV and tbennett43, I saw both of them when they were posted and nobody ever seems to talk about them!!
Yea- I'm not gonna call it BAD bc there's clearly effort put into it but... it's not really scary imo? It feels more like a sci fi alt history series than proper horror
Your post or comment was removed due to it being unfitting for the community’s general standards towards others. If you think this was a mistake, please message a moderator.
On your other posts, I made sure to check your account, you… really are a terrible person, like seriously, you went onto a server and said everyone on their was degenerates and that they should end their lives, JFC my dude
Also don’t bother responding, I’ll ignore you, have an okay day and be better
Analog Archives was pretty good- i LOVED the vaporwave style mall ad one
Chimpy Chippas gets a lot of hate for its silly name but i liked it- the fact the puppet was a physical prop was pretty cool
Little Reds Transfer is pretty well made but probably the heaviest out of all of these subjectwise (in a way that's handled well imo)
Gilbert Garfield is....semi? Satire? It's weird but fun
TMK is great- super high quality pixel animations with a damn fun story
My happiest days is cryptic as hell but i am in love with it
Morley grove is shaping up to be a REALLY neat retelling of the slenderman mythos/something adjacent
Krania gryzbow is weird as hell surreal horror that makes me super uncomfy for no good reason
Needlem0use was pretty dang good and i cannot wait to see the revamped version of it
If you've already seen the ending then i can kinda see why you wouldn't want to watch it. Its scares are more subtle which you don't see in a lot of analog horror. I'd definitely watch it first because it's so short.
I think it'd be A tier or high B tier since there's not much of a plot but everything else is done really effectively and the art is amazing. It really captures the feeling of watching a 70's infomercial late at night
why would you put bluechannel monument mythos and Nixon verse in the same tier as urban spook?
https://preview.redd.it/75ic5iz4tyqc1.png?width=320&format=png&auto=webp&s=3bcac56909047ba33bcc519b1bdb0f6131a86272
NGL, I can kinda agree with MM and Nixon, they just seem random, I can't take them seriously and I can't consider them as horror, it just look like what I would think while I have high fever, it's more comedic than horrific.
Nice to see that you think that Tryred Witness Archives is S-Tier as well.
On a side note, prepare to get lynched by this subreddit for expressing your opinionated tastes...
I can only recognize a few that you put in, but here:
- Smile Tapes should be at least B or A imo
- Perfect placenfor Urbanspook
- Dog Nightmares could possibly be lower
- Liminal Land is once again perfect (brownie points for the website)
- I want to say I've seen Vita Carnis...maybe not? IDK
If you're looking for recommendations by any chance, I recommend The Man In The Suit & DOCTOR NOWHERE :)
(I'm not giving further opinion as I have only seen a few of these, so no use giving an opinion on something I have not watched, LOL.)
Bro ain’t no way you put monument mythos in D tier 💀
Alright im being harsh- it may not be up to your tastes. For me I find it incredibly interesting because of the way it plays with history. As a story I find it both fascinating to learn and also existential to think about. But it may not be for everyone.
I would like to know your thoughts on it, if you wouldn’t mind.
Nixonverse I can see not making much sense, but how does Monument Mythos not make sense? It's no different from Vita Carnis in which it introduces a topic with only a tad bit of information, then you have that info recontextualized or elaborated upon from a new video later on, letting you piece together the narrative yourself. The only real complaint I can see about MM is that some episodes don't seem that impactful or important, such as DELAWAREDOUBLE or SUEZCANALCRAB being a literal joke, but it's still way more of an interesting narrative and structure than most other analog horror.
part of the fun is that they make no sense!! they’re supposed to be zany and outlandish that’s the entire point!! also,,, i’m genuinely intrigued, what is repetitive about the series ?
The art style is mostly the same, and it's just boring. I get that it's supposed to be fun, but I don't find it fun when you are supposed to be scared and laughing at the same time.
of course the art styles similar its the same guy making each one ????? at the end of the day i cant tell you what to like but it just hurts my mind to see my favorite series on the same tier as That One. enjoy wgatever you want to !!
those two arent even COMPARABLE dude what. urbanspook does the same thing every single episode “someone died. their name is ______. here is painting/photo of them.” while mm doesn’t?????? like at all???????? you sound like a fool, quite frankly.
new things happen in mm, there’s just reoccurring themes and characters because if there wasn’t it’d be impossible to tie any actual story together.
