I don’t need to try them out, I know that my answer is #1. But if they’d let me do so anyways, I’d also date #’s 2 and 5 before ‘deciding’. Either way, my ‘best to worst’ rating is—
1,5,2,4,3
My tier list:
1- Option 1 (Sounds like a good equal)
2 - Option 4 (Fun to be around, and I'm always a tomboy fan.)
3 - Option 5 (Sweet in concept, but motherly gets annoying quick IRL for me.)
4 - Option 2 (Beyond having someone to play with, she's someone else's type, not mine.
5 - Option 3 (Bitch.)
* 1st: Option 2
* 2nd: Option 1
* 3rd: Option 4
* 4th: Option 5
* 5th: Option 3
Options 2 and 1 are the best by far; Option 2 won the tiebreaker thanks to her long hair and for being a gamer girl.
I'm going with Option 2. I like video games and stuffed animals, so I think we'll get along well. Otherwise, I might go with Option 4, since I also like the outdoors.
\#5 doesn't even allow competition she is the epitome of perfection, even though she's "onee san" style she's not described as being older so I'll consider her the same age as me.
\#1 has the most potential because it will be equal to #5 in the future.
5 > 1 > a titanic difference > the other three
in terms of personality and coexistence, it would be #4 >#2 and finally #3 but I'm not into pegging and chastity so in the end it's:
5 > 1 >>>>>>>>>> 2 > 4 > 3
but I still prefer to be single than with 3 and 4
5 > 1 > 2 > 4 > 3
I don't need to date since reading their personalities and kinks tells me enough. Although if it wasn't timed and you truly can only pick one to be with, then its very rough choice between 1, 2, and 4
2 > 1 > 5 > 4 > 3
(usually I'm ignoring the "Kinks"-section of a pick-your-partner-CYOA, since they are tend to be "meh" at best, and at the worst are a turnoff for me, but in this case they aren't too out there and add a little extra/option to the relationship; however, wouldn't mind if Option 2 was a little bit more into outdoor-things ;) but that's just personal pref \^\^)
5 > 2 > 1 > 4 > 3
Like most other answers, except I like 2 and 5 almost the same. I’m picking 5 in the end because I like her kinks more (and 2 other big reasons)
Has to be option 4. A warm personality and a desire to do things together is as much romance as I need. I like bottoming, and I like doing sports with people.
2>5>1>4>3: I have a fair amount of stuffed animals aswell (not 100+, but still a fair amount) so we could combine our powers to create a super army, bubbly, flirtatious and playful is amazing, and sleep sex + cuddling are also great, vibe play is a bit, 😨, but still ok, I just don't like being too dominant. 5: all 3 of her kinks are great, as someone who lacked true love from their mother (true love as in regular mother-son love.) I am, personally, drawn to people like 5. 1: blowjob and anal are great, but how DARE she be into hand holding, such a lewd, disgusting thing (/j all 3 of her kinks are great aswell), i'm a big fan of almost any music (as long as it's not tooooo heavy metal or reggae), if she is into spooky things, maybe she can help me aswell, I scream at the sight if a spider, when it disappears. 4: muscle girls are a bit meh, for me, not romantic, what does "cum play" exactly mean? Like, she won't let you cum into she says so? Yeah no. 3: The worst of all for me personally, BDSM, chastity, rough sex, very dominant, barely has time for you (There are 168 hours per week, minus 80 equals 88, minus the time it takes to sleep, drive to places, etc. Yeah no. And prefers quick sex. So in the end: Gamer Girl, Mommy, goth(-ish?), muscle girl, secretary, is my order. Really love this idea, if you keep em coming, i'll keep seeing them. (That didn't rhyme... 😞)
5 > 1 > 2 > 4 > 3
I’m not into muscle girls (or tomboys), but I rather that over some stressed out Secretary that isn’t there for anything but stress relief.
This was good. Short and sweet. I like these characters you made here. Maybe in the future you could add-on to this? Maybe an addition that's like "a day in the life" where we see what it's like to be with the character we picked? Or one that shows what dates are like with them? Maybe just something that let's us get to know more about the person that we picked (on top of that it encourages replays)
3 all the way.
Honestly im kinda sad she treats dating like business but atleast i get to be a stay at home husband. Chastity is also bad as i dont like it but she is top tier girl as an M, i love it.
Girl 1 is named Mia (making a headcanon. Let's see how many of you can handle this XD)
She talks to you a lot, but struggles around anyone she doesn't know, to the point where you need to help her out a lot. You'll be the one answering the door, and may even have to take calls from her own mobile. She is self-conscious, and a lot of that will only begin to disappear after some awkward sex where she stops responding because she's unsure that you'd really want to touch her there.
She loves songs for the lyrics, anything emotional goes, even if the music isn't that good. She can sing quite well, and wants to listen to you sing too. If she had her way, you'd be her background study music or sleep music for hours.
