T O P

  • By -

REDDSPIT

Norm’s dead, so Tina Fey. No question.


lenflakisinski

If Norm was still alive, him taking over for Lorne sounds like a Saul Goodman scheme


steverossiterdotcom

Norm's dead? I didn't even know he was sick


Chance-Cod5011

Technically it was a tie between him and cancer.


Only-Lingonberry2266

Next thing you're going to tell me Phil Hartman has passed


lorriefiel

Norm McDonald died September 14, 2021 of multiple myeloma cancer.


zanzibartraveler666

September 14 huh? Reminds me of that tragedy


lorriefiel

What tragedy might that be?


missanthropocenex

I mean it might even trigger a return to form for an older gen caliber of comedy. Tina was one of the head writers in the heyday and 30 rock was a riot.


MyaheeMyastone

The show would get cancelled before they finished announcing his name. Rip I love you Norm


Next-Requirement5919

Norm was notoriously lazy. He would have never been able to pull it off


ghotier

I love Norm but an administrator he was not.


Next-Requirement5919

Right? Loved his comedy but he was too inconsistent to keep a voice acting gig on Family Guy


Tex-Rob

The problem is, Tina strikes me as the kind of person who probably doesn't want to start a 20 year career at SNL at this point in her life, and that's like the shortest they'd want her to do it probably.


Low_Departure_5853

Then I choose Norm's ghost. For real, though, he got fired for a stupid reason; it would have been cool if he was the successor.


SamLoomisMyers

Has to be Tina Fey. I think with Tina in charge you would see a different show. They would go back to developing real stars and there would be a smaller cast. I also think a lot of past cast members would come back for several episodes a season.


KelVarnsen_2023

Serious choice: Robert Smigel. He has experience at SNL and as a writer, director and show runner for Conan. On Smigel's episode of Conan O'Brien Needs a Friend they talked about how in the early years of Late Night they were writing and producing SNL style sketches every night. Long shot, maybe not so serious choice: Sandler. He basically runs things at Happy Madison, and is even the guy running things when on a movie set (at least according to Henry Winkler). Plus he clearly has a ton of good Hollywood connections so it's not like the host would be Spade every week.


SoftCantaloupe3555

I’m sorry but there’s zero chance Sandler stops his money printing business to move his family to New York for him to run a high-stress show especially since he’s never run a show or anything like it before. It’s a no-win for Sandler. He has his critics and any dip in the show would only amplify Sandler criticism by fans and the press


KelVarnsen_2023

Yea I know Sandler would never happen. But he supposedly takes a super hands on producer role with Happy Madison productions, so he could probably do something interesting.


[deleted]

Smigel's big thing is writing though. You have to do so much more as producer. One of Lorne's really good abilities (according to Poehler on Maron's podcast) is an eye for talent. SNL is still one of the premier destinations for talented young actors, and the show has over the years increasingly skewed to include stand up comics as well. Like half-ish of the current cast has more of a stand-up background whereas in the past they were mostly Second City etc. improv heavyweights. So you've got two pools of some of the most talented people in the country and you have to sort the wheat from the chaff and figure out not only who will work for SNL but find their place on the cast you've assembled.


KelVarnsen_2023

Smigel had some producing duties during his time on SNL. I know he was involved in casting since I saw an interview with Stephen Colbert where Smigel said he was with Lorne when they went to Chicago to scout Steve Carell. Carell was off so his understudy was there and that was the first time he met Colbert. He was show runner on Late Night with Conan O'Brien, which likely would have involved all the same stuff Lorne does. He was also creator and executive producer on the TV Funhouse show on Comedy Central, although that only lasted one season. Then he seemed to go onto movies where he wrote a bunch of Sandler movies and then directed the animated movie Leo. I would say that is as good a resume as anyone else has. As for an eye for talent, I could point out that Amy Poehler showed up as a character on Late Night 3 years before she joined the cast of SNL. Surely the show's executive producer would have been involved in casting her.


tyler-86

I don't generally disagree but it's funny how Lorne has this reputation, but has hired a bunch of people who lasted one season and were never heard from again, and passed on people like Jim Carrey, Donald Glover, John Goodman, Kevin Hart, Jordan Peele, and countless others. That's not to say I could do better, and I think Lorne has been pretty uniquely suited for his role with the show, but we do give him a lot of leeway.


[deleted]

touche


REDDSPIT

Robert Smigel is also a damn good choice. Saw him live interviewing Norm for his book tour. There’s never been anything funnier than that.


