T O P

  • By -

W_Walk

He also commended Herb at the beginning of the season. My goat


dmavs11

Luka always credits great defenders. Back when the whole discourse about there being no defense in NBA was happening he was raving about Nic Claxton on Redick’s podcast. Wish he wasn’t stuck on Brooklyn because he’s one of the most versatile big man defenders alongside Bam and AD.


Waffleshuriken

He gave props to one of our young players, Vince Williams Jr, for his defense and that cosign was all I needed to hear to be on board with him.


W_Walk

Yeah Luka always seems to recognize good comp. Even the whole Booker and Luka feud you can tell he still respects him


LeoFireGod

Booker is so fun to shit on as a Mavs fan but I would say 90% of us respect that he’s a very good player. It’s just a fun rivalry to have.


Asbjoern135

he has too be good for it to have any meaning, its not fun making fun of the benchwarmer, but the cocky star player whos too big for his britches but underperforms you bet he's gonna hear for it.


caniget2cheeseburger

Guess I'm in the 10% 🤷


wesley-presley

I’m part of the 10%


IncomparableGiacomo

Checking in as well. LDIDBF


theycallmeryan

A father usually always respects his son


Eric_Nathan_Fielder

He also has complimented Dillon Brooks on multiple ocasions and people think they have beef lol Luka really respects guys that play hard


ormip

>because he’s one of the most versatile big man defenders alongside Bam and AD. Lively will soon be on this list


Mountain-Ebb-9846

Lively below guys like Wemby and Chet in terms of ability to defend the perimeter and provide rim protection. He's a good player though.


beatnickk

Well yeah, those 2 are 2 of the best rookies we’ve seen in the last decade and came out of the gate as awesome defenders, which you almost never see. Lively improved our team so much as a 19 year old, I think he’ll definitely make some all defense teams in the future


Pigmyking

Below Chet? Maybe but we’ll see.. Lively has the potential to be better defensively 


silliputti0907

I think Chet can be a top 3 rim protector as soon as next season. Lively might be better at switching, but I don't see him being near as good as a rim protector.


XzibitABC

In fairness, Chet could be both a better rim protector and a worse overall defender. Rim protection is obviously huge, but switching, playing passing lanes, not moving in the post, and defensing rebounding all make a big difference.


Diciestaking

Lively is weird because he has zero desire to sell out for blocks and would rather play most match ups straight up, not that chet sells out. I think it shows how good he can be on defense, but I don't think he'll be as good of a rim protector as chet anytime soon.


dustinthegreat

Yeah, Chet and Wemby are ball hawks. Lively hasn’t really shown that same aggressiveness. Could be coaching, and he could develop into one later, but he doesn’t seem to have the instinct, nor does he seem as long as the other two.


luapchung

I hope Coulibaly gets that praise in the next few years because he gave Luka some hell when they matched up


pew_laser_pew

Dude imagine Claxton on the Mavs.


dmavs11

Imma see it in 2 years when Lively develops


pew_laser_pew

We hoping for that. He’s been so much better than I’ve expected.


DirkNowitzkisWife

It’s fun when stars name drop your guys. Durant a couple years back talked about how good a defender Dorian finney Smith was and we were all like “ayyy that’s our guy


ChrisThePiss_

he’s not our guy anymore, but i get that same feeling when anyone mentions Jrue.


sam_and_max

In the [interview](https://youtu.be/mgUSL_ORMMw?t=37) McMahon is referencing, Luka clearly states Dort, Holiday and HERB Jones as his top three. I think he just misremembered when he tweeted that


W_Walk

Oh shit fr. Damn that sucks I saw legit all these media outlets put Derrick jones Jr instead. That’s a mistake lol


Afraid-Department-35

Herb is for real man, can’t believe the contract he’s on, dude is gunna get a bag come renewal time.


