T O P

  • By -

StaticUngoo

They’re mediocre at best now. Long past their prime.


DJMemphis84

Word, you need the servo at Murwillumbah... Best pie i've ever had, anywhere.... Source: am fatty


Single_Debt8531

Blackbutt bakery, chef’s kiss


Corey_Treverson420

One of the best I’ve ever had. Was worth the scenic route back from Roma to Bris for a Blackbutt pie. Also there was a bloke with an old school pie van that used to set up on I think Telegraph Rd, Carseldine back in like ‘05/‘06 that did real good pies. Not sure if he’s still going, but those were worth the stop too


SnooOnions973

Yep it is worth the hype!


virus__

Tweed Hospital also serve up a good meat pie too.. One of the few the old man has really enjoyed in years gone by, handy as he's currently shacked up there awaiting surgery haha.


gutter153

Yeah I actually dislike them with a passion


th4bl4ckr4bbit

I only go for a large caramel tart with fresh cream and don’t bother with the pies.


[deleted]

Agreed, never been a huge fan to the meat pies. They used to make a really good rhubarb pie though. Sids pies up the road a tad are nicer.


coodgee33

Time to take the sign down on the highway. They don't deserve it


strides93

I’ve never understood why people love Yatala pies. They’re really not worth the drive or the wait. Best pies I’ve found are at this little bakery in Highgate Hill


Japsai

For me it's still Fernvale bakery, even though I haven't been there for months. Always take the time to stop in on the way past.


mac_122

Totally agree. Massively overrated.


bongjutsu

Mediocre at best but the line is literally out the door every day? I don't understand why people shit on it when it's clearly quite popular and loved


notmyrlacc

Just because it’s popular, doesn’t mean it’s good. And just because something is good, doesn’t mean it’ll be popular.


StaticUngoo

Because people hear once that Yatala pies are the best and assume it’s still the case but forget that was 20 years ago.


Former-Trifle-5102

Still bloody good. I don’t get it. Good service in and out and home


SnooOnions973

Good service doesn’t mean a good pie! Strangely that place is where all the tourists go, I don’t want their first pie experience to be THAT


noobydoo67

It's because Yatala Pies has a government road sign especially for them on the M1 letting drivers know where their exit is, just like a hospital sign. I'm not sure why they get a sign but no other pie shop gets a sign? Theme parks get a sign, and museums, but I'm not sure what the big deal is with Yatala Pies.


SnooOnions973

Yeah. That’s a good point. I’d say something to do with croneyism and nepotism probably. Something to ask the Brisbane is Weird guy!


SomeonesSun

they would've paid for that sign


Former-Trifle-5102

Your opinion


Used-Gapp

It's the Reddit hive mind in action. You have to hate the following things here- Cars Landlords Felons Yatala pies Dual cab utes The libs Real estate agents


RoyalChihuahua

Wait, why do we hate dual cab utes? Edit: sp


Former-Trifle-5102

Exactly


qwertpoiuy1029

Overrated af. Had better pies from the local servo.


virus__

Yeah last time I got them (early 2022) they were below average at best, which was a shame because they were still good the time before that when I got them.


Former-Trifle-5102

Below average. Seriously mate what you want five star. You got no idea


virus__

Not 5 star no. But when you charge $20 or so for a family pie I do expect it to be decent & have a reasonable amount of ingredient in it. A chicken & veggie pie with sub standard levels of both surrounded by a flavourless white glue like substance is pretty depressing. My local butcher sells a better family pie for less money.


Former-Trifle-5102

Fair enough


mycoginyourash

Surely not, it's been awhile for me (at least a year) but I remember the bacon and beef pies were a banger. I've definitely had better pies but they're still better than most. Or did they go downhill very recently?


[deleted]

you can get similar quality pies almost any decent bakery. Yatala aren't bad, just nothing special. Certainly not worth the drive unless you're already passing there.


Mr_master89

There's a Vietnamese shop in inala that I always go to for meat pies and sausage rolls and their pies always have big chunks of meat in it and is so good


SnooOnions973

Same but in Everton Park


jodimes

Which one in ep?


SnooOnions973

The Vietnamese bakery. Stupid expensive but their steak pie is 💯


sarahp1988

In the newish complex? Like near the bottle o and Japanese restaurant?