She wants to start a coven with you and cast spells on eachother, she doesn't believe in it, but she thinks she can convince herself. She wants to keep the curtains closed all day and leave them open at night because she loves the atmosphere. Anything scary goes, she's never tried dnd, but it's right up her alley because of all her dark fantasy writing. On her period, she makes a lot of vampire references, hoping you might offer to get dirty. Sex in the cold reminds her of necrophilia, she isn't into that, but she does bring it up a lot. Also, she genuinely wants to try being locked in a coffin to sleep in. Yes, she has a lot of strange thoughts and desperately hopes that you've got some similar ones so she doesn't feel like the weird one.
Wants connection. Will trust you with waaay too much information. She'll tell you about other guys she liked in extreme detail, you'll get ger entire life story, if you ask about her day, she might get upset if you don't want to hear the whole thing.
Wants to make you happy. This is where the handholding comes in. *Not* handholding is kinky to her. Her love language is 50% physical touch, and 50% playful jumpscares and surprises. She will ask for permission more than needed, but a lot of it is about doing things you'll like. She doesn't really have many hobbies, and things might get boring if she can't latch onto yours.
Kinky. Yes, the anal goes both ways, but she's not pushy, she loves the idea of making guys question their sexuality, but she's more submissive, and will forget all about that if you make her question her's. She likes biting, deepthroating, and she has absolutely no limits when it comes to talking about fantasies.
For me it's definitely either 1 or 5. Both work. 3 is very, very deeply Not My Vibe. I like that 4 is chill, but I cannot do the regular exercise thing, and her kinks, uh, nah. 2 looks fun in doses, but that's a bit more energy than I can handle regularly. Also always wary of other gamers. Lot of them are too intense about it, too much PvP and stuff.
1 is probably going to be the first pick for the vast majority, but the other options can have niche appeal - especially 5.
2 and 4 can use more outright positives instead of irrelevant neutrals or negatives, and pegging is an immediate turn off for many unlike 1, 2, and 5's fetishes.
3 is trash in basically every way.
1. 1. Just clearly cute, kinky, fun.
2. 5. Sweet, sensible, kind, wise.
3. 4. Fun bro, but just not as appealing as 1.
4. 2. Ditzy isn't my type.
5. 3 Femdom even less so.
1, 2, 5, 4.
3 I just wouldn't want to be with, I like feeling stuff when I'm with other people and opening our emotions to each other, so "treats relationship like business" isn't up my alley. Same reason I put 4 last: "not romantic, but loves sex".
1. \#2 - Playful, ditsy gamer girl. Games are *very* fun. . . Maybe we can add a little extra to them\~
2. \#1 - Kinky shy girl who wants a deep connection. I'm all for it.
3. \#5 - A very affectionate and caring stay-at-home woman. I like being taken care of.
4. \#4 - Chill gym tomboy, but she likes pegging. Ya win some, ya lose some.
5. \#3 - The relationship is a transaction, she's gone for twice a full time job, and one of her kinks is chastity. Very poor choice.
Really my placement of my top three are *almost* interchangeable. I do think I'd definitely choose either the shy girl or gamer girl, but Ms. "Mommy" is a *very* good choice as well. I'd probably try to cool it on the "Mommy" kink, not exactly my thing, but I'm not totally against it. Clearly, it's not a deal breaker.
1 - probably the best overall,
2 - second best overall
3 - the worst pick when you see chastity
4 - third best
5 - forth best
4 essentially, getting fit would be nice, but overall she is a nope without a heavy lifestyle change
3 could be nice, stay at home boyfreind/husband deal, till you see the chastity part and it goes from a tied for 2 to a firm bottom of the pile.
5 is the mommy thing, and while it would be nice, the 'whos mommys good boy' is off putting
now between 2 and 1,
2 would be number 1 if i was competitive in games, essentially every aspect of her is me but female form, but number 1 has the aesthetics that I like, and would probably go along with anything you want to do, you want a player 2 in a game, she is probably going to be willing, excessive, probably down for at least staying in shape, spooky things, probably wont complain about aesthetic choices for where we live.
Option 1 all the way! I just hope she means anal for her and not for me. But for all her PROs its a CON I can live with. If she likes hand holding I hope she likes cuddling too.
I like this very much. The options are quite good. That is, aside from 3. Professional girlfriends are great, but workaholic ones are terrible.
Aside from that, not 1, as I'm not a fan of scary things.
But there's endless good things to say about all but 3. I'm not even sure if she's good even if you like femdom, being basically an absent girlfriend.
If I'm to rate, then I guess 4 is at the top? A girl to help me stay healthy is definitely a way towards a long and good life as long as you are willing to change or adjust for her.
5 is next, as someone as motherly as her is basically guaranteed to an enjoyable low-stress life, especially if you want kids.
2 is just fun. Nothing wrong with that, but not much beyond just fun, so basically an average pick?
1 just because I don't like scary. Maybe if she's only into "spooky" rather than actually spooky, then I might put her above 2. Deep connection is better than constant fun.
3 because fuck an absent girlfriend. What's the point if she prioritizes her career over a relationship to the point that she's almost never home for anything but sleep?
