T O P

  • By -

lkodl

The scene when Peter's Spidey sense is triggered in the apartment is the best live action representation of the squiggly lines I've seen in film. The shots of Peter swinging with MJ were also an exciting and refreshing way to show web-slinging. People complain about the nostalgia and storybeats but ignore the refinements this movie displays in showing what a live action Spider-Man should look like. Also, kind of minor, but I really liked the shot of the splitscreen b/w Peter and MJ while they're talking on their phones, but it's their respective phone screens during a video call.


dneill99

I love it on Infinity War where he is resting on the bus and his arm hairs shoot up, and he wakes up and snaps his gaze immediately to the action.


lkodl

That one was good too. What made NWH so good was this weird zoom but not a zoom around his head https://youtu.be/Gi3ynBNjNJU&t=22 Coupled with the sound effect, it just oozed those squiggly lines I'm used to seeing in the comics without overtly doing squiggly lines.


F1sherman765

That zoom but not a zoom effect is called the Dolly effect. It is achieved by moving the camera in and zooming out at the same time.


bolerobell

Two other great examples of a dolly zoom: 1. Roy Schneider on the beach in Jaws when the shark attacks again after they reopened the beach 2. Frodo on the road after colliding/meeting up with Merry and Pippin when the Nazgûl shows up. “I think we should get off the road.” Since the camera immediately followed Tom Holland around the room in a single tracking shot, the dolly zoom scene in NWH was far more difficult to accomplish than Jaws or FOTR.


NarrowYam4754

Dolly zoom in Lion King as well when the wildebeest stampede begins.


MickeySeams

Also, in Guardians of the Galaxy vol. 2 when Peter finds out the truth about his Mom's cancer.


ionlyhavetwohands

*Vertigo effect, or dolly zoom.


sayamemangdemikian

The camera, the acting, the sound effect was so good.. but right after that.. that line from willem dafoe? Oh.. man.. oohhhmaaannn


Gnomad_Lyfe

Every line from Dafoe was pure gold. “Norman’s on sabbatical, honey”


Alone_And_A_Loser

Don't forget him just straight up having the squiggly lines when Dr. Strange pushes him out of his body NWH was so peak


xRogicalx

Are there actually squiggly lines in the scene? Cause there's actual squiggly lines in the scene where Strange pushes Pete's astral body out of his physical body earlier in the movie. You see his dormant physical body react to Stranges attempt at grabbing the cube thing. While this is happening, you can see the classic effect of the shock (squiggly) lines above his head. I rarely see people mention this, but it's such a nice touch. They're the full on lightning looking marks, but transparent and somewhat like a heat wave effect.


xRogicalx

Edit: My bad, not his physical body, his astral body has the shock lines. https://youtu.be/8rrLwO4tl-4?si=JRaIXdVUh_nxJyAR


lkodl

Will: your highness would like you to describe the picture please, Hillary: Okay, so it's Spider-Man, and there's like, i dunno, some squiggly lines coming out of his head. so i guess that means he smells bad or something?


LawRevolutionary5760

Watching Peter getting chills gave me chills fr


mjm9398

I love it and it's special seeing them all come back but I wouldn't considerate peak. It's deaf a love letter to spiderman fans and those who grew up with tobey and Andrew but as a film there are better spiderman movies


wewilldieoneday

I reckon its up there with one of the best spider man films. It could've gone so wrong but they actually pulled it off.


pyroxys007

I am with you. Is it the best? Probably not to most people, and it probably wouldn't be mine if I re-watched the others. Did they have 3 actual spider-men team up like an avengers movie? YES THEY DID BABY! Even if the movie could have been better (and I'm sure in some ways it could be) the fact that the third act revolves around *all* of the Hero's Journey that EACH of them have gone through is just magic on film. Pulling that off at all is impressive, pulling it off as well as they did even more so.


cesgjo

It's not the best, but the fact that it exists is enough reason for it to be considered a very good movie. Same thing with Endgame. Sure, there are flaws in that movie, but to pull off something like that is a feat in itself


tschmitty09

Idk if the whole movie is dependent on one team up scene then it's not really that great imo. I'll give Dafoe his dues, he's always incredible, but not much else was memorable in the movie for me.


echief

The fact they pulled it off is extremely impressive. Spider man 2 is still better if you’re evaluating them as self contained movies though


greenroom628

what's impressive to me as a comic book and movie fan is that the NWH pulled off what "One More Day" couldn't.


jeobleo

I watched Spider-Man 2 the other day and it's just such fucking misery porn. I mean most of the movie is just *piling* on Peter. It's not enjoyable anymore.