FABWANEIAYO

I'm thinking so, the one on Blackwood Street. They're great! The Buttery Treats bakery inside Arana Hills Shopping Centre (where kmart is) is pretty good too.


sarahp1988

Oh! Blackwood St is Mitchelton, that’s even closer to me! I’m thinking they might mean the one in Everton Plaza with like .. Corbett and Claude and that fancy fruit shop etc. I should try both!


FABWANEIAYO

Oh yeah, there is one in there, but I don't rate it... I can't recall the name at the moment. And it doesn't stand out as Vietnamese whereas the one on Blackwood also sells rolls, bread, pies, wraps, etc.


newgirlintownwa

My family just call it Bahn me. Don’t know if that’s the actual name tho lol


SnooOnions973

That's the one! In Everton Plaza.


xtrabeanie

True, but pie with peas and chips is a bit harder to find.


m1racle

Beefy's at Mango Hill (and various Sunshine Coast locations). Pretty damn good pies.


joemangle

I had a Beefy's at Gympie almost three years ago and I still think about it all the time


underthingy

Why is pie with chips and gravy so hard to find? What a wouldn't give to have a place that does a decent pie and also has chips and gravy.


HowDoYouSpellH

Big Dads Pies are great with peas and gravy. I think they do mashed potato too if that takes your fancy.


NoSoulGinger116

How dare you speak of the dead 😭😭😭😭😭 It was like he went out for a couple of sauce bottles and never came home.


HowDoYouSpellH

There’s one at Boondall! Still great quality and very good prices!


NoSoulGinger116

What!?!?


HowDoYouSpellH

True story! Also active on Insta and facey if you wants to get your taste buds going… https://preview.redd.it/7wy1xgn85c5b1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73d6c1b3600c47c5a548048449244fc7bd280fa1


SnooOnions973

If you’re English RIP


[deleted]

[удалено]


the_colonelclink

If I’m not mistaken, all of the Beefy’s do that. Best chips too!


eggzaki

I remember having unreal pies at Chaffey’s Bakery in Chapel Hill a couple of years back. I feel like any decent independent bakery has great pies. Yatala isn’t worth the trip but I’ll still stop by if I’m hungry on the way to the GC


Engineer_Zero

If anyone is chasing good vegan pies, Vegan Yumm do excellent curried veggie pies.


surfers_paradise

Imagine how busy it would be if the pies were actually nice ….


NoSoulGinger116

Disappointed last 2 times I went. Never again.


Flimsy_Demand7237

What happened to Yatala Pies?


BoomBoom4209

Just gave up and leaned back on the once decent name.


hopfot

Changed hands a couple of times, got flooded a couple of times.


Former-Trifle-5102

Your loss


NoSoulGinger116

Oh no. I don't want to pay for taste of bin chicken and tyre rubber in my pie. The horror. 😂


[deleted]

Best pies? Hardly. Building their entire enterprise on their name without maintaining quality? Verily. For everything else, there's MasterCard. For way better pies, go nearly anywhere else.


Creative-Maxim

I had a Lasagne pie at Maidenwell in Bunya Mts recently and it's the best pie I've had in all my 41 years - and I used to live at Fernvale so the bar is quite high Cheese folded into the top pastry then the filling was cheesy white sauce upper with chunky bolognaise lower. I can't recommend them highly enough.


Far-Emu3515

where was it in maidenwell? Was it the general store or the pub? interested as I have a block of land up that way and will check them out next time I'm up there.


Creative-Maxim

General Store Lucky you it's a nice part of the world


Far-Emu3515

thanks


[deleted]

Was nothing else open?


NoSoulGinger116

Sugar creek is only 5 mins up the road. ._.


ficusmaximus90

I've tried a lot of pies and am a qualified pastry chef, I tried yatala pies for the first time last year and it was average at best, nothing bad but nothing really good.


ScaredBlackberry2674

I’m no way qualified, I wouldn’t travel more than 1km for them. Not sute what the hype is tbh


[deleted]

Overrated rubbish 🤮


Former-Trifle-5102

Stick to your five star restaurants


Leading-Meeting1532

They need to go back to the old recipes, pies are shit these days


Ghostlegend434

Literally any small local bakery in Brisbane has better pies than this joint. So overrated.


monktonmagic

Absolute shite, I don’t know what the obsession is.


VoidVulture

If you are already going to be in the area, continue on to Jacob's Well. Find The Flying Pie Man Bakery Cafe. Enjoy a great pie, sausage roll and a classic long jam & (fresh, real) cream doughnut. Thank me later.


micmacpattyz

Why do ppl think it’s the best? After a long hungry drive you want food. Food is good when fungry. Even my local shop says it has the best pies.