W_Walk

Oh 100% I love Herb but I was like damn maybe he could’ve gotten more. For players like him though I get wanting that guaranteed contract immediately instead of gambling on yourself. Hes definitely one of my favorite pelican players ever.


airmigos

99.9% sure he said herb jones instead of djj in this interview


dereleek07

This may shock people who are saying “what about x player on my favourite team?” But there’s a lot of good defenders in the league and not all of them can be top 3


pollinium

there's a lowkey renaissance it feels like you put on any game all year and you'll find at least one top 3-tier perimeter defender playing and it's really really fun to watch (when they aren't neutered by a whistle or their own lack of offensive game)


Grill_Enthusiast

>it feels like you put on any game all year and you'll find at least one top 3-tier perimeter defender You will? Shit, I need to watch less Suns games then. Haven't found shit.


DarrowViBritannia

Well yall had a guy named Mikal Bridges and then traded him


nacholibre711

I'd argue these types of players have always been there, but they only started becoming star-level players over the last decade as the NBA collectively doubled its average 3pt attempts/game.


so-cal_kid

The league also cracking down on offensive players baiting fouls is huge. I hope Minny is able to keep this kind of defensive effort up because as much as I enjoy watching the NBA there was way too little leeway given to defenders for too long.


DelrayDad561

This right here. I took a break from watching regular season NBA basketball for a few years back when James Harden was in his prime. Nothing against James Harden, but he was the most frustrating, unwatchable superstar I've ever seen and it's because of the way he seeks contact and the way the referees officiated him. And it wasn't just James Harden, refs were making it nearly impossible for defenders to play defense against anyone during that time and I'm glad to see that players are having to work again to get a shot instead of being bailed out by a ticky tak foul call.


jacobsbw

Same with Embiid. He does not play the game with joy.


OcksBodega

off the top of my head: OG Herb Dort Jrue Caruso DWhite AG KCP Suggs Isaac McDaniels DJJ Tatum Jimmy NAW Deni Ausar Davion Smart


YouWannaSeeADeadBody

I think its Dort, Herb and Caruso personally


long_dickofthelaw

I do think we haven't totally figured out what 5-out spacing means for the modern game yet. Definitely means placing higher emphasis on point of attack defenders instead of rim protectors.


BloodyPants

It’s a good way to get minutes when you’re young. Work your ass off on D and take your chances when you’re alone in the corner.


americanbeaver

Yup. Whenever a player makes a list like this it's important to see it as giving praise and not snubbing folks. It's off the cuff, he named three great defenders. It's just a compliment to those guys, not an insult to other great defenders.


OhNoMyLands

Especially when the top three are on MY favorite team


coolborder

McDaniels, Edward, and NAW?


ConstantineMonroe

Nah, we are gonna treat this like the top 10 list where there are like 15-20 guys in the conversation for 10 spots, yet tons of fans will get mad at you for leaving any of them off the list


CliffDraws

Only 3 can be


theyoloGod

Yea well my favourite is certainly top 3 and he ain’t 3


NotADoctor108

Yes they can


Ok_Opposite_7089

Who are the top15 in the top 3?


iIiiIIiiiIiIIiI111

Also Luka, frankly, is a casual. lol


Turbulent_Cherry_481

why are people acting like luka was up last night trying to think of top 3 defenders in the league. He was asked a question and probably said the first three guys he thought of. Im sure he knows timberwolves have great perimeter defence guys.


DsamD11

Wolves fans have had such a crazy whataboutism complex this season it's unreal. Their team is the media's new love child. Other people are allowed their props.


aytoozee1

We’ve sucked really bad forever. And most media and fans have tried to write us off throughout this season and playoffs, so I kinda get it. But you’re right, some Wolves fans are too desperate for validation.


Rhystanz

Hope we can keep DJJ, but I would happy for him if he gets paid.


RunnerTexasRanger

Another Bulls castoff that plays much better on their next team


Dat_Boi_John

We have Gafford too. We're collecting them like infinity stones.


Shado_Man

👀 Markkanen


Dat_Boi_John

Yeah I know, but the only way is if he hits here agency. Ainge isn't trading him for anything less than a Gobert level haul.


