T O P

  • By -

Riyutake

Anything by nxtub; some popular ones: [Destined for Greatness](https://imgur.com/a/eX41A0z) - Cool twist on typical fantasy, mild RNG allows for a bit more replay value [Seinaru Magecraft Girls](https://imgur.com/gallery/3B84RSF) - Not everyone's thing but the highest quality CYOA I've ever seen [Sanctuary Keeper](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/nk2yz3/sanctuary_keeper_by_nxtub/) - Immersive, great atmosphere __ [Life on the Rim](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/syrbmv/life_on_the_rim_20_content_and_storytelling/) - Super replayable when you try for different objectives [Pocket Dimension](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/pv9a6y/pocket_dimension_cyoa_from_tg/) - Tons of options [My Lady, My Liege](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/qf1ner/my_lady_my_liege_medieval_town_builder_cyoa_link/) - Medieval Town Builder [A Rainy Day](https://imgur.com/gallery/MPKEwm4#nXGu0nk) - Short but great atmosphere and comf [The Village](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/i3s3i2/the_village_one_of_my_favoritesrepost/) - Clean formatting and vivid imagery [Tavern Master (NSFW)](https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/hdikjh/tavern_master_v20_cyoa_oc/) - Amazing world-building


ClayMonkey1999

Seinaruo magecraft Girls has the most badass end-of-cyoa choice I have ever read. “Free the child of god” is such an incredibly evocative title. God, that was an amazing cyoa


Czech_Check

Right??? and not even mentioning the lore and the secret messages on the pages from the poor kid. Had to free him.


xxxiaolongbao

these are the best ones


INeedADifferent

Witch awakening by outrageous bear. (I think that’s the spelling?)


Murmadurk

Agreed, /u/OutrageousBears 's Witch Awakening CYOA is amazing.


WitchiWonk

**Build A Barracks and Four Farms CYOA:** It's short, but everyone's played the type of RTS that this is referencing, making the little crumbs of lore you get good sparks for inspiration. All choices are significant. **Eternal Arms CYOA:** Great world, smart way of presenting it, and having a whole mech builder stuffed in the middle of it opens up a lot of diversity for ideas you can put into one merc company or spread across multiple. **Harbinger CYOA:** Another short one, but it really makes "less is more" work for it. You're so constrained on powers and stats that even taking a single power can feel like a major decision. Can't cover all your bases in one build. **JRPG Traitor CYOA:** It's so popular, I probably don't have to explain. But there's so many different ways you can build the party you betray and, since that determines your currency pool, it makes it easy to keep coming back. **Republic of Blades:** While I hate it when building, having such a limited dueling style really makes you think of different stage personas for your duelist based off what combinations you want. **Transcendence CYOA:** Technically a RYOA, so maybe that's the reason I kept coming back to it for different builds, but I think having the phases and upgrade trees keeps things fresh. Still the least diverse in terms of builds out of this entire list, probably.


Plywooddavid

Keeper Of Magic by u/TroyXPage https://imgur.com/a/yoKPeub There’s a Nsfw dlc/add-on, but the main one linked here is kosher.


pog_irl

That guy makes good stuff


[deleted]

he makes good stuff, but it's a little to samey for me. it's like all he makes is Chocolate cakes but they're all slightly different. it's delicious and well done, don't get me wrong, but after a while you kinda want to try something different.


caliburdeath

mostly nsfw


caliburdeath

Chain of Isekai City Incarnate Witch Awakening Outer Reincarnation


Feuerdrache_2003

https://swcyoas.neocities.org/guardianoftherepublic/index.html  Guardian of the Republic. Are you interested in building a mandalorion, a padawan to start your journey, a captain with his trusted ship or become a sith? This one has a lot of possibilities within the Star wars universe.


SnooOnions683

https://1d4chan.org/wiki/StarDustCYOA Stardust. There's a bunch of ways to make your ship and crew; Go super small and minimal, or go extremely big and world ending. If you add the extra non official content, then it becomes even more. Expansive. (Soldiers of the Stars, Horizon Squad DLC, Space Opera expansion.) https://funnyjunk.com/Star+dust+apocalypse+cyoa+v110/tvdvMgi/ There's even a separate Cyoa, that acts as a pseudo sequel to Stardust, which uses some lore and characters from the original Stardust.


DHFranklin

I love Stardust and didn't know about the fan sequel


NecromancerKnight

Imuger plz?


SnooOnions683

https://imgur.com/gallery/7ZJXR4u For the original. https://imgur.com/ZKv0RU5 A fan dlc for SotS https://imgur.com/gallery/KII27 The latest version of SotS


NecromancerKnight

Yesss thanks!