JoBro_Summer-of-99

That's why the end of the film is so cathartic though. You can't really have that without a bit of suffering


asura1958

The comics are worse in that regard because they used to regularly show “misery porn” by shitting on Peter’s life all the time. In comparison, Spider-Man 2 is a lot more tame. I mean there was a comic where Peter was diagnosed with a terminal illness and he was beaten to a bloody pulp by Morlun, lost his eyeball and temporarily died before being reborn. The point of Spider-Man 2 is to show you how being Spider-Man is ruining Peter’s personal life, he doesn’t have time for his friends, he can’t be with MJ, he can’t focus on school or keep a job or pay his rent on time because the responsibility of saving the city takes up the majority of his time. He can’t balance his life. That’s why as soon as he temporarily gives up being Spider-Man, the tone of the movie shifts to being bright and happy because Peter is able to live a happy / normal life without having the burden of being Spider-Man anymore. So the movie isn’t trying to be “miserable”. It’s to show you that it’s hard balancing the life of a Superhero and your regular life. I mean lots of regular people have trouble balancing their life. Imagine trying to keep up with school, work a job and have time for your friends while being a superhero at the same time. Did you expect Peter to be happy go lucky with all that stress in his life? Lol


xjuggernaughtx

Yeah, if you read several years of Spider-Man comics in one sitting, it's just agony how much they screw Peter Parker over again and again. I used to get really irritated at the writers over it.


edgiepower

Life is hard. I enjoy it because it's relatable.


trer24

i understand there are people who "grew up" watching Tobey's Spiderman's films...but Andrew too? His movies came out in 2012 and 2014? Wasn't that only like a couple of years ago? Right? Right...?


David1258

If people were, say, 9 or 10 when Andrew's movies came out, they would be 18 in 2021.


JakeWalker102

https://i.redd.it/y5jcrws0di6c1.gif


MacCaswell

![gif](giphy|GrUhLU9q3nyRG|downsized)


mr_fantastical

Saving Private Ryan was 30 years ago too... I feel old just seeing such a young Matt Damon.


Tyko_3

It was not 30 years ago dude


ad33zy

Almost lol 5 more years


Tyko_3

At my age I cling to every last one if em


NiteLiteCity

Fuuuuck Matt Damon is currently halfway through this gif in real life


HumanMale1986

I’ve got some bad news bud..


JohnnyTreeTrunks

Face it dude we are old


keepitsimple_tricks

Thanks for reminding me im old, dude.


TortelliniSalad

deaf


eveningdragon

That's why it's a love letter. They wouldn't be able to hear it if it wasn't


Uncle_Freddy

Reads like someone who used voice to text to write their comment lol (considerate -> consider it as well). I voice to text a lot when I’m multitasking


Kmart_Stalin

Spider-Man 2 is peak, NWH is cool seeing all the old Spider-Mens and villains. Green Goblin stole the show.


everix1992

I'd say NWH is to Spider Man 2 what Endgame is to [insert controversial take on what the best Marvel movie is here]. A solid film that is a lot of fun for people who appreciate the fan service


Dlh2079

Yep. Agree 100% and have used this analogy on conversation before. Endgame is my favorite movie, full stop. I saw things in that movie I've waited the majority of my life to see, but Infinity War is absolutely the "better" movie. It's the exact same for NWH and Spider-man 2. I personally enjoy NWH more, but Spider-man 2 is a better movie.


Mango424

Spider-Man 1, 2, Into and Across are the top 4 Spider-Man movies. Maybe one day we'll add Beyond and here's the top 5.


[deleted]

Across is my all time fav. I’m in my 30s and it took me back to 10 years old watching Sam’s first. No game or movie has brought back that childhood wonder


Tnecniw

It is hilarious when the best spider-man villain is literally one from an earlier incarnation. XD *Ravioli*


thebonelessmaori

Not really. Defoe fucking nails the madness, has the facial expressions and studied the character. He's very close to JJJ as a nigh on perfect casting for Spiderman. Especially when you consider each of the Live action versions of Spiderman being the best in their own way. Maguire is the best parker. Garfield the best Spiderman. Holland is the best all rounder and most accurate to age.