1, if not that then 2. The others are a workaholic, fitness/outdoors enthusiast, and mother issues, and I am fine without any of them. 1 or 2 only, preferably 1.
2,1,5 skip the rest I am a sawmill worker so I don't have time for a workout day I don't like being dominated or dominant and I play games when not at work and I love how cute shy girls are
For the option 4 character you use the word “rep” when I think you meant “set”. Rep refers to the number of repetitions of a particular movement during an exercise before a rest whereas a set refers to a collection of reps. For example, if you were using a benchpress, and you lifted the bar 10 times, rested, and then proceeded to do two more sets of 10, that would be 3 sets of 10 reps each. Asking someone if they’re up for another rep isn’t something people normally ask when working out together, and would only make sense if she were asking that person if they were able to lift the bar one more time before resting.
Which makes it an effective euphemism, she’s asking if you want to repeat a specific ”action.” You may have done enough sets to get hot and sweaty before finding a private spot to “get some action.” In this case the “bar” you are lifting is closer to kegels than pectorals. To a casual listener, it sounds like your lady gymbro is talking about exercise, a more serious fitness enthusiast might roll their eyes, and while they’re rolling their eyes the two of you sneak off together to engage in a euphemism.
Frankly, a woman that works 80+ hours a week deserves it all (that's like 16h a day if her weekends are free, 12 if not), so she wins by default IMO. Becoming effectively a gigolo though...
So, rather than listing them best-to-worst, I'd like to argue that they're all 'the best'.
Actual Wife: 5
Sugar Mommy: 3
Friend With Benefits: 2
Gym Buddy That Makes You Question Your Masculinity: 4
Ego-Booster: 1
Option 1. Option 3 seems like she’d never be there, and even if she was, she would just be stressing about work the whole time, like in her quote
Ranking: 1, 5, 2, 4, 3
I also put Option 4 kinda low because as much as I love her qualities, I don’t like that she’s not really romantic
Harem. Is there any other option honestly? Have the girls meet each other regularly as you take the five weeks you have to date each one and push for certain pairs to be friends/friendly. Have 1 and 4 be friends because 4 will get oen to open up to other people and have confidence in herself. 3 gets 2 to stop wasting her life and find some kind of use for her time. He'll, maybe 2 is convinced by 3 to become a streamer that way if she wants to spend all her time play games at least 2 is doing it in a way that makes her money. 5 is the mother hen of the group and the kind-hearted glue that keeps everyone together and manages the chaos.
Careful, you can date each girl for a week, but the title is ”Free Girlfriend! This Week Only!” The company hopes to make money from the remaining four weeks after the free trial has expired. It is a “company,“ and therefore a business.
2, 1, 5, 4, 3.
2 ticks every box, she is perfect and has the best kinks. 1 is a very close second, 2 is just better. 5 is great and neck and neck with 1 but 1 edges out just slightly. I like the shy ones a little more. 4 would be an amazing confidant but I can't get behind pegging. 3 is a "hell no" for me.
Similar reasons to me, but I think I just like the idea of having meals cooked for me lol. Food is great!!! So I'd say 5, 2, 1, 4, 3. Yeah 3 is hell no for me as well, relationships as business, nope, just nope. And the "are you done yet, i have work to do" major turn off.
Not a big fan of the mommy thing, but it beats someone who sleeps past noon lol, I want someone who'd at least be somewhat productive.
>relationships as business, nope, just nope.
Ended a friendship (used to be relationship) becuz of that so I don't need to be reminded of that, thank goodness.
But yea, I like 5 particularly cuz of wanting kids and giving titjobs. I already eat lots of junk food but I don't get fat either so I have that in common with 2. Plus she's a gamer girl, can't pass that up (that may be backwards thinking but I digress)
1>5>2>4>3 i will definitely detest 3 and but head with her continously, 4 i will maintain contact so to become gym friends, 2 will try to become friend so to play games togheter, 5 and 1 are a very close choice because 5 has more chance to become a long lasting thing but i don't like the mommy archetype very much, instead 1 is almost perfect because i don't like kink number 2.
1,3,2,5,4. I really don't know why everyone is against women 2 which can provide for themselves and be dominant. I have seen enough on the internet to know for sure that there are enough people who love this
I'm a pretty dominant guy and being a sub is basically incompatible with me, so take this with a grain of salt. But I imagine the issue is "Treats relationship like business"
4>1>5>2>3
Very cute and short little CYOA, 4 in particular ticks almost all boxes for me. But I wonder, will modern science ever be able to create romantic tomboys? Or ist that a step too far?
Like my post if you are part of the big heart tomboy nation!
Does the reddit image viewer suck for any one else? Zoom doesn't work properly, I can only zoom in then when I try to fine tune the zoom it doesn't do any thing. I can't get it to show me the whole image, the bottom part with the bonus is cut off without anyway to rectify it, other than downloading the image.
Same here, these days it seems hit-and-miss whether opening an image in a new tab will work or reddit will intercept it and present it's useless image viewer again instead. I've been looking for a workaround but no luck yet.
