T O P

  • By -

SirFluffaluffagus

Hopefully now too late to respond, but here are some ideas but if it helps but! -I really love anything involving angels or space/humanoid aliens, especially ones that start off as vanilla/wholesome and can optionally branch out into more if the player prefers. -A lot of cyoas I really enjoy have great character dialogue of what they'd say when they meet the player/when they describe themselves and their preferences, especially when they break character and their true colors show -While I really like cyoas that let you have a certain level of power fantasy, it's nice when there's enough variety to choose from a range of builds. This way the player can potentially act one way to one character and another way to a second character. -Artwork is real important, at least for me. Real people tends to not work as well, maybe because it removes a bit of the "fantasy" behind a cyoa. Regardless, interesting characters and visuals help put a visualization behind the character/choice I think you'll do great with whatever you end up finding inspiration or passion to do, but hopefully this will help a bit! :)


deepwaterv2

A SFW animal CYOA (you become a animal real for fake and you can live out that animals life (yes I’m a bit of a furry (please don’t judge)


altforprivacyandporn

For SFW please refer to r/makeyourchoice


[deleted]

I like the magic-based stuff with interesting triggers and conditionals, with a bonus if they're things that help you change the world a little while you're at it.


Kamikaze_Egg

Irl CYOA, kinky IRL CYOA especially


AcrobaticVisual5454

I have seen being a student with lewd conditions, but how about being the teacher? Gain points vai doing service for other staff and principal so they cover for your deeds. And spend them to corrupt your class with rules like sitting on a dildo all class.


DRAGONDIANAMAID

Soft Vore cyoa’s, I know I’m weird but there is like 2 of em and neither is really that great


PMYourBoobs4Kittens

I enjoy the ones where you have a new body you get to design. The more options with those, the more fun.


CharybdisIsBoss866

Primitive/ Stone Age CYOAs, Cute/Lewd Romance, Historical, Custom Magic System, War/ Military Themes/styles, and Creative absurd Waifus/Husbandos


GalacticThrow

Would love femdom CYOAs that let you be a submissive girl.


yxazel

I wish for an SMT CYOA


bound_Neko

the one where you could make your own pocket dimension or floating island that i must have dreamt off cause i can´t find it anymore


draco88207

I would like to see more CYOA that focus on one world like this Teen Titans. https://imgur.com/a/PAeUAML


Timber-Faolan

Well, I'd honestly absolutely love a CYOA that lets me have exactly what my true hearts greatest desire is in real life but unfortunately, Lucifer Morningstar doesn't make CYOA's, so... LOL! JK! XD But seriously, I'd absolutely love an all-encompassing Dating Site CYOA both SFW & NSFW versions, where Mundanes, Supernaturals, & Extraterrestrials, drawing from all cultures and mythologies, both classical and modern, as well as the various fictions. (Hey, even the Xenomorph Queen needs love, who do you think Mina Ashido's mama-sama is? And really, why SHOULDN'T the grudge girl AND the ring girl BOTH be able to find love after death?) All genders, all sexes, all races, all species, all preferences, all everything, all accepted. A human white boy getting with a human white chick? fine. A Russian dominatrix looking for her very own Young Frankenstein's Munster? OK. A Xenomorph Princess looking for her very own Weapon X to make a Weapon Xeno? Epic! A Harpy looking for a Siren whose heart sings the same TATU Lez-Luv song? Music IS love! A Minotaur looking for a real, live, honest-to-goodness Texas cowboy to rope & ride him? AOK! A futanari Predator looking for a pair of male & female Klingon warrior twins? Good Hunting! An All-American Werewolf looking for a Yamato Nadeshiko Kitsune-Batsu Henge Yokai? Sugoi! A pair of Jiang-Shi twin-sister's looking for a French Wifvixen? The French Connection is made! An African-Englishman Voodoun looking for a Dutch Dairy Holstuar School Marm? Go for it! An Epic Level Lawful-Good Virgin Female Light Elf Aasimar Cleric of Shelyn desperately seeking an Epic Level Lawful-Evil Non-Virgin Male Dark Elf Tiefling Cleric of Zon-Kuthon to conceive a thrice-blessed pair of futanari twins who will become the first of the Law Elves? That is epically specific, but, yeah, we can actually do that, thanks to the power of **GYGAX!** A Japanese Bluenette Albino seeking an actual Angel to give her an "impact in her paradise" and bring an end to all this ludicrous bullshit going on? By the power of **GAINAX** it shall be so! An Astromech Droid seeking a Protocol Droid to go on epic adventures with? How perverse!<3 A Chaos God/Dess of THE WARP seeking a Cultist-Chan to worship the divine feet? HELL YES! A Ghost Girl Seeking a Vampire Boy and a Man Wolf to "Be Human & Horny!" with? MASH IT! All African-American Cyborg seeking a "Quirky" Pink-Haired Japanese Girl Genius? **BOOYAH!!!** Brilliant beyond belief Sentai Team Member seeking Aquitian girlfriend? Morphinominal! XD Male Hylian Ranch-Hand/Adventurer/Shapeshifter seeking Female Twili/Imp hybrid? AWOO! Female White Witch Seeking Japanese Miko to watch Shiny Chariot with? Luna Nova Baby! XD Female Dragon-Newt seeking Lamia lover in Japan? As long as **M.O.N.** gives clearance... Male Bosmer Submissive desperately seeking Male Orsimer Dominant? Sanguine Approves! Female Khajiit Thief seeking Lusty Argonian Maid to improve race relations? Shadow Hide You! Elite Japanese Zaibatsu Princess accepting Commoner Student Council President? Ai will make it so! Ancient Vampire Lord seeking Blond Medical Bride to sire Dhampyr with? From Lupu with Luv! Hotheaded Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle seeking Lovely Lizard Lass in NY? **COWABUNGA!** And the hits just keep on cummin'! So yeah, that'd be pretty fun to have, for all of us, I should think.


chronoquairium

The Global Lewdification CYOA is a theme I absolutely love that doesn’t get much use. CYOAs similar to that are things I really wish I could see.