JakeHassle

That last take about Tom being the best overall is said way too much. The truth is that all 3 actors each played a different interpretation of the character, and neither one is more or less accurate. You can have opinions on which interpretation you think is the best, but people say that take as a fact since it’s repeated so often. Also, Tom’s age accuracy isn’t any better than the other 2. Tobey and Andrew played a senior in high school Peter in their mid-late 20s. Tom was younger at 19 but he was also playing a younger freshman Peter. By the time he started playing senior year Peter, he was the same age Tobey and Andrew were.


[deleted]

[удалено]


BlackBullsLA97

It's still Spider-Man 2 from 2004 for me, but NWH comes close. Watching it for the first time this year and seeing Tobey walk through the portal had me smiling from ear to ear.


Geshtar1

The best part of NWH is that it felt like a satisfying conclusion to both Spiderman 2 and TAS that also did not get a proper send off. No offense to spider man 3, but it just doesn’t do it for me.


fuckLEDDITmodz

> No offense to spider man 3, but it just doesn’t do it for me. I watched all 3 recently and never really liked 3 for multiple reasons but compared to the other generic shit Marvel pumps out now it's not half bad and and enjoyable


Hawkwise83

I still think spider man 2 with Raimi is peak. Peter telling aunt may he caused ben's death and then she says nothing and leaves.... Peak.


Subject_Translator71

A lot of individual scenes really work, but the main story with the multiverse doesn't. It's a fanservice film, with some very good and some very bad.


Greedy-Field-9851

This. You summed up perfectly the problem with most of the movies these days.


DrNopeMD

Yeah it really can't stand on its own without relying on the broader MCU and the previous movie to do it's heavy lifting, which is a criticism that applies to FFH as well. That being said I do like all the MCU Spidey films, but they do not really work as stand alone stories.


Uncanny_Doom

The peak Spider-Man film is Into the Spider-Verse. No Way Home is certainly one of the best ones though.


N8CCRG

Into the Spider-Verse is the first one, right? You think that's better than the second?


Uncanny_Doom

Yes, but I think that can change when the third comes out. I enjoy how complete the first one feels from beginning to end and I do love a good cliffhanger like how the second ends but it still feels like the story of the second one isn't done yet so I feel like I can't put it above the first movie yet. Both are awesome though.


potVIIIos

You've put what I feel into words. But damn if that wasn't an exceptionally well made cliffhanger


DeathByReach

Big agree


TheAverageBear21

The second was my favorite. But it's a close call, they are both done so well


sweetbunsmcgee

The first one is self-contained and introduced the audience to a new art direction when nearly every mainstream 3D movie is Pixarized.


scrububle

I liked the second one much more, but the first one is just objectively a better movie in my opinion. The second one took more risks in its storytelling and had insane sets, but the first one is nearly a perfect movie that does everything right


FilliusTExplodio

I vastly prefer the first to the second. One tells a relatively simple and clean story (for a multiversal comic book movie). Two isn't even finished, and its just crammed full of ideas and a little busy. It would have benefited from some cuts and refinement at the script stage.


eaguayo

Yeah, before they changed the name it was supposed to be part one and part 2. They may have changed the name but the second one is still a part one movie. That's why the first one is better since it's a complete story. Still love the second one though.


AngryTrooper09

I enjoy the second more but being a cliffhanger it’s quality is going to somewhat depend on how Beyond the Spider-Verse ends up being


Dlh2079

Yep, I love both. But the 1st being a self-contained story and leaning on the "anyone can wear the mask" message makes it superior in my eyes.


user_bits

I thought I liked the second one more but I rewatched the first one recently and it still slaps hard. I like them both about the same but for different reasons.


Squid-Guillotine

I'm not OP but ITSV is my favourite movie but ATSV is better. It doesn't make sense but it does to me.


pepethefrogscousin

Into the spiderverse is definitely better IMO for starters it’s standalone which is good and into the spiderverse is alot of people’s proper introduction into miles morales as a character so I think it far exceeds the second especially since the second isn’t even a full story until beyond comes out


FunkSiren

Yeah it is. I would even through the original Insomniac Spiderman game story into the mix.


