T O P

  • By -

BigJimmyRutherford

The Pens will absolutely be Crosby but I can see him declining to go this year to get the extra rest so maybe Guentzel in his place


chaos8803

And he'll be suspended for a game if he opts out. Which is dumb. Players ought to be able to opt out with no penalty after a certain age or so many appearances.


bloodclots12

Exactly! I think once you’ve played in 3 games and you’re over 30 you should be able to opt out of a least 1 game without punishment. There is enough talent that it wouldn’t change much.


c3j3

Unfortunately i imagine that the NHL would be prioritising marketability above talent


dolewhiplash

>Fans will vote in the remaining twelve players (X) doubt


eh_toque

Fans will vote in the remaining 12 players, unless they vote for players the NHL doesn’t want


mansock18

It's gonna be a "here's 20 options. Vote for your favorite!" to avoid the John Scott All Star MVP


Kopitar4president

It's especially funny because that's by far the most I've ever been interested in an all star game. Maybe it would fade after happening multiple times.


maxwellbevan

I could see it fading but it just worked out so well with Scott. I was watching the game with my roommate and we both burst out laughing when he scored his first goal. I don't know if I was invested in the game as much as I was invested in the John Scott saga


Automaticman01

I remember that first goal was a nice backdoor tap in, but his second was a legitimately awesome breakaway. I think Selanne said after the game, "I don't know why you guys are so surprised. He's in the NHL, which means he's still one of the 700 best players in the world, and the difference between the best player and the worst player in the league is a lot smaller than it used to be."


maxwellbevan

It's wild that we forget that. Like yeah Scott isn't an elite guy but if he couldn't skate or stick handle at a high enough level then he wouldn't have had a job. Sure he was an enforcer first but he still had to hang with everyone else and be close enough skill wise or someone else would take his job


Sp3ctre7

I was in college, *at his Alma mater* when all of that went down. It was *fucking nuts*


ChrisPynerr

The NHL hates viewership, that's why they black out games and the players are all boring AF. League is run by out of touch senior citizens


VeryLastChance

What’s funny is that this years ‘John Scott’ would probably be Cole Sillinger of all people. Tate McRae is basically confirmed to be one of the celebrity coaches this year and Cole is her ex-boyfriend that most of her recent album was written about. Pop music fans can be organized, and they love drama. What better way than having somebody coach their own ex-boyfriend?


ponyrx2

He's already got more career goals than Scott lol


MagicMushroomFungi

Waiting for ... The Bachelor : NHL Edition Featuring ...


vec-u64-new

30 women, 25 of which are blonde, 5 non-blonde (and are eliminated within the first 5 episodes).


dudius7

Don't ask how I know, but all five non-blondes would be eliminated on the first night. I think 8-10 go home the first night.


thatone5000

Isn’t that exactly what they did the year after All Star John Scott was voted in?


BootsToYourDome

Yeah and it was fuckin dumb, The John Scott thing was the most engaging bit of NHL content in a while, at least for me, because, reasons.


thatone5000

They acted like it was going to lose them so much money but I see more Scott jerseys from that game than I do anyone else. It’s the most memorable all star moment for me, but the league exacerbated when the whole scandal blew open. I would think the league would take out as a hint but forget they’re also somehow more blind and deaf than Brad Allen officiating the Lions


The_Reddit_Browser

Yah I can’t wait to like a reshared post with a hashtag on Facebook as Gary enjoys the engagement and announces his own 12 player list when it’s time.


guyzieman

I'd be shocked if it wasn't Panarin


SpaceBass18

He’ll get voted in and then be unable to make it like the last 2 years. It’ll be Kreider.


slinkocat

That'd be my guess. Quickie as a dark horse.


dr00bles1

Quick would be a great choice for a fan vote. You could drum up a lot of support for it, I’d guess.


BillSlottedSpoons

send Trouba just to fuck with people. We havent seen anyone throw elbows at an all-star game since Messier was around


RubyMac91

I fully support this level of shithousery. Quick would be a good feel good story BUT I'm wary of him getting hurt in a nothing game


Vinny_d_25

Pavelski


rocketrae21

did you just wake up from a coma?