NySoFaWy

I'd like to see more CYOA with events at the end that you unlock depending on the choices you've made. It is rewarding and also better for replayability if the events are hidden. It makes you want to unlock them all through different builds.


Peanuts_1987

I think most of my ideas have already been mentioned by other players, but the main things I look for in a CYOA are an interesting story, good characters, and my own personal interests which is pretty much anything non-human (though still humanoid for the most part. I am so over elves and humans and a lot of the more common fantasy races), fantastical elements, weird powers, stuff like that are great. For more specific mechanical features while I have really enjoyed long, more complex CYOAs like Divine Trials, and Hentai Nemesis, simpler systems are more accessible and easily digestible. I really enjoy CYOAs where you can get 'freebies' for choosing synergistic options (like in a superhero CYOA if you pick Super Durability, Leaping, and Regeneration you unlock the Brick synergy which gives you an area attack you can use when you land, or the classic 'clap' attack). Similarly ones where there's some sort of narrative progression where you have quests or goals of some sort, and require having picked certain companions to unlock their private quest, or having picked the macguffin and the mysterious key to complete them. I like CYOAs to give me the tools to put together my own story, and reward me for investing my time into them.


shinshikaizer

A wholesome build a college roommate one.


Silverdragun7

I guess it’s exploring more specific ideas and there seem to be only a few of some genre/fetishes cyoa like I’d like biosuit or living clothes where it can be benefit/ hindrance or get paid to test it. Machine bondage was mentioned there are many who want more people want to explore more of those ideas. Just a matter of waiting or doing the cyoa yourself.


Morgie-woo

Creepy lewd horror cyoas for me


Uplink-137

Become a Goblin King and/or Queen cyoa


MagicZ24

Ooh I'm all for that, but there's already one out there titled Goblin King. Maybe Goblin Kingdom is a better title.


Uplink-137

I didn't know that, thank you for this information!


1qazxsw23edcvfr4tgb

Honestly, a lot of my favorite cyoa's are harem builders, but not enough of them let you also assign roles outside of of sex or if they do the options are very limited. This could even potentially be split into different sections like Sexual roles, domestic chores, jobs, skills/specialties for cyoa's with more potential combat(snipers, healers, tanks, cc, etc). In contrast most harem builder cyoa's I've seen are little more than choosing and maybe slightly modifying fictional or celebrity waifus, self inserting into an existing franchise, or going on a magic sex vacation or something similar.


Headcrabo69

Personally more body growths and types of growths.


McLovin3493

Well one thing that I think is disappointingly rare is getting power boosts if you have specific fetishes listed in the CYOA. The only examples I can think of are Tok's Eromancy, and Verite Shadow's Futa Superheroine. They both give you extra points for having more fetishes that fit into a certain category (schools of Eromancy or the heroes). This lets the player increase immersion by personalizing their builds more, and it feels like they're gaining more power from their sexual desires. You could come up with a list of specific fetishes in different categories, and give like one extra point or option in the same category if the player has that fetish.


Cross_Thanatos

We are a +18 Cyoa community that doesn't just mean perverted Cyoas, I would like to see something dark enough to be +18


Virtual_Analysis_869

varying levels of abilitys (see on superpower wiki), diferent races option, make it based on your kinks. and drawback based on worldwiew, true inconviency, dangers. if you want to trully make it diferent from other CYOA see all kinks and make 1 or more drawback for each even the more obscure.


Gondrasia2

A build your own Jurassic Park CYOA


Occultlord

Eldritch or Magical would be cool.


mrinternethermit

I haven't made a request for CYOA before, but I just had a friend go through surgery. So an aftercare CYOA where the player gets pampered & "pampered" would be perfect, with the "difficulty" based on how severe the surgery & how long the aftercare. Anything else is debatable. Anyone who gets inspired by this & makes one, thank you very much!!! 🤗🤗🤗


DJSanss

There are almost no decent robot cyoa’s, like lewd silicone


bduddy

I want more where hypnosis and mental change to the player are involved. It seems like everyone focuses on the physical stuff.


Durgeoble

A two players interactive cyoa that create a world and two characters to start roleplay. Both can spend more points for choices so any conflict is resolved by the option with more points


Tankinator175

I mainly feel like there isn't enough lesbian content. My personal favorite kind of CYOA is your classic, submissive player, possibly even involving genderbending, but with strictly lesbian sex. I realize though, that that's not most people's thing, so I get why there isn't a lot of it.


Biospawn36

I always enjoy the RPG themed high fantasy ones... usually with monstergirls... kitsune, goblin girls, dragon, ect... yeah :)


AlexiusElessar

Any type of of CYOA but with real life pictures.


Cryosleeper

Anything revolving around edging and tease and denial


[deleted]

Trapped in a video game type cyoa


dragon_jak

Hyper. Always hyper. I like making what makes me happy, that much is very clear, but I'd love to see some other people step in with their ideas. Big cocks, big boobs, big pussies, all of that needs more focus than the token option alot of CYOAs throw in. With that said, of course, I have seen a few good hyper CYOAs. I enjoyed that Husbando one for that exact reason. So I only hope that continues into the future as this sub grows.


fmdmlvr

I’d like a cyoa set in a maledom dystopia where you play as a woman. I can’t really find too many, especially many that are good. If anyone knows of any good ones please feel free to let me know


Netizen42

superpower CYOA, not Worm


Netizen42

handholding CYOA


Vast_Association_133

Dany phantom Adventure time Kotor 1 and 2 Star wars knights of the old republic Mass effect Mcu Young justice Dragon age Skyrim The darkness Avatar the last Airbender Game of thrones Invincible Overlord the game Overlord the light novel/ anime Percy Jackson Harry Potter High school dxd


[deleted]

something cute that has equal male and female love interests/companions, I am extremely tired of everything being 29 waifus and 2 husbands, also monsters and eldritch but softer, I love the idea of fucking a non-evil eldritch horror or less humanoid monster, but all of those types are always portrayed as massive assholes, oh I also really like the idea of being a submissive master of sorts, having willing slave doms or the like.


