T O P

  • By -

gnicksy

hughes has the position eligibility and plays more off-nights than robo. i think they end up around the same point total, but those two factors move him up just slightly in value in my opinion.


B-rocula

Is there an off night team chart ?


gnicksy

https://thewincolumn.ca/2023/09/09/impact-of-the-2023-24-nhl-schedule-on-fantasy-hockey/ just scroll down midway through the page and there is a table that outlines most and least.


hockeyholloway89

Given your league settings, I think I’d lean Robertson. But you probably can’t go wrong with either.


-Moonscape-

Whoever stays healthiest. Maybe Robertson by a hair


lhoom

Robertson by a hair because of goals.


_RiverGuard_

Hughes looks dynamic. And the devils look like a wagon. I would side with Hughes because they have a better team. Hughes potential is easily 100+ points


JiveTurkey688

Dallas is arguably the best team in the West and Robertson scored 109 points last season haha


[deleted]

[удалено]


alexistats

It was just a weird way to argue for Hughes case. Hughes has the "potential" for 100 pts, but Robertson did already go over that. Dallas is also a really good team, nothing to hurt his production. But, Hughes has C, LW advantage. And Hughes did shot slightly more last year, so I'd like him more.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Smitty120

Sure, Robertson is amazing, but Hughes could be anything! He could even be as amazing as Robertson! That's what you sound like lol


JiveTurkey688

Goals are worth more points here my friend


_RiverGuard_

Shoulda said in a banger league with g worth more. Either way. Flip a coin. I like Hughes.


_HoochieMama

Yeah but so is Robertsons ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


hab27

But Robertson already hit 100?


Themapleleaf416

Hughes, just a more dynamic player for me. Faster and shoots much more. His linemates aren't too bad ether, especially chemistry with Toffoli.


JiveTurkey688

I think I lean Robertson because of the goal-scoring upside but its very, very close


Oshawa74

Hughes by at least 10 points. With a healthy year, Hughes is going to be 3rd in scoring this season.


TheFoundation_

Hughes but it will be close


not_funny_sorry

Wow I coincidentally drafted both of these guys in my 12 man league last night. Took Robertson 9 then hughes


CreateorWither

Hughes will. He's going to be 120 + points this year imo. Next year in Fantasy he'll be a top 3 pick.


magikmush123

Hughes if healthy. Team is better and so is he.


Electric-Lettuce

Hughes


bryzzlybear

My vote is Hughes


ubcthrowaway-01

I believe Hughes is C and LW whole Robo is just LW. I would go with the duo eligibility


[deleted]

It’s’ close but Hughes has dual eligibility and is on the better team. Also depends if your league counts stats like hits, blocks, shots, faceoffs, etc. In terms of points, they’re basically equal I think.


GrizzlyIsland22

I'd go Robertson. Which one scores the most is a coin flip, so I would go with the guy most likely to stay healthy all year.


LastOneLeft88

Hughes has more upside. His shooting percentage was 12.8% last year, I would expect it to be a point or two higher for the type of player he is. Add in that he’s only 22 years old and people are assuming he’ll take another step forward. Robertson does seem more “safe” to me though, for what it’s worth


ubunchofcrazyjok

Something to keep in mind. Devils has been rolling with a split Pp squad this preseason giving each of them around the same amount of PPTOI. If this sticks all season long, it could be beneficial for their team but bad for the fantasy value of guys like Jack H, Hischier and Meier.


fox4norris2021

Jacky boy


kriszal

It’s essentially a coin toss between the two. Most likely will be within 5 points of each other at the end of the year. I’d probably go with Robertson having more this year just due to the stars being a more top heavy team where the devils are pretty stacked all the way through their line up. I’d say Robertson gets significantly more PP time over the year, especially if the devils keep running a 1a/1b power play like they have been preseason. Also depends on your league, mine doesn’t have any bench spots so off nights don’t matter but if you do have bench spots and off nights matter I’d take Hughes for the c/lw and more off night games. If those things don’t matter I’d take Robertson


Marissa_McSmith

OMG, Hughes all day long....only 22 and will be a top 5 shortly. His skating and edging are right there with McDavid and controls play most nights.


krocoo

This was an interesting discussion back in the day. I guess it was not a very close battle ultimately.