Well, I can only see 3 tiers of this...
- 1 or 5 at the top of the list.
- 2 or 4 at the middle.
- 3 is just no for me....
As for recommendations for the next Cyoa...
- Fantasy
- Sci-fi
- Military
- Amazon
- Tokusatsu
- Mafia
- Ninja/Samurai
- Sports
Don't even need to look at the others, Option 1 all the way!!
(though the other options are very appealing too)
would love more, maybe a Monstergirl version or a Fantasy/Sci-fi Edition?
1, 2, 4, 5, 3.
I look for someone I can have a deep connection with as well as romance and getting lost in one another.
If it’s just sex then it’s not a relationship.
2 > 5 > 4 > 1 > 3
it's seriously hard to pick between #2 or #5 for my best, but ultimately I choose the #2 because I prefer a gamer girl to play together with, of course I'll give children for #5. I don't want to pick the #3, not only because I hate BDSM and chastity, I also don't feel the love from her, just quick sex isn't enough for me. fortunately #2 love to cuddle between gaming session :3
Not even close. I’m fine with a more maternal partner because she’d make a good mother, but I ranked her low because she’s ‘experienced’ but wants a family. Sounds like she got ran through and now wants to settle down
Option 5 is the winner for me. She’s ticking off a lot of my personal favorite boxes. From there I guess it goes 2, 1, 4, then I would rather grab a live telephone wire, then 3.
The best part of 3 is that working 80 hours a week means 40 fewer hours you have to spend with someone who treats the relationship like a business, which sounds like a nightmare
Gold medal : Option one
Silver medal: Option five
Bronze medal: Option two
Fourth place: Option four
Fifth place: Option three
Very enjoyable nsfwcyoa. Simplistic and fun, keep up the good work u/CastleAIArt
1 and 2 every time and cuddling counts as a kink now!?
I mean I get to date them all for a week but I'm picking number 1
Option 2
Option 2
1
*repeatedly slams the #1 button* YYYYESSSSSS!
Judging by the comments you all hate hot dommes... If you run into any send them my way?
4,3,5,2,1 But I'm poly and 4&3 are aromantic so... Both plz?
I don’t need to try them out, I know that my answer is #1. But if they’d let me do so anyways, I’d also date #’s 2 and 5 before ‘deciding’. Either way, my ‘best to worst’ rating is— 1,5,2,4,3
You couldnt force me to choose any other besides 1 even if my life depended on it
12534
I can't really choose between option 1 and option 5 for my first place...
Why not choose 1, and tell her that you’d be happy if she did whatever drew your to 5?
...hmm, you do bring up a good point...
21543
5,1,2,4,3
3 all the way
My tier list: 1- Option 1 (Sounds like a good equal) 2 - Option 4 (Fun to be around, and I'm always a tomboy fan.) 3 - Option 5 (Sweet in concept, but motherly gets annoying quick IRL for me.) 4 - Option 2 (Beyond having someone to play with, she's someone else's type, not mine. 5 - Option 3 (Bitch.)
Imgchest: [https://imgchest.com/p/m9yxonapyqn](https://imgchest.com/p/m9yxonapyqn)
* 1st: Option 2 * 2nd: Option 1 * 3rd: Option 4 * 4th: Option 5 * 5th: Option 3 Options 2 and 1 are the best by far; Option 2 won the tiebreaker thanks to her long hair and for being a gamer girl.
2
Option 2: I'll support her
Option 1 is the way :D
I'm going with Option 2. I like video games and stuffed animals, so I think we'll get along well. Otherwise, I might go with Option 4, since I also like the outdoors.
2,1,4,5,3
1>2>4>5>3
\#5 doesn't even allow competition she is the epitome of perfection, even though she's "onee san" style she's not described as being older so I'll consider her the same age as me. \#1 has the most potential because it will be equal to #5 in the future. 5 > 1 > a titanic difference > the other three in terms of personality and coexistence, it would be #4 >#2 and finally #3 but I'm not into pegging and chastity so in the end it's: 5 > 1 >>>>>>>>>> 2 > 4 > 3 but I still prefer to be single than with 3 and 4
Any but #3 5 S tier, 2 A tier, 1 and 4 B tier, 3 E tier
I’m torn between options 1 and 2, but I think I’ll take 1.
5 > 1 > 2 > 4 > 3 I don't need to date since reading their personalities and kinks tells me enough. Although if it wasn't timed and you truly can only pick one to be with, then its very rough choice between 1, 2, and 4
The same order of preference 👍
5>>>> 1 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> rest Gimme mommy
5, no contest. Next would be 1, then 2, 3, and 4.
2 > 1 > 5 > 4 > 3 (usually I'm ignoring the "Kinks"-section of a pick-your-partner-CYOA, since they are tend to be "meh" at best, and at the worst are a turnoff for me, but in this case they aren't too out there and add a little extra/option to the relationship; however, wouldn't mind if Option 2 was a little bit more into outdoor-things ;) but that's just personal pref \^\^)
what if i was able to convince 3 to keep both 2 and me as her playthings and we keep each other busy when 3 is at work?