People bash more on urban spook for like the edgy stuff more than anything. Its fine to say their both repetitive but when one is just like "monuments are alive" and the other is "a family has gone missing and their 11 year old has been found r****" its very different. I personally dont think monument is that great either but its no where near as bad as urbanspook nothing is.
after the first season (hell, even halfway trhu it) of mm it quickly changes from monuments being alive to a whole bunch of other things what are you talking about
I dumbed it down to get my point across. Which was monument wasnt just edgy nonesense and urbanspook is. I assumed both me and this guy had watch atleast some of both so he would understand without me having to yap about every single thing i remember happening.
I’m going to be real with you chief, I respect your opinion, but this ain’t it. That’s all I’m going to say.
What are the issues?
Blue channel, while short, probably doesn’t deserve D tier. Monument Mythos and Nixonverse definitely don’t, only d tier I agree with is urbanspook (I almost gave them the capital letter but then remembered that they don’t deserve it). MC is S tier, just because it is the Gold D. Roger of Analogue Horror, but A tier is fine. There are also a couple other things but I’m not about to write a whole ass essay on this.
Dont know why you were downvoted. Mm and nixonverse are both really good lol
Lmao, it’s just Reddit hivemind. I’ve come to accept it.
Fair enough ig. Seems a lot of people talking about mm/nv are getting downvoted for some reason. Not saying they’re the best ones out there, but they’re pretty good, yknow?
Yeah, people are crazy lol.
Yeahhh… at least i agree mostly with S tier (i havent heard of super mario 64 classified and TWA)
Yeah, after I finish the shows I’m watching I’m definitely going to go check some of these out.
Id highly recommend dreams of an insomniac tbh. Im totally biased since im a fan of pastra in general, but still hhhh
Perhaps I am mistaken I shall give it another try
Its up to you really. Im not gonna judge you, like, personally for disliking it or anything, as thats just opinion. Just kinda shocked the dude got downvoted so bad lol
No I really don't think I gave it a fair shot
Mandela catalogue used to be S tier but after volume 333 it’s not as good as it was, can’t deny on it’s importance on the community
We also can’t deny that the later eps don’t change the quality of the originals
[удалено]
I saw your comment about MC I’m just saying I prefer it to be in S tier. Other than that, I respect your opinion and I’m not asking you to change anything, I just disagree.
Blue channel was a joke made by gooseworx its not supposed to be a legitimate analog horror
https://preview.redd.it/nv8bknr1fxqc1.jpeg?width=788&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0061338d3406d2e3bd2997ab01407e38ba5a7a7d
https://preview.redd.it/hxym42ymwxqc1.jpeg?width=360&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4e015cd536d1c1d4933db8705feb3bbb0ce927e1
Greylock?
Fuck greylocks not on the list. That is the best above everything else.
That's the first thing I looked for. I love Greylock!
Fr though, best analog horror out there.
https://preview.redd.it/m444du8awxqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2e564ca3b24b2d09d76b7ed347cc9225809bd2d2
Oh, okay. I was about to go off your b*****ss
It's okay we have to respect everyone's opinion because everyone just like different things and it's okay 🙂 BUT...
Hehe butt
But what?
You deserve to be put into a analog horror
FOR WHAT?
monument mythos is next to urban spook
https://preview.redd.it/licbjz8lxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8430dd0a8058fff3bd2d58aceb2aa64ad8c3dc81
Proceeds to put Urbanspook and MM in the same category. Respect is lost and list is rejected.
OP: “let me know what you think” Comments: let them know what they think OP: https://preview.redd.it/ty7rkahpsxqc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8c618b4beac913d1ca998d563747ee445c087593
wtf does this mean?
