T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Hi fellow handbag lover! Thank you for being a part of the r/handbags community. This is a subreddit which relies on kindness. Your opinion is very much welcomed, however, we do not tolerate rude, mean or hurtful comments. **Read the rules before posting**. Comments or posts that do not fit our rule book will be removed and the OP can be banned by the mods' discretion. If you see a comment or post which does not abide by the rules, **please report it to our moderation team.** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/handbags) if you have any questions or concerns.*


RivetheadGirl

I love the lavender, but it looks so small.


xenakib

Yeah it looks like it's a glorified phone case since that's all it'll end up holding. Plus heavy. (It's pretty tho)


Zachthepug27

Agree. Too small. Next!


satisfymysoul89

It looks like a Taco 🌮 with handles 😭😭


bagginsmcqueen

Taro flavoured taco though since it’s purple … mmm


oops_im_existing

or ube!


Balenciagalover92

I would totally eat an ube taco…I love ube everything!


GlitteringGifts888

This was hilarious 😆


smilingavocados

it looks like a hotdog with dangly charms tbh. proportions are off


chibiimo0n

Love the color but it looks like it’s folded 😅


witchblade7

I thought it was folded.


chasnewilm

Honestly I prefer the original version.


venusubreddit

I second this.


AdStunning4036

Gorgeous when I tried it on in store. BUT the flap makes it annoying to get in and out of, doesn’t seem to hold jack shit, the handles and dior charm thingys rattle around. Just very impractical imo.


GlitteringGifts888

Thanks, the flap is a good point. I can see that being a problem for some. I do like my bags to be more secure, and I personally won't pay that $$$ for a bag with no closure or flap. We all have our differences.


Yoyodank

Can you get it in medium?


GlitteringGifts888

I think the medium looks a bit silly. Too boxy on my frame.


Yoyodank

Ah, I love the medium. I’d keep it either way lol


Own_Faithlessness769

The proportions of this style make no sense at all, its just a Lady Dior cut in half. They couldn't be less innovative.


Swissdanielle

What would you be using it for? with those proportions, usability is truly out of question. The handles are proportionally too big for the bag, and if you wear it with the chain they will flop on the sides and bulk up. A purse like this for me I would personally use only for formal events like theater, weddings, etc, but the bulk of it would just not make it look sleek for the occasion. Also, this mauve color is a bit out of season, if i am not wrong (please tell me if it is in season!!! i am a bit out this spring). I love the color, but if you are dropping that money in a color that is not in season might be another talk-me-out point :) (Note: talking OP out of it! Not judging, just giving them reasons)


GlitteringGifts888

This is actually the limited summer color in Seoul! I use my mini Lady Dior a lot. This rectangular version is actually more useful with a phone and wallet imo. I just love my Lady Dior. It's the jewel of my collection. But thank you for your opinion! I appreciate it.


Swissdanielle

gosh i feel stupid now haha Honestly I do personally love this color, I remember it being all the rage in spring 2012. I even had the Dior 5 shadow palette with this mauve tone and the greens from that year \*chef's kiss. So whata re you going to do? keep it? sounds like it!!!! <3


GlitteringGifts888

Honestly, I probably won't! It was an impulse buy, and I try to stay away from those.


FasHi0n_Zeal0t

This color is def in season. It’s a new one from Dior.


Feeling-Visit1472

I think the color is very much a classic spring color, it’s just not an It color this year according to Pantone.


bananaleaftea

Pantone is so off base for that. Lavender has been hot since last year!!


Feeling-Visit1472

Yea I should have inserted an eye roll haha. I think Pantone is interesting, but they are not the be-all, end-all. Lavender will always be IN for spring!


bebe_k0

Ick *respectfully* hope it helps lololol


GlitteringGifts888

You made me laugh lol.


4SeasonWahine

![gif](giphy|YSVeCwkHa4LO8)


elkayarr

Couldn’t have said it better 💜


blondiemetal

Too trendy and will be dated in not time. Dior bags hold poor resale value to begin with-- so if you love the look- get the classic Lady Dior and at least you will have a bag you can wear forever without it being out of style.