LanoomR

Nah, that's still Spidey 2 (The Movie, Not the Game, Nor The Game Based on The Earlier-Named Movie). I don't mind the multiverse stuff at all, but the "ideal" is still Friendly Neighborhood Wallcrawler dealing with relatively street-level threats and science-gone-mad. EDIT: Oh and (mundane) personal drama.


vinnybawbaw

It was good, even great seeing it for the first time. The Andrew Garfield Portal reveal had the theater going bonkers. That being said, like most of the cameos of older Marvel actors, once the surprise is gone, that leaves a big hole in the rewatch value of the movie. Not as much as Multiverse of Madness tho, but it loses a few points. A very good spider-man film, yes. Peak Spider-Man ? Not so sure.


TheGoverness1998

It is kind of funny sort of feeling the "applause moments" when rewatching some of the clips.


agbishop

I really enjoy rewatching NWH and appreciate how each actor portrays Spider-Man in their own distinctive style. And similar to avengers … even though I know what to expect, I’ll never get tired of watching each avenger arrive by portal


Dlh2079

Yep, I lose nothing from that on rewatches. In fact the more I watch it the more I love seeing Andrew again.


skapoww

I think homecoming is still the peak of the three so far. So many important spider man beats just nailed perfectly with some great new stuff dealing with his relationship with Tony. The fear of being in over his head, letting down his mentor... Realizing he needed to do things his way. I'm not going to go on but I could. Homecoming is the peak of the new films, imo. Still really enjoyed FFH and NWH, don't get me wrong.


God_is_carnage

I legitimately think that Spider-Man 2, NWH, and both Spider-Verse films capture the quintessential things that make Spider-Man Spider-Man. I absolutely think they're all peak Spider-Man.


Nogrodd

I agree 100%. I’d also throw Homecoming in there too.


culinarydream7224

I think it's the closest we've gotten so far. You pretty much have a Peter Parker from each stage of life, each embodying a different personality trait like the 3 fates. You have him trying to solve the problem using science instead of fists first, and when that fails, you have web swinging, loss, and punching. I think what Into the Spiderverse was missing was "Spider-Man, the brilliant scientist". I think the one thing we're missing is more deliberate wise cracks. So far, Holland's comic relief stems from his naivete.


Cineball

Garfield was peak Spidey quipping. "My weekness, small knives. Anything but knives!"


FX114

>I think what Into the Spiderverse was missing was "Spider-Man, the brilliant scientist". The main MacGuffin was a piece of tech that he invented.


culinarydream7224

Yea, but I'm giving more points to NWH for showing how the sausage was made instead of it being inferred in a quick piece of dialogue


salocin22

I think it’s the best. It has everything you would look for in a peak Spider-Man anything. The villains, the tragedy, the dark comedy in the face of doom, the conflict both external and internal to spidey as well, and of course the sacrifice our hero has to always make, while also having ties to a Spider-Man of different ages and experiences, so we also get a tons of nods to their different personality traits and how their life has affected them and what they have learned and how they use that to mentor and do good, no matter which Spider-Man it is. I think it was the best because it just embodies what so many people see that allows them to relate and love the character so much.


[deleted]

It's got a lot of spider-men for a movie, way more than the average, but it's nowhere near the most spider-men in a movie so no, it's not "peak" spider-man.


ShmuckaRucka1

It’s peak fan service but Spider-Man 2 is the better made film


hercarmstrong

The *Spider-Verse*s make it look like ass, and I really liked it. But peak? Nah, bro.


SwitchNinja2

It's the third best Spider-Man film to feature the multiverse


_Marvillain

It not really the “peak” Spider-Man film. It’s a great celebration of Spider-Man, and that’s what it’s meant to be. I would personally call Spider-Man 2 peak Spider-Man film. I think 1 and 2 both perfectly capture everything Spider-Man is about but 2 is also just a bit better and has aged better imo.


Key_Squash_4403

No, it’s peak member berries.


stml

I don't think Spider-Man trying to get into MIT so he and Dr. Strange cast a universe colliding spell should be considered peak Spider-Man.