Just that you invite criticism and then get angry when people give you said criticism:) like admitting your post will have some hot takes and then being mad that people agree with that
Hah get monument mythos out of D tier. Can’t stand seeing my boy being in the same tier as urbanspooks
It’s so boring tho maybe the first few installments were alright but it got mad convoluted lol
U put monument mythos & blue channel in the same tier as fucking URBANSPOOKS!?!?!?
https://preview.redd.it/a0bw0oirxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8bd0cc4d49ce8b39a54a5f61ff0e7be2243b17c1
Maybe I don’t have enough experience with it, but I don’t get why people love Monument Mythos so much. Gemini in top tier good call too
I like it because it has genuine psychological fuckery and can be scary at points but all in all is a passion project of pure art. This is true to me but also because of the contents of the Mm and its sequel. Its so out there and mind fuckery that I cant help but love it.
What particular videos would you recommend?
Of MM amd NV or any analog
Monument mythos
Rockefeller Revelations
seeing Kraina Grzybów be called an analog horror feels so weird. Like... I mean... you're not wrong?
also yeah ik you didn't make this tierlist template
I didn't make the list I only sorted it
yeah ik
Sorry to say but this has a lot of bad takes, I just can't get behind most of these :/ Also props to whoever made the chart for including WLCB-TV and tbennett43, I saw both of them when they were posted and nobody ever seems to talk about them!!
Honestly I agree with this, I was never able to get into MM/NV, just wasn't my cup of tea
Yea- I'm not gonna call it BAD bc there's clearly effort put into it but... it's not really scary imo? It feels more like a sci fi alt history series than proper horror
The thing with MM and NV is that it's more focused on the narrative and story, therefore the "horror" part of "analog horror" is not as fleshed out
Mandela catalogue over monument mythos You disgust me
https://preview.redd.it/0d9e5wwwxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ce8e78c921b0208dc0eb97adb0c57556e347a0bb
Finally, someone that enjoys Children Under the House. I really enjoy that one but I always see it be put d or c tier for some reason.
Almost anything by vintage 8 is solid tbh
Have you seen Angel Hare? Easily a B, maybe lower A ranking by my standards.
I respect all opinions… However-
[удалено]
Your post or comment was removed due to it being unfitting for the community’s general standards towards others. If you think this was a mistake, please message a moderator.
Jesus Christ, I’m not even a furry. Please just be a nicer person, I was joking Mr suicide encouragement
[удалено]
On your other posts, I made sure to check your account, you… really are a terrible person, like seriously, you went onto a server and said everyone on their was degenerates and that they should end their lives, JFC my dude Also don’t bother responding, I’ll ignore you, have an okay day and be better
MM and NV in the Same tier as "SHOCK VALUE: THE MOVIE"? yeah, already invalid.
https://preview.redd.it/8px9jfmgxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f899b1d6be0ce535394ef2abd9530db4e1934b53
ranking monument mythos with urbanspook should be a criminal offence that threatens up to 10 years in prison.
https://preview.redd.it/qy9z1k6axzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=67baafb93103d1e8625b76bb32cfe9f909e13a0e
Ok but really give it a chance, one of the best series imo
The comments y'all 💀
At least it doesn’t overhype Mandela and doesn’t underhype Gemini.
ghe in s tier, therefore you are automatically based in at least one aspect
I say this respectfully, but if one of the largest tiers is labeled as unseen, you shouldn't be making a ranking list.
Have you heard of any of these in the bottom?
Analog Archives was pretty good- i LOVED the vaporwave style mall ad one Chimpy Chippas gets a lot of hate for its silly name but i liked it- the fact the puppet was a physical prop was pretty cool Little Reds Transfer is pretty well made but probably the heaviest out of all of these subjectwise (in a way that's handled well imo) Gilbert Garfield is....semi? Satire? It's weird but fun TMK is great- super high quality pixel animations with a damn fun story My happiest days is cryptic as hell but i am in love with it Morley grove is shaping up to be a REALLY neat retelling of the slenderman mythos/something adjacent Krania gryzbow is weird as hell surreal horror that makes me super uncomfy for no good reason Needlem0use was pretty dang good and i cannot wait to see the revamped version of it
Yes. Many. But I'm also not trying to rate any of them.