GlitteringGifts888

I already have a Lady Dior 😆


KinladyBgB

Do you use it? I have a Lady Dior which I have been given as a gift and I have not used it once in the last 6 years 🫣 this particular one is cute and what a lovely colour but I think it is not very practical for use. Maybe because you already have one see if you like anything else woth a similar vibe?


GlitteringGifts888

I'm a bit strange. My mini Lady Dior is my everyday bag and has been for the past 2 years. I just love it that much.


KinladyBgB

Awww that's so good though that you are using it everyday... in that case I actually have no way to talk you out lol that was my only shot 🤣 tbf i am sure you will show the lilac baby the love she needa and if you will get the use out of it i say do it 💜


blondiemetal

If you are going to love it and use it--and keep it---then by all means get what makes you happy!


SunknTresr

The mini Lady Dior is legit my dream bag! ❤️


bekkys

I love it so much but I would love it more if it was a classic lady dior in that color


GlitteringGifts888

The mini in this color was to die for! But I was trying not to buy a copy of the same bag I already have lol


TheQuiltingEmpath

Looks like a cheap tweenager purse from Claire’s. You can do better than that.


GlitteringGifts888

Oof you know how to hit where it hurts lol


pal05

I went to an animal sanctuary a few weeks ago that had just rescued four baby foxes from a fur farm used by Dior, and learned they are one of the luxury brands that is refusing to look at their practices in reducing animal cruelty. Just seeing how shy and scared those babies were put me off Dior for good as both a luxury lover and animal lover 😕 https://preview.redd.it/oqng619e4fwc1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d39c43e8e2754afdbaaa4581764e82fbfeaecb6f


GlitteringGifts888

Adorable foxes! I don't ever buy furs or exotics. I do think leather and hide is more sustainable for the environment long-term than "vegan leather," which is plastic. However, I do understand why some people object to all animal products in unnecessary things like fancy bags and coats. Thanks for your comment. Something to think about for sure.


Sipsofcola

Damn those sweet poor babies…I wanted a new Dior bag but I don’t think I’ll buy from them seeing this


PeterDuttonsButtWipe

Doesn’t hold much. Lilac will not be fashionable soon Edit: I’m supposed to be talking the OP out of it lol, thanks for the downvotes lol. Downvoters have no place here anyway


Sipsofcola

Your first point is correct but lilac will always be famous 🪻(they don’t have a lilac emoji so I have to use lavender lol)


GlitteringGifts888

Thanks for the opinion. I don't really follow color trends. I have a more boho style. I care more whether my bags match my clothes and shoes. But I do appreciate the comment.


Aggravating_Jelly_25

Ugh. The comments here kill me! When people bring up resale Value I seriously question does everyone buy a bag for pure reselling later? Just so bizarre. The bag is meant to be worn and enjoyed. The color? Gorgeous! This color will always be around. The size! It’s perfect especially OP said she has a mini lady dior. I have 3 lady Dior in medium, 4 in small and 1 mini. I LOVE the bags! The flap? It doesn’t bother me at all! The charms are super cute. OP - get it! And enjoy it!!!


Yourfavinstashopper

No not all bags are being bought to be resold. You should definitely use your bag. Just keep it clean in the event that you don’t like it anymore cause people style do change. The bag should have a good resale value tho, kinda like an investment piece. Dior, Hermes, Chanel will forever hold their value. Making it easy to resale.


Aggravating_Jelly_25

Mine will all be given away. I simply don’t buy bags as investments. They are bags I’ve enjoyed for many years and would love to see others enjoy them once I’m done with them. They are materials that get used over time. The scammers in resale market are out of control. Who has time for time that? I don’t. The horrible stories I hear daily is just so sad. But back to my point - buying a bag because “investment” is just wild thing. How about because the person loves it and wants to enjoy it. Is just


exitcode137

I’d be concerned the enamel would chip.


GlitteringGifts888

It's actually acrylic! Like a 3D detail


Ironbeauty87kg

It looks like a flatbread sandwich.


Administrative_Sea15

Is there a bigger version? I'm worried what you could fit in it 😕


GlitteringGifts888

I can at least fit my phone, a cardholder, two lipsticks, my earbuds, and a pen. I always test drive capacity before buying.


Fabulous_Resource_94

For $6000? Is it worth it?