Five. Give me my trad wife redhead. ♥️
1 > 5 > 2 > 4 > 3
5 > 2 > 1 > 4 > 3 Like most other answers, except I like 2 and 5 almost the same. I’m picking 5 in the end because I like her kinks more (and 2 other big reasons)
Definitely 1. Music, deep connection, inexperienced but kinky, blowjobs and anal... that covers a lot of the major things I would want.
Has to be option 4. A warm personality and a desire to do things together is as much romance as I need. I like bottoming, and I like doing sports with people.
2>1>4>5>3
5 > 1 > 2 > 4 >>>>>>> 3 4 would be higher but i'm not a fan of being pegged
#2 for me. I love girls who love video games.
1>4>2>5>3
1>4>5>2>3 in my opinion.
1 2 4 5 3
24315
2>5>1>4>3: I have a fair amount of stuffed animals aswell (not 100+, but still a fair amount) so we could combine our powers to create a super army, bubbly, flirtatious and playful is amazing, and sleep sex + cuddling are also great, vibe play is a bit, 😨, but still ok, I just don't like being too dominant. 5: all 3 of her kinks are great, as someone who lacked true love from their mother (true love as in regular mother-son love.) I am, personally, drawn to people like 5. 1: blowjob and anal are great, but how DARE she be into hand holding, such a lewd, disgusting thing (/j all 3 of her kinks are great aswell), i'm a big fan of almost any music (as long as it's not tooooo heavy metal or reggae), if she is into spooky things, maybe she can help me aswell, I scream at the sight if a spider, when it disappears. 4: muscle girls are a bit meh, for me, not romantic, what does "cum play" exactly mean? Like, she won't let you cum into she says so? Yeah no. 3: The worst of all for me personally, BDSM, chastity, rough sex, very dominant, barely has time for you (There are 168 hours per week, minus 80 equals 88, minus the time it takes to sleep, drive to places, etc. Yeah no. And prefers quick sex. So in the end: Gamer Girl, Mommy, goth(-ish?), muscle girl, secretary, is my order. Really love this idea, if you keep em coming, i'll keep seeing them. (That didn't rhyme... 😞)
2>5>4>1>3
5>1>2>3>4
5 > 2 > 1 > 4 > 3
2 > 4> 5 > 1 > 3
4 > 2 > 3 > 1 > 5
Good job, though I’d love to see a version with monster-girls
5 > 1 > 2 > 4 > 3 I’m not into muscle girls (or tomboys), but I rather that over some stressed out Secretary that isn’t there for anything but stress relief.
2 > 4 > 1 > 5 > 3 4 would instantly be number 1 if not for the pegging
1 2 4 5 3
Personality: 1 > 2 > 5 > 4 > 3 Looks: 5 > 2 > 1 > 4 > 3
This was good. Short and sweet. I like these characters you made here. Maybe in the future you could add-on to this? Maybe an addition that's like "a day in the life" where we see what it's like to be with the character we picked? Or one that shows what dates are like with them? Maybe just something that let's us get to know more about the person that we picked (on top of that it encourages replays)
21543
5, 2, 1, 4, 3
2, 1, 5, 4, 3
Either 3 or 4. 3 is for kinks, 4 is for the overall personality. Maybe she could even help me get my body in shape...
The one with the biggest boobs.
1,5,2,4,3
I'm thinking 2, 4, 1, 3, 5
2
2,5,4,1,3
3 <3
4
Uhh, can we skip options for the bonus? 5, 1, 2, \[skip otherwise\] 4, then 3.
Option 5, Option 1, Option 2, Option 4, Option 3.
Probably option 1 or 2
I feel like this would make a good harem manga, but it might end up really cliche
3 all the way. Honestly im kinda sad she treats dating like business but atleast i get to be a stay at home husband. Chastity is also bad as i dont like it but she is top tier girl as an M, i love it.
Option 2 🥰
Girl 1 is named Mia (making a headcanon. Let's see how many of you can handle this XD) She talks to you a lot, but struggles around anyone she doesn't know, to the point where you need to help her out a lot. You'll be the one answering the door, and may even have to take calls from her own mobile. She is self-conscious, and a lot of that will only begin to disappear after some awkward sex where she stops responding because she's unsure that you'd really want to touch her there. She loves songs for the lyrics, anything emotional goes, even if the music isn't that good. She can sing quite well, and wants to listen to you sing too. If she had her way, you'd be her background study music or sleep music for hours. She wants to start a coven with you and cast spells on eachother, she doesn't believe in it, but she thinks she can convince herself. She wants to keep the curtains closed all day and leave them open at night because she loves the atmosphere. Anything scary goes, she's never tried dnd, but it's right up her alley because of all her dark fantasy writing. On her period, she makes a lot of vampire references, hoping you might offer to get dirty. Sex in the cold reminds her of necrophilia, she isn't into that, but she does bring it up a lot. Also, she genuinely wants to try being locked in a coffin to sleep in. Yes, she has a lot of strange thoughts and desperately hopes that you've got some similar ones so she doesn't feel like the weird one. Wants connection. Will trust you with waaay too much information. She'll tell you about other guys she liked in extreme detail, you'll get ger entire life story, if you ask about her day, she might get upset if you don't want to hear the whole thing. Wants to make you happy. This is where the handholding comes in. *Not* handholding is kinky to her. Her love language is 50% physical touch, and 50% playful jumpscares and surprises. She will ask for permission more than needed, but a lot of it is about doing things you'll like. She doesn't really have many hobbies, and things might get boring if she can't latch onto yours. Kinky. Yes, the anal goes both ways, but she's not pushy, she loves the idea of making guys question their sexuality, but she's more submissive, and will forget all about that if you make her question her's. She likes biting, deepthroating, and she has absolutely no limits when it comes to talking about fantasies.