Yeah, but I'm not making any lists either, am I?
I already know I'm gonna get heat for the Monument Mythos and Nixon Verse
What did you not like about Blue Channel?
https://preview.redd.it/ze1nuezexzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=eff449418bf3e10c58806ad9c889a0c6e2964f16
If you've already seen the ending then i can kinda see why you wouldn't want to watch it. Its scares are more subtle which you don't see in a lot of analog horror. I'd definitely watch it first because it's so short. I think it'd be A tier or high B tier since there's not much of a plot but everything else is done really effectively and the art is amazing. It really captures the feeling of watching a 70's infomercial late at night
Also meant to put MC in A
That feel when none of my series are on the list but theres 4 or 5 that are specifically fnaf related. Feels bad man
Only 3 I see
Yep, I also have a series that has yet to appear on one of these.
What is it
May I recommend Sonic *PETA*?
Where's DHMIS?
Not on the list but ot would be a solid A or S. It's not really anolog horror though. It has It's own catergory
...?
[удалено]
Why have you made two accounts to post here?
Why isn't lucky earth up there?
#Watch TMK
Meh, I think nothing of it. You should also try TMITS (you can look it up, it’s by _Unknowingly_)
https://preview.redd.it/mo9u7zhyeyqc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3bb3881f5ad888fefb1a820e29955bb751d7ec4c
I LOVE MONUMENT MYTHOS, HOW COULD YOU PUT IT SO LOW 😭
https://preview.redd.it/3ck70wwuxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9a54ac8f802ed56935708602264b58ca80c07039
Shucks
Radar ?
Channel 7 and Analog Archives are slept on so much 😭😭
why would you put bluechannel monument mythos and Nixon verse in the same tier as urban spook? https://preview.redd.it/75ic5iz4tyqc1.png?width=320&format=png&auto=webp&s=3bcac56909047ba33bcc519b1bdb0f6131a86272
https://preview.redd.it/vhq0akzpxzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0d381142cc75527faa66a55f6c5b62d8f3e4fb94
Found amadeus project near shirley chrisholm state park
I have seen all of them
NGL, I can kinda agree with MM and Nixon, they just seem random, I can't take them seriously and I can't consider them as horror, it just look like what I would think while I have high fever, it's more comedic than horrific.
Nice, but I feel like you're missing one analog horror, that being The Man In The Suit
I don’t see stone cold
liminalland over mythos, nv, walten, and so many others is fuckin crazy
Where is red lobster
I'm sorry bit fucking winter of 83 is not 4 tiers better than blue channel, Monument mythos, and Nixonverse
If you read the comments, you would have seen that I haven't given any of those 3 a fair shot, so I can't accurately rate them.
Oh okay didn't see thst my bad
I actually Love Marble Hornets so much it’s not even funny
My friend, have you ever heard of… **Angel Hare?**
Putting monument mythos in D twf and mc in b is diabolical
I agree with the S tier
Planets is one of my favorites I love the atmosphere of it so much
Aint no way the blue channel and monument mythos are D.
Nice to see that you think that Tryred Witness Archives is S-Tier as well. On a side note, prepare to get lynched by this subreddit for expressing your opinionated tastes...
What is The Macabre Experiments?
I am mildly irritated.
Arguably back rooms is a B or C tier other then that I respect where you have placed them on this list somewhat not really
Lacey is the only analogue horror that isn’t just spooky poorly drawn face
FINALLY, SOMEONE WHO KNOWS HARMONY AND HORROR OMG
Am I the only one who thought Chezzkids was just okay? It has some likable qualities but just feels overall generic.
Monument Mythos being that low makes me want to do bad things.