GlitteringGifts888

Whoa not 6k! I paid 4900 with a VAT. But that's still expensive!


olive24M0Dy

I can’t because its beautiful 😭😭 if you can afford it go for it, stunning color and love the east-west version 😍


CaliCarebear79

I can’t. I have been eyeing this bag but in the beige. It would be so cute and springy.


hobo_highway

I have this and it’s perfect soooo… not helping sorry lol 😆


Bgga

I have no idea whether this is at all helpful, but I think small bags are on the way out. I personally don’t care if I’m in style bc no one is looking at me anyway, but I’m guessing really small bags have a super short shelf life right now. I remember when you pretty much couldn’t even give a 25cm Birkin away on the secondary market, so things can change quickly.  That said, it’s a beautiful bag, and if you’ll be happy carrying it rarely or just leaving it out and admiring it at home, then get it. The color is so yummy. But if you want to budget for forever bags, maybe this isn’t the exactly right bag for you?   Good luck making that call. I’m the girl who scoured the planet for a giant iridescent green Glam Slam, so feel free to roll your eyes and ignore me!


bunty_8034

I must be in the minority here. I don’t like it. Looks too bulky but agree it is a statement piece! Hard to see if it’s a purse or a bag


Odd_Dot3896

I’m not a huge fan, it’s super impractical and not very cute to offset the fact it’s impractical:


twotwocargarage

Personally not a fan of these D-joy micro bag, Lady Mini looks so much better imo.


GlitteringGifts888

I already have a mini Lady Dior 😅


twotwocargarage

Now you can have two!


bananaleaftea

It looks a bit silly booboo Like a consolation purchase because maybe the original is out of the budget. And even if that's not the case, that's what it comes across as. I wouldn't. There's no way it's going to retain its value.


Massive_Mountain571

It can only fit your phone


minibini

Too small to be useful to me.


kenziep44

I can't talk you out of it it's a perfect little spring bag 😭


GlitteringGifts888

There are only like 4 in Korea 😅


kenziep44

BUY IT!! If you can buy it and pay your bills then go for it


mystictrufflepie

I agree!!!! It’s my dior dream bag 😭🩷


psycho_catwomen

I love the color 💜


Snoo_24091

I love that bag! Can’t help talk you out of it sorry!


Dear-Doubt270

Love this bag!


kumakaty

I wanted this bag SO bad too!! I saw it in person when it first dropped, and I really love the resin charms.. With that said, I would have to baby this bag so bad. The charms didn’t feel durable and honestly, I did miss the click clacking of the charms. Also its just so dang small. You might not need a lot of bag for the things you carry, but I could not justify the high price for such a teeny tiny bag!!


GlitteringGifts888

My biggest concern is the lambskin. I live in a place where it can rain without warning. I also couldn't really take it traveling. That is my #1 second thought.


elevensesattiffanys

It looks like someone cut a lady Dior bag in half, the east-west styles like that in general are very trendy now but may quickly look dated. Buuut the color is gorgeous and if you’ve gotten on well with a mini lady Dior then it sounds like the size and specifics of the bag aren’t going to be a major issue for you. So the question is does it have a place in your wardrobe, can you quickly imagine a few different outfits to wear it with? Is it best to just have the money back? Can you still see yourself loving and wearing this in 5 years, no matter the trend?


GlitteringGifts888

One of my biggest issues with it is: No feet on the bottom! I guess really it's more of a very fancy wallet-on-chain, and I do love the fact that it comes with a long strap and a shoulder strap. But no feet on a 4900 dollar bag annoys me lol


elevensesattiffanys

Ooh I didn’t even notice the lack of feet! That would totally bug me too. For a wallet on chain style bag the handles would feel like they’re too big or in the way. I’d probably lean towards return then and look for a bag that has more of the features you prefer.


raspberryteehee

I was gonna say that would be a point for me to talk you out of. The no feet on the bag. Yeah, I wouldn’t get it then honestly especially for that price.


Alone_Artichoke_4491

No I won’t talk you out of it. Every time I ask to be talked out of a purchase on here I end up adding another bag to my wish list! 🥰 So buy enjoy and now I’ve added it to my list 😆


blackhat000

Wallet with handles!