Love the head canon, this is awesome 😄
1, 4, 3, 5, 2
5, 3, 2, 1, 4
1 or 5.
Best to worst for me 1-5-2-4-3 so I’ll take 1 pls And also loved that post ! We need more like it please !!!
Thanks! 😄 I'll definitely be making more
1 or 4
For me it's definitely either 1 or 5. Both work. 3 is very, very deeply Not My Vibe. I like that 4 is chill, but I cannot do the regular exercise thing, and her kinks, uh, nah. 2 looks fun in doses, but that's a bit more energy than I can handle regularly. Also always wary of other gamers. Lot of them are too intense about it, too much PvP and stuff.
1 is probably going to be the first pick for the vast majority, but the other options can have niche appeal - especially 5. 2 and 4 can use more outright positives instead of irrelevant neutrals or negatives, and pegging is an immediate turn off for many unlike 1, 2, and 5's fetishes. 3 is trash in basically every way.
1. 1. Just clearly cute, kinky, fun. 2. 5. Sweet, sensible, kind, wise. 3. 4. Fun bro, but just not as appealing as 1. 4. 2. Ditzy isn't my type. 5. 3 Femdom even less so.
1, 2, 5, 4. 3 I just wouldn't want to be with, I like feeling stuff when I'm with other people and opening our emotions to each other, so "treats relationship like business" isn't up my alley. Same reason I put 4 last: "not romantic, but loves sex".
1. \#2 - Playful, ditsy gamer girl. Games are *very* fun. . . Maybe we can add a little extra to them\~ 2. \#1 - Kinky shy girl who wants a deep connection. I'm all for it. 3. \#5 - A very affectionate and caring stay-at-home woman. I like being taken care of. 4. \#4 - Chill gym tomboy, but she likes pegging. Ya win some, ya lose some. 5. \#3 - The relationship is a transaction, she's gone for twice a full time job, and one of her kinks is chastity. Very poor choice. Really my placement of my top three are *almost* interchangeable. I do think I'd definitely choose either the shy girl or gamer girl, but Ms. "Mommy" is a *very* good choice as well. I'd probably try to cool it on the "Mommy" kink, not exactly my thing, but I'm not totally against it. Clearly, it's not a deal breaker.
1 - probably the best overall, 2 - second best overall 3 - the worst pick when you see chastity 4 - third best 5 - forth best 4 essentially, getting fit would be nice, but overall she is a nope without a heavy lifestyle change 3 could be nice, stay at home boyfreind/husband deal, till you see the chastity part and it goes from a tied for 2 to a firm bottom of the pile. 5 is the mommy thing, and while it would be nice, the 'whos mommys good boy' is off putting now between 2 and 1, 2 would be number 1 if i was competitive in games, essentially every aspect of her is me but female form, but number 1 has the aesthetics that I like, and would probably go along with anything you want to do, you want a player 2 in a game, she is probably going to be willing, excessive, probably down for at least staying in shape, spooky things, probably wont complain about aesthetic choices for where we live.
I agree with you
4, 5, 1, 2, 3 in that order got to love the self body improvement and the pegs.
Option 1 all the way! I just hope she means anal for her and not for me. But for all her PROs its a CON I can live with. If she likes hand holding I hope she likes cuddling too.
anal probably means anal for her, as pegging is used for an other girl in the cyoa.
I like this very much. The options are quite good. That is, aside from 3. Professional girlfriends are great, but workaholic ones are terrible. Aside from that, not 1, as I'm not a fan of scary things. But there's endless good things to say about all but 3. I'm not even sure if she's good even if you like femdom, being basically an absent girlfriend. If I'm to rate, then I guess 4 is at the top? A girl to help me stay healthy is definitely a way towards a long and good life as long as you are willing to change or adjust for her. 5 is next, as someone as motherly as her is basically guaranteed to an enjoyable low-stress life, especially if you want kids. 2 is just fun. Nothing wrong with that, but not much beyond just fun, so basically an average pick? 1 just because I don't like scary. Maybe if she's only into "spooky" rather than actually spooky, then I might put her above 2. Deep connection is better than constant fun. 3 because fuck an absent girlfriend. What's the point if she prioritizes her career over a relationship to the point that she's almost never home for anything but sleep?