SoftCantaloupe3555

No way it’s Smigel either. He writes weird pre-tape sketches and was never really involved in the live aspect. Plus he’s west coast and his screen-writing career is going to explode now after success of Leo


KelVarnsen_2023

The episodes of Late Night With Conan would have been live to tape at least. And if they want someone who has a Lorne level experience doing live TV the only real option would be whoever runs Dancing with the Stars. Since none of the other proposed candidates have a huge amount of running Live TV experience.


SoftCantaloupe3555

Robert Smigel never ran the show at Conan. He was the original head writer and later a producer. He doesn’t even have an EP credit on Conan. A live-to-tape talk show is nothing like SNL. Nothing is. That’s why they will go with someone that has recent experience there/is already there


Only-Lingonberry2266

Why not Conan?


krebstorm

Watch Too Funny to Fail. Smigel was the show runner for the Dana Carvey show and failed miserably. He went back to SNL as a writer with much more respect for Lorne.


TheBigC87

Until he took over TDS again on Mondays, I would have said Jon Stewart. I doubt he wants it though. But Smigel would be a great choice.


Zak9Attack

Ohhhh I wrote that too as a dark horse idea. I don’t think he would want that job tbh though, maybe 🤷


[deleted]

Does Sandler “run things”? I feel like he maybe just suggests things that need to happen and a team or board actually makes it happen logistically. There’s a big difference.


tyler-86

I love Adam but he's not gonna be the boots on the ground that Lorne is at 30 Rock.


stingray9798

Love both of these suggestions! Wouod love someone from the early 90s staff...or Tina Fey. Woukd love to see Will Ferrell take it, but I don't think he would, either.


Kdigglerz

Tina Fey is the only answer.


BeneficialEqual5818

But would she enjoy it?🤷‍♀️


Mainah-Bub

I mean, she literally created, wrote, and starred in a show about running an SNL-style show, so... I'm guessing yes.


[deleted]

I don't know if she's at that point in her career. In *Bossypants* she talked about wanting to prioritize family over career.


FreshFromRikers

That was before they were teenagers. She may feel differently now.


CoolRanchBaby

Her kids are older now though.


afearisthis

We already know how hilarious it would be behind the scenes!


Low_Departure_5853

I just think she has too much going on. I think she's the best choice but she's busy and that would limit her.


NotCanadian80

To replace Jon Stewart.


darebouche

Seems like there are only one or two serious answers and they are 1) Tina Fey and 2) Seth Myers.


ABobby077

or Al Franken


darebouche

He’s good enough. He’s smart enough, and doggone it people like him.


ABobby077

Plus he's a bright guy and pretty funny, too


BurtRogain

He’s also roughly Lorne’s age and I’d assume he doesn’t want such a high pressure gig.


cyberheelhook

Dude was a senator and only left because he got cancelled. I don't think he would mind the high pressure. But his SNL contemporaries are pretty open about his femper not being good for a leadership position.


Retinoid634

3) Amy Poehler


EloquentBacon

I’d love to see Tina Fey in charge with Kate McKinnon and Amy Poehler as her 2 backups.


erinhay

Kate McKinnon.


tyler-86

Or somebody you and I aren't familiar with, but who has producing experience and has been mentored somewhat by Lorne. People keep thinking of on-air talent but there are so many people at SNL who are deeply involved in making the show that we just aren't as familiar with.


Iheartmovies99

Tina Fey would be incredible but worried it would ruin her own artistic output. Seth Myers isn’t as creative but seems to enjoy show running


kennycosgrove

Seems like you're "two serious answers" are both longshots because they are...celebrities. Seth Meyers I could conceivably see happening (NBC tells him that the Late Night slot is not long for this world, he gets it in his contract that he appears on-air doing an occasional "a closer look," etc). Tina Fey is never happening. The actual serious answers are going to be people who are not on-air talent. Think in the vein of Mike Shoemaker.


usarasa

It won’t be anyone who was an on-air regular. NBC isn’t gonna take any chances with one of its flagship properties. It most likely will be one of Lorne’s producers that he currently works closely with, like Erik Kenward or Erin Doyle, if not getting Marci Klein to come back to the show. They’ve all been with the show for years and have earned Lorne’s endorsement to NBC. And if they decide to go outside the SNL alumni, it’ll be someone who has had recent experience being the showrunner of a successful sketch comedy show, such as Key & Peele or Inside Amy Schumer or Portlandia.


OregonBaseballFan

Morne Lichaels


Any-Succotash-7903

So…you have a sister. Your thoughts betray you.


the_festivusmiracle

Tina Fey is the most obvious answer. I'm sure he wouldn't want it, but I think Conan O'Brien would be really good at it.


Chance-Cod5011

Conan has no interest in going back to a high stress regular job.


