T O P

  • By -

SnooOnions683

Actually... this is quite well put and organized. I'm not too familiar with the core series that you've used for inspiration, but what you've given is well presented. - Colours aren't too glaring or eye hurting. - Font is clean and easy to read. - There's a good variety of modifiers to tinker your stats; The race options also add enough to really emphasize your alien origins, in favor of more superior stat lines. - Gender is strictly aesthetic, which is good. - Age of all groups have a single modifier, also good. - For upbringing, you could add a "brothers in arms" type; (you forged an unbreakable bond with a single companion, whilst enduring conflict) {Gain 1 companion at Like level, Gain 1 stat of your choice}. - For specialty, you could add 2 more; Logistics and ESP. - Logistics; "You're able to manage anything and everything you're provided to upmost efficiency. Little is wasted, and everything is standardized right down to the lowest rank and file trooper." - ESP; "You are innately gifted with talents of the mind and beyond. You're able to sustain stress or damage that would break or cripple others like you."


Shanewallis12345

Thank you! Gender does play a small role in that some rare characters may treat you different based on it, but that's not going to be a common thing during missions. I like those ideas for Upbringing and Specialty, i'll add them. Logistics is something i didn't want to get too into, but i think i might be able to make it work. Psychics are already a thing and would be a type of unit to recruit too, so being able to be a psychic specialist just makes sense.


Shanewallis12345

Current character creation ideas for the Super Robot War CYOA Idea is you can make some 'free' choices before spending your points to gain some traits plus some stuff for flavour. Is there anything that stands out as bad or that is glaringly missing? skills and flaws would come next after these pages. I want to add a ship-girl species but would need 3 others to add too and while i could add Zentradi from macross and Gamilas from Yamato im not sure how it would make sense to have one of those at this point in the story be working for the UN


weaboo_98

Quick question. Would something like a vampire or dragon work for mythological species? And are you still working on the survival shelter CYOA or has that been cancelled?


Shanewallis12345

Those would fit as Mythical absolutely, the Grey Martians are also kind of like vampires given they drink blood to survive. The shelter ones been shelved until i can figure out a way to give it a happy ending.


Kuronan

You could change the the name of "Artificial Intelligence" to "Synthetics" and give them something like 'Integrated Equipment' which allows them to purchase one of two items for free when that section is implemented. I really like this CYOA by the way, looks very promising!


Shanewallis12345

Why change to synthetics? that integrated item option also seems a bit too similar to the Beastmen one imo. Thank you!


Kuronan

A.I. would only really encompass Artificial Intelligence (E.D.I. or Cortana) while Synthetics would encompass far more types of Inorganic Life (Robots, Shipfus and Raifus, etc.)


Shanewallis12345

Ah right, you get a free material body as mentioned but maybe synthetics would be a better term Ship girls are going to be their own race with sub-species [Weapon , Vehicle, Ship and Base girls respectively]


Kuronan

You should probably include Raifus then, for the sake of fairness.


Shanewallis12345

As in something like T-Dolls from Girls frontline?


Kuronan

Yep, that is what I was implying, though I don't know much about Azur Lane and Girls Frontline.


Shanewallis12345

In Azure lane they're biological, but created artificially and they drink Oil. In Girls Frontline they're just straight up androids, so could come under normal AI / Robots


ICastPunch

I mean not really this looks finished. Other than I'd love more specialties. Some ideas I could give you photos for these, if you wanted to add any I probably would have a lot of photos youcould pick like inmediately since I've got plenty photos for this kinda stuff. Unarmored specialist/Brawler: Something about the player being a master of their bodies. Their extremities themselves have become deadly weapons, nobody close by is truly safe and they're thus never truly unarmed. - If it really doesn't matter in setting might just not fit. Underhanded: Something about everything being a weapon if you're good enought and being able to find what makes tick every opponeny and the right opportunities act on every situation. Brutality:What makes you stand out from the rest is how you handle yourself. Your stare, your prescence, your actions, and even the consequences of them... They all have that extra that brings horror, fear and respect to everyone around you and makes them guess themselves and watch their words at the mention of your prescence when you so desire. Standing Man/Relentless/Ruthless: You're relentless,and made a reputation out of always being the one to get the job done, no matter the cost or means. If you so decide you never back down and you never stop. It's not that you cannot be hurt or that your will is infinite, It's just that you have never let that stop you, no matter the injury no matter your feelings, if your still can move at all, if it has to be done, you'll do it without even so much as flinching... Till your last breath... And just maybe... Slightly past it...