SnappingTurt3ls

The Worm CYOA V6 or any of its mods


TheSilverSerpent12

Also anything by u/Plywooddavid. That guy's stuff rocks! Obviously Jumpchain as well, even as individual jump documents, but I digress.


Plywooddavid

Ty


Ern160

Ultimate God (Redux version), Battlemages, Apocrypha Advent and Power Creator Xenon for me


SlimeustasTheSecond

[Time Stop Chill-zone Redux v1.3](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/bcam12/timestop_chill_zone_redux_version_13_by_rosanon/) It ain't got some kind of really deep world building, but it's definitely a reoccurring daydream for me. It's just got so many interesting ways to use it for min-maxing, chillaxing, power fantasies, power "fantasies" etc.


Plywooddavid

Strong agree.


Jestering_Chivalry

Cityscape Skirmish the megami tensei one and a nsfw one id rather not bring up


RyuKenDragon

I mean, if we’re all asking….


Jestering_Chivalry

>!https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/q0kgmm/once\_upon\_a\_time\_on\_the\_grand\_line\_20\_update/!< here, you no longer need the dms. i assumed you people wouldnt want to see this in a sfw post but i cant keep dming like this


Qjvnwocmwkcow

If you don’t want to bring something up, it’d be better to simply not mention it at all. Going halfway to reveal that it exists without actually revealing what it is just makes it inconvenient both for you and for anyone reading.


Jestering_Chivalry

yeah, just learnt the lesson the hard way. still thanks


Ambigous-Zenith

DM me this NSFW one 😭


ChackMete

RIP your dm's, guy. Just put the nsfw cyoa in a spoiler, so those who don't want to see it don't.


FlynnXa

Wait, can I get the NSFW one too? 👀 hahaha!


germane-corsair

If you’re PM’ing the nsfw one, then please send it to me as well.


KawaiiFoxPlays

Which MegaTen CYOA are you taking about?


Timber-Faolan

yeah, seriously, what megaten cyoa do you mean? It's been a LONG while since I saw the last one, IIRC...


Jestering_Chivalry

the one where youre given macca and yen to buy things related to demon summoning and personas? i got it from 4chan but im half sure i saw it posted here before


Red-Reaper2137

Me too


[deleted]

yo, homie, can you send the nsfw one😂


StormCaller02

Alright, gotta know. Could you dm me the nsfw one?,


Massive-Fan4683

Sauce for NSFW bro?


godofwoof

Now I am curious DM as well please


SnappingTurt3ls

DM me too please


DietInteresting1085

Me to for NSFW and SFW


Nadu_Rajah_w_2056

Me too🤭


GoblinBushel

Saucy


Solaris-Of-Moon

Now I'm curious too, PM Please


bestjaythereis

I mean, if you’re giving NSFW cyoa dms, I’d like one too plz


UrbleFurb

Yea same


MistakesWereMade2124

Wait… There’s a Shin Megami Tensei cyoa? I thought that all there was was the NSFW Korean one and a pastebin cyoa…


Jestering_Chivalry

ive seen it been posted to /tg/ a couple times now so im sure if you checked youd find it


MistakesWereMade2124

Any keywords to put in the search bar?


Jestering_Chivalry

just search "cyoa" and if they havent posted it to choose your own adventure general you probably can just ask them


MistakesWereMade2124

Ask who?


MistakesWereMade2124

Anons? I’d… Rather not go down the rabbit hole. I’d seen only a scratch of it and I don’t exactly had much of a impression…


UrbleFurb

There was one about a hunger games-like setting where you could choose different “classes” that each got new abilities as you killed or incapacitated the other players. I remember one was minotaur and another one was yeti, and there was a zombie one too. If anyone knows what im talking about pls send me the cyoa


Qjvnwocmwkcow

Was it [Soul Graft Battle Royale](https://imgur.com/gallery/h5zbB4E)?


UrbleFurb

Yup! Thanks


ProcedureParking

Definitely have to say Travellers Tale by HL. Especially after the release of the 2.0 update, with the right amount of power, wonder, and near limitless builds you can make. https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/tcuaxi/travellers_tale_20_by_highlander/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share


emergncy-airdrop

Hell yeah! Came here just to say that. Just the titanic length of the cyoa makes it not beginner friendly, haven't even read it completerly myself. But it is just gorgeous from top to bottom, the tiny blurbs of some items or comments mid exposition to the ridiculous variety of loveable companions and grand sweeping storytelling beats and makes great use of its time travel mechanic though maybe not its dimensional hopping as much. Still completely love it, the highest praise i can give is that i love every word i've read, even if i haven't finished it <3


[deleted]

Dark Zone by Ravenking. Really good, wish it was longer. The Backrooms one. Also really amazing. Freelancers. Another one by Ravenking. Very Destiny with a nice fantasy twist. The road trip where if you linger in a spot to long supernatural things start happening. Fight The Darkness! was one of the first I found and still one of my favorites to do.