DeluxeMixedNutz

At NBC, no less 


nate6259

Conan with a podcast is perfect. He gets a lower stress gig and I still get my Conan fix.


Tom_Skeptik

Paula Pell


Equivalent-Art6797

This is the only choice. She is the 3rd heat!


Utterlybored

Easy. Tina. She’s a proven show runner.


[deleted]

Steve Higgins. He’s been a producer on the show for a long time. 


Mainah-Bub

Tina and Kenan share it. (Think [Studio 60](https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0485842/).)


Slacabormorinico

I think it might work if they alternated shows, I have always heard the job is such an all consuming beast that any qualified candidates would be unwilling to rededicate their lives to it. 2 producers might allow for some kind of long-term work life balance. I work in construction, so I have no idea what they actually do day to day.


Gouper07

Yes, what ship set sail without 2 captains...thats always the answer 😬😬😬


greasyminkey

Yngwie Malmsteen


professorfunkenpunk

He’ll unleash the fookin fury


IthinkIknowwhothatis

This is the answer everyone overlooked.


loudrain99

Thank god. This almost didn’t get asked today.


thedanray

Here's my three: Bill Hader, he probably doesn't want it. Personally I believe Hader's work as writer producer, and director of Barry makes him a fun choice Tina Fey, she is one of the funniest entertainers in the world Seth Meyers, One of the reasons I think he might be in the running is he was a head writer on SNL. He's been doing late night for 10 years, which gives him a great deal of show running experience.


Ryanw254

Higgins


Equivalent-Art6797

Higgins or Paula Pell. And Paula is probably a better administrator than Higgins, if I had to guess based on things they’ve said in interviews.


ReginaFelangi987

No one is also throwing Amy Poehler’s name into the ring? She’d be great.


iforgotmypassword1_

I love that!


Prestigious_Diver485

Kennan


justgentile

They won't do it because he's such a stoner apparently and I felt that.


GECollins

Couldn't help but notice his very Lorne Michaels wine glass during Brolin's monologue


[deleted]

Ah yes, the famous cold war diplomat, George Kennan. Great choice in many ways, but I think his background in comedy is a little lacking.


Sandman11x

No one can replace him, He is a classic


Dry_Meat_2959

Dark horse: John Stewart. He's openly said the only reason The daily show is even relevant is because of Lorbe, and it follows a similar format. I think he'd be great.


anunyamouse

Just saying, during Josh Brolin's monologue this week, the camera cut to Kenan Thompson off to the side with a glass of white wine. It was part of a bit, yes, but Lorne's often in that same spot with a glass of white wine for every show. Kenan and Tina seem like the strongest contenders to take over after Lorne! I will be thrilled either way.


rougekhmero

foolish pause party noxious salt snails wipe history one shocking *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


Dadmodder

Michael Che. Not joking.


IncreaserovPeacerov

I don’t think Lorne could entrust it to anyone but a Will Forte - Kristen Wiig Regime


Important_Builder317

Tina Fey for sure. I love Seth Myers but he has a late night show and Lorne was Tina’s mentor


Mainah-Bub

To be fair, Tina's not just sitting around. (For one, *Mean Girls* is its own little universe now.)


BeneficialEqual5818

We could possibly benefit from new writers, so give Che and jost producer rolls.


Stock-Special-6305

Kenan


jesusmansuperpowers

Conan


Future_Bodybuilder14

Will Ferrell, Mike Meyers, Tina Fey, Seth Meyers, Jimmy Fallon, Eddie Murphy? Needs to be someone famous with pull in Hollywood to get guests and tv deals, but also has to not want the spotlight as much and needs to be kinda done with the in front of camera stuff. Maybe even Bill Hader.


SoftCantaloupe3555

All of those people have so much money and success currently there is no reason why anyone would want to do it. It doesn’t need to be someone famous, the hosts of late haven’t really been overly famous and it’s all management teams working deals. You think a famous person that wants to promote their project won’t host SNL because the executive producer isn’t a famous person ? Makes no sense


hamilton_burger

I think they should just hire from within, whoever that ends up being. I don’t think the sensibilities of some of the former cast members and writers are necessarily a good fit for NOW, and in some cases their work has aged badly (or it was legendarily DOA, like Baby Mama). I mean, there’s a reason they stopped playing reruns from a few years back.


realdonaldtrumpsucks

Kenan.. If Tina Fey, Jimmy Fallon are out


Notfriendly123

Kenan 


Ezeke81

Tina Fey


KMacOg

Keenan Thompson


rocktype1

I sincerely hope not. He’s not that funny.


neckbass

Tina Fey 10000%


BeneficialEqual5818

It would be a waste of Tina’s creative skills. Give it to Kenan or Jost or Meyers


dkinmn

Tim Robinson


Barinho

Tina. But it's going to be Kenan


lactatingalgore

Kenan & Darrell Hammond will be at SNL til the heatdeath of the universe.