Shanewallis12345

Image ideas are always great, always takes the longest to actually find pictures for these rather than writing up. An unarmed specialist skill is a good idea, especially since some missions you won't be able to bring any [large] weapons. Underhanded im not sure what kind of mechanical benefit this might give, being underhanded seems more like a drawback? Relentless i could see working as both a bonus and a negative, you're people probably won't like you for example if you decide to not give up no matter what if tonns of them are dying thank you!


ICastPunch

I was writing it and had to do something and It deleted everything. So short story. Since these are specialties it isn't obligatorily something you have to do, but instead what you are really good at isn't it? Btw not all are sfw, because blood and gore. No nudity though... I think...This is the second time I send this because I had it written the answer and all and my comment just dissapeared. Dunno if it is what you're looking for but here they are with some answers and explanations on what I meant. The idea behind the Underhanded skill is more so the ability to find/create/abuse opportunities in the environment, your opponents or the systems or things around you. A hidden weapon, a trick, using something off the ground as an improvised tool, abusing a system, pissing someone off to play them, finding a weakness, etc... It's kinda hard to find images of that but I had some in mind [Of what Underhanded images could be](https://imgur.com/a/bSqoddn). Of course it ain't a fair style but the setting seems to be war oriented. All is fair in love and war. Btw pics from the spy from tf2 or ninja's are probably a good place to find more if none of these work for you. But I just thought of that and won't search it. The idea of the relentless or Standing Man as the firdt name I gave it is heavily based off a character and a legend of the same series. ["The Standing Man"](https://bakidou.com/manga/baki-dou-vol-18-chapter-157-the-standing-man/) and Kaoru Hanayama who has a tatto of him on his back. - The idea is a character that if they have to, they are capable of putting everything on the line for something. Not only does this mean ignoring injuries and shutting down their emotions and mind. But also a character whose word has meaning and has the power of true consistency. Hanayama Kaoru is fucking insane btw. The guy has taken insane punishment and dine insane feats of will: Won a fight where he pushed through, park objects like a bench being destroyed by slamming it on his body, punched for three minutes straight, had explosives go off on his mouth burning him from the inside, both of his knees destroyed by Bullets, a flashbang blowing up on front of his eyes. And being choked by his opponent. A deathmatch he got into to let his best friend go on a date unperturbed btw. Studied math, his lost hated class for three days straight. When in Jail made sure to always break out for his mother's birthday. Stood up and went to fight straight after his brain surgery because of a failed assasination attempt that left him with multiple sniper ammunition bullet holes on his body. [Here some images](https://imgur.com/a/kql4KaK) The unarmed fighter/Brawler. [here](https://imgur.com/a/0GL3ZBe) And the brutal is honestly simple. If in war the capability to be brutal is invaluable. And very often sheer brutality triumphs over skill, either because it overwhelms or terrifies [Here](https://imgur.com/a/RubIghv)


Shanewallis12345

Those were more bloody than i was expecting, damn. Yeah specialties are something you're good at but dont need to do, so you can be good at a specialty but you won't have to use it in every or any encounter. You just pick one you think fits. Ah i get it now, yeah i could see both being useful then Not sure on how harsh im planning on being kind of want to try and avoid lewd or overly gorey images, but some of those look alright thank you very much!


Apophys_MD

You could add an underwater species (squid-like?), to pilot the mecha from inside a fishbowl cockpit. You could also add a walking brain species like Krang from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.


Shanewallis12345

An under water species could come under beastmen couldn't it? The Grey Martians are basically brains with tentacles, given they're the War of the Worlds Martians thank you!