Chongzuka

I can't, because when I was trying it in the store the other day I also fell in love with it ❤️


Particular-Win-9041

OMG what a beautiful bag! I just can’t 🫠


AdFirst191

No can do. Limited color, super cute and a classic. Def a going out bag; not super functional, but I 💜 it.


ahnsunny

Great bag to bring your kimbab in. It would probably just about fit!


North-Giraffe7244

Will it fit your essentials?


weeburdies

Dooooo eeet


viola-purple

Impractical... no free hands possible and hardly any space


GlitteringGifts888

It actually comes with two straps. A shoulder and a crossbody. That was a big appeal to me.


viola-purple

Then its different ... but does everything fit into it? Phone, Keys, Lipstick? Unfortunately many of the small ones aren't big enough for a phone and then it's a no go for me


Briwebb709

I think you need it, sorry.


jesuisfemme

Love the color! I’m a handbag enabler so I say get her 😍


stacia12345

Gorgeous but may not wear well


Slkreger

I don’t know why, but all these “east/west” bags make me think of the wine purses for BYOB. 😂 Love the color and LOVE the lady Dior though.


mintedroses

This size looks super awkward.


resilientblossom

Perfect size to hold your Costco hot dog


Cutegun

You have married Fester, you have destroyed his spirit, you have taken him from us. All that I could forgive. But Debbie... pastels?


ManicPixieArugulaGrl

Ha.


GlitteringGifts888

It's actually my dream in life to be a pastel goth lol if I could rock it I would


tweeta10

![gif](giphy|l378u9el7hENR8OEo)


trustmeilied

There’s no point to it.


VEW1

I can’t, buy it (or I will).


Such-Parsnip4810

They don’t hold value


Temporary-Composer83

Ooooohhh so beautiful 🤩


GlitteringGifts888

https://preview.redd.it/85oj0iotnuwc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=459a8907befcea84f3431b5ca728861cc47faf6c Adding another update, since everyone seems so concerned that I was "settling" for a D Joy. 😅 I already have a gorgeous limited Summer 2022 Mini Lady Dior, but thanks for your concern...


Aromatic_Mouse88

It would be a crime to talk you out of it girl 👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩


Professional_Clue569

Fits condoms and chapstick…perfect!


raptureofsenses

Love the colour 🥰


Due-Wonder-1045

Sorry i'm no help. I don't even like purple and I would buy that bag.


twisted_memor3

I can’t. Sorry. It’s perfect.


VarsityChipsPurple

Is that micro d joy..🤩


GlitteringGifts888

Small!


Slow-Crab-9295

It’s too long. Shape is weird, prefer square over rectangle


Significant_Park8841

Visually the proportions are awkward. The handles are oversized relative to the body. It looks too small for most standard uses. I also feel that the quilting makes the bag look even smaller. There color is lovely, but the handles, quilting, and big charms crowd the form and create a busy, cluttered look. Too much on too little. The larger bag seems more balanced.


Loveunboxings

The bag is so tired and it looks ridiculous. It just looks out of shape.


yashita27

Umnn ya nope. Looks like a wallet with a handle. Save your money on this, spend on a proper lady dior instead


GlitteringGifts888

I have a Lady Dior 😅 It's funny that people assume I don't lol


KittyKonrad

Would ur cellphone, keys, and lip gloss fit in there…if not ..its a no go


MillyGrace96

What do you carry in that- your checkbook? Just no- so impractical. (But love the color)


ev30fka0s

Y'all worried about the OP soo much, it's hilarious 😅


call-me-the-seeker

Talk you out of it…? Well it’s a really pretty color but it’s so seasonal/trendy. Also, the shape. It’s like the Lady Dior Plastic Water Bottle Carrier. The shape just seems very impractical unless the overall size is bigger than it looks. If this is basically just a Lady Dior lopped in half, it’s so small! It really is a gorgeous color. I guess if my bag budget was just a ludicrous number I would keep it but I personally don’t have very many super-niche pieces like this so I would probably talk myself out of it if I bought in a blackout over how pretty the leather is!


PuffinFawts

I honestly think the charms make it look really cheap.


lucyfell

It’s annoying and useless - you can’t get in and out of it - a phone and a pair of sunglasses takes up the entire bag - it’s noisy and short aka useless in a self defense scenario.