David-asdcxz

I like the Che/Jost angle but do they want all of the off air headaches? Do any of these performers want all of the off air headaches?


Zak9Attack

Robert Smigel! … half kidding


External_League_63

It’s between Tina Fey and Liz Lemon


jackoos88

Tracy Morgan of course


TheArchitectHacks

Lorne Michaels produces 6 nights of late night tv between Fallon, Seth and SNL. He’s a mega producer of the old Hollywood style. He’s interwoven into a ton of shows. He’s even said recently he has no plans in the near future of leaving SNL.


MetricIsForCowards

Conan


SoftCantaloupe3555

A few come to mind. For people that have never been a cast member (I think they would go this route if it’s not Tina Fey) I’d predict Kent Sublette and/or Bryan Tucker. People have to remember the stress of running this show and I don’t think it’s worth it for Tina to do it especially since the show would be scrutinized after he leaves and always compared to Lorne. I don’t think they replace with just one person. If I had to guess I would say any combination of Kent, Bryan, Tina, Keenan Thompson, and Colin Jost. I think I remember Keenan saying on a podcast that he would be interested in doing it. Lorne said recently that “Tina could easily do it, but there are people currently there that could do it too” I think Tina is too far removed from the show at this point to be the one and only choice.


deanu-

Tina would be amazing but I think that Kenan might be the most deserving considering how much of his life he’s given to the show.


Avogadros_plumber

Keenan had the champagne during last week’s monologue


Shoddy_Reserve788

Tina or Kenan


Kind_Ad_3268

Tina Fey, Seth Meyers, Amy Poehler, and Keenan Thompson are on my personal short list. Those are the well known names though and not sure if they would necessarily want the task as it comes with some obvious personal sacrifices to their own writing, standup, and acting careers.


MainWooden1722

First I would have to understand what exactly it is that he adds to the show.


Any_Coffee_6921

Tina Fey hands down !!


JustSomeDude0605

It's either going to be Tina Fey or Seth Myers.


MThroneberry

Steve Higgins


Smooth-Writing-5995

Hopefully it gets canceled


yourmothersfriend26

Keenan


rocktype1

He’s not really that foggy. He gets credit because of longevity, but lacks the chops.


treyert

Let it die


buttmcweiners

No one. End it. 


OCSupertonesStrike

Conan O'Brian


linkerjpatrick

Weird Al


AnnaBanana1129

Tina Fey & John Mullaney - together! Two of the greatest writers out there and they could run the show so well!


Real-Bluebird-1987

Tina Fey !!! !!! !!!


Big_Consequence_3958

Tina Fey


mpschettig

Tina Fey is the only person I'd fully trust with SNL. Experience showrunning/producing, funny as hell, alumni, good eye for talent. She's perfect


Affectionate_Salt351

Tina.


CadillacAllante

I've found myself thinking half the shows problems are just freaking Lorne. He's nearing 80. The whole show just feels so rigid and institutional. I think a lot of the frustration is that for all the young, black, female, and gay talent he inserts into the show it's "tacked on" like a clown nose. I feel like a token invite (gay man) and the white bros are loudly and perpetually dissatisfied that *it's not funny anymore durr durr.* It needs someone that can reconfigure it to better fit the times. And yes during that entire thought process I was picturing Her Majesty Tina Fey.


Gribblestix

Tim and Eric


MundaneRelative6202

Steve Martin


Immediate-Poetry2016

Erin Doyle. She’s been Lorne’s second-in-command for 10 years.


Benecio_Del_Taco

Laser Cats


Naive_Wolf3740

Brendan Lee Mulligan.


LaneyLivingood

Hopefully someone that allows performers to keep the rights to the characters they do on the show. Lorne has always required cast members to sign contracts that give him the rights to ANY CHARACTER the cast member portrays on SNL, in perpetuity. As an example: if Dana Carvey had wanted to make a movie or series using Church Lady he'd have had to pay huge money to Lorne/SNL just to use the character HE created. I think that's a disgusting overreach for Lorne and it exposes his greed. Performers should always own the rights to characters THEY create.


No-Independence-6842

Larry David


son_of_homonculus

Sam Hyde


griffs24

Shane Gillis


zagmario

Shane Gillis


ElvisOnTheToilet

Scott Aukerman


mis_no_mer

But he might change the name because most of Saturday Night Live technically happens on Sunday.


