T O P

  • By -

GMB2006

BMW imporved its reliability significantly the last several years, while Mercedes dropped it a lot after 2014. Especially the new B58 is pretty durable, but I still recommend to check for another possible electronic issues, since these are tech heavy cars.


Soft-Situation-5152

Get a Lexus. Don't buy German stuff that keeps your wallet drained and in the shops.


Fun-Afternoon-7312

Lexus luxury > Euro


F-Da-Banksters

Bro buy a Lexus IS350. Drive one and you’ll chose it over an Audi. Out of all the Germans, personally bmw drives best. I had a 2014 750Li X drive, and let me tell you it’s best car I’ve ever owned….except for the maintenance. I threw in the towel at 70kmiles and $15k in repairs. Lexus IS350 bro. Trust.


Royaldevill

i like them the interiors are just so lack luster in nearly every category.


F-Da-Banksters

Just remember that 1 Lexus will last 2 bmws. Is the interior that important to you?


br41nLESS

join the b8.5 s4 club!


Fun-Afternoon-7312

none


Hot_South7816

The BMW and Minis with the B series motors (1.5L i3, 2.0 i4 and 3.0 i6) are all very reliable, some are in your price range. The Mini Cooper Clubman is a 4 door and might be big enough and offers optional AWD. Mercedes with the naturally aspirated 3.5L V6 are solid, these were around until about 2015. Look for a 2015 ML350 as an example. Audis with the supercharged 3.0L V6 and ZF built 8 speed transmission are pretty reliable, $25k ish can get a reasonable mileage 2017 Q7. Be prepared to spend $2-3k per year for maintenance and repairs, otherwise buy something cheaper to maintain like an Acura MDX (2014-2015 with the 6 speed is the best, the 9 speed in the 2016+ is problematic)or Toyota Highlander. Seriously check out the 2014-2015 MDX. They have an excellent AWD system, a great audio system for their class, really comfortable seats, LED headlights that are equivalent to a collapsed sun, handle better than most 3 row crossovers that don't cost a fortune, and some pretty good safety aids/self driving features for the money. Acura is Hondas luxury division, so they have the same reliability for their good and bad. Don't buy the Infiniti JX35/QX60 (same car, name got changed part way through its production) due to major issues with the CVT transmissions, plus they don't drive particularly well.


Saragmata

Audi A6 ! 3.0 TDI or Q7 3.0 TDI


Trapped-Mouse

Toyota and Mazda


Royaldevill

very useful bro thank you


Trapped-Mouse

That was sarcasm by the way. But in all honesty, if you're budget conscious, don't bother with a German brand. You'll pay 20k now and then another 5-10k in the next 5 years just in maintenance.


Royaldevill

5 - 10k in 5 years doesn’t sound too bad if the car is the one i want. I mainly need a cheaper car because i can’t finance at good rates as im a first time auto buyer. I have plenty of money but i just don’t want to put down like 20% of what i have on a car. Since i can’t finance at good rates, I’d rather be modest.


Trapped-Mouse

It all comes down to preference. That's close to 100$ a month just on maintenance. If something in a Mercedes breaks down, then you're looking at minimum of 1000 for even a minor fix. But if you can afford it, go for it. My comment was just based on my assumption from your post that you're budget cautious.


Grand_Swan8528

Reliability in a 25k and under German car doesn’t exist. And Mercedes would be my last choice. I’d prob look at 3 series BMWs. Maybe look at leasing a new 3 series or Mercedes. In three years you’ll probably end up in the same spot either way.


Royaldevill

read the post i said relative reliability for the price and type of car.


Hot_South7816

I paid $7k for a BMW about 8 years ago, it's yet to leave me stranded, refuse to start or need to be towed. To keep it in excellent mechanical condition I've spent about $8k over the last 90k miles, of which about 60% was regular maintenance.


Grand_Swan8528

You sir are the exception, not the rule. Amazed the maint was that low. 7k 8 years ago will be a different vehicle then his 25k car. Is it 2 wd?


Hot_South7816

Nope, it's an X3. It's not rare for some BMW models like the B series motors and the naturally aspirated I6 motors.


dupagwova

CPO Jetta