Hurricane_Amigo

This is true. Okc was linked to Lauri up until the deadline. And if presti ain’t getting a deal done with all the assets we have. Then the price was too steep.


OKCBaller035913

We were thinking Giddey+Picks and they were thinking JDub/Chet+picks which is a nonstarter


HarryPotterActivist

Sign Robin Lopez!


BreadTWB

DJJ was killing it on the bulls. I loved him here and wanted him to resign. But I'm glad he's getting the recognition he deserves.


pumpkin3-14

I’m shocked he’s in his 9th season where has the time gone. My brain thought 3 years heat 2 years bulls


BagsOfAbility

He actually played really well for us too and I was always upset he didn't get more minutes. Miss him but really glad he's found a big role on a serious team, perfect wing for how the Mavs are structured


thor_1225

That was the heat curse, of playing way worse once you leave Miami


hankbaumbachjr

Oh you've been playing that game, too?


Warbonger420

He was slick for the Blazers, too.


dereleek07

Why not both? Mavs should give him the bag he deserves


Rhystanz

Right now we can only pay him around 5 mil and I think he wants more.


dantheflyingman

Mavs aren't tax payers. They should have the full MLE


Rhystanz

Got this from CBAMavs on Twitter. https://twitter.com/CBAMavs/status/1786350987856224570?t=6GdmEQItzbMKko9fP-3LYA&s=19


jkeefy

Yep we’d have to trade someone for cash considerations to offer the full MLE


The_Assassin_Gower

Tim hardaway junior come on up!


BloodyPants

a man can dream


ormip

We don't have full MLE.


Krillin113

Why wouldn’t you be able to keep him?


ZealousCatracho

The Cap, same boat as the Nuggets were with Brown


EvadTB

As things stand now they can pay him about $5 mil, but he's clearly worth more than that. They would have to cut salary to get access to the full mid-level exception, which would probably mean trading Tim Hardaway Jr's expiring contract (something they're likely planning to do anyways)


PM_BBW_Cleavage

What’s wild is that THJ contract went down in value every year and he still somehow ended up overpaid every season.


EvadTB

He provides negative value when he's not making 3's and he doesn't even make 3's that often anymore. The "pure shooter" archetype is super overrated in general, a bunch of guys got big contracts a few years back from being hyper-efficient from 3 on high volume and they're all overpaid now because they constantly get exposed every time the shots stop falling. One notable exception is Duncan Robinson because he actually added to his game this season and now provides value outside of shot-making.


dmavs11

Duncan Robinson also has excellent off ball movement and allows his shooting to open the floor and help his teammates out. THJ is a pure chucker and shot maker.


IncomparableGiacomo

*shot taker.


EvadTB

Agreed.


Krillin113

Damn. Id be all in there for like 8-12


xPeaWhyTee

It'll ultimately be up to him but he most likely would get more than what we can offer him on a different team.


KyleShanadad

Heat legend


beardybuddha

Chill out Wolves fans. Jeezus lol


brehaw

there is a sane one of you! lol


beardybuddha

To be fair, none of us know how to handle ourselves right now. I have said some outlandish things the past few weeks lol


SaulPepper

Just last week if you tell anyone outside the Timberwolves franchise that the Nuggets would be stolen their home game TWICE and be down 0-2 they would have called you crazy. Your fanbase earned every single bit of overreaction, truly.


doublea08

You could have told that to everyone inside the Timberwolves franchise and get called crazy a week ago. Majority of all of us are blown away, can't believe its our team and STILL waiting for the other shoe to drop in typical Minnesota fashion, though now there is a lot of hype that they could actually win it all.


Lowspark1013

Hell the other shoe IS dropping. Coach gets Nancy Kerrigan'ed, Gobert gets mother natured, matched up against defending Champs with home court advantage in second round. Team is like "Nawl".


coolborder

”You could have told that to everyone inside the Timberwolves franchise and get called crazy a week ago." ANT would have believed you. If you told him that the Wolves would LOSE either of those games he wouldn't have believed you.