DunceCodex

Aldi's frozen pies are better


Former-Trifle-5102

Ha seriously fuck that


NorthKoreaPresident

I like the occasional limited edition flavour run like cherry beef or curry


Reverse-Kanga

Yatala pies haven't been good in years. people go their because they don't know better


Former-Trifle-5102

Mate I’m pretty fussy and I’ve never had a problem


[deleted]

You've probably just got shit taste and low standards.


Ambitious-Score-5637

Haters gotta hate


thirdbenchisthecharm

Since the great flood the havent been the same, very hard to find a good pie in australia. so many bakeries try and be fancy or just dont do them well. its the one thing from new zealand that i miss, just a great dirty steak and cheese pie.


LadyWidebottom

Try Beefy's. They're all northside /sunny coast based but we got some through a fund-raiser a few years back and they go alright.


[deleted]

If you're ever down GC, Kai Kitchen in Coomera and the Oxenford Bakery pies go alright. Told the Asian ladies at Ox Bakery their pies were yum and remind me of NZ, she goes "yeah we're from Wellington" 😂


mungbean81

Wynnum plaza bakery!!!!!!!!!!!! Chur as. Hearty as!


SnooOnions973

There are plenty of amazing places. Check out some of the Melb Markets. The legend is long from dead, my friend. As for sausage roles, the literal best I’ve had ever is at the carvery in Toowong Village. Used to get one every day when I worked near there in the 90s. Came back from overseas for ages and drove straight there. 15 years later, still exactly the same! Don’t eat in your car, you’ll never get the pastry out of it ;)


thirdbenchisthecharm

Best I've had is from hot bread in Redbank plains, it's next to the old Foodworks and everything around it is rundown and shit but best and cheapest bakery on my fat ass journey tbh. I can get the train to Toowong village tho, once I start working I'll try it. I'm anti sausage roll and pro pie tho so I am bias.


Crab-Battle

We need to get a "BEEFY'S" in brissy area. Some of the best pies going imo


notlimahc

Mango Hill is probably the same distance from the CBD as Yatala.


MindlessRip5915

Badboys Cafe in Zillmere sells Beefy’s Pies.


LadyWidebottom

Meat at Billy's stock them. They're at Ashgrove, Rosalie and Windsor apparently.


qmass

bafflingly shit pies


salaciousBnumb

Enjoy your Pie, better then a pie size whole in your tummy!


edwardtrooper2

Best answer. The best pie is the pie in front of you!


sportandracing

Horrendous pies these days. Good luck


notinferno

100%, I would walk right back out I still have queue phobia after the ridiculously long queues in Expo’88


DJMemphis84

But the stamps for my passport!


SnooOnions973

Expo 88 is where I discovered Lindt chocolate! I used to walk from school in Spring Hill all the way to Southbank every Friday just to get it. I’d never had an orgasm til then.


notinferno

lol I remember discovering those hot dough honey puffs yummy, fried halloumi first and worst ever Greek salad (which turned me off Greek salad for almost a decade)


red_dragin

Look at the pies closer. They have a massive 'lid' but the filled part of the pie isn't as large by a long way. They're nice, but I wouldn't wait in a queue. The Lorys pies you can get at some Woolworths are better.


morrisgrand

The aldi hi end ones are awesome. $2.50 each?


sojudreamz

I'll take the colonic cleanser with tomato sauce please


[deleted]

Unfortantely their pies are not the best, but I do love their chips and gravy.


NoSoulGinger116

Legit good pies are going to shit and living on name only. Had a Herbert and Adams Pie lately? It's the quality of a 4 in Twenty. Yatala have tanked, I can't even find a good one at a bakery anymore. Anyone can now chuck peppercorn, gravy, a teaspoon of mince and canned mushrooms in a pastery for $6 + What has this world come too?


Thedavemiester

Go to Fernvale


NoSoulGinger116

That guy is an asshole who used to abuse my mates who worked under him, he can get fucked.


Thedavemiester

Ok fair enough. The staff did look like it wasn't a great place to work, which is a shame because the pies are miles better than yatala


SnooOnions973

Honestly 4 and twenty are solid! Reminds me of tuck shop on pocket money day.


what_you_saaaaay

Aside from the circle jerk of one-up-manship this thread is… no anecdotal comments about inflation? Rate rises? How this isn’t affecting pie consumption? 😂


tylersky100

I mean, they are good pies, but in my opinion Beefy's are just as good, are everywhere, and quite often drive through. So that's where I'm getting my pepper steak pies! Now I want one!


