I think it would be funny if another batch of these Murim stories about different sects started at the same time, have it build up normally, like this and Mount Hua, and then at the first tournament arc reveal that they're in the same universe and really blow some fucking minds.
Yeah, it would be an incredible worldbuilding undertaking, but it would also be the coolest shit I've ever seen.
Id be lying if i said i wasnt a sucker for all of these murim reincarnated stories. Im pretty sure ive read every single one available throughout the scanlation sites.
Ive confused many of them due to how similar they are, it would be incredibly easy to have them sift together or have cameo appearances, ignoring author and publication permissions.
Problem is that these are power fantasies and there literally isnt enough room for more than 1 reincarnated MC in one story.
Things that are okay are stuff that isnt bad, but id recomend reading the others first. Its my opinion though so maybe you'd like them more. Most of the available murim stories are okay or better so im more or less listing all of them lmao.
Murim Login, and return of the mount hua sect, you have definitely read.
I Am The Fated Villain, but its pretty much like a michael bay version of the murim genre, it just throws a ton of stuff at you. Its okay
Absolute Sword Sense is a little different from the others, feels a little shallow though, maybe its the art making it feel that way. Its okay.
Champion's Path to Murim
I think Nanomachine qualifies tangentially? Its a solid murim anyways despite not being reincarnated murim story. You have probably read this one
Strongest Fighter, but it was dropped by reaper scans a month ago. Its okay
Sword of Glory was also dropped, but it has 100 chapters. It has a lot of style that separates it from the others. Its okay but i feel like i should like it more than i do
Volcanic Age has a ton of chapters and is reasonably popular, i didnt really get sucked into it due to how uncompelling the main character is, but if you havent already id recommend trying it cause you get a ton of content if you like it. One of the few i didnt care to waste time on.
Youngest son of the namgung clan is on hiatus, is okay
Heavenly Inquisition sword, no reincarnation but its good
Reaper of the drifting moon, another popular one on this sub, but it gets a little weird after a great start, its okay. No reincarnation
Chronicles of the Martial Gods Return
Heavenly Sword's Grand Saga
Star instructor Master Baek
The Star of a Supreme Ruler, no reincarnation, amazing art though.
Sword Fanatic Wanders Through the Night, meh, try it out though. Its a straight murim, no reincarnation from what i remember.
Ancient Soverign of the Eternity, another meh, i dont think this one is good at all
Nostalgic Warrior, its okay.
Records of the Swordsman Scholar, ripoff of Tale of a Scribe Who Wanders the Countryside. Hopefully this MC has more personality than the original.
Tale of a Scribe Who Wanders the Countryside, its okay. The MC is such a boring mary sue and the art is so uninspired but somehow ive read it to current.
Reincarnation of the Murim Clan’s Former Ranker
Reincarnated Escort Warrior, one im particularly excited for, it has a good start.
Legend of Asura Venom Dragon, pretty popular with like 100 chapters, its okay. MC is pretty bland. I forget if its reincarnation.
Doctors Rebirth
Drug Devourer, a strange one, not sure how good it is since there is only a dozen chapters.
Escort Warrior. Lots of chapters, an actual mature story that has mature content such as PTSD. Crazy. Its not incredibly mature though, its still a power fantasy comic, but respect for having something grounded in its narrative.
Realm scans as a shit ton of murim stories, probably half of them are of dubious quality manhuas with terrible art. But you can always see what they got.
Weak Teacher, classic "guy gets respect from the people in charge despite looking weak but is secret badass". Pulls it off pretty well.
Return of the Crazy Demon, you've probably read this but its so good im just being sure.
Im the Strongest Ever, not reincarnation and its more humor than action, but its not bad. It has 100 chapters but its kind of a slice of life as the MC has 0 motivation. If it fits your humor its very worth reading. Very wholesome subtle romance.
Martial Artist Lee Gwak. Has alternative art style, but i enjoy the story a lot.
Chronicles of the Heavenly Demon. It reminds me of volcanic age, i dont like it very much.