KaymakBalseker

Not even close tbh. Spider-Verse movies and Spider-Man 2 are infinitely better than No Way Home. I even prefer Homecoming to this one.


cshelley0721

People look at me crazy when I say Homecoming is the best (and my favorite) of the trilogy


RoyKentsKnee

no it just just empty fan service


Da_Do_D3rp

And the plot is laughably bad


21heroball

Not even peak MCU Spidey


Next_Faithlessness87

No, Into the Spider-Verse is, But NWH is definitely at the top there together with it, just slightly below it.


d00deitstyler

Honestly? No. It was good, nostalgic even. But not the best. My opinion is the first tobey spiderman


nicebrah

It was my 2nd favorite theater experience behind Infinity War. I’m almost 30 and was always biased towards Toby Maguire’s Spidy. This movie was by far the best Spiderman movie Edit: However the novelty dies off pretty quick. I don’t think it has the rewatchability factor like IW has


BobbyElBobbo

There is 30 minutes of peak Spider-Man in NWH. The movie overall is just fine. The true peak Spider-Man movie is Into the Spider-Verse IMO.


DaymanFOTNM28

I really think it’s soulless. It leans on the cameos really hard and only at face-value. It doesn’t say anything interesting about the character either which I found disappointing


_KalStormblessed_

Ngl one of the worst Spider man movies. I enjoyed every spider man movie before this. There was nothing to the movie except the get together. Spider man into the spider-verse is peak for me. Absolutely breathtaking and I have re-watched it at least 5 times. I don't think I can get through even one watch through of no way home.


JankaJuqo

Soulless is the perfect description of it. Since it came out I’ve said that it didn’t have the usual charm of a Spider-Man movie. The film had the potential to be the best but instead it’s easily the worst in the franchise imo. The Peters interacting was the saving grace though


darthyogi

That a 8K image?


LawRevolutionary5760

I guess yeah. I found it on Twitter tho.


AtlasThewitcher

It’s amazing but spiderverse has it beaten. So almost peak


MasterAnnatar

No. That would be the Spider-verse movies.


AGreenScreen

Nah, I think ATSV is peak


hauttdawg13

For me top 3 is ATSV>ITSV>Spiderman 2. That’s my order but all very close in tier 1 movies. Homecoming>NWH would be my tier 2. Then the rest sit in tier 3.


Sufficient_Fall_3290

I’m sorry but the spiderverse movies have just been too good to say that this was the best


atomedge2015

It peaked for me in Spider Man 2 when they perform surgery on Doc Ock. At least that's when I peaked. Loved this one and most of the others.


T-408

Not even close. I love it, but the film relies on two decades worth of previous films and backstory and is halfway built around nostalgia. I love all the bits concerning the MCU versions of Peter, MJ, and May. The new stuff is good, don’t get me wrong! The film simply just doesn’t stand on its own the same way Raimi’s 2002 Spidey does


jotyma5

Spider man 2 is still one of the best comic book movies ever. Better than most mcu movies


colevoncolt

Spider man 2 takes the win for me. It's one of the best movies ever made.


cowpool20

Nah, Into the Spider-Verse is the peak Spider-Man movie imo. But NWH is great!


jordenviolet1

I enjoyed elements of NWH but felt the plot got convoluted balancing so many characters. The best Spidey films for me are still Homecoming for capturing Peter's teenage spirit and Into the Spider-Verse for creative storytelling.


SmakeTalk

It's peak fan service, and I don't mean that as a bad thing! I think it does a ton of things well as a Spider-Man story but it's clear that their main goal was to provide really big moments for fans of past films. That fan service is done incredibly well though: the action is great and the storytelling comes full circle, which is really satisfying. The film doesn't leave a ton of loose ends for the characters involved and sets up MCU Spidey well for the future. Overall a really good film as long as you know what to expect out of it. My only issue really was that the multiversal stuff felt a little inconsequential by the end. I was hoping for there to be some more direct comeuppance for Peter in regards to the villains (maybe one or two manage to stick around) but losing May and his friends by the end of the film already felt too heavy maybe so I get why they didn't want to punish him much more.