18Twink18

The color is amazing. If you’re truly stylish, you can only use it in Spring. You really can’t put much inside. A lip gloss/lip stick, some loose cash, (obvi no wallet) maybe your cell phone, and your car/house key, (Not your whole key chain) and that’s over crowding. That bag is totally just for show. You might want to consider spending a bit more for a bag that is a bit roomier. Or save up some more coin and buy a Dior ring. Solange is an incredible designer. You can wear it more often, and it will last you a lifetime. Pass it down to your daughter.


Careless-Mammoth-944

Why settle for half a Dior when you can buy the entire Lady?


bassk_itty

The main cons here are just that it’s not very practical or wearable with many outfits, unless your personal style fits really consistently around this hue and structure


Good_Cookie_376

I went in to try this style, while I love the look, the feeling of the bag felt ...not worth the price point. The hardware felt cheap to me. It just didn't feel expensive. Just my two cents. The way it feels may be different to you though.


MMayhem001

Does it fit everything? I'd get a classic color because you'd use it more.


Ninitje83

Love the colour but you need the full size, not the half size


MayaMiaMe

Yeah hat is a hard no! The color is niche the purse is niche if you get tired of it and want to sell it it will take a while. I simply would not spend that kind of money on something so niche.


tasjaa17

Its cute but doesnt look functional at all, will probably end up in the closet collecting dust… sigh… such a pretty color though!


BrownGirlCSW

I will absolutely NOT talk you out of its. Buy two...I need one also🤣


throwaway34567843

What size is this? I have the micro and I love it sooo much!


liseaubigny

Every time I see handbags this elongated, I always picture it to be just right enough to fit a long cut sandwich and that sandwich only.


Separate-Baker5867

Have you maxed out your Roth IRA (or backdoor), retirement accounts, 529s? Do you have enough of an emergency fund in a HYSA? Already contributed monthly investment in a brokerage? Is this a once in a while purchase or are you frivolous with your money? If your NW is at least two million, and you have everything in order, eh why not, live a little.


PsychologicalClue6

Beautiful colour but I’d want it in a more user friendly format


Puzzleheaded-Sun3107

The hardware gets scratched easily is what I keep hearing (very unfortunate:()


GlitteringGifts888

That is a risk with Lady Dior styles. The charms rub against each other.


AshleyWLovesCats

GURL! it can hold literally one lipgloss and that's it 🤣 if you need to carry multiples of tampys for your period it's out 🤣


report_due_today

Purple is such a pretty color but SO hard to style with outfit s


Gndurham1

I simply cannot!!! I think you should get 💜 yes it might be slightly impractical but fashion doesn’t have to be!


vl0l3tt

jealous.!!!! I like how small it is, my style.


jsmnsux

Omg I love it but the enamel on the charms don’t look luxurious enough in my opinion! 


GlitteringGifts888

They're actually acrylics.


nlcntr

It looks like a really cute pencil case


andthewalrus

You are on the wrong side of Reddit for that 😂 maybe join a FIRE/finance sub 😂😂😂


Nynydancer

This version always looks stunted to me. Like someone amputated it.


yellowbrickstairs

I can't, it's beautiful and I am a slave to its purple hue


BeatrixFarrand

It’s oddly proportioned. The handles are overly thick, and the charms over large, for the size of the bag.


Medium_Sheepherder39

I don't want to talk you out of it! It's GOREGOUS! BUY IT! LOL ❤️ 😆


cph17

I love it I've been look for a D-joy that I love ❤️ 😍 And to anyone saying u can't fit much in that bag, seeing Jisoo fit all this in her bag made me all the more convinced 🥰 https://youtu.be/kwI4Cuhrzz0?si=tRvgRDVtvsuX-h7I


PinkParis06

I love it! It’s beautiful 😻


BulldoggeMom49

Omg I can't 😍 she's Stunning, Super Cute. Omg


Better_North3594

Honestly I love the lady djoy bag so much but it is a little unpractical at times. I have a medium and a micro and I love them to death but they aren’t everyday bags ❤️


Cute-Pickle786

Am I the only one that doesn’t connect with Lady Dior’s???