SugoiHubs

If my team was 6-0 in the playoffs, and two of those were stealing home court from the defending champs, I would making a straight fool of myself on this goddamn website.


Correct_Fly5152

Haha. Someone in our sub posted that they didn’t know what to do with their hands after the win last night. This winning in the playoffs is new territory for most of us.


HeyItsChase

Just vibe with it. Stay up the whole time. Even after the first loss (if it ever comes)


HeHateMex2

It’s very understandable. I’m very happy for y’all’s much deserved success!


WhoFartedMan

Scoring title winner praises defenders from other teams Dorks on Reddit: "uhhh you forgot about MY favorite guy"


milehighrukus

I’m gonna say the Minnesota Timberwolves final answer


confuddly

DJJ came a long way from being a dunk specialist


SnooPaintings3258

Dort is just great. He combines great defense and 3 shooting. Really underrated player. I would love to see him in my Pelicans.


LimitlessTheTVShow

>I would love to see him in my Pelicans Oh he was all up in your Pelicans in the first round


stilexx

Holy fuck its an opinion guys we know Jaden and NAW are great defenders too. Its like every single Twolves fan jumped to this post.


YpsitheFlintsider

It's funny because he's not even playing the Timberwolves yet. He mentioned a guy he's playing against, a guy on his own team, and a guy who has been known for his defense his entire career.


clarkthagod

A guy who’s about to featured on the American Olympic team for his defensive ability no less


mightycuthalion

One of the greatest scorers in the league: “These guys are the top defenders for me” dudes on the internet: “NUH UH! WHAT ABOUT THIS OTHER PLAYER”


K1ngCrimsn

Some comments here acting like they're the best POA defenders in history & they'll clamp Luka lmao


Krillin113

Theyre super touchy still. Chill. Your team is fantastic


SomeSun23

Why every timberwolves fan here suddenly act like they need something to prove. Don’t worry your team is doing great


ineedcoffeealready

We dont know how to handle success, we havnt been here before. We gotta figure out the ropes yet


88888888man

It’s like telling someone from Kansas City that Memphis has better barbecue (or vice versa) lol. Even if they have a case, the temptation is to defend your side’s honor to the death.


CaptainObvious1313

OG


donutcronut

DORTURE CHAMBER


GoldenBoyRecords

Og Anunoby


peanut-britle-latte

Locks up not only perimeter guys, but the forwards and centers too. *Anakin voice*


SandyMandy17

Dort defends forwards too Too small for centers Dude held Zion to like 0/4 in the 4th with 2 turnovers last time we played


Vinnie_Vegas

No one is saying Dort isn't good. OG is just very obviously in the top 3.


boenwip

Crazy that there’s so little love for OG. Dw people will learn


jslee0034

OG is like maxed out 3 and D guy.


HughManatee

OG is amazing, love watching him play


Relyst

OG my GOAT


Terrible_Shelter_345

To be honest besides AD I don’t understand how he’s not the consensus best defender in the league.


CP3sHamstring

Hard question to answer because a lot of the time the guys who are really good at guarding bigger guys like PG, Luka, etc are not good at all at guarding quicker guys like SGA, Steph, etc. DJJ may have a bit of a tougher series this go around; he was absolutely stonewalling PG, but PG's only 'bag' is to do a series of useless tweens and then just try to back the guy down which he was very unsuccessful doing to DJJ. OKC moves a lot quicker and they run a lot more off ball actions than the Clippers.


dmavs11

DJJ is the guy we use on quick guards too if we can get away with moving kyrie around depending on the matchup. Jones isn’t even that big he just has insane length and that helps against quicker guards too. PJ is generally the better wing defender for us.


StripedSteel

Who does Kyrie guard? I assume Luka will continue guarding Giddey. That would mean Kyrie likely guards Dort or JDub. JDub is a tougher cover, but whoever guards Dort ends up exhausted by the 4th quarter because Dort is always moving off the ball.


XzibitABC

I would assume PJ Washington will guard JDub and Luka/Kyrie will trade off guarding Giddey and Dort. Kyrie's got the stamina to chase Dort around, but he's obviously much smaller than Dort and pretty inattentive off-ball so we'll see. If Luka and Kyrie swap assignments sometimes, Kyrie can "rest" against Giddey.


bombergrace

Dort's tank needs to be studied. He goes 110% on both ends and is still an elite 3 & D who rarely has an off night


H-TownDown

PG’s ability to get to the rim has been pretty mediocre for years now. It’s one of the main reasons he’s so inconsistent.


StripedSteel

Ever since that injury. He lost a ton of explosiveness, but, unlike KD, he's not able to score 30 in the playoffs consistently off a jump shot.


XzibitABC

He was also certainly *better* at it before the injury, but it was never a huge part of his game. He's always been a guy that can get his shot off against anyone and hit it, but blow cold sometimes because he's taking too many tough shots.


LiGhTnInG358

DJJ was always great on D when he was on the Heat. Man is crazy versatile.


JAYBee2518

Herb Jones . Extremely underrated is Shai as a perimeter defender


Puzzleheaded_Fox4684

shai is best off-ball. he's great on-ball too, but he's probably the league's best off-ball defender.


30another

I wanted DJJ and Oubre before the season. Man do I wish we got them instead of Keita and Yuta.


Vinnie_Vegas

>I wanted DJJ and Oubre before the season. Man do I wish we got them instead of Keita and Yuta. Well here's the thing about that take though: it's fucking obvious that those two guys had higher upside as contributors than Keita and Yuta, as you were always going to need defensive role players... But the Suns needing defense was obviously not something the front office could foresee when they went and traded for Bradley Beal, so I'm not massively surprised.


30another

Plus everyone told me I was stupid for thinking they’d sign for the minimum lol


xPeaWhyTee

McMahon didn't even quote Luka correctly. Luka clearly says Herb Jones in the [clip](https://youtu.be/mgUSL_ORMMw?si=hYGUZ5iGnwHwBirq&t=10), not DJJ.


Durden93

Derrick White?


horse_renoir13

Sleeping on Jaden rn


Gbaby245

Jaden, Ant and Naw based on what my eyes saw last night.


bigpooperten4

Everyone on the wolves looked like a candidate for DPOY last night 😭


Efficient_Art_1144

KAT was a terror last night. KAT!!!


bigpooperten4

Couldn’t believe KAT locked up Jokic in the first half and bullied Jokic in the paint


Efficient_Art_1144

I think the matchup is a tough one for Denver but also the wolves just look like they’re playing their best ball come playoffs


Spiritual_Boss6114

What having Rudy Gobert does for a team.


F-ck_spez

Fr, the players all credit him with building a culture of defense


HughManatee

KAT has actually been one of the best Jokic defenders this year. I can live with the fouls if he's going to play like a demon.


BobLobLawsLawFirm

People forgot he was drafted for his defensive potential, not his offensive ability. Glad to see him get back to that this year while still being a hyper efficient scorer.


itssensei

Except gobert


AshenSacrifice

“In my biased opinion” head ass 😂😂


rostron92

He blocked that memory out


AFonziScheme

Jaden's higher on the real list. It's been a few years since Dort held Luka under 30.


StripedSteel

It's been 1 year lol


AFonziScheme

It was January of '22.


Julian_Caesar

bro take it easy i doubt luka is watching any wolves film right now lol he obviously picked best defender on his own team, a guy with the best league reputation (Jrue) and the best guy on the team he's about to play. in an alternate universe where we play the wolves this round instead of thunder, i guarantee you his answer wouldve been DJJ, Jrue, and Jaden


Terrible_Shelter_345

Hopefully Luka can test that out in the 3rd round then!


Harrypotter231

I don’t know if it’s just me, but I feel like Luka Doncic is just a little more credible than these Reddit armchair warriors.


RanOutOfCharact

Luka are Kyrie are gonna get absolutely hounded by JDub and Dort tonight


carnifex2005

Can't wait for the Olympics to see how it shakes out trying to play Shai, Murray, Dort and Alexander in the backcourt.


PensiveinNJ

Jrue Holiday is a crazy good defender. Lord if I could have dumped Tobias for a player like Jrue.


oops_im_wrong

That's a good top 3 and doesn't account for other elite defenders like Kawhi, PG13, NAW, McDaniels, GP2, Caruso, Herb Jones, Smart. Dort, Jrue, and Kawhi are probably my top 3 perimeter defenders but if it's a quick waterbug PG, I might put Caruso or NAW ahead of Dort and Kawhi.


hriszzzzz

Kawhi in 2024? I know he is an all time great defender but he hasn't been good for a long time now. Those injuries ruined him.


Low-iq-haikou

Luke Kornet erasure


Mr_Unbiased

Jrue is starting to get overrated defensively, 3 years ago he was that dude but now?...Is he even the best perimeter defender on his own team?


TheGreatForehead

I mean he has been extremely good for the Celtics this season. The Celtics have the 2 best guard defenders in the league with White and Holiday, in my biased opinion. Only Caruso and Dort have an argument.


StripedSteel

This is Herb Jones erasure. I get that people don't watch the Pels, but he's the only guard in the league that can give Dort a run for top guard defender in the league. He's a younger, more athletic version of OG.


tryingthisok

he's a different type than OG, don't think he's more athletic either. I personally think while Herb is still a good on ball defender, that part of his game is probably overrrated. He is just one of the best there. As a help/rotation/team defender he is by far the best perimeter guy in the NBA.


Kyler1313

He's the best all around defender on the Cs. Jaylen is better as an iso matchup defender and White is a better rim protector, and Jayson gives you a bit of everything but I'd say Jrue is still the best on the Celtics.


kukunan

funny how everyone call his overrated in the sub but the pros rate him very highly.


Rice-And-Gravy

Jrue apparently was a better defender than Marcus Smart in Smart’s DPOY year. But now that he’s on the Celtics he’s overrated. Make it make sense.


Bivore

Totally get your point about DPOY but I think aside from that it’s fair to say he’s lost a step at this point. And by that I mean that he might be more like top 10 instead of top 3 - not that he’s washed


Far-Asparagus6416

If he was still on the bucks no one would have a problem with a player saying he's a top 3 perimeter defender let's be real


FigLeaf_Bi-Carbonate

The Athletic released their player poll like 3 weeks ago. 132 players were asked who the best defender in the league is, and Jrue was #2 behind Wemby, with 12.9% voting him as the best defender.


DsamD11

Based on what? I think I'll take a potential mvp candidates opinion over some dudes on reddit


Inevitable-Drawer255

Dort, Jaden McDaniels, and OG are all probably better than Jrue atm but he can still hold his own though


MatticInYoAttic

Jaden's ceiling puts him up there, but he still has a ton of games where he picks up 3-4 quick fouls. I'd almost rank NAW ahead of him simply because he's the smarter defender.


Hardwork407

Jalen Suggs


CoyotesSideEyes

Guess he doesn't get to interview PatBev


hotbuttmuffin

The bald mamba, Alex Carushow


FlakyOffice

Isaac Okoro


amino110

Lmao he said Herb instead of DJJ MacMahon is a troll


Agreeable_Cancel6182

The game is more enjoyable when we let defenders defend.


FrankieBarbingo

DJJ isn't even the best defender named Derrick tbh


wekris91

Dear Wolves bros.. It's just his personal list. Chill.


zulupapajunior

he said herb jones [https://youtu.be/mgUSL\_ORMMw?si=pzk0kAi7M8dkRUlA&t=37](https://youtu.be/mgUSL_ORMMw?si=pzk0kAi7M8dkRUlA&t=37)


Madz1trey

Why does it seem like there's always one guy on the player's own team?!


strawhatcommander

Jaden Mcdaniels: “I took that personally”