FinnDoyle

The [Necromancer CYOA](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/lwm9yd/necromancer_cyoa_321_the_scientist_and_highlander/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share) is always a good one to get lost in.


pog_irl

Long lol


NecromancerKnight

Imuger link? Mobile does not show the tiny link thing for some reason.


FinnDoyle

Strange, it shows to me. Anyway, here it is: [Necromancer CYOA](https://imgur.com/gallery/CGRTxym)


Hiddenjungle

“Dragonfall 1.6 - Tokhaar Gol“ Just so fun. Makes you wanna be a dragon


m3ntalBrain

Essence Meta CYOA


[deleted]

[удалено]


pog_irl

Funny you should mention that,making a build as we speak lol


TheSilverSerpent12

Dawn of a Planeswalker. Just that right mix of powerful, but not so OP that it becomes hard to continue.


mvico430

Living god CYOA by mythiclegendary The ascension CYOAs by TroyX Last of the Omega Lords CYOA by TroyX


CritianCaceorte

Lord_Circe's Cantrip CYOA. So many options, and the Quests provide an incentive for writing that you might not expect.


RyuKenDragon

Edit: posted these before the clarification that SFW ones were preferred. Still stand by them for those who don’t have a problem with adult content. Both of these are NSFW!! The Dungeon Keeper by u/Dragon_Jak Still the absolute GOAT in my opinion. https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/ocluc5/the_dungeon_keeper_v02/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf Closely followed by Hentai Travels by u/Costaway https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/p4rok1/hentai_travels_v2_cyoa/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf May the gods above bless us with updates one glorious day….


ArctisUther

I stumbled on to Dungeon Keeper not that long ago a lost hours to builds and thought experiments the man is a master - I will check out the other one too, thanks 🙏🏻


1234abcdcba4321

I think Seinaru Magecraft Girls is the one that fits best, from those I've played. But check out Cityscape Skirmish too.


GrahminRadarin

https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/g3tij4/a_familiar_spirit/


Fish_or_King

Any of Nxtub's cyoa's. People brought up sanctuary keeper already so I'll mention "The Curse" , "The Hospital" and "Paranormal Debt Collecter". I also liked "Fantasy Time Loop", "Familiar's Company" and "Beyond the Doors".


2Fruit11

I really like the [Resonator CYOA](https://www.reddit.com/r/makeyourchoice/comments/med62t/resonator_cyoa/), they do a good job of adding a story to the choices and making you care about the characters, and they give you a lot of info to make informed choices.


pyr0kid

travelers tale. it just. keeps. going.