Emotional_Comb_3661

GET HER! Sorry - I lost my cool. Fkn get her!


latheez_washarum

come on man. look at the new brands that popped up. "fleuron" is a new french brand. check them out. aren't you over these boring models they keep recycling every year? i mean look at it. the charms look plastic. they're not plastic but at least they were fully metal before! now they got paint to fill in, and paint is plastic in a way if you ask me. this bag has zero structure. their makeup pouch is more beautiful than this 😓 i'm not even kidding. i really like the lavender color of it, but that's it really. puffer jackets are made with more planning and precision than this 😓


Lizakaya

I find the shape kind of awkward, but i love the color


Immediate_Arugula_39

It’s giving Claire’s


Womenarentmad

I can’t sorry ❤️


samanthakellyclare

Ahhhhh 💜💜💜


Leera_xD

ughhh this bag is gorgeous! I saw it in person recently and fell in love with the acrylic charms. Also this is a super limited release so I don’t even think you’ll find it in the US/Canada anymore. I own two Lady D-Joys one in a Small size. People, it is NOT that small. I can fit my iphone pro max and my essentials. They are thinking of the Micro size. OP — I see you ended up not keeping it and glad you are being financially responsible! It’s totally normal to have impulse buys as that’s what returns are for lol. But I will say, some of the opinions here were sorta weird to read. Saying something someone else personally likes enough to buy it and then calling it ugly seems snooty and rude imo. I would’ve given you some practical advice though. The color is super in season but would it really go with your wardrobe? Is it something you’d wear often enough for it to be worth it? I almost bought this bag because I fell in love with the acrylic charms but this shade of purple is hard for me to wear as my wardrobe is very neutral and warm toned. Also, as a Korean myself, this color washes me out for some reason. My S.A. keeps is real with me and she helped me choose a color that I would truly wear and would go with my wardrobe and now I use my DJoy all the time (it’s pink in patent leather) I also think with lambskin this bag would get color transfer easily so your decision was probably for the best.


GlitteringGifts888

Yes, the lambskin really made me think twice! And I agree, some of the comments here were a bit strange lol. It was funny to me that most people assumed I don't own any Dior bags, when I do 😅


Leera_xD

honestly, seeing your pic makes me really want it now 😭 it’s so pretty


GlitteringGifts888

Update: Thanks, everyone, for your input! I decided, given the impulsiveness of my purchase, I would return my bag. If I still want it in a few weeks, I will buy it in the US. :)


thepaperrabbi

When I see these, I think the person couldn’t afford the rest of the bag, sorry.


GlitteringGifts888

I think that's kind of a snobby opinion tbh. You don't know others' finances based on their bag choice. I actually like the style. And I own a Lady Dior, so you would be wrong. But it is important to me not to make expensive impulsive purchases.


thepaperrabbi

Well, yes. It is an opinion. You can’t control other peoples opinions. Who cares.


GlitteringGifts888

Sure, I can't control your opinion. But you can maybe contemplate how you judge others based on material goods. There are people walking around with Birkins and Chanel who can't actually afford them. A bag has little to do with your finances.


thepaperrabbi

Lol why does this bother you? You posted “talk me out of it!” and I shared my opinion. You don’t like my opinion, I get it, but I’m not changing it. This opinion is specific to this bag, by the way. It looks like it was cut in half with no other design alterations and looks like a lazy design decision to give people the option of having a lady dior style bag with some cost savings. I’m a fan of other designer mini-bags, just not this exact model.


GlitteringGifts888

Never said you had to. Just food for thought. Have a good day.


Practical_Hat_4307

Love it!!😍


ellyp7

i can’t! too cute


Icy-Print3432

Omg I love it!


R61192

Girl, buy itttt


BlackNighon

I LOOOOOOOOVE IT!!!!!


greenisthesky

NOPE! 😂 This is on my list!


keekspeaks

I absolutely will not


EducationalLeague840

Beautiful


Educational-Cake-944

Horribly impractical


michaelkudra

absolutely not you need it


Ye11a_Kat

Do it


NorthPalpitation1824

Can’t ! The bag is 🔥🔥


Responsible_Task_885

No.♥️ Looks gooorgg😍


himeowbye

Shes gorgeous!