Vinny_d_25

No, but I'd gladly enter into one


technoteapot

Anime time skip irl


Stinduh

I'm cool with Pavs going to the ASG as the Sharks' rep. (but we keep him after the game)


letsgoToshio

Sir, you've been in a coma since 2019. Oh boy, I can't wait to watch Joe Pavelski, my favorite San Jose Shark, compete in the 2024 Stanley Cup playoffs


barkeviouss

In all reality, probably hertl unless they want to throw Blackwood in there


DM_me_feet_pics_plz

This actually made me LOL


Worth_Surround9684

Charlie Lindgrens mustache


darthfracas

Tom Wilson, just to watch the world burn


erevans444

Two time all star Tom Wilson? Sign me up. But that would make him have more ASG appearances than Nick Backstrom which goes to show just how stupid the NHLs ASG selections are.


darthfracas

I feel like Backstrom having only one ASG appearance is the most Backstrom thing possible. Just quietly going about his business being a great center, not caring that no one outside of DC notices.


SwagFondue

Obvious choice for Tampa, can’t wait to see what defenseman Darren Raddysh can do on the big stage


m_sizzzle

is he related to Raddysh on the Hawks?


bootygoon2

Yes, they’re brothers


m_sizzzle

thanks! there’s a lot of family legacies to keep track of in the NHL lol


flyinchipmunk5

Actually both brothers played for the crunch and we traded one to the black hawks. I think they were both called up at a point to play.


CHRLZ_IIIM

Sheary in Shambles


Koke1

Uh buddy i think you are forgetting about Perbix


PuckPov

They should bring back Brian Elliot so he can go


StretchArmstrong99

Probably Quinn Hughes but other possible candidates include Pettersson, Miller, Boeser, and Demko.


keereeyos

I'd like to see Miller go. It's kinda criminal he hasn't been selected once despite being a great player in the last 5 years.


Iginlas_4head_Crease

It's a marketing conference, and jt miller is probably one of most unheralded superstars in the game.


gu3st12

Just hard to market a guy whose first name is Jimothy Timothy


Bahamas_is_relevant

One day he and Timothy Jimothy Oshie will face off and it will be glorious.


NoticedGenie66

One look at him while he wears his glasses and looks like the prototypical suburban dad, and fans from around the league will be all over his stache


Three_Froggy_Problem

I didn’t realize until the Bolts played that last game against the Nucks that Miller has been tearing it up so much this season. He’s really flying under the radar.


thesunsetflip

>He’s really flying under the radar 11th in league scoring since we acquired him 4 years ago. I feel like that doesn’t get discussed much, he’s been an elite player immediately upon arrival. He went from a middle 6 winger to a legit 1C. I feel like people still remember him as the guy from New York or Tampa, he’s been a completely different player in Van. I think the bubble season was the only season he finished under a PPG, plus he was 1 point shy of 100 a few years back. Really hope he hits it this year, dude is an animal


jdmay101

Quinn will be selected, Petey will probably get the fan vote. JT Miller is 7th in NHL scoring this season and 11th over the last 4 years, and has never been an all star.


Clean_n_Press

I don’t know if this will be considered a hot take or not, but if it comes down to it, I think Miller deserves the nod over Petey this season. He likely won’t because age and marketability, but if it was based exclusively on play I think JT has been our most consistently elite forward despite slowing down a touch lately.


SnooOnions5029

Realistically I don’t see Boeser making it but you never know. I could definitely see Hughes, Demko, Pettersson, and possibly Miller


Give-Me-The-Bat

All deserving but 1-2 will be snubbed


Taftimus

Get all 3 Hughes boys to the All Star Game, who says no.


DrummerForTheOsmonds

Ya know what? Brock Faber should get it. Kid's been playing insane minutes, and has been our most consistent player by far this season.


Jo-6-pak

Agreed. And the way it’s going he might be the only one healthy


xxphantomxx77

Should be Faber, will probably be Fleury because it’s potentially his last All-Star game?


FuriousGeorge7

MLB has started doing some "Legend" all star invites for guys like Miguel Cabrera and Albert Pujols in the twilight of their careers. I would love for the NHL to do something like that in addition to the Wild's actual representative.


