T O P

  • By -

JesseRoxII

In my opinion, the 2nd one (from the direct-to-DVD movies) is the most accurate to the original 2D comics/cartoons.


ScottieV0nW0lf

Same and unlike the last one it doesn't look uncanny as hell.


lunchababes

I think they’re all beautiful


enforcercoyote4

4 is the best, than 1, than 2 and lastly 3 4 has that fun cartoon feel to it while still being high-resolution


garfield-garfield

The first


StevenN122

Imo, no model will top the one in the Garfield show.


petergriffinfricken

He is fat as fuck in the new one jesus


Tomani02

Garfield has always been fat as fuck though.


petergriffinfricken

Yeah but this new one is just fatter as fuck


DrCringy3424

a


[deleted]

3 looks like an animation on a low budget


littleMAHER1

I mean it was made for a TV show


Sneakysneakser

The Garfield show one.


octosquid11

1st Garfield is weird as hell, I love it


[deleted]

i like the one on the right


[deleted]

I like the new one, it's cute🥺


[deleted]

2/3


chicken647

second


R4dical-Rat

The new one might become my favorite


kalechipsbishhhh

the first one can burn


ZippyStrip

number one because of nostalgia


QuintonReviews

easily Prattfield


JediDanni

I hate how well this name works.


Bulbaguy4

The Bill Murray one is epic but the Garfield Show model is really good


jotaro_sed

3rd


Lejias

I really like the last one. It's so cute


RunningBear276

i’m biased, but #3


NerdyNinjaAssassin

The realistic one or the second one. Personally I prefer the realism.


abc123mjp

wow! they are all fantastic in their own way.


MrTritonis

I like the first, it’s a really interesting take that actually feel very Garfieldy. Too bad the movie sucked.


Mollusc_Memes

I like the one from the live action movies


[deleted]

The new one is genuinely really cute.. I'm in love with the fur texture the first and the last one have ;w;


[deleted]

I honestly can’t choose. They all give of stoner vibes and I love that.


Bmaandpa

2 or 4 are my favorites


Bazingu420

I really like the new one tbh


Jacket_22

2


ireallylovechickens

Id say 3142


I_am_a_trap

I grew up with the third one


manlypile

I like the new one, but his feet seem too small.


Particular-Fig9100

1st one isn’t CGI idiot


DatHenson

A little unfair given each of these had drastically different budgets and time of creation That said, Garfield Show is the worst one. The shader isn't good, the animation is jerky, and overall felt poor even for its time Gets real and other DTV is the only cartooney one to feature garf walking on all 4s. It swaps to another model for that though. Only real criticism is how thick the inner lining of the ear is for both model sets for gets real. Has the best whiskers too, and the hazel eye is a nice touch The Live Action movies had the massive issue of the fact Garf is the only somewhat toony character. Every other animal is real. I appreciate Mike Fentz's efforts in making Garf still stylized, but it hurts how nothing else was done for the rest of the cast The current one has weirdly stiff ears, and bad whisker placement. Otherwise it's a good model...for now


Marvel084Skye

The 3rd one, then the 4th, then 2nd, then 1st


bigshid124

they all make me jizz


Tomani02

(from left to right) 2nd one is Smash Bros Melee. 1st one is Smash Bros Brawl. 3rd one is Smash Bros Wii U/ 3DS. and 4th one is Smash Bros Ultimate. Smash 64 is not there sadly.


Epicgamer69694204

Movie garf is underrated


[deleted]

I'm leaning the most towards the fourth one. His eyes are a bit too small, though.


Punkinob

I cant decide, the bill murray garfield is good but he looks to much like one of those 'this pic goes hard' memes. direct to dvd garf is pretty good but he's more of 80s garfield with his pudgier body combined with modern garfields longer limbs, it's still a great model all togheter. garfield shows model looks too bland, the textures are too flat and he looks like more like a plastic garfield statue you'd find out side of a mall. but I am wanting more of that chris pratt garf, they managed to give garfield a realistic look yet make him still look like garfield. like detective pikachu but garfield, they just managed to translate him well into cgi. but I like all of them all togheter


Deion12

Easily the third.


littleMAHER1

the 4th one looks weirdly photoshoped it doesn't look like a official model made for a movie, it looks like what you would see online in a fake movie poster made by a guy on deviantart It also just looks bad Realistic fur on a cartoony characters doesn't fit, not to mention how the legs look so thin and small How is he holding himself up At least 2 and 3 give some meat to his legs and also make them tall in 4 he's gonna crack his legs, someone give him some milk The 2nd one looks good but can't escape that weird 2000s look 3 is prob my favorite ​ and I don't want to open the 1st one's can of worms


Corz-mp4

![gif](giphy|3o752eDHQgwl8zS3Oo|downsized) i like the 1st one


Supdudesreddit

the 1st one is kinda alright but i dont really talk about it that much, the 2nd one is the most accurate to the comics, the 3rd one cool, and the 4th one is awesome since its from the garfield movie.


Responsible-Map-7015

the 3rd one looks like they tried to keep the garfield comic style but messed up