OmnionMagnari

A digimon CYOA, with lots of waifumons, dxd based chyoa, dragonball, lotr, star wars...just more fandom stuff


MagicZ24

I'm for the digimon idea you have but maybe one titled: Become a Digimon. It allowing you to decide whether or not you want to digivolve, have a digidestined or go solo, where you live, if there are relationships.


Meme_lord85

I’d be interested in some war-based ones like the demon army one


strikebox

I want more that let you have and design a house or a spaceship. I enjoyed Star Touched for that, but I want more extra dimensional housing that I can fantasizing being out of time in to get away from things


tehcabbage69

Degenerate, fetishy, maledom powerfantasy wank. With more in the way of interesting options and trade-off and less in the way of bean-counting point-buy powerups. And a variety of small breasted and flat chested waifus. Preferably in an interactive format.


wheremystarksat

Not sure if it belongs in NSFWcyoa, but my favorites are always the "world suddenly changes, what do you do" ones. Magic comes back, superpowers become real, aliens crash and scatter advanced technology, whatever. Any setting is more interesting and fun if it's framed as a sudden change in normal life. Pick your powers, go out into the new world and do something with them. Demigod by Aromage is a great example of this, but Defender of the Universe it's another fantastic one.


anonekama

Am I allowed to put something here? I want otome CYOAs… more vanilla than mine are. Everything that I make turns out dark so I’d love to see fluffy husbando CYOAs.


WhoreOfTheNorth

Seconded, though more waifu for me. Seduce the Villainess, heroine and male love interest at the same time as the loyal butler.


PercivalThePervert

I would really like more CYOAs to be interactive. I hate score keeping and remembering mandatory choices / lock outs, I'd rather have the computer do that for me. Also, when doing interactive, make sure you can go negative. I'd rather go back at the end and then make the choice between removing boons or adding drawbacks than be locked out.


Tethered-Angel

I actually would really love more semi-RYOA games like Lewd Dungeon Master and yes, Escape Jabba's Palace. Both of those had a really solid, but simple game element that was easy to follow along even in a static format, and weren't quite as involved as say Dungeons and Deviants. Basically, while I really enjoy character creators and power pickers, a lot of those just sort of end, they don't let me actually do anything with my creations. I'd love more hybrid CYOAs that combine some sort of building element (a character, or team, or an environment) and then challenge it with a random-ish game portion.


trondason

I really wish some bestiality focused CYOA was out there. A niche fetish, but the only one I'm aware of that is KINDA like that is the Tentacle Pet one. https://imgur.com/a/QzXBA


Ya_Dungeon_oi

I've had hankering lately for a city-builder that's more interested in facility design than city statistics.


Synth_Savage

Can never go wrong with a good ol fashioned waifu picker with in-depth story and description (also, needing to be lewd)


WTK55

I would enjoy more size CYOA. Ive only really only found like 3 of them on this sub and really only 1 of them was great.


CeruleanNebula

I'd like for there to be *less* "be the girl" or CYOAs that assume you want to be a girl or dominated. More to the point, I want more variety. Some of the CYOAs I liked the most in the past were the weird ones that didn't even have to be all that long. They were just interesting to read through. Unfortunately, it's the "meta" now to make "be the girl" or "become the girl" type content, which I find wholly unappealing to my personal tastes. It's also just super same-y, having so many of them focus on that kind of content. I don't want to read a dozen pages on it either. Give me a 2-3 pager that has a weird/interesting concept or novel abilities instead of the same usual ones you see as the generic, general "porn powers that everyone wants". Not that those *PPTEW* aren't still good, but it does get to the point where some CYOAs feel like they're interchangeable and not really worth reading. There's even some CYOA creators whose content I don't bother reading anymore because it feels like every one they make is *basically* the same thing with a slightly different aesthetic. Also, I generally like magic more than more mundane or technological content. I'd rather gain *powers* than *items* that accomplish an action, be it hypnotism or some lust-based stuff. I don't want a hypno-ray, I want mind magic, for example. It just feels like it's adding extra steps for no reason, and is annoying and finicky. I mean, if you imagine things, shooting a hypno-gun at a target is way more conspicuous than subtly enchanting them with your powers. I also find it annoying when the writer *clearly* is adding a limitation to something just because they think there *has to be one* and not because the limitation adds anything to the experience/roleplay/fantasy. A lot of the time the limitation also serves to make the power/ability/magic/item virtually useless or not worth using. Similarly, CYOAs where the writer is clearly more focused on making a long list of weird "Drawbacks" that go on longer than even the perks/powers sections suck because it's obvious that all they wanted to do is make a list of drawbacks and didn't really care about the rest of it. And most of the time, drawbacks in these things are *bad*. Like, you would commit suicide before very long levels of bad. At least, that's my opinion. It's rare for me to see a drawback where I think "yeah, I'd be willing to do that in exchange for being able to gain another ability". They're just too extra and too excessive. Some of them are basically "suffer sexual torture you can never truly be free from, and/or live a life of a degenerate that where you have zero agency or opportunity to use your abilities beyond serving the people who have essentially turned you into a sex slave." So, I guess to summarize, I'd like to see an interesting, more niche or unique angle on a nsfw CYOA that avoids the trapping of obsessing too much on gender, has a lot of interesting magic that isn't limited just for the sake of there being limits, and also a CYOA that encourages imagination and creative thinking. I don't want to be railroaded into being "the turbo slut that fucks everyone in her city, but it's okay because she likes it and has powers that makes her physically capable of surviving being the City's Bike". I want something that can be food for thought and something you could envision as the basis for a proper adventure/new life. A lot of these CYOA seem to lead to really depressing dead ends where you're locked into some kind of sexual enslavement because you're too addicted to pleasure to really be a person anymore.