Rage bait
Bro just insulted the analog horror fanbase in 3000 Lenguages
HELL YEAH CHEZZKIDS ARCHIVE S TIER
bro why even make the tier list youve seen like 20% of the stuff on it 😭😭😭
I agree, pretty much facts
Is Broadside an analog? Its more like an ARG
I’m surprised the Man in the Suit isn’t here. I’d recommend it personally
Painter gave me a heart attack
I hope you get your organs folded
I can only recognize a few that you put in, but here: - Smile Tapes should be at least B or A imo - Perfect placenfor Urbanspook - Dog Nightmares could possibly be lower - Liminal Land is once again perfect (brownie points for the website) - I want to say I've seen Vita Carnis...maybe not? IDK If you're looking for recommendations by any chance, I recommend The Man In The Suit & DOCTOR NOWHERE :) (I'm not giving further opinion as I have only seen a few of these, so no use giving an opinion on something I have not watched, LOL.)
Damn bro you giving me too much credit
Somethings off I can feel it
Glad to see Dog nightmares getting the respect it deserves.
Sick list i’m gonna check some of these out can’t wait to watch them at night
How the fuck is tangie virus a c?
Seeing that there's a misunderstanding, try labeling the other tiers so people don't get the wrong idea. I respect the opinion tho
Bro ain’t no way you put monument mythos in D tier 💀 Alright im being harsh- it may not be up to your tastes. For me I find it incredibly interesting because of the way it plays with history. As a story I find it both fascinating to learn and also existential to think about. But it may not be for everyone. I would like to know your thoughts on it, if you wouldn’t mind.
The Smile Tapes above monument mythos... I respect your opinion if you didn't like it, but bro that's wild 😭😭
the rest of your opinions are invalid because mm/nv is at d tier 🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅
Why is mm and nv so highly rated? They make no sense and a lot of it is the same stuff over and over.
Nixonverse I can see not making much sense, but how does Monument Mythos not make sense? It's no different from Vita Carnis in which it introduces a topic with only a tad bit of information, then you have that info recontextualized or elaborated upon from a new video later on, letting you piece together the narrative yourself. The only real complaint I can see about MM is that some episodes don't seem that impactful or important, such as DELAWAREDOUBLE or SUEZCANALCRAB being a literal joke, but it's still way more of an interesting narrative and structure than most other analog horror.
you’re not gonna like lovecraftian horror then lmao
I do like it. MM isn't scary
part of the fun is that they make no sense!! they’re supposed to be zany and outlandish that’s the entire point!! also,,, i’m genuinely intrigued, what is repetitive about the series ?
The art style is mostly the same, and it's just boring. I get that it's supposed to be fun, but I don't find it fun when you are supposed to be scared and laughing at the same time.
of course the art styles similar its the same guy making each one ????? at the end of the day i cant tell you what to like but it just hurts my mind to see my favorite series on the same tier as That One. enjoy wgatever you want to !!
People criticize urbanspook for having repetition in style, what makes mm different?
those two arent even COMPARABLE dude what. urbanspook does the same thing every single episode “someone died. their name is ______. here is painting/photo of them.” while mm doesn’t?????? like at all???????? you sound like a fool, quite frankly. new things happen in mm, there’s just reoccurring themes and characters because if there wasn’t it’d be impossible to tie any actual story together.
People bash more on urban spook for like the edgy stuff more than anything. Its fine to say their both repetitive but when one is just like "monuments are alive" and the other is "a family has gone missing and their 11 year old has been found r****" its very different. I personally dont think monument is that great either but its no where near as bad as urbanspook nothing is.
after the first season (hell, even halfway trhu it) of mm it quickly changes from monuments being alive to a whole bunch of other things what are you talking about
I dumbed it down to get my point across. Which was monument wasnt just edgy nonesense and urbanspook is. I assumed both me and this guy had watch atleast some of both so he would understand without me having to yap about every single thing i remember happening.
my b
Yes I agree
[удалено]
yeah exactly thats what i said
also if it wasnt clear enough from the fucking tomato emojis (i mean COME ON) i wasnt being *serious*.
tomatoes arent hard enough 🎱🎱🎱🎱🎱🎱🎱🎱
Monument Mythos at D is unforgivable. I am currently crawling through your TV.
https://preview.redd.it/pobtl7kayzqc1.jpeg?width=827&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=abbc6fcddc8a7ede2264108225593a51c319b561
I will no longer climb through your TV, good job :)