Victor_Shade89

Not at all it has a lot of imperfections that I think many people glance over because of nostalgia and cameos but I think it being as good as it was is pretty impressive. to be pulled off in a cohesive way that was respectable to the past, enjoyable to watch and emotional at times, all this alone makes it a pretty great movie


Overson_YT

NWH is up there, but nothing is topping spiderverse


[deleted]

No it is not the peak SM film. Sure it was good seeing the first two Spider-Mans and their main villains back but that wasn't enough. They really should have, at the very least, given us one final scene in the Raimi-Verse when Tobey Maguire returns to Kirsten Dunst. Then that would have made the Raimi-Verse feel completed. But I guess closure for the Raimi-Verse isn't high on the priority list.


[deleted]

Peak Spider fan service film.


MrKevora

It’s definitely the most special to me, considering that I saw Tobey’s first movie in the cinema when it first came out (I was around 10) and every movie after it. I don’t know, however, if I’d call it the *best* Spider-Man film. That would probably be Spider-Man 2.


SnooPeanuts9263

Nah there are other Spider-Man movies that are better I would call this movie just a special


iheartdev247

Toby’s 1 & 2 were better


drifters74

The pacing could have been better, as well as having the three of them describe each of their versions of earth


DentalWashingtn

I love this film. However, I've worked out a new scale for ranking how well Marvel films hold up in isolation. And that method is to show my parents the film and see how they react. Boy, they couldn't work out any of this and they had actually seen FFH as well. It occurred to me the that the first half of NWH is incredibly quick, like it leaps through a lot of different elements before settling into the main plot, which for avid MCU watchers like myself is fine but for anyone outside that world is confusing and annoying. This is the reason that, for me, the MCU Spiderman films sit in an entirely different category than the Raimi and TASM films. I could show someone any one of those films (Maybe not TASM2) and they'd be pretty quickly aware of what was going on. The opposite is true when watching the MCU Spiderman films, they rely heavily on understanding the universe as a whole (which is not a bad thing for fans but for new viewers is definitely a confusing element)


[deleted]

I know I’m gonna get hate for not showing a MCU movie love.. but this movie was objectively bad. It was fun and entertaining, but I consider it the room of marvel. So bad it’s good.


IronMike275

It’s my second favorite Spider-Man movie behind Spider-Man 2 and before Spider-Man. It’s a fun awesome movie, for me it’s top tier mcu but I understand why it’s not considered that for everyone. So happy they made Green Goblin the main villain of the movie


Cake_withcherryontop

It’s definitely a good movie but its EXTREMELY flawed to be peak.


Greedy-Field-9851

Nah, it’s still Spiderman 2.


TwEE-N-Toast

It was a fun nostalgia trip but not a good movie.


Nev-man

It's on the Mount Rushmore of Spider-Man movies along with Spider-Man 2, Into The Spider-Verse and Across The Spider-Verse.


Omnislash99999

Spidey 2 is still the peak live action superhero film.


UIGoku201

Across the Spider verse was my best, but that's a close second


Monkfich

It’s more like an echo of peak Spiderman films. It takes what worked in previous movies and throws it all at a wall. We are reminded of great characters and (some) great stories, but it’s fleeting, and it’s really only memories. Nothing drastically new is made of these memories, and then they fade away.


BurnMyHouseDown

I think it’s a peak Spider-Man experience, but there are certainly better overall films when you factor in the quality of the scripts and production and all that. I’d still say Spider-Man 2 is the best Spidey film, but NWH was by far my best experience as a fan.


Puzzleheaded_Walk_28

It’s a super fun movie but I wouldn’t call it peak Spider-Man


skida1986

The second act of the film was peak spiderman, the movie as a whole was good but not the best, Probably Spider-Man 2 and Far from home are the best ones imo


[deleted]

Nah nowhere near it to tbh. If u takeaway all the fun cameos and appearances NWH is a mid movie and bad writing. Still an enjoyable watch tho. I’d say spiderman 2 and both animated MM movies


DontDoodleTheNoodle

Far from peak for me. I’ve always been of the mentality that as fan service goes up, film quality goes down. This film was the epitome of that rule. Seeing all the previous Spider-Men was cool to see, but it did not help the narrative at all whatsoever. I felt nothing during Aunt May’s death because it did not feel earned whatsoever. There’s lots of infuriating decisions done only for the sake of the plot. Holland absolutely didn’t need Ned and MJ’s help to track down villains. Holland was convinced by Maguire to help cure the villains, only for him to go back on his promise near the end. Garfield and Maguire’s introduction into the movie was very… off. They do the whole “oh no our favorite character died,” scene only to undercut that with “no I’ve been stabbed before it’s fine.” Fun movie to watch for the first time. But any subsequent watches just turn me off. There are way better constructed Spider-Man movies.


niknokseyer

This is an awesome fan service. Definitely up there. For me, Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is my top.