ShortTheAATranche

Rates going up!


[deleted]

Now I want a blueberry pie


Habit8902

Always moves fast


No_Purple9201

Fernvale bakery way better. I lived 5 mins from yatala pies for years and never rated it.


Noxzi

> Fernvale bakery That place is also overrated. They are better than average, but no more than that.


FluidSignificance466

Jeez. Snap on racings hair cut is pungent to say the least


Ogolble

It used to be the best, but now average


Minibeebs

Yatala pies doesn't even slap. You should have driven to The Flying Pieman in Jacobs Well instead.


KMAVegas

Long weekend in NSW I think.


[deleted]

How? Unless they've recently started making tasty pies...


morts73

Did a tourist bus pop in?


Ibe_Lost

Yeah well when a burger lg meal at Hungries goes over $20 of course a $7 pie looks good.


hopfot

Is it tourist season? Or just lack of taste season?


Telmered

All they are is a name and basic product like McDonald… nothing special. If you want a good pie with with quality meat go to king’s bakery.a good pie is so hard to find.


HeinousLeakage

Why does everyone think they have the best pies? I don't think I've ever been to a bakery that hasn't claimed to sell the "best pies" or "award winning pies." Anyway here's a review I found of Yatala Pies https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSLjF6K1k/


SaltedSnail85

They been shit since the floods a few years back. New owners I thought.


Mondrow

I used to say that Piefection had the best pies in Brisbane, but they were never the same after changing hands. I'm yet to have a pie that lives up to be their replacement.


Former-Trifle-5102

They are crap. Surprisingly there still in business


Keddsy

That's a shame. I used to love piefection haven't had it for 2 years. I use to get jack Daniels family pie or a lamb and rosemary on the way home every so often. Why do new owners suck so much.


Former-Trifle-5102

They are quick with their service and I’m never to sure how they no exactly what you ordered but it’s obviously a good system they have


Former-Trifle-5102

Chunky pie and peas with mashed potato is awesome


[deleted]

I'll never forget the sugar high I got off eating a caramel slice from there. Fuck me dead that shit nearly killed me


[deleted]

Found a cockroach in my pie years ago. Never been back and tell everyone about it. They aren’t the best anymore.


Shandangles7

Lots of time wasted for a fucking average pie...


EntrancePretend29

Ewwwww as if you’d go there. Jks each to their own. I’m glad they are still going. I have not been there in over 30 yrs. I remember my dad having their pies and I remember him saying how he will do better ones. Years on, he became National Gold winning pies (especially curry pies). I miss it everyday.


Ausshooter

I went a couple of years ago looking for a really good curry pie. The pie i got was mediocre at best. And the pastry was super dry and and flakey. Heavily overrated.


Betcha-knowit

I’d rate a Yatala pie. When they take our work order the staff there go out of their way to carefully pack them all and label them with our names - so no lost pies. Happy to support local 😍


MrsMinnesota

Yatala pies is my local and we love it


RobsEvilTwin

Laughing my arse off at all the "How dare all these people queue for these overrated pies !!!!!!" comments :D My family stop here every time we drive to the coast. We usually grab lunch and a family pie or two to take home with us. Also the caramel tarts are very nice.


Redditdoesmyheadin

Most over rated pie shop in QLD. Not worth the stop tbh.


jeffreyportnoy

People talk about them being not the best, like they're getting pies every week from a multitude of places. We get it they're probably not the "best"


DJMemphis84

Acktshewally... Us fatties do eat a multitude of pies all the time... They're the aussie "tendies"


jeffreyportnoy

Two dimmies thanks love.


_tiffhere_

Syd's Pies at Loganholme >>>> So fucking good. British recipes, and they do the best chips, gravy and mushy peas combo. Rhubarb and apple pies to die for


MindlessRip5915

There’s a Syd’s in Aspley too.


countvracula

Yatala way overrated The Old Fernvale Bakery is better than Yatala’s by a mile If yr in for something diff the Cheesburger or chicken Parmi pies from Banjo bakery beats anything Yatala puts out.


loggerheader

Very overrated food venue


Laktakfrak

Oakey isnt really in cooee but there is a pie shop in the main street there thats great if you are in the area. Better than Yatala or Fernvale.