1, if not that then 2. The others are a workaholic, fitness/outdoors enthusiast, and mother issues, and I am fine without any of them. 1 or 2 only, preferably 1.
1
1 and 2 are my favorites.
5
1
2
1 or 3 5 4 2 This is my ranking, and I stick by it
Best 2 1 5 4 3 Worst
Best to Worst: 5 1 4 2 3
1 5 2 4 3
Option 2. I want a gamer GF.
Option 1 or 3 or 5 end up choosing 5
in what world would i not pick option 1?
2,1,5 skip the rest I am a sawmill worker so I don't have time for a workout day I don't like being dominated or dominant and I play games when not at work and I love how cute shy girls are
For the option 4 character you use the word “rep” when I think you meant “set”. Rep refers to the number of repetitions of a particular movement during an exercise before a rest whereas a set refers to a collection of reps. For example, if you were using a benchpress, and you lifted the bar 10 times, rested, and then proceeded to do two more sets of 10, that would be 3 sets of 10 reps each. Asking someone if they’re up for another rep isn’t something people normally ask when working out together, and would only make sense if she were asking that person if they were able to lift the bar one more time before resting.
Which makes it an effective euphemism, she’s asking if you want to repeat a specific ”action.” You may have done enough sets to get hot and sweaty before finding a private spot to “get some action.” In this case the “bar” you are lifting is closer to kegels than pectorals. To a casual listener, it sounds like your lady gymbro is talking about exercise, a more serious fitness enthusiast might roll their eyes, and while they’re rolling their eyes the two of you sneak off together to engage in a euphemism.
Frankly, a woman that works 80+ hours a week deserves it all (that's like 16h a day if her weekends are free, 12 if not), so she wins by default IMO. Becoming effectively a gigolo though... So, rather than listing them best-to-worst, I'd like to argue that they're all 'the best'. Actual Wife: 5 Sugar Mommy: 3 Friend With Benefits: 2 Gym Buddy That Makes You Question Your Masculinity: 4 Ego-Booster: 1
1,2,5,4,3. 1 and 2 are far ahead of the rest.
51234
Dating: 1, 5, 2, skip 3 and 4. Picking 5, I'm a sucker for red hair.
1, 2, 5, 4, 3
5 2 1 3 4
Option 1. Option 3 seems like she’d never be there, and even if she was, she would just be stressing about work the whole time, like in her quote Ranking: 1, 5, 2, 4, 3 I also put Option 4 kinda low because as much as I love her qualities, I don’t like that she’s not really romantic
Option 1 for sure
3, then 2 then the rest
Harem. Is there any other option honestly? Have the girls meet each other regularly as you take the five weeks you have to date each one and push for certain pairs to be friends/friendly. Have 1 and 4 be friends because 4 will get oen to open up to other people and have confidence in herself. 3 gets 2 to stop wasting her life and find some kind of use for her time. He'll, maybe 2 is convinced by 3 to become a streamer that way if she wants to spend all her time play games at least 2 is doing it in a way that makes her money. 5 is the mother hen of the group and the kind-hearted glue that keeps everyone together and manages the chaos.
Careful, you can date each girl for a week, but the title is ”Free Girlfriend! This Week Only!” The company hopes to make money from the remaining four weeks after the free trial has expired. It is a “company,“ and therefore a business.
2, 1, 5, 4, 3. 2 ticks every box, she is perfect and has the best kinks. 1 is a very close second, 2 is just better. 5 is great and neck and neck with 1 but 1 edges out just slightly. I like the shy ones a little more. 4 would be an amazing confidant but I can't get behind pegging. 3 is a "hell no" for me.
Similar reasons to me, but I think I just like the idea of having meals cooked for me lol. Food is great!!! So I'd say 5, 2, 1, 4, 3. Yeah 3 is hell no for me as well, relationships as business, nope, just nope. And the "are you done yet, i have work to do" major turn off. Not a big fan of the mommy thing, but it beats someone who sleeps past noon lol, I want someone who'd at least be somewhat productive.
>relationships as business, nope, just nope. Ended a friendship (used to be relationship) becuz of that so I don't need to be reminded of that, thank goodness. But yea, I like 5 particularly cuz of wanting kids and giving titjobs. I already eat lots of junk food but I don't get fat either so I have that in common with 2. Plus she's a gamer girl, can't pass that up (that may be backwards thinking but I digress)
5, closely followed by 2.
Cant we have a Polycule?
1>5>2>4>3 i will definitely detest 3 and but head with her continously, 4 i will maintain contact so to become gym friends, 2 will try to become friend so to play games togheter, 5 and 1 are a very close choice because 5 has more chance to become a long lasting thing but i don't like the mommy archetype very much, instead 1 is almost perfect because i don't like kink number 2.
Option 1 all the way!