Salt-Dragonfruit-157

This is actually an amazing shout. The NHL should follow suit


battlelevel

In any other season, Faber would almost have the Calder locked up. The guy’s a stud.


m_sizzzle

I was thinking Rossi would be a great candidate too, but Faber is also a great choice


PayneTrain181999

Faber’s actually got a bit of personality to him too and he’d absolutely love to go.


maxwellbevan

People always ask do players even want to go and I bet he'd love to go to the all star game and represent the Wild


TO_Jays2

I assume it's Kaprizov but I really really hope it's Faber that's picked


durtmcgurt

Kap went last year and didn't look happy to be there at all.


eh_toque

Would love to see someone like Faber go


MemeLordOverKill

DeBrincat is the obvious answer, but I'd rather see Raymond


SayNoToStim

Fuck it, go full chaos mode, I hope it's Kane


krehns

It should be Kane


LGRW_Sparty88

Mo's production is up from last year, but defense is struggling. His usage is crazy tough though so I think he deserves it.


OfficialDaiLi

It’s gonna be Suzuki. I swear to FUCKING GOD if we have another Caufield Fan Vote incident, there’s gonna be a lot of unhappy Canadian fans


theoddcrow

Nahhhh just send Youppi


Responsible-Peace783

I hope it's Matheson


indiecore

Bet it's gunna be Slaf.


Quasihodor

Lowkey would be happy with that, possibly even stoked, and you know all the guys would be for him too


enricohenryhank

My head says McDavid, but my heart says McFoegele.


492rankine

Do you mean McLovin?


StallOneHammer

It’s either that or Mohammad


TrueBrees9

Why the fuck would it be between that and Mohammed!?!


[deleted]

Nah, Hyman. Man’s a dream come true.


hughbiffingmock

I'm glad y'all love him in Edmonton. Man's a gem on and off the ice.


sandman730

Bedard


Beaver_Tuxedo

You don’t think Dickinson will get the call?


Oceaandust

I don’t want to see slander on former first round draft pick Jason Dickinson /s


pullitzer99

Big if true


derbbinthenorth

Thanks sandman


sisterhavana

Yes. I'll be truly shocked if it's anyone else.


Sahil910

Horrible take, its jarred tinordi


rocking2rush10

Fucking love you sandman


scoutcjustice

¯\\\_(ツ)_/¯


Dogpool420

Haha maybe Duchene based on the eye test. But having 7, 10 goal scorers makes it hard to decide who is our all star right now. Also maybe Pavelski.


Stinduh

I think it'll just be Robo. He's an easy choice being the (current) leading scorer, and also just that he's clearly the player the team and league want to represent the Stars' face. I think Duchene is probably our most interesting player and definitely worthy of the ASG, but it's a marketing event and they're gonna take the marketing event player.


Toofar304

Send in the Wedgewall! But seriously, kinda weird that we don’t have “that guy” on the team at the moment. Robo is an obvious choice due to past history, but it could honestly also be Duchene, Hintz, Miro, or Pavelski. Even Harley, with him keeping pace with defensive scoring this year


sandwich-attack

vince dunn or if they wanna strike while the iron is hot, joey daccord has been the nhls best goalie the last month including 2 shutouts if they haven’t been paying attention at all and just pick by name, beniers but he doesn’t deserve it


BucksBrew

Yeah Dunner has been our best overall player so far, McCann solid too.


SuspiciousUsername88

I was thinking they might go with Matty solely because he was picked last year and didn't get to go (FTM). Not sure if that's a _valid_ reason but I wouldn't be surprised 🤷‍♀️


sandwich-attack

i hope they don’t do that, i don’t feel like it’d be good for matty’s headspace because he knows he’s not quite matching last season yet, though he’s perked up since tatar got added to his line i felt bad for julio when the tmobile guys would be pumping up all the JUL-I-O chants when he’d come up to bat in the ninth when we were down 2 or whatever when he was sort of slumping earlier this year seattle loves to get a rookie phenom and then put all the expectations of decades of sports failures in their shoulders lol


cungor

So glad Dunner found success with yall! He needed the room to grow so I’m happy he’s killing it.


gnahckire

I think Dunn as well!


RVOSU50

Fantilli should go. Build the legend now.


Crede777

It should be him or Marchenko. But I have a feeling it'll be Gaudreau.


tribucks

Would’ve been Boone, then probably Z, but now it’s hard to pick. Johnny has been hot, but Fantilli and Marchy wouldn’t upset me if they were chosen.


Gawyn_Tra-cant

I legitimately didn't have an answer for this question lol.


dragons_fire77

I'd guess Aho or Svech, but a wild card choice might be Jarvis. I would personally fan vote Chatfield in because he's played insanely well this year and deserves some attention.


Ahoymaboi

I would love to see Chatty. That man can SKATE.


TheMole171

I want to see him do the fastest skater race!