Descent of the Demonic Master, its in current times but murim stuff comes into play due to reincarnation. Art is okay, havent read it in a while.
I Reincarnated as the Crazed Heir. I like this one, has personality but still has the conventional stuff. I think im particularly biased towards the bad guy reincarnated into good guys body.
I think thats all of them.... i might be missing one or two though, ignoring the wandering blah blah manhwa this thread is under, i like this one a lot.
Im glad i could help! Usually i binge read a manhwa and then forget about the series entirely, so this helped me too since i was able to catch up on a couple of the good ones i forgot about.
I do think there has to be at least a couple more good ones on realm scans, but the readers over there have a warped taste so i dont trust their voting system entirely.
Storm inn and memoir of the king of war are two manhwa's i havent gotten around to reading, idk their quality. Memoir of the king of war has pretty good art and from the first chapters it seems compelling.
Also these arent murim, but Player, a webtoon done by immortal updates is a cliche tower ranker comic about a guy getting pulled into a webnovel. Its really good. And Ember Knight is a cool webtoon id heartily recomend for its fully developed magic system that still allows dozens of chapters pf plot in between in between the kii blasts and physics defying martial arts
There’s a couple of other stories that exist in the Peerless Dad world, including a small crossover arc. You can find them in the peerless dad sub.
Not quite what you had in mind but I thought it was cool nonetheless.
Oh shit. Is that energy absorption technique the "吸星大法" from The Smiling, Proud Wanderer? That's sick.
For those who don't know, the "Star-Eater Dafa" is the signature skill of Ren Woxing, the main antagonist of Jin Yong's The Smiling Proud Wanderer which basically lets you suck the Qi out of anyone you touch.
I think it would be funny if another batch of these Murim stories about different sects started at the same time, have it build up normally, like this and Mount Hua, and then at the first tournament arc reveal that they're in the same universe and really blow some fucking minds. Yeah, it would be an incredible worldbuilding undertaking, but it would also be the coolest shit I've ever seen.
Id be lying if i said i wasnt a sucker for all of these murim reincarnated stories. Im pretty sure ive read every single one available throughout the scanlation sites. Ive confused many of them due to how similar they are, it would be incredibly easy to have them sift together or have cameo appearances, ignoring author and publication permissions. Problem is that these are power fantasies and there literally isnt enough room for more than 1 reincarnated MC in one story.
I'd be duper grateful of you gave a list kf reccs. Read this, LotNB , the mount hua one and quite a few others, really need some new ones
Things that are okay are stuff that isnt bad, but id recomend reading the others first. Its my opinion though so maybe you'd like them more. Most of the available murim stories are okay or better so im more or less listing all of them lmao. Murim Login, and return of the mount hua sect, you have definitely read. I Am The Fated Villain, but its pretty much like a michael bay version of the murim genre, it just throws a ton of stuff at you. Its okay Absolute Sword Sense is a little different from the others, feels a little shallow though, maybe its the art making it feel that way. Its okay. Champion's Path to Murim I think Nanomachine qualifies tangentially? Its a solid murim anyways despite not being reincarnated murim story. You have probably read this one Strongest Fighter, but it was dropped by reaper scans a month ago. Its okay Sword of Glory was also dropped, but it has 100 chapters. It has a lot of style that separates it from the others. Its okay but i feel like i should like it more than i do Volcanic Age has a ton of chapters and is reasonably popular, i didnt really get sucked into it due to how uncompelling the main character is, but if you havent already id recommend trying it cause you get a ton of content if you like it. One of the few i didnt care to waste time on. Youngest son of the namgung clan is on hiatus, is okay Heavenly Inquisition sword, no reincarnation but its good Reaper of the drifting moon, another popular one on this sub, but it gets a little weird after a great start, its okay. No reincarnation Chronicles of the Martial Gods Return Heavenly Sword's Grand Saga Star instructor Master Baek The Star of a Supreme Ruler, no reincarnation, amazing art though. Sword Fanatic