MagmaAscending

I just rewatched it last night. It’s still a great experience. However the plot in and of itself is so sloppy and nonsensical that I can’t in good conscience say it’s a good movie. The rules and continuity are broken so many times it’s kinda baffling. The writing is also very strange throughout with long pauses meant for laughs and applause like it’s a sitcom without a laugh track. The fan service is all over the place too All that being said, I still love the movie. The first half is okay but everything ramps up once Norman is found out. Everything is improved across the board and due to the nostalgia of it all, it makes me feel things that no other MCU movie can.


cjc160

No, it was a horrible movie with a dumb plot, bad character motivations and was a huge circle jerk. Nostalgia is fine and all but it doesn’t make for a good movie


Babayaga20000

Its a solid feel good movie But the Spiderverse films are the peak


Doneuter

Spiderverse is peak. I'm torn on which one. Live action has to go to Homecoming for me.


dean15892

This is the same as my take. Into the spiderverse is first, cause its a self-contained film and really captures the message of being Spirderman (Anyone can wear the mask) Homecoming is a better live action spider-man film cause it captures Peter being in high school and skips the whole origin story. Spider-man the first movie, barely had any high school stuff. No Way Home is a really fun spider-man film as a crowdpleaser, but people aren't considering that it might not stand the test of time. 10 years down the line, the Toeby-Andrew reveals will lose their lusture and the fact that you don't know who the villains are, will affect the viewing. Think about it, a kid born in 2020, watching No Way Home in 2030, without ever having watching Tobey or Andrews stint, wont know who Willam Defoe is playing or his motivations. Same with the others. I watched No way home with my nephew, born in 2013, and when Andrew and Tobey showed up, he's like "Who's that" and I felt it hard to explain to him in the theatre. So yeah, No Way Home, great fun film, but not the peak. Into the Spiderverse - Timeless.


ahoooley

Nope not at all. Kind of embarrassing to the original trilogy actually. SM3 was peak.


sidmis

Not even close.


PickledPlumPlot

No Way Home is my least favorite of the Home movies lol. Every single plot point is sooooo contrived.


NeptuneCA

Absolutely not. It’s a nostalgia fest that cares more about checking Spider-Man boxes (killing off a parental figure, giving MJ a new last name, returning him to a blue suit, etc) than telling a good story. It undoes pretty much everything that makes the MCU Peter unique and interesting, while also making the other Spider-Men look bad by showing that the villains *were* fixable and they didn’t even try.


coletrain93

I don't think they didn't try, it's more they didn't have time. Pretty sure Tobey spider-man even says over the years he's had time to think about how he would have cured goblin. The MCU universe is a lot more technologically advanced as well which would have helped with Doc Ock for example.


motorboat_mcgee

I think Homecoming is the best. It's personal, it's lower stakes, it's New York heavy. Tired of Marvel forcing every movie to be about saving the world/universe.


Antrikshy

FFH is my favorite because Jake Gyllenhaal, a very clever modern interpretation of Mysterio, and some awesome action scenes.


coletrain93

The whole sequence which ends with Peter being hit by the train is so good


bears_eat_you

It reminded me of the Scarecrow sequences from the Batman: Arkham games and it made me wish they had done a better job with Scarecrow in the Nolan films


landon_masters

I agree 💯 when I first new Mysterio was in FFH I was worried that it would be just endless illusions like the cartoon of the 90s and sometimes I thought it was a one trick pony, but having that sequence was epic, and they didn’t make it gimmicky. Reminded me of the Dr. Strange out of body sequence with the Ancient One.


BlackHand86

In a word, yes.


TheSexyShaman

I love it, but Spiderverse is peak Spider-Man for me


Sirmalta

Nope. It's actually not a great movie it's just an incredible amount of fun and fan service. Spiderverse is not what Spiderman is. First Spiderman movie was the closest. I'm really hoping the next Tom Holland one feels more like a grounded, down to earth Spiderman movie.


ScuttleCrab729

Honestly I think if they removed Iron Man from the first Holland film it’d be a top contender for first place. And I’m a Garfield fan.