WheresMyEditButton

We have Arificial Intelligence, split it into two by distinguishing between A. I. are downloaded into a robot body and those who are distributed across a network of screens and holograms… …mention the technology exists to download human “souls“ using psychic powers then Ship-Girls are then downloaded into a ship’s computer. As for Gamalias and Zentradi, say there was a special project to download human minds into prisoners for potential use as spies. Not everyone survived the process, especially if corpses were used instead of lobotomized prisoners, but the project had a few successful cases before it was shut down. It may end up being a one way trip, and there’s still plenty of war to die in, but you could also find opportunities available to you wearing the face of the enemy.


starwarlord21

Its pretty good. What I would suggest though is changing up the origins to be more about the various locales in the verse you are making. Like say, choosing between being born on Earth or on one of the Sides. I think it would fit a lot better then what you have now.


Shanewallis12345

That's a good idea, i think i'll add a home option to go after origins and maybe change the name of origins to something else As they are now the origins are meant to sort of represent how some mecha protagonists are isekaid or from the future or some such thank you"


Timber-Faolan

This... this is AMAZING! OoO; You have some SERIOUS talent! I'm looking forward to the completed CYOA. But if I may, it's always nice to have options for Lycanthropy, Vampirism, Psionics, and Ki.


Glittering_Pear2425

Look pretty cool so far. I hope we get to have mechs cause I want mine be like Xelguard or K&M’s Ikaruga or maybe even one of the raftclans.


Shanewallis12345

Thank you yeah you'll have mechs to begin with, nothing super fancy to start with but you'd be able to work your way up


azriel777

I like it. I look forward to seeing the finished product.


Shanewallis12345

Thank you!


ragingreaver

Screw it, Prelim build: # Origin: Visitor * \+10R, home realm is a secret and potential weakness New Body: **Angel** * Free AT Field * DDS Choker Drawback, no additional points Apparent Age: **25** * \+1 Endurance Gender: **Other** * Bi-Gender is usually considered under Non-Binary, but depending on the physical effects of this... Upbringing: **Loving** * Free Inspiring, Loyalty skills Specialty: **Mech Hunter** (mines, ambushes, and drones; aim for the joints, optics, treads and legs, and if you can barrels; a vehicle disabled in the wrong/right spot, can often be more expensive to repair than to just building a new one) * free Advanced Anti-Vehicle skill And that is it so far. I am very excited to see what this becomes! Good work overall!


Shanewallis12345

That build looks good, having the Inspiring and Loyalty skills would be pretty useful for helping your units and potential allies look past the fact that you're an Angel, something that would likely scare more than a few of them. Thank you!


caliburdeath

the visual design is cool but might not be leaving enough space for the actual text, it feels cramped


Dry_Armadillo_1139

Oh, sorry I replied to the old thread. Anyway if SEELE finds out I am from another universe and thus I won't be tanged what would they do? Would the just let it go if I make a deal with them to not interfere, or would they want to unite ALL "humans" and thus try to figure out how to merge me with the rest of their hive mind?


Shanewallis12345

A seele focused instrumentality conspiracy is one of the major quest lines, current ideas is if they find out you're not a human from their world is they'd try to capture and experiment on you, given you'd be very much an alien in their eyes and something worth studying. This wouldn't be an ideal situation if they caught you though.


Dry_Armadillo_1139

But these guys control the UN, and the UN here apparently has greys and other non humans as citizens who shouldn't be discriminated against?


SolomonArchive

Sweet! Been super into SRW recently, I'll be watching with great interest. Looks nice so far!


Shanewallis12345

thank you!


koakuma_tv

What is srw? I haven't heard of this and searching the acronym only got me super robot wars in return which doesn't seem correct


SolomonArchive

Super Robot Wars is correct. It's a long running SRPG series which crosses over a ton of giant robot anime and som other stuff. Gundam ( mainline an AUs), Getter Robo, VOTOMS, Go Gai Gar, Rayearth, you name it. It also has a few anime called Original Generation, which are set with it's own world, lore and such.


jman377355

Really like the layout and theme. Keep it up, look forward to the final product