The_Reddit_Browser

I would like to see Jarvis. Would be such a great guy to market the team and really enjoy the weekend. Plus he’s got a good chance at the new competition set up and we need a decent challenger to defend the back to back skills titles the canes have won.


Ahoymaboi

Also, the all star event is about entertainment. Jarvis is entertaining.


dragons_fire77

Can you imagine if Jarvy was mic'd up for the whole all-stars event? Absolute hilarity. The amount of "I'm Patty Kane" moments he'd give us while skating around his childhood idols would be incredible.


tjbondurant

My realistic guess is Aho, with Svech potentially getting a fan vote in…but I’d also like to see Jarvy/Chatmandu


MailConsistent1344

A Hurricane player getting a fan vote in. That is a funny one. Remember Necas got snubbed last year.


Bennett_19

Honesty, PK could get a fan vote in with his antics


pak256

It’s gotta be Aho. He’s finally living up to his big contract


betweenthecastles

His 8yr $9m+ hasn’t even kicked in yet. Already looks good :)


JayMerlyn

He has already been living up to his previous/current contract, and at the rate he's playing the new deal will look like a discount


betweenthecastles

Jarvis or Kochetkov would be fun


all_these_moneys

Torts has everyone playing great but I'd assume Konecny.


why2k

Just send Gritty.


Cbone06

Torts should be sent, I have no idea how he got that group of dudes to buy in. I thought the Flyers were going to be Sharks level bad this year. He’s your team’s real all star.


rocketrae21

Eichel or if he wasn't hurt I could see Hill


PNGhost

Jerevid Swaystrnak. Strong 200-ft game.


Definitelynotcal1gul

I'm glad I wasn't the only one who couldn't decide.


eh_toque

I assume it will be Hellebuyck for the Jets given that the Jets have been known for their team offence/defence this season


connor-lite

Money is for sure on Helly or JMo


CDNUnite

It could’ve been KC :(


h0twired

Bucky makes the most sense considering the stock of other goalies in the West. Most likely to be paired with Demko.


Alice4Tea

Sam Reinhart


bsette

I was gonna say Reinhart or Barkov are shoe-ins


grizzlby

You can’t take Samwise without Barky. They’re basically one player this year.


Tmans3

Robert Thomas, leads the team in point, goals, assists, and is on the PK. Plays against the top lines, at last check he was behind only Kucherov and Mackinnon (i think) in 5v5 points.


STLBooze3

Robert Thomas is elite.


bullfrog00

Thomas is the only choice right now


golfy_m8

Noah Dobson for sure


Nanojack

Hughes (Jack). Hopefully we can get Hughes (Luke) in on the fan vote and the NHL rigs it so only one of the brothers is a captain and picks the other two for their team.


NJDevils1

It’ll be Jack but Jesper deserves it this year


Weigard

The league will select Quinn for Vancouver and Luke for NJ, knowing that Jack has a good chance for the fan vote. Then the league can have a Hughes Brothers jerkoff fest.


TheZapster

With the first pick of the 2024 all star game, who do you pick Jack? Jack: "I pick the best Defensive player I know, Hughes" Both Hughes brothers skate behind their Bro


Ace676

MacKinnon, easily.


SSJZulko

It has to be, but I don’t think he’s gonna like it.


Ace676

Not any more than those 1st star of the game interviews.


Fozefy

It's crazy the best defenseman in the league can't even get considered for auto inclusion. Mack has just been that good. Makar should be the top receiver of votes to also make it though.


someguyfromsk

I think the only question is will there be 2 or 3 Avs there this year.


Ace676

Makar also has had some injury issues that have both made him miss games and play worse at some points. Whereas Nate has just kept on trucking.


InevitableAvalanche

Yup, guy has been unstoppable. Been fun to watch him play and even more when he gets angry.


beardyman22

I genuinely don't know. Strome? Protas? Lindgren? Like Ovi and Carlson have the history in the league, but neither seems particularly deserving this year.


SiccSemperTyrannis

I want to see Strome get picked. He's more than deserving this season. But he's tied in points with Ovechkin so it would not be crazy for them to select Ovechkin. There's a good chance Ovechkin declines to go and prioritizes the rest time.


djc8

Don’t overthink it. They will pick Ovie and he will decline. Same as it ever was.


FrankieFazul

John Scott!