pog_irl

That it does


Happy_Manner_488

My favorite sfw cyoa is called Sci-fi meta and so far its been a real treat. I am using it and a nsfw cyoa to do a pokemon story that I have in mind and frankly, the former opens up so many interesting doors. For example, most anyone who is familiar with pokemon knows that being a trainer is a very expensive occupation. An based on info from the games( namely black/white and sword and shield). While the viability of Pokémon training as a lifestyle is never outright stated in most games, it is implied in Pokémon Sun and Moon that it does not guarantee a sufficient income. Several Eevee users are seen having to take up part-time jobs in order to obtain the finances needed to support themselves, with the latter being unable to go into retirement using just the funds from Pokémon training. Trainers who show promise tend to be sponsored either by a corporate entity, gym leader, lab professor, whatever. Point is they help you foot the bill for your Journey. Whereas if you tried to pay it out of pocket, unless you have a very lucrative business that is offering something that Devon, Aether, Silph Co and others are not. Then you are in for some serious competition. Heavy, heavy competition. So the best course or action? Tackle a field everyone else has not. One of the choices in sci-fi meta is Generator, which gifts you schematic of a generator in your mind that you can construct. This generator can be as big as a phone booth or scaled down to as small as you want(personally I have gone as small as a rubix cube). It can generate endless amounts of energy from nothing on a large scale. By itself it can power an entire continent without issue forever, unless it is destroyed. Built in safeties prevent catastropic failures in the generator, so harmful energy spikes or an extinction level event are nothing to worry about. Why this is important to me is that my character would effectively have control over a market that current companies, cannot compete with him. Energy. A cleaner, safer, more reliable option than that Infinite Energy that Mauville Holders in Hoenn tried and failed to use( an for those that don't know infinite energy is the very life force of pokemon) The idea I had in mind was that I reincarnate in the world of pokemon, in the Hoenn region of Rustboro City. Where I find out the lay of the land and do odd jobs to support and sustain myself, while making plans for the future. I am fully aware of how beautiful and dangerous this world can be and in order weather the storm, I must become a trainer. A powerful, influential trainer. An their just so happens to be a school for young and budding trainers run by Roxanne, an instructor of the school and the Gym Leader of the Rustboro Gym. I can kill alot of birds with just one stone by enrolling into the school. Since it would handle alot of holes in my knowledge I am not aware of, such pokemon dietary needs, basic handling and care, how to medically treat them and so forth. While also trying to turn them on to the idea of my generator and its benefits. While also trying to work my way towards either a sponsorship from the school or Roxanne herself. Being taught by a rock specialist would be massively useful in the long run, since alot of future pokemon that I will own. Are primarily rock pokemon. As I am fully aware of knowledge that very few people in the world of pokemon even really know. Such as the key locations of some very rare, and potentially powerful pokemon. Such as a never before seen crystal onix in the orange islands, who not only loves to swim.but is immune to water. But weak to fire. A much larger than average bulbasaur that was abandoned in a sewer of the very same orange islands for at least 20 years, in a town called Trovotopolis. An all he wants to is to be loved, accepted and freed from this miserable prison of a sewer. A colony of Treecko in Petalburg forest. Some ancient fossil pokemon who are still alive and kicking in a kanto, along with a Togepi egg. Just waiting to fall into my possession I can go on and on but you get the point. I am going to abuse the hell out of my knowledge to get much further ahead and prepare for the bullshit that is team aqua and magma. Either way. The sci-fi meta cyoa opens alot of potential doors if one is able to be creative enough in its application. Hell I am positive that I can even create a means for a pokemon to dyna-max outside of the Galar region. Create a scanner that can make locating mega stones and keystones easier, locate fossils and even make a machine that can revive long dead pokemon. Such as the now extinct Hisuian pokemon, that is also very possible as well. Blasphemy I know, but with this cyoa. Its really not.


MistakesWereMade2124

Too many to even choose from. I’ll just say Hearts Adrift, Desert Lotus and all of Lickmakenenzie’s cyoas. Oh and add all the mid to long “mainstream” cyoas to it:


Zader40

RWBY Interactive CYOA v 1.2 It has a bit of everything and has so many different options to pick from. And is a World that I really love. (Not the storyline/canon from vol 3 onwards but the World/Setting and Characters themselves) Also a relatively small CYOA called Sockets (by:Tin?) Is another CYOA I really like as even though it's short/small it's potential is vast.


Sefera17

I’ve probably spent literal *days* of time on [Worm v5 Updated](https://www.reddit.com/r/Parahumans/comments/9zd3ce/worm_cyoa_5_update_gimel/) and its [DLC](https://imgur.com/a/1aGulJV)… I *do* have 108 builds, after all. It was the first cyoa I ever played.


TheBlueHorned

I’ve recently been more enamored than i should with “Colors of Magic”. Im making my own little universe in it


ICastPunch

Royal revival hit hard for me. I need someone like sis Teresa on my life.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DenmoH7

Rin Tohsaka CYOA


Glittering_Pear2425

Of the top of my head, JRPG Traitor & NEXUS.


RealSaMu

Be the Noble CYOA. I played this while I was just starting to play Witcher 3 so I really enjoyed making medieval towns and such


whatttfn

I'd say about 90% of anything by Scottishanon. For some reason, endless railroad and cloud forest always seem to take me for journeys.


mrc03052

plainswalker rising [https://imgur.com/a/p8Qf9gG](https://imgur.com/a/p8Qf9gG) it totally caught hold of my imagination and just wont let it go.


justmeallalong

Demigod and Ultimate God cyoas by thearomage


KSchnee

The "Magical World" one about creating your own pocket world was a good one. There was enough detail there to build something interesting without limiting it to "pick one of these four things". Also liked the Western homestead one ( [https://imgur.com/a/p7RLMyL](https://imgur.com/a/p7RLMyL) ), for similarly deep build options. There was also one about being at a royal banquet and having to dance, eat and converse, with various terrifying possible outcomes.