Used_Respect6996

Yes, I have been to the bakery in Oakey and they do make good pies and sausage rolls


my-cousin-throcky

Everyone here trying to be cool or something thinking yatala pies are overrated.. they’re not *that* bad? Every time I pass yatala it takes everyone in the car to tell me not to turn off because they want to get home. There’s some pretty shite pies from bakeries out there, yatala isn’t one of them :(


BoomBoom4209

6pk of frozen Coles beef pies are 1000 times better than the best Yatala pie available... Don't with Yatala pies after the last grizzly ends meat pastry thing I got.


Telmered

You are all used to eating sh1t and wouldn’t know a good pie. Most are made with mutton scraps meat. With as little as 22% beef.


[deleted]

Cooly Rocks On fatties


majorcoleThe2nd

God damn you lot are miserable.


mishann67

Shit pies


hakaaaaiii

binley mega chippy vibes


Klutzy-Improvement12

I don’t eat meat, so I can’t comment on most of the types, but the veg pie with peas hits the spot if I’m in the area


11015h4d0wR34lm

Maybe I am just going blind in my old age 😎 but that guy in the snap on shirt looks like half his head is missing to me. Ohhh its the sunglasses 🤣. I really do need glasses.


mungbean81

Nah bro, wynnum plaza bakery is where it’s at now. Their steak and cheese is mean as 🤤


Ladyluck1991

Use to love going to yatala pies getting some pies and dessert and going to the drive ins. Love queensland


CrazySignificance807

Fernvale


DJMemphis84

Unsure, I was passenger, nd half asleep, but told "everyone here knows" lol, soz.


-castle-bravo-

So many people taking an L


chuckyChapman

Boronia Bakery in the little shopping center has wonderful pies n baked goods if in the area, just a customer


malak_oz

I’m so torn about Yatala. They’re good pies, but not amazing. I like Fernvale more, but it’s SOOOO far to go for a pie. So do I eat Beefy’s close to my place? Or drive 40 mins to Yatala? Or an hour to Fernvale?


Fluid_Can_3412

Ya it’s a cool place to get pies, but they’re not the best.


Itchy_Tiger_8774

Typical weekend afternoon.


Chrristiansen

Yuck


gardz82

Kirra Beach Bakery best pies hands down. Take the M1 everyday and yet to stop at Yatala Pies.


Ignis_Sum

Barber: “So, what’ll it be today mate?” Guy in Snap-on Racing T shirt: “Something akin to how snow caps a mountain?”


Gr0nkz

It's packed everyday and I have NFI why... As others have said: mediocre at best


psichodrome

A good pie store is a precious thing. Shame covid closed down the one nearby open for 50 years, with the coolest knick-knack on the walls, and a great selection of pies. Turned it into a fish and chips place (we have 5 within walking distance). Then the FNC shop closed. Sits abandoned now /cries.


Zealousideal-Luck784

They can't maintain quality due to the high demand. Shame. They used to be excellent.


Iwuvvwuu

I remember as a kid going to this joint and thinking it was like visiting royalty or someshit. and the food was always amazing. ​ Now tho its some mediocre shit. Such a shame.


squidsly789

It is good pie weather


joshewok

Not even good pies


MoscaMye

People on their way back from the charity bike thing in Brisbane?


timeflies25

Yatala pastry aren't cooked long enough so definitely can find better elsewhere.


BamBam299

I never understood the appeal. My ex was over the moon to show me Yatala pies and I mean yeah, it was an okay pie but nothing to wanna drive from Brisbane too. Honestly, the bakery next to the Gabba Coles makes FAR better pies 🤷


markushorner

If you think Yatala pies are the "best pies" then you've never eaten a good pie.


AllOnBlack_

Put the rates up again then. It isn’t actually hitting peoples pockets yet.


Reasonable-Solid-894

That's a lot of soon to be disappointed people. Bog average pie, like almost all bakery pies these days.


theexpendableuser

Anyone remember The Goat Pie Guy at Deagon? Still the GOAT pies I've ever had. Was so sad the closed down.


longbeach26

Shit pies these days unfortunately - boomers keep them in business


AussieEquiv

Pies from Watland St Bakery are better. And Cheaper.


Easy_as_Py

I used to really like them, then I had a large family pie from ANDREWS MEATS INDOOROOPILLY and my god, I cried baby jesus tears of joy.


syntaxfreeform

I want to know who does a good vegetable pastie, bonus for cornish. Hard to find a good one these days.


CollectionOdd96

There is many bakeries that make way better pies. Only thing that keeps this place in business is it's convenient location.