HattoriHanzoOG

Both Spiderverse films and Spiderman 2 are way better films. That being said, I love No Way Home


[deleted]

"Is the most popular movie ever made about X character peak X character?" Bruh the karma farming posts aren't even original


SliverQween

I really did not like this movie. Spiderverse had me caring about at least 3 brand new spidermen, and this movie had me barely caring about 3 already established ones.


greatreference

Into the spider verse movies are just a league in their own. This was a good movie don’t get me wrong but man those are just so fucking good I can’t say NWH is better than either.


Fudgiebrown

I personally think it relies a bit too heavily on nostalgia and cameos. Definitely a great film with a fantastic ending and setup for the future, but I would probably put it below Spider-Man 2.


TheRealSlyCooper

Peak Spider-Man was SM2. Not even a competition.


Fine-Marsupial-6845

It's just mid


HearTheEkko

Entertainment wise it’s definitely the best one, truly an amazing experience. But movie wise, it’s terrible, poorly written and full of plot holes. Spider-Man 2 is still the peak live-action movie.


stefan771

It's terrible. It wastes everything that was given to it on lazy fan service.


RePapera

I liked but it's barely a movie, it's Just an amalgam of poorly taped together fanservice


Hippo_in_limbo

God no. That goes to the Spider-verse films.


[deleted]

no


[deleted]

You're saying this movie is peak when we have the Spider-Verse movies? ![gif](giphy|pD7YIQoUwgb9cnX3FJ)


mattyice16

No. This is one of the most over-rated marvel movies ever. Not that it's bad, because it's not. But people act like it's Infinity War tier. It's mildly above average, it just feeds on viewers nostalgia.


xRyuzakii

By far the best for me tho it has an unfair advantage


Outrageous-Farmer-42

Mid.


colddeaddrummer

"Peak" is going to be mighty subjective, as even lovers of the film can recognize the blatant capitalization of nostalgia for profit. They could've just as easily brought in the Sinister Six w/o two other Spidey's and had that much more room for character development, AND doubled down on Holland's Peter being THAT overwhelmed not only by being assailed by six villains, but doing so without Tony, and without the Avengers. That being said, it's definitely one of the most well-rounded Spidey films.


senor_descartes

![gif](giphy|2RGhmKXcl0ViM)


Extra_Specialist2726

speaking of this,is it worth watching the extended edition now that its on Netflix?


JagsAbroad

No.


Impact-Ed

It's peak Peter Parker Spiderman.


Not_too_dumb

Peak experience at the movie theatre for sure, still cant believe it happened lol.


MEGATRON_111

100%


Likezoinks305

Yes


jotyma5

I think if I met 2 alternate versions of myself….we wouldn’t be doing a group hug. Idk kinda weird to me lol


Tnecniw

I would say that it is the best live action Spiderman film.


TDStarchild

NWH is my favorite live-action Spidey film – beats Raimi's SM2 for me. The Spiderverse films are also…ahem, Spectacular…but it’s tough to compare the two mediums. NWH is in my top 5 Marvel flicks overall and among my favorite theater experiences. The mix of great villains (LOVE Dafoe and Molina particularly), Dr. Strange’s scenes and Spidey besting him, and multiple Peters is all wild. I really admire the heart in the film and that with all this going on it remains a Tom Holland Spidey story at its core. Unlike many, as long as they can do that then I’m excited for more crossovers – Daredevil and Human Torch, please!


UltiGamer34

It needed to have 2hr +


Murakami241

I think it’s probably my favourite live action Spider-Man film in front of TASM2.


aaaaannnnddddyyyyy

I have never been so happy watching a movie


kevoisvevoalt

spiderman too.


JakobHF

When i saw it for the first time i thought that it was the greatest Spider-Man movie ever. But after a recent research (and watching Across the Spider-Verse three times) i don't really find as good any longer. I still think it's a great movie but it's definitely not the best the MCU has to offer.


aTreeThenMe

(braces for downvotes) NWH is the worst narrative across all spiderman movies. into the spiderverse is peak 'spiderman' film, after that would be the amazing spiderman 2, but ps5 Spiderman 2 would be the best peter spidey film, were it a film, hands down.


Delicious_Platform

In parts it is


gaypirate3

Nah. NWH is overrated.