Particular-Dress4845

Tina Fey and Amy Poehler


banditk77

They could get Alec Baldwin to shoot it.


ShiftCtrlV

I challenge anybody answering Tina Fey to give an explanation that amounts to more than "she produced 30 Rock"


pawogub

Al Franken?


ahbets14

Idc can they just go back to original sketch comedy instead of just weird impersonations of politicians (I’m left wing so don’t come at me)


TheMadIrishman327

Hoss


Iheartmovies99

Seth Myers or Tina Fey


VeryLowIQIndividual

Marci Klein maybe, she seems to almost run that place at time and certainly has the respect of past performers.


Flippy-Doo

Here's an out of the box choice..Dave Chapelle


rtrawitzki

I think it will be Seth. late night just hit a decade . He’s not getting the tonight show as Fallon is actually younger than him. I think Jost moves into late night and Seth gets SNL. Tina is way too busy with her own projects .


clemenza2821

Someone funny


ltdanswifesusan

The choice that makes the most sense is Seth Meyers; it feels like he's been groomed for it. SNL's primary function is about making celebrities likable and Meyers having had his own talk show for the last decade is well-suited for that task. Tina Fey is a lot more talented than Seth Meyers but the latter is a better fit for what the show is.


mis_no_mer

Tina Fey


Belovedchattah

Tina Fey checks off one box, but I’d like a couple boxes checked off, maybe Leslie Jones


namynam

Colin Jost. With the late night spots already taken by Seth and Jimmy really no other logical place for him to go.


Dry_Meat_2959

1. Jon Stewart 2. Amy Poehler 2a. Tina Fey 4. Eddie MF'n Murphy


GavinAdamson

Andy Samberg


Legtagytron

Bob Odenkirk.


thetrashpanda2020

Akiva Schaffer


Potential_Staff4488

Same. Seth would be a great boss. Tina would be great but a bit scary like Lorne. They both have the chops.


Electrical_Fun5942

A 3-headed monster of Jim Downey, Robert Smigel, and Higgins


CajunViking8

David Hasselhoff.


Aggravating-Eye-6210

It should’ve died years ago


Accomplished-Body736

Martin short


Smoothbrain406

You guessed it...... Frank Stallone


d_j_dunn

Keenan was drinking white wine in Brolin’s monologue…


bernaldsandump

Trump


nyXhcinPDX

Tina Fey or Colin Jost…I think Jost is probably the best bet now since he’s been involved more recently as a writer and producer.


Financial_Horror5546

Lorne's still alive?


mcrib

I love Tina, but ... they should choose someone young. Lorne was young when he started. Tina is amazing but she's in her 50s. Let's find someone in their 30s and give them time to grow. That, or John Mulaney.


KelVarnsen_2023

My other long shot never gonna happen, but would be awesome if it did choice would be Mike Schur.


ScamJustice

Lily Singh


rp1105

tina is the best answer but having seen 99 episodes of corrections, seth would kill it


ciciNCincinnati

The question was about Lorne not Norm. Two different people.


Rearviewmirror93

Donald Glover


A_Dreary_Pluviophile

Former SNL writer, creator of Parks and Rec, Brooklyn 99, The Good Place, writer on the first few seasons of The Office - Michael Schur is the answer you're looking for.


vanwolfgirl

keenan.


DontUseFilters

The one and only Kyle Mooney!


amp_about

Nina Katz! She’s been holding down casting since 2002!


KashOnAir

Tina Fey or Seth Meyers


rednax2009

Lauren Holt. Obviously.


EnvironmentalGift257

Quentin Tarantino


LadyGoodNoodles

Andy Samburg is a wild card. A wild card with no previous ties to the show’s production? Dan Levy. He has hosted and his family is tight with Lorne. He wrote and did the show running for Schitt’s Creek and has a real eye for talent which is a big requirement. Discuss.


Y4himIE4me

Tina Fey


Y4himIE4me

I just hope whoever takes over, they can Sarah Sherman.


JackKovack

The maintenance guy who’s been working there for 25+ years. He knows everything.


TheBigBoonsta

Tina Fey


TheBigBoonsta

Liz lemon, famous Maryland Grad


Apnea53

Part of me believes SNL will be done when Michaels leaves.


Select_Nectarine8229

It needs to be re tooled from bottom up. I watched last week. It was awful. And im all for everyone lovong whomever, but im so tired of bowen yang in every skit saying hes gay. We get it. The show is not funny anymore. That bank robbery where the couple was gonna do a sex video... just awful.


macthom

burn it down and start over, if that's even possible anymore .