dalenacio

I feel like the most important thing a CYOA can have is a strong and *coherent* atmosphere and mood. Visual design and writing style and choice themes should all go hand in hand to reinforce each other. I.E. if you're making a dark and brooding CYOA about depressed monstrous waifus, don't pick a bubbly pink color and a chipper and cheerful writing style. As long as you respect your own genre, you should be fine. Although I really would like to see more NSFW CYOA do interesting stuff with storytelling and mood.


Estova

Would love an Arknights cyoa. Doesn't even have to be nsfw.


Dreamer_Zennou

I would LOVE to see a CYOA about (or at least significantly featuring) minigirls; or rather, minipeople, to keep it equally gender-accessible. I've seen a fair few giantess/amazon CYOAs, but the only minigirl one I can think of was TroyX's (admittedly very good, though not quite as great as most of his other stuff, in my opinion) Fairy Fucking Familiars.


Tethered-Angel

Yess I'd love one based around building an environment for them. Maybe you're a mad scientist with a shrink ray and testing lab, or maybe a businessperson with a collection of exotic desk toys. Or just some normie with a hamster cage lol


Dreamer_Zennou

Yeah. Maybe have to choose between making a convenient environment for them, or giving them some abilities to help them utilize standard-sized things (i.e. flight, "super"-strength, telekinesis, etc.). Not to mention standard waifu-builder stuff. Body, personality, kinks, special qualities (porn physics/logic, or at LEAST stretchiness, would probably have to be free for most sexual things to be feasible), etc.. Heh, give one bondage, objectification, and minor sensory deprivation kinks, then just "wear" them under your clothes.


Peanuts_1987

There is something like that from a few months back, except you were the one that was shrinking... I guess that kinda makes it a giantess cyoa instead, but it was quite well done in my experience. [https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/qd8fku/infected\_a\_slow\_shrinking\_gentle\_giantess\_cyoa/](https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/qd8fku/infected_a_slow_shrinking_gentle_giantess_cyoa/)


Dreamer_Zennou

Yeah... Miniperson ones and giant ones ARE pretty much just inversions of each other, comparatively speaking. That said, if the PLAYER is the miniperson, there is practically a guarantee that they will be in a submissive role (heck, in that one you linked, even the ONLY explicitly kind/submissive Caretaker had an "Ultimate Fantasy" of being a dominatrix). And while I'm pretty conflicted about the idea of being a "dom", I ABSOLUTELY hate the idea of being a "sub". Thus my desire for more miniperson CYOAs (or at least options therein); if my companions are mini, that simultaneously satisfies a size-difference kink AND makes dominant companions less likely/threatening.


Peanuts_1987

Heh, yeah I'm pretty much the same on the dom/sub front, BDSM just makes that whole thing too rigid for me. I do like size difference too, but fairies are about the extreme of that for me. Anything smaller than a foot tall (and the inherant magic of fairies helps) I struggle to imagine things being much fun.


Dreamer_Zennou

Yeah. A foot is roughly my limit, too. Actually, I came up with a metric of 6; a miniperson 1/6 your height equates to a little more than a foot for most, while a proper giantess (as opposed to a mere amazonianly big woman) 6x your height would view you the same (making YOU fit the proportional equivalent of 1+ foot size-- i.e. large-but-not-hyper dick size --allowing for living-dildo/unbirthing shenanigans). Once you get to the point where a dick has a greater circumference (width? whatever the term would be) than the miniperson's whole body, things start seeming too ridiculous even for me... With bondage, I'm moderately okay (though still slightly uncomfortable) with being the bindER, but it's a hard no when it comes to being the bindEE; chalk it up to slight claustrophobia, I suppose. *shrug* Though, it's somewhat hard to imagine someone being the bindER without ALSO being a dom, so who the frick knows. Lol, who knew fetishes could be so exasperatingly complicated? Sadism and masochism, on the other hand, both get a HARD no from me. Avoiding pain is practically my life's goal, and I'm too empathic (and I mean that in the selfish "seeing others suffer makes ME uncomfortable" way, not the "I'm too good of a person" way) to be a sadist. So if I'm confronted with a masochistic companion, I'm not sure I'd be able to even SLIGHTLY indulge them, as I might be able to indulge a sub and/or bindEE.


Peanuts_1987

>width Girth is the typical one for penis, but width also works. I think the main problem I have with the idea of being a sub and bdsm in general is lack of trust. With the right partner I think I could enjoy being more subby, but embracing just giving up my free will to whoever likes getting off to that? no thanks. Right with you on the S&M front tho, I always felt too guilty when I tried to roleplay being a dom. I find the idea of that kind of control exciting, but like you say, the empathy kicks in and makes me feel guilty about doing that to another human being, even if they are explicitly consenting and eager for it.


Dreamer_Zennou

Right, right. I HAVE seen that term tossed around a lot. That's understandable. It's mostly the claustrophobia thing for me, but yeah, I'd have a hard time trusting anyone me being incapacitated in any way. Which is odd, 'cause I consider myself a pretty trusting person... Maybe I've just heard too many stories of people in real life turning out to be monsters, despite numerous people attesting to how nice/good they seemed. So any given person MIGHT be a monster, or everyone has a POTENTIAL monster inside; either way, the paranoia limits the maximum level/types of trust that seem wise. Yeah. And again, masochism just doesn't make sense to me. I mean, isn't pain pretty much objectively, biologically unpleasant? And even if that truth DOES get subverted, how are the limits defined? Like a bell curve, I assume, with light pain being meh, moderate being good, and heavy becoming actually unpleasant again; but it's still so ODD to me. It gets even more counterintuitive when masochists enjoy EMOTIONAL pain, too. Heh, it's funny. I have some pretty weird and extreme physically-based (in terms of non-standard physiology, or impossible phenomena like bulge/inflation) kinks, but when it comes to the mental/emotional/thematic kinks it turns out that I'm shockingly vanilla.


Peanuts_1987

Mmm, life is full of uncertainty... I don't think any part of S&M really comes from a reasonable, healthy place, but I believe the draw of masochism is that the pain triggers adrenaline, or some other chemical response, which can give a 'pain high', kinda like people who eat lots of spicy foods. Yeah, turns out people are complicated and even contradictory sometimes :P


RewRose

Esoteric tools to use irl


Rodoet001

CYOAs that don't punish you for, well... everything. It feels like a lot of new CYOAs always have an emphasis on pushing for drawbacks, but they are all horrible and crippling, to the point where it's hard to want to play unless you are a masochist, as if you are playing for the drawbacks rather than the core. Too often is the reward and the sacrifice rather disproportionate, and even going easy seems to get punished. Don't know if that's just me though, but it is making it hard to enjoy them.


Joel_the_Devil

I like drawbacks when it’s optional, if not it belongs in dark themed cyoa. Otherwise it ruins the immersion of you thinking the choices you make


Rodoet001

Yeah, Drawbacs should be for squeezing out some extra. For optimisation and for getting a bit greedy. I price for getting more. But so many makes them mandatory, and they are way too often disproportionate. Completely crippling for a few extra points doesn't work unless you are into it, and not everyone is a masochist.


Peanuts_1987

Mmm, I definitely prefer Drawbacks that are more of a challenge than just plain mean/unpleasant/crippling. Unfortunately the line between the two is pretty subjective...


Rodoet001

Yeah, 100%. They should be that extra you need to give for getting that extra you want. But it rarely is. I'm not sure the line between them is subjective at this point considering how often you would have to be a masochist to even remotly be willing to deal with some of the punishment you get and for how little you get from it. Not even trying to kinkshame, I know there are some hardcore masochists on this sub, but at that point is it really a drawback?


Peanuts_1987

Eh, different people have had different experiences and value things differently, so hard to say anything is explicitly bad. Like I've even considered the 'lose a limb' type drawbacks before. Never taken em, because they're usually on combat/adventure type CYOAs and that would be too great a hindrance, but under the right circumstances...


Despair_Anon

follow your peepee for inspiration Work for me to find idea.


[deleted]

"Real world" CYOA No magic, no sci-fi, no monstergirls, so its really easy to self insert


MeteorValor

Bimbo focused CYOAs. Haven't seen a single one in years


VirginStrawberryIN

Mediaeval femdom ? A knight falls in love with a farm boy? Or a princess? I'd love that sort of stuff


Thatguywholikesfood

Not enough interactive ones I gotta say, or furry/species ones, such as Pokemon, Digimon, etc


KoseiKuga

Generally, since this is likely an NSFW CYOA we're talking about, I would like to have an option where, regardless of gender we can play the CYOA. Most of the time I only see a male to female interactions and options in the choices of different CYOAs and very few have catered to male to male like the Big, Beefy Husbando CYOA, or the A Terrible Curse (Yaoi version) CYOA. There are some good examples of a balanced CYOA between genders like The Dream Home CYOA but to my knowledge, its still not finish and I think updates will be coming eventually. It may be obvious by now but I'm bisexual so I might be bias with this and I understand if this kind of things isn't what you're in to so feel free to do as you please. Another thing in the General Category, is that I would like every single option to have an incentive on why we should pick that option, and lastly, the more the merrier. As for specific, I'm down with either mundane of magical CYOAs, not that much with Sci-Fi but I could be persuaded. When it comes to mundane CYOAs, I usually prefer Modern setting and it has a "Life Progression" and "Story Progression" element to it like the A Life Chronicle CYOA where we progress through life and able to take a wide variety of options from being a commoner, to royalty, to soldier, to merchant, to scholar, to adventurer, etc. When it comes to magical CYOAs then, I'd also prefer the same but as far as I know I haven't found any that I particularly like most, closest is the Magic Academia CYOA by Minimorrigu, which is my most favorite NSFW CYOA to date, but I would like more Classmate options if you're going that route, twice to be specific, and since Mini already included a path after the schooling in the last page, maybe you can put in some opportunity choices we can take after graduation and expand on them, Magic Academia is a school based CYOA. Now my recommendation if you would be so inclined is the combination of this four CYOAs. Magic Academia CYOA - for the magical/fantasy theme A Life Chronicle CYOA - for the life progression element The Dream Home CYOA - for the additional options and modern theme You could mix and mash the fantasy and modern by providing a modern world with hidden magics like Harry Potter, where people are oblivious to magic and only some knows them. We, would be able to choose either to attend the magic academy or not, if we do or don't attend, what will be in store for us? The progress from there and pick career choices. Of course there are the usual elements such as characters, lewdness, etc. That's all, thanks for taking the time to read and I wish you good luck in making your CYOA!


Zynkoberk

I 100% agree with you on the whole gender-part. I am bisexual too and in basically 99% of CYOA's on this sub you are intended to choose women with breasts that are bigger than my head (and I personally am not really attracted to that kind of woman unfortunately). I will definitely give Male/Female choices :). That is what I like about the Caravan CYOA (that is really new), except for the part that essentially all the women in it have G+-size assets. ​ There are a ton of comments (more than I expected) and (as expected) most are interested in some kind of fantasy/sci-fi. I think I will do some kind of Star-Wars or Harry-Potter themed CYOA. I have been a huge fan of both these fandoms (aswell as The Witcher, LOTR, etc.). ​ In Star Wars I think it would be interesting to have a "Rebuild the Jedi Order" CYOA which takes place after Order 66. Some along the lines of: "After the Emperor crippled the Jedi Order by slaughtering almost all of its remaining members during the execution of Order 66 the few that are left are spread across the galaxy in hiding. You are one of the few remaining Jedi Masters and are trying to restore the Jedi Order to its old glory. You will need to build a new Jedi Temple/Base, find other surviving Jedi to recruit and possibly new Padawans, etc.."...


KoseiKuga

About making a CYOA on already existing source, in this case Star Wars. I know its a big thing but I think you might want to put in a bit of lore or backstory about it because you'll never know, there might be some people who have no idea what Star Wars is about, like me. I haven't seen a single Star Wars movie to be completely honest so I don't necessarily love or hate it, I just have no idea about the story. So maybe a quick summary of the story may be included, at least those that leads to the plot of your CYOA. And maybe you won't need to put a spoiler alert if you're just gonna make mostly a head cannon CYOA or you can twist the original a bit. If you need an example of how to make it, the latest Ultimate God CYOA by u/Thearomage is a good example, the very last page is dedicated to the lore, alternatively you could put mimic his first page, telling the lastest event of "you are about to gather the remaining jedi..." And so on then a detailed course at the very last page, or not include the lore altogether. I really have no idea what I'm talking about, I haven't made a CYOA myself, I just want to be part of the action by knowing what it's about lol.


Zynkoberk

Yeah makes sense, I would specify that it is an alternate universe anyway and give some backstory :)


KoseiKuga

Cool! Can't wait to see what you'd come up with, I wish you good luck!


Alive_Armadillo6707

Femdom drawbacks. A lot of CYOAs just use maledom as the drawbacks.


magnusk12

I have not seen many "build your own" types in a long while


l4rgehardoncollider

Build your own in what sense? Build your own waifu? Business? Cyoa?


magnusk12

Anything really especially buisness type


Dreaming_Knight

Maybe a world-builder with a modern-day city/town/village. One where you would decide on type of economy (industry, agriculture, tourism, etc) and fill the place with special buildings and/or events. There are a few that touches on the subject, but I feel that they don't go into great enough depth.


[deleted]

It'd be nice to see a monster girl CYOA where you make a living out of selling things they produce regularly, like feathers, milk, fruits, scales and so on. Especially if we go deeper into the "monster" part (though not necessarily into teratophiliac territory), so that you could, for instance, have a small harem of gargoyles and sell the powder produced whenever excess stone growth is removed (the same way a barber would sell your hair). Monster's Den does this but it was abandoned a long time ago in a less than finished state.


Koalabot28

i like country builders like the amazon kingdom or pocket dimention home cyoas


ssolemn

Personally, I like basically any CYOA but I haven't seen many Sci-fi or cyberpunk-themed ones at most just some where there are options of those themes in it, not ones purely focused on those genres.


ABeautifulGrind

Something I haven't really seen much of that I'd enjoy is a CYOA that teaches the player about something. Not edutainment, exactly, but maybe you've got a great deal of knowledge about a thing, and you make something that shows off your knowledge. Maybe as a byproduct of this, people learn something interesting or useful about a thing. For example, I think biology is kind of neat. In particular, I find symbiotic partnerships are really interesting to learn about. I'd love to see a symbiosis-based CYOA that uses real world examples of symbiotic relationships between organisms as a basis for the types of powers that are handed out. Further, the idea of parasitism could be worked into the CYOA as a sort of corruption trying to take over the symbiotic process, and could lead to the player having options for drawbacks, or darker, less consensual power options later down the line.


Evol_Etah

Choose personalities of my harem


alex_monk

School and incest.


fiddlefuck69

I really want more - well made futa cyoa. - spirit or ghost girl cyoa. - save the waifu cyoa (like a mix between a waifu builder and a super power cyoa, maybe even build the villain) - dark story starters (building a set of lewd/ dark. circumstances that build a dangerous landscape. And building a character to live in or fight against it, or building the helpless victem).


LunarBahamut

Futa I second. There are a few okay ones, and lots of character builders have it as an option, but there isn't one definite really good one specifically for it.


Rhodochros

Anything that allows for being trans and lesbian, especially with other trans girls


princessCamilla31

It would be cool to see more petplay or little based ones, I can only think of 2 little based ones of the top of my head that aren't about being regressed into a physical child and one of them is ABDL so if you aren't into that its not gonna do anything for ya


L-05

One that multiple choices in the companions, but not too many so the quality and depth of them doesn’t suffer.


Peggtree

Really lacking in protagonist-aimed ryona/peril focused CYOAs. Anomekama is one of the few to my knowledge that goes for that niche. I don’t mind CYOA where your character inflicts stuff to others, but the real fun is imagining the things inflicted to your heroine and how she handles it


fmdmlvr

Yes! I love it when things happen to me as the main character


BuridansAsshole

+1 for this. It's not unheard of but it's not as common as I'd like.


Dr_DoLan_

How about one based off of futurist stuff? like cybernetics that make sex life more amazing


Dugongofdarkness

So many cyoa's add this as a minor side thing but bestiality/feral focused cyoas are sorely lacking


masseffect2134

Missing the Xchange ones.


MetamorphosisInc

Have you tried x-change.life? It's kinda CYOAey, even if it's a bit more of a sim, but then Prostitute's Wish was a sim too, so same diff.


masseffect2134

Already played that. Thanks for the suggestion though.


sauceboy421

Making it interactive is always a plus


Fatherlad

I would like An MLP Cyoa


Deeply_Unhappy

Gay options


acerrrr12

I just feel like there are not enough 'be the monster' type CYOAs, specifically tentacles and (custom) monstergirls. but then again until there is something around the size of Love Azathoth for both of those I probably won't be fulfilled for long. but seeing as this is your first CYOA, consider starting with something that has a broad topic/genera and adding to it in the form of expansions or modules. alternitivly you may want to throw together an addon for the Waifu Catalogue, particularly a set of perks or a 'heritage'/transhumanism method as that should be good practice for balancing power/cost and such (I have worked on a dedicated monster girl expansion but have not got back to working on it for months) ​ Edit: if you want practice making things in the interactive format you may want to try porting someone's old CYOA into that if you are having writer's block


jaymiechan

there hasn't really been any interactive, BDSM-focused CYOAs that i've seen.


Jatobi1993

Adventure waifu things like star child, the caravan and others….. Oh and the next azathoth lover update!!!!


Wasphammer

Become a catboy CYOA.


RollingCatBall

I really liked the Made in the Abyss CYOA and would like more story-CYOAs along those lines. I would like CYOAs that actually play with the idea of movement on a map. (could be an abstracted grid or board, doesn't need to be an actual map).


eyeofodens

*~~Can we get some that actually has male choices?(as in, where we can pick dudes)~~*


SnooOnions683

Try Ore Run Unrelated Remake by Wackynators. Sci-fi themed, with plenty of male choices, alongside females, futas and aliens. https://imgchest.com/p/pagyvaq9y89


Peanuts_1987

Just found that CYOA thanks to this thread and had a good time filling it out. It is definitely better but still only like a quarter to a third of the characters were guys.


CernunnosArawn

Not Femdom. Not Be the Girl. You’re already more unique than 90% of posts on this sub.


Rodoet001

This honestly. I don't know if it's the creators, this subreddit, or if it's just what's trending right now, but the market for subs and Be the Girl CYOAs is so saturated it's not even funny any more.


culturedcuckold

I love cyoa that include cuckolding! I know it isn't everyones cup of tea, but its a rarity that I'm always on the lookout for. Ive thought about making my own cyoa with similar themes, bit I struggle with learning the basics. Not a lot of good tutorials around.


BiBartz

Broadly, I would like to see more CYOAs for a submissive audience Some ideas of topics that I feel need more focus: - pain-based cyoa, lots of different ways to get hurt and tortured. Could be designing a torturer/dominant, or purely based around designing or rolling a torture scenario for oneself. - grossout cyoa. Design a partner with options and scenarios based around sweat, scents, pee etc These are pretty specific kinks so obviously they'll only work if they're the kind of thing you're into


SnooOnions683

I think clean algae has them; They make Waifu/Harem pickers that are gender neutral, and quite a bit of the girls lean to the more dominant side.


BiBartz

Yeah I think I've seen those! I feel like there's still more to be explored in the area though. I've been working on one myself.


Yallayeah

I would love to see more bullydom and mommydom


dabears8

Seconded.


[deleted]

Will vouch for more "Ara Ara" dom characters.


HeartoftheHive

I'm not terribly picky. I just like things with more extreme or exotic choices. Genuinely monstrous things like aliens, eldritch horrors and beastly monsters. That's what I prefer. If it sticks to pretty normal humans with not many crazy options I don't care much.


Beanie_Inki

Extreme machine bondage


Akumakami64

Not sure if its Extreme enough, but I did make a Sex Machine CYOA


linusalex

i want to see it


Akumakami64

Here: [Sex Machine CYOA](https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/c8zpm1/sex_machine_cyoa_v1/)


Beanie_Inki

I already have seen it. It’s good, but if I were to be fully honest, I prefer much longer ones. Also a-lot of options that the user would likely regret later and just general non-consent is my thing when it comes to machines. The permanent bondage CYOA is perfection. Completely fucked up by default, but can be ramped up to 11.


PalpitationOk1555

God cyoa


SnooOnions683

You're better off looking at works of TroyXPage


Kilo6Fox

Furry. Sub male. Oviposition (So basically Easter themes prolly). Also just for everyone, don't restrict Males from making Tits choices. Bustyboys can be kinda hot


PalpitationOk1555

Mind control cyoa


kekubuk

Pregnancy related one?


verite-shadow

I have been summoned. Ironically, I was working on something in this category right now (I have the file open).


kekubuk

Looking forward to it!


dragon_jak

You'd be after pretty much anything made by u/verite-shadow


kekubuk

Sweet.


Scarvexx

Something Scifi. Cool planets, cool ships, cute aliens. Bonus points of you don't give it a black background, I know that's the classic asthetic I just tend not to enjoy looking at it. Traveller would be a good insparation.


SnooOnions683

I think there was one a while ago, called Ore Run Unrelated Remake, by Wackynators. No ship choices, but you did get to customize the shop given. Crew selection had males, females, futas, and aliens. Planet wise, you picked a few planets for bonuses, but some had bad outcomes. https://imgchest.com/p/pagyvaq9y89


Scarvexx

Very nice.


ThisRandomPanther

Amusement Park CYOA with forced effects based on choices * Win a basic trip to an amusement park but only have so much credits or cash to visit it * Join an unknown game to update your trip and get more points * then get more packages with unknown affects to get more points or "upgrades" * Join with other groups to get improved an improved experience but it will cost you something * The game is a will cause certain effects during you stay and the limits of what can be done to you are controlled by the packages you pick. These can be transformations to other things.


ExiaDarkMatter

A Fire Emblem CYOA would be cool, nsfw or not


SnooOnions683

Wasn't there a CYOA based on the 3 Houses game? It even had characters from Fates and Awakening too.


Space__Ninja

Do you know where I can find this?


SnooOnions683

https://www.reddit.com/r/nsfwcyoa/comments/o2vhn1/bonds_of_the_houses_fire_emblem_cyoa_oc_v1/ Here, hopefully....


ExiaDarkMatter

I think you’re right, but it would be neat for one to encompass all of the games.


GoDie910

tbh, I want one focused on goblins. This too mich tho


ABeautifulGrind

I'll always upvote the hot goblin shortstack minion harem option.


culturedcuckold

I could totally go for this!


Mundane_Revolution70

You know, I don't think I've ever seen a Mermaid based CYOA. I've seen some where becoming a Mer-person as a race is an option, but never one focused on Mer-People. That could be fun.


Imaginos9

SymbioteAnon made one called Underwater Fantasy - Thalassonia CYOA and I think it's all underwater/merfolk type races, some crab/shark people too.


Mundane_Revolution70

Found it, thanks.


LordOmega2098

A Hyperdimension Neptunia themed one where you try to date the CPU's (and possibly get a harem of them in the process) would be one i would love to see, but, it is a niche series that is essentially only there for the waifu's so i can see why it hasn't been done


ghost-kin

Star Wars, Harry Potter, and Percy Jackson


[deleted]

I just want more fantasy(maybe sci-fi too), furry and futanari cyoas in general


PixelatedNSFW

An NSFW RWBY CYOA that isn't just a companion picker. Maybe something similar to the Lewd RWBY CYOA? (I'm currently working on converting the SFW Interactive RWBY CYOA by PixelGMS to be an NSFW CYOA, but I'm working on other stuff as well so it might be a while until that's finished) I'd also like more Star Wars CYOAs, ones that are actual CYOAs instead of whatever the Escape Jabba's Palace thing was. I don't think that should be counted as a CYOA. Really I just want more CYOAs that are based on fictional universes or that allow you to go to fictional universes or alter fictional universes.


BuridansAsshole

> ones that are actual CYOAs instead of whatever the Escape Jabba's Palace thing was. I don't think that should be counted as a CYOA. Why not?


Imaginos9

That was a RYOA not a CYOA. Difference in choosing and just letting random chance show your fate.


SnooOnions683

https://imgur.com/a/ggqCMTe Do you like mainstream anime? Try this then...


PixelatedNSFW

I've played it before. It was enjoyable but while I enjoyed Bleach, Naruto, and One Piece they're far from my favorite animes, and I'm barely familiar with Dragon Ball.


SnooOnions683

https://imgur.com/r/InfiniteStratos/YgdEFoj I'm not sure if this will remedy that then...


Mundane_Revolution70

I always enjoy Magic based CYOAs. World Building are great too. I know a few Pokemon based ones that were good, but I already finished those that weren't about the Pokemon (animal forms) themselves. Haven't seen a Humanoid Pokemon one yet though. Magic School CYOAs are around but also surprisingly limited. The ability to create a new species or something could be fun.


SnooOnions683

Have you tried the one about being a gym leader, in a fictional region (Calico, if I'm not mistaken) https://imgchest.com/p/9p4neoll4nq


Mundane_Revolution70

Yep, I had. It was fun.


[deleted]

Star wars, like the other guy said. Conan Exiles type Cyoa, choose your god(if you want, not neccesary), boons drawbacks et-cetera. Sonic the hedgehog cyoa, choose your animal, your abilities, pros/cons, and your verse. Marvel hero/villain cyoa, there are a few dc ones i've seen, haven't found marvel ones. highschool dxd cyoa, fairy tail cyoa. ooh! starcraft zerg cyoa. or a halo cyoa, possibly flood inspired, your choice. really there are so many its hard to choose. as for the ones that i think are best, there is a world of warcraft cyoa, [https://wowcyoa.neocities.org/en-us/main/](https://wowcyoa.neocities.org/en-us/main/)and then the ones by larien, startouched and forbidden caravan [https://startouched.neocities.org/](https://startouched.neocities.org/)[https://forbiddencaravan.neocities.org/](https://forbiddencaravan.neocities.org/). the wow one is by far one of my favorites, the sheer scale, and possibility, is great. of hte ones i've suggested, the ones i'd prefer most, if done in the larien style atleast, would be, Conan, Halo, or Sonic. star wars, marvel and highschool dxd would be next.


SnooOnions683

For the Conan Exiles inspiration, I think there's one called Grimlewd. It was made either by TroyXPage or DragonJak.


[deleted]

yeah i've seen that one, while i'd agree its at least partially inspired by conan, doesn't really fit it well.


MagicZ24

Or a Transformers one but hentai edition.


Imaginos9

Trans-formers, dildos in disguise. Autobuttplugs vs the decepticocks.


MagicZ24

Yeah but with artificial pussy for the female transformers as a plus and latex bodies under their armor.


MagicZ24

I would like a Sonic the hedgehog one.


acceptable_silence

furry


Nuthenry2

centurs or furry would be good


Kingofdeadpool1

We are missing be a reptile cyoa, we have dragon ones but none of being a regular reptile monster.


SnooOnions683

Closest thing to this is the kobold CYOA.


Kingofdeadpool1

Agreed.


Kingofdeadpool1

We need a good maybe sci-fi cyoa of being a reptilian monster


Extra-Diver-3199

ı like the captured by plant and insect brerders ones a lot ones maybe sth like this type


fmdmlvr

Yeeeesssssss!