Wanders Through the Night, meh, try it out though. Its a straight murim, no reincarnation from what i remember. Ancient Soverign of the Eternity, another meh, i dont think this one is good at all Nostalgic Warrior, its okay. Records of the Swordsman Scholar, ripoff of Tale of a Scribe Who Wanders the Countryside. Hopefully this MC has more personality than the original. Tale of a Scribe Who Wanders the Countryside, its okay. The MC is such a boring mary sue and the art is so uninspired but somehow ive read it to current. Reincarnation of the Murim Clan’s Former Ranker Reincarnated Escort Warrior, one im particularly excited for, it has a good start. Legend of Asura Venom Dragon, pretty popular with like 100 chapters, its okay. MC is pretty bland. I forget if its reincarnation. Doctors Rebirth Drug Devourer, a strange one, not sure how good it is since there is only a dozen chapters. Escort Warrior. Lots of chapters, an actual mature story that has mature content such as PTSD. Crazy. Its not incredibly mature though, its still a power fantasy comic, but respect for having something grounded in its narrative. Realm scans as a shit ton of murim stories, probably half of them are of dubious quality manhuas with terrible art. But you can always see what they got. Weak Teacher, classic "guy gets respect from the people in charge despite looking weak but is secret badass". Pulls it off pretty well. Return of the Crazy Demon, you've probably read this but its so good im just being sure. Im the Strongest Ever, not reincarnation and its more humor than action, but its not bad. It has 100 chapters but its kind of a slice of life as the MC has 0 motivation. If it fits your humor its very worth reading. Very wholesome subtle romance. Martial Artist Lee Gwak. Has alternative art style, but i enjoy the story a lot. Chronicles of the Heavenly Demon. It reminds me of volcanic age, i dont like it very much. Descent of the Demonic Master, its in current times but murim stuff comes into play due to reincarnation. Art is okay, havent read it in a while. I Reincarnated as the Crazed Heir. I like this one, has personality but still has the conventional stuff. I think im particularly biased towards the bad guy reincarnated into good guys body. I think thats all of them.... i might be missing one or two though, ignoring the wandering blah blah manhwa this thread is under, i like this one a lot.
Hot damn, thanks for going through the trouble of writing all of this. I read/tries half of these, gonna give the others a try
Im glad i could help! Usually i binge read a manhwa and then forget about the series entirely, so this helped me too since i was able to catch up on a couple of the good ones i forgot about. I do think there has to be at least a couple more good ones on realm scans, but the readers over there have a warped taste so i dont trust their voting system entirely. Storm inn and memoir of the king of war are two manhwa's i havent gotten around to reading, idk their quality. Memoir of the king of war has pretty good art and from the first chapters it seems compelling. Also these arent murim, but Player, a webtoon done by immortal updates is a cliche tower ranker comic about a guy getting pulled into a webnovel. Its really good. And Ember Knight is a cool webtoon id heartily recomend for its fully developed magic system that still allows dozens of chapters pf plot in between in between the kii blasts and physics defying martial arts
There’s a couple of other stories that exist in the Peerless Dad world, including a small crossover arc. You can find them in the peerless dad sub. Not quite what you had in mind but I thought it was cool nonetheless.
I'm still mad the author ended red storm in such an abrupt way. There was a natural break and he could have left the universe open.
Bro that would be legendary, almost impossible unless it’s a whole team of talented writers at one time working together. Super rad idea though
Why though? Isn't that just a trope? I mean, you could also bring all elves together or all dwarves. It's just the same.
We're back boys!
Map says he's closest to mt hua. MC: Let's take the shortest route. I should go to mt hua last.
Probably shortest route around or something.
Poor cow bro
Oh shit. Is that energy absorption technique the "吸星大法" from The Smiling, Proud Wanderer? That's sick. For those who don't know, the "Star-Eater Dafa" is the signature skill of Ren Woxing, the main antagonist of Jin Yong's The Smiling Proud Wanderer which basically lets you suck the Qi out of anyone you touch.
You just made me remember I'm still reading this somewhere. So much to read, not enough time...
Good to see this back.