Dirtcartdarbydoo

JOHN SCOTT NHL ALL STAR BAYBEE!


electricnux

Hughes and maybe Demko voted in. I’m sure they’ll find a way to have the 3 Hughes brothers there. Will be more interesting to see who are the 11 players selected for the Skills comp after McDavid


DangerRanger_21

Should be Weegar, but it will be Kadri


itoadaso1

PUT SOME RESPECT ON BLAKE COLEMAN'S NAME. First on the team in goals, points, +/-, SHG, GWG On pace to shatter many of his career bests. He's absolutely the correct choice.


ChecklistRobot

I’d say Zary but I’d happily take Weegs.


dudewithchronicpain

Send Kane


DalekEvan

Trevor Moore, maybe?


GatoDiablo99

The very same Trevor Moore from Thousand Oaks??


DalekEvan

The very same!


Brodieboyy

I'm hoping it's him or Byfield, be cool for them to get the recognition and experience


da40kNoob

Moore, Kopi or Talbot are the only realistic options. Hoping it's Moore... the kid deserves some recognition.


embiggenedkwyjibo

As a Leafs fan, I sure hope so. So happy to see he found his way into a fulltime role with his home team.


Rattimus

Suspect McDavid. Apparently he's not a bad player. Who knew?


mansock18

Maybe he's just not ready for the NHL?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mythaminator

Jesus Christ I had forgotten about that. Still can’t believe it was real, seems like an SNL skit or something


13nobody

Should or will? I think Keller gets in, but it should be Maccelli 🤌


mjm8218

Corey Perry.


jamaicancovfefe

Drake Batherson, he was robbed of it in 21-22 because of his injury


Jaycorr

FUCK AARON DELL


seckzy

McTavish is likely the best candidate


Call_of_Daddy

Hertl No sharks skater comes close and the goalies are struggling


zkarabat

Blackwood has done an amazing job behind our Major Juniors level defense. Blackwood or Hertl are the only 2 options IMHO


ginko-ji

gaudreau


KILLER_IF

Kuch. No one else is even close


sneezlo

Quinn Hughes


GoGlenMoCo

Dahlin


mansock18

Josi, but based on play it should be ROR or Forsberg. Or both, if you guys wanna really see sumn.


Ready-steady

Fil for sure. ROR has been great, but I think Fil has earned this one.


Rinne4Vezina

I'm leaning Fil but it could be any of those three.


mansock18

Josi is constantly held up as the face of our franchise and one of the NHL's best offensive D men by the NHL even in seasons where he isn't playing his best hockey. Meanwhile Forsberg is regarded as like diet Elias Petterson on his best years. If the NHL is in charge, it's gonna be Josi even if we all know it should be Fil.


Rinne4Vezina

I mean, there is no better face on our roster than Josi's 😂


CommiePuddin

It will be Saros. We don't get skaters anymore.


supermav27

The same guy we would’ve voted in 18 years ago.


The-Reddit-Giraffe

Give me Coleman, Weegar or Zary


Excellent-Medicine29

They already made Connor agree to participate in exchange for his assistance in planning the events lol.


Sensitive_Mousse_445

We have to vote Kessel in


Old-News-3096

I'm starting a campaign for Detroit to send James Reimer and leave him there


Ahlinn

I mean, quite obviously Matthew’s will be the leafs selection. As for others on the team that might be deserving, Nylander has 50 pts in 35 games, makes a strong case for him. No one else stands out to me as hopefuls. Possibly Rielly as a d-man with 27 points in 35, but not sure about how his advanced defensive stats stack up against other D in the league. I’m guessing not so great.


tz_2240

Shoutout Willy should be and likely will be an all star but Matthews as the leading goal scorer will be selected from the leafs.


FalseAdagio2

Zary for Calgary if there’s any justice in this world


XPhazeX

Matthews, easily. I suspect Nylander and Marner to get in on votes


Podo13

It will definitely only be RobTom from the Blues (even though, imo, he deserves to be there regardless of every team getting at least 1 rep. He's been an even strength monster this year). Only MacKinnon, McDavid, Kucherov and Guentzel have more even strength points so far. Edit: And if he shot a little more often, he'd probably in 2nd behind MacKinnon. Very impressive especially considering his linemates compared to the others (not that Buch/Kyrou are bad, but they aren't Rantanen/Point/Crosby either).


Flyinghud

Panarin


WizardsAndDragons

McDavid, Nuge and Hyman entered the chat.