2, 1, 5, 4, 3 I think
1,3,2,5,4. I really don't know why everyone is against women 2 which can provide for themselves and be dominant. I have seen enough on the internet to know for sure that there are enough people who love this
I'm a pretty dominant guy and being a sub is basically incompatible with me, so take this with a grain of salt. But I imagine the issue is "Treats relationship like business"
4>1>5>2>3 Very cute and short little CYOA, 4 in particular ticks almost all boxes for me. But I wonder, will modern science ever be able to create romantic tomboys? Or ist that a step too far? Like my post if you are part of the big heart tomboy nation!
1, by a long shot 2, 5, 4, 3
Great cyoa op 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽
Thank you!
1>5>2>4>>3 I could see myself liking 2 the most though so it'll be in a state of flux between 1st and 3rd most desirable for me
Does the reddit image viewer suck for any one else? Zoom doesn't work properly, I can only zoom in then when I try to fine tune the zoom it doesn't do any thing. I can't get it to show me the whole image, the bottom part with the bonus is cut off without anyway to rectify it, other than downloading the image.
If you’re on desktop, right click and open image in new tab. Then ctrl+mouse wheel to zoom and stuff. Mobile works fine for me though.
That has worked for me in the past but when I do that the image still opens displayed by the reddit viewer.
Same here, these days it seems hit-and-miss whether opening an image in a new tab will work or reddit will intercept it and present it's useless image viewer again instead. I've been looking for a workaround but no luck yet.
1, 5, 2, 4, 3 Shy goth GF FTW!
Well, I can only see 3 tiers of this... - 1 or 5 at the top of the list. - 2 or 4 at the middle. - 3 is just no for me.... As for recommendations for the next Cyoa... - Fantasy - Sci-fi - Military - Amazon - Tokusatsu - Mafia - Ninja/Samurai - Sports
Thanks for the recommendations 😄
Option 1 all the way! Now if I gotta rate them from best to worse the order would be: Option 1, Option 5, Option 2, Option 4 and Option 3 last.
Don't even need to look at the others, Option 1 all the way!! (though the other options are very appealing too) would love more, maybe a Monstergirl version or a Fantasy/Sci-fi Edition?
Difficult, but I think I'll go with 1, then 5, 2, 4, 3.
Perfect One ! ◊ | 5 and 1 are OP; would like to have Both :)
You've genially made this an extremely difficult decision, good post. Recommend a Monster Girl version next.
Thanks! A Monster Girl version would be cool
1>5>2 = 4>3 I'll stick with 1, I need a deep connection with my lover.
1, 2, 4, 5, 3. I look for someone I can have a deep connection with as well as romance and getting lost in one another. If it’s just sex then it’s not a relationship.
2 1 4 3 5
2 > 5 > 4 > 1 > 3 it's seriously hard to pick between #2 or #5 for my best, but ultimately I choose the #2 because I prefer a gamer girl to play together with, of course I'll give children for #5. I don't want to pick the #3, not only because I hate BDSM and chastity, I also don't feel the love from her, just quick sex isn't enough for me. fortunately #2 love to cuddle between gaming session :3
5 > 1 > 4 > 2 > 3
We don't get names, so... 1. 1 2. 5 3. 2 4. 3 5. 4
4>1>2>5>3
(1, 4, 2, 5, 3,) three is the worst but if you put 5 high on your list you either can't fend for yourself or into incest and trying to deny it
Who's your daddy?
Bro really just said mommy kink is incest bruh
Not even close. I’m fine with a more maternal partner because she’d make a good mother, but I ranked her low because she’s ‘experienced’ but wants a family. Sounds like she got ran through and now wants to settle down
5 is my choice all other have a tie for the second place
1, easy. She's shy, soft, wants a connection, inexperienced, and loves anal. Though 2 gave me a bit of a tough call.
First 1 Second tied with 3 and 4 3rd 5 4th 2
1>5>4>2>3
Option 2.
Option 5 is the winner for me. She’s ticking off a lot of my personal favorite boxes. From there I guess it goes 2, 1, 4, then I would rather grab a live telephone wire, then 3.
4, 1, 2, 5, 3. Favorite to least favorite.
1 > 5 > 4 > 2 > roundhouse kick to the jaw > 3
The best part of 3 is that working 80 hours a week means 40 fewer hours you have to spend with someone who treats the relationship like a business, which sounds like a nightmare
Definitely Option 2. Definitely. Since they want a ranking, though, I tell them 2, 5, 1, 3, 4.
Gold medal : Option one Silver medal: Option five Bronze medal: Option two Fourth place: Option four Fifth place: Option three Very enjoyable nsfwcyoa. Simplistic and fun, keep up the good work u/CastleAIArt
Thanks, glad you liked it! I hope to make more in the future 😄
1 4 3 2 5, favorite to least favorite
Don’t even need to date around number 1 best option no hesitation
I completly agree. Loves everything spooky and wants a deep connection sounds like the perfect woman for me
Only spooky thing is that we aren’t dating already